TY  - JOUR
T1  - Probabilistic Liability and Judicial Insurance for Environmental Risks
AU  - Nacar, Abdulkadir
PY  - 2025
DA  - August
Y2  - 2025
DO  - 10.26650/mecmua.2025.83.2.0003
JF  - İstanbul Hukuk Mecmuası
PB  - Istanbul University
WT  - DergiPark
SN  - 2636-7734
SP  - 605
EP  - 629
VL  - 83
IS  - 2
LA  - en
AB  - This study analyzes the responsibility framework for environmental risks from legal, economic, and philosophical perspectives, focusing on both individual and state-level accountability. Recognizing the need for proactive (ex-ante) risk management, we challenge the current frameworks that only respond after damage occurs. Tort liability, which operates on the damage-compensation axis, has disadvantages in terms of environmental protection. Besides, pre-determined norms can lead to standards that are either excessively strict or too lenient than necessary before damage occurs. Moreover, the stochastic nature of environmental risks renders them unsuitable for purely normative consideration. We argue that pure normative approaches fail to consider the case-specific and dynamic nature of environmental risks. Instead, our study proposes probabilistic liability. The legal foundation of probabilistic liability lies in the recognition that the customary no-harm obligation encompasses the risk of harm as well. The research question of our study is: What is the legal consequence of causing a risk of harm? Drawing on insights from the theoretical arguments of the reality of risk, probabilistic causation, and risk attribution, we propose an innovative solution: courts mandating “judicial insurance” for those posing environmental risks. Courts may identify the coverage gap resulting from activities altering risk values and impacting sustainability in the incident under consideration. To address this gap, courts may enforce insurance obligations on operators under market conditions. This introduces a probabilistic liability model applicable to both states and individuals. This novel approach offers a more effective and adaptable mechanism for managing environmental risks while ensuring accountability and sustainability.
KW  - Environmental Risk
KW  - Environmental Litigation
KW  - Probabilistic Liability
KW  - Reality of Risk
KW  - Risk Attribution
KW  - Judicial Insurance
CR  - Aristotle, Ross WD and Urmson JO, The Nicomachean ethics (Oxford University Press 1980) google scholar
CR  - Beck U, Risk Society : Towards a New Modernity (Sage Publications 1992) google scholar
CR  - Busnelli FD and others, Principles of European Tort Law: Text and Commentary (Oral T, Göka ME and Gündüz E trs, Oniki Levha 2021) google scholar
CR  - Creutz K, State Responsibility in the International Legal Order: A Critical Appraisal (Cambridge University Press 2020) google scholar
CR  - Davis M, Thinking like an engineer: studies in the ethics of a profession (Oxford University Press 1998) google scholar
CR  - Deschenaux H and Tercier P, La responsabilité civile (Özdemir S tr, Kadıoğlu 1983) google scholar
CR  - Douglas M, Risk Acceptability According to the Social Sciences (Russell Sage Foundation 1985) google scholar
CR  - Douglas M and Wildavsky AB, Risk and culture : an essay on the selection of technical and environmental dangers (1st pbk. print edn, University of California Press 1983) google scholar
CR  - Eren F, Borçlar Hukuku Genel Hükümler (Yetkin 2021) google scholar
CR  - Faure MG and Partain RA, Environmental Law and Economics: Theory and Practice (Cambridge University Press 2019) google scholar
CR  - Faure MG and Verheij A, Shifts in Compensation for Environmental Damage, vol 21 (Springer 2007) google scholar
CR  - Fischer JM and Ravizza M, Responsibility and Control: A Theory of Moral Responsibility (Cambridge University Press 1998) google scholar
CR  - Freeman PK and Kunreuther H, Managing Environmental Risk through Insurance (Kluwer 1997) google scholar
CR  - Friedman LS, Microeconomic policy analysis / Lee S. Friedman (McGraw-Hill 1984) google scholar
CR  - Gürkan Ü, Hukuki Realizm Akımı (Sevinç Matbaası 1967) google scholar
CR  - Hansson SO, Setting the Limit: Occupational Health Standards and the Limits of Science (Oxford University Press 1998) google scholar
CR  - Hart HLA, Punishment and Responsibility: Essays in the Philosophy of Law (Oxford University Press 1968) google scholar
CR  - Işıktaç Y and Metin S, Hukuk Metodolojisi (Filiz 2003) google scholar
CR  - Jhering Rv, Geist des römischen Rechts auf den verschiedenen Stufen seiner Entwicklung, vol 3 (Breitkopf und Härtel 1865) google scholar
CR  - Kılıç T, Yeni Bilim Bağlantısallık Yeni Kültür Yaşamdaşlık (Ayrıntı 2023) google scholar
CR  - Le Grand J, Equity and Choice: an Essay in Economics and Applied Philosophy (Harper Collins 1991) google scholar
CR  - Lumer C, The Greenhouse: A Welfare Assessment and Some Morals (University Press of America 2002) google scholar
CR  - MacLean D, Values at Risk (Rowman & Allanheld 1985) google scholar
CR  - Magnus U, Unification of Tort Law: Damages (Kluwer Law International 2001) google scholar
CR  - Martin MW and Schinzinger R, Ethics in engineering (4th , [international ] edn, McGraw-Hill 2005) google scholar
CR  - Mettler FA and Moseley R, Medical Effects of Ionizing Radiation (Grune and Stratton 1985) google scholar
CR  - OECD, Environmental Risks and Insurance (2003) google scholar
CR  - –––, Guidance on Sustainability Impact Assessment (2010) google scholar
CR  - Oftinger K, Schweizerisches Haftpflichtrecht-I (Polygraphischer Verlag 1975) google scholar
CR  - Ogus A, Regulation: Legal Form and Economic Theory (Clarendon Press 1997) google scholar
CR  - Owen A, The Law of Insurance Warranties: Flawed Reform and a New Perspective (Taylor & Francis 2021) google scholar
CR  - Renn O, Concepts of Risk : A Classification (Universitätsbibliothek der Universität Stuttgart 2010) google scholar
CR  - Revesz RL and Livermore MA, Retaking Rationality: How Cost Benefit Analysis Can Better Protect the Environment and Our Health (Oxford University Press 2008) google scholar
CR  - Rob Merkin and Jenny Steele, Insurance and the Law of Obligations (Oxford University Press 2013) google scholar
CR  - Rudall J, Compensation for Environmental Damage Under International Law (Routledge 2021) google scholar
CR  - Sanlı KC, Haksız Fiil Hukukunun Ekonomik Analizi (Arıkan 2007) google scholar
CR  - Sen A, On Ethics and Economics (Basil Blackwell 1987) google scholar
CR  - Shrader-Frechette KS, (University of California Press 1991) google scholar
CR  - Slovic P, The perception of risk (Earthscan Publications 2000) google scholar
CR  - Smith A, An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations (ed. R.H. Campbell, A.S. Skinner, and W. B. Todd) (Oxford University Press 1976) google scholar
Spinoza B, The Ethics (Elwes RHM tr, Blackmask 2001) google scholar
CR  - Stempel JW, Swisher PN and Knutsen ES, Principles of Insurance Law (LexisNexis 2012) google scholar
CR  - van Boom WH, Lukas M and Kissling C, Tort and Regulatory Law (Springer Vienna 2007) google scholar
CR  - van de Poel I and Royakkers L, Ethics, Technology and Engineering (2011) google scholar
CR  - Wallace RJ, Responsibility and the Moral Sentiments (Harvard University Press 1994) google scholar
CR  - ‘Probabilistic liability’ in Steel S (ed), Proof of Causation in Tort Law (Cambridge University Press 2015) google scholar
CR  - Anderson GM and Crerar DA, ‘Statistical Interpretation of Entropy’ in Thermodynamics in Geochemistry: The Equilibrium Model (Oxford Academic, Oxford University Press 1993)  <https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780195064643.003.0010> accessed 6/1/2023 google scholar
CR  - Berner B, ‘Constructing risk and safety in technological practice: an introduction’ in Berner B and Summerton J (eds), Constructing Risk and Safety in Technological Practice (Routledge 2003)  <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-9566.2007.01059_ 3.x> google scholar
CR  - Dougherty ER, ‘The Evolution of Scientific Knowledge: From Certainty to Uncertainty ’ in (SPIE 2018)  <https://lens.org/006-835-727-815-897> google scholar
CR  - Faure M, ‘Economic Analysis’ in Widmer P and Kissling C (eds), Unification of Tort Law: Fault (Kluwer Law International 2005) google scholar
CR  - Fitzmaurice M, ‘Due Diligence in the Use of International Watercourses’ in Krieger H, Peters A and Kreuzer L (eds), Due Diligence in the International Legal Order (Oxford University Press 2020) google scholar
CR  - Gibson M, ‘Quantified Risk Assessment’ in Humber JM and Almeder RF (eds), Quantitative Risk Assessment: Biomedical Ethics Reviews · 1986 (Humana Press 1987)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-59259-656-0_7> google scholar
CR  - Hansson SO, ‘Risk and safety in technology’ in Gabbay DM and others (eds), Philosophy of Technology and Engineering Sciences (Elsevier Science 2009)  <https://books.google.com.tr/books?id=prvCTW4V7jEC> google scholar
CR  - –––, ‘A Panorama of the Philosophy of Risk ’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer 2012) google scholar
CR  - Huber BR, ‘Temporal Spillovers’ in Huber BR and Mathis K (eds), Environmental Law and Economics (Springer 2017) google scholar
CR  - Kampourakis K and others, ‘Uncertainty Is Inherent in Science’ in Uncertainty: How It Makes Science Advance (Oxford Academic, Oxford University Press 2019)  <https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780190871666.003.0011> accessed 5/17/2023 google scholar
CR  - Lahnstein C, ‘Aggregation and Divisibility of Damage: Insurance Aspects’ in Oliphant K (ed), Aggregation and Divisibility of Damage (Springer Vienna 2009)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-211-92209-5_17> google scholar
CR  - Lidskog R and Sundqvist G, ‘Sociology of Risk’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer Netherlands 2012)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1433-5_40> google scholar
CR  - Möller N, ‘The Concepts of Risk and Safety’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer 2012) google scholar
CR  - Nickel PJ and Vaesen K, ‘Risk and Trust’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer Netherlands 2012)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1433-5_34> google scholar
CR  - Oliphant K and Steininger M, ‘Aggregation and Divisibility of Damage in Tort Law and Insurance: Comparative Summary’ in Oliphant K (ed), Aggregation and Divisibility of Damage (Springer Vienna 2009)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-211-92209-5_18> google scholar
CR  - Rayner S, ‘Cultural theory and risk analysis’ in Krimsky S and Golding D (eds), Social Theories of Risk (Praeger 1992) google scholar
CR  - Riesch H, ‘Levels of Uncertainty’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer Netherlands 2012)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1433-5_4> google scholar
CR  - Roeser S, ‘Moral Emotions as Guide to Acceptable Risk’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer Netherlands 2012)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1433-5_32> google scholar
CR  - Sadeleer Nd and others, ‘The UNECE Convention on the Protection and Use of Transboundary Watercourses and International Lakes: Its Contribution to International Water Cooperation’ in The Role of the Precautionary Principle in the Convention on the Protection and Use of Transboundary Watercourses and International Lakes (Brill | Nijhoff 2015)  <https://brill.com/view/book/edcoll/ 9789004291584/B9789004291584-s013.xml> google scholar
CR  - Siew R, ‘Analytics for Sustainability Issues’ in Sustainability Analytics Toolkit for Practitioners: Creating Value in the 21st Century (Springer Nature Singapore 2023)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-8237-8_9> google scholar
CR  - –––, ‘Sustainability Decision Analytics’ in Sustainability Analytics Toolkit for Practitioners: Creating Value in the 21st Century (Springer Nature Singapore 2023)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-8237-8_4> google scholar
CR  - Sinnott-Armstrong W, ‘It's Not My Fault: Global Warming and Individual Moral Obligations’ in Sinnott-Armstrong W and Howarth R (eds), Perspectives on Climate Change (Elsevier 2005) google scholar
CR  - Taebi B, ‘Intergenerational Risks of Nuclear Energy’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer 2012) google scholar
CR  - van de Poel I and Fahlquist JN, ‘Risk and Responsibility’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer Netherlands 2012)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1433-5_35> google scholar
CR  - Viñuales JE, ‘Due Diligence in International Environmental Law: A Fine- grained Cartography’ in Krieger H, Peters A and Kreuzer L (eds), Due Diligence in the International Legal Order (Oxford University Press 2020) google scholar
CR  - Weirich P, ‘Multi-Attribute Approaches to Risk’ in Roeser S and others (eds), Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk (Springer Netherlands 2012)  <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1433-5_20> google scholar
CR  - Union Carbide Corporation & Others v. Union of India & Others (Supreme Court of India) google scholar
CR  - Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons (International Court of Justice) google scholar
CR  - Case Concerning Gabčíkovo- Nagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia) (İnternational Jourt of Justice) google scholar
The Mox Plant Case (Ireland v. United Kingdom) (ITLOS) google scholar
CR  - Request for provisional measures and statement of case submitted on behalf of Ireland (ITLOS) google scholar
CR  - Pulp Mills on the River Uruguay (Argentina v. Uruguay) (International Court of Justice) google scholar
CR  - Certain Activities Carried Out by Nicaragua in the Border Area (Costa Rica v. Nicaragua) (International Court of Justice) google scholar
CR  - Case of Verein Klimaseniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland google scholar
CR  - Poel Ivd, The Relation Between Forward-Looking and Backward-Looking Responsibility (2011) google scholar
CR  - Cockburn H, ‘Sellafield nuclear decommissioning work 'significantly' delayed and nearly £1bn over budget, report reveals’ The Independent  <https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/sellafield-nuclear-power-plant-decommission-overspend-delays-budget-report-a8609671.html> accessed 03/06/2023 google scholar
CR  - Humphreys S, ‘A Swiss human rights budget?’ EJIL Talk  <https://www.ejiltalk.org/a-swiss-human-rights-budget/> accessed 22/04/2024 google scholar
CR  - Look B, ‘Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz’ The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy  <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2020/entries/ leibniz/> google scholar
CR  - NAIC, ‘Peer-To-Peer (P2P) Insurance ’  <https://content.naic.org/cipr-topics/peer-peer-p2p-insurance> accessed 04/05/2022 google scholar
CR  - Nedeski N and Nollkaemper A, ‘A Guide to Tackling the Collective Causation Problem in International Climate Change Litigation’ EJIL Talk  <https://www.ejiltalk.org/a-guide-to-tackling-the-collective-causation-problem-in-international-climate-change-litigation/> google scholar
CR  - Baumol WJ and Oates WE, ‘The Use of Standards and Prices for Protection of the Environment’ [Scandinavian Journal of Economics, Wiley] 73 The Swedish Journal of Economics 42 google scholar
CR  - Bond VP, ‘The Cancer Risk Attributable to Radiation Exposure: Some Practical Problems’ 40 Health Phys 108 google scholar
CR  - Bradbury JA, ‘The Policy Implications of Differing Concepts of Risk’ [Sage Publications, Inc.] 14 Science, Technology, & Human Values 380 google scholar
CR  - Braham M and van Hees M, ‘An Anatomy of Moral Responsibility’ 121 Mind 601 google scholar
CR  - Broude T, ‘Behavioral International Law ’ [The University of Pennsylvania Law Review] 163 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1099 google scholar
CR  - Campbell S and Currie G, ‘Against Beck:In Defence of Risk Analysis’ 36 Philosophy of the Social Sciences 149 google scholar
CR  - Coase RH, ‘The Problem of Social Cost’ [[University of Chicago Press, Booth School of Business, University of Chicago, University of Chicago Law School]] 3 The Journal of Law & Economics 1 google scholar
CR  - Ehrlich I and Posner RA, ‘An Economic Analysis of Legal Rulemaking’ 3 The Journal of Legal Studies 257 google scholar
CR  - Erkiner HH and Nacar A, ‘Strengthening Environmental Soft Law Commitments with the Principle of Pacta Sunt Servanda’ 21 Galatasaray Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi google scholar
CR  - Estep SD, ‘Radiation Injuries and Statistics: The Need for a New Approach to Injury Litigation’ [The Michigan Law Review Association] 59 Michigan Law Review 259 google scholar
CR  - Fahlquist JN, ‘Moral responsibility for environmental problems—individual or institutional?’ 22 Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 109 google scholar
CR  - Feleppa R, ‘Epistemic utility and theory acceptance: Comments on Hempel’ 46 Synthese 413 google scholar
CR  - Fischhoff B and others, ‘How Safe Is Safe Enough? A Psychometric Study of Attitudes Toward Technological Risks and Benefits’ 9 Policy Sciences 127 google scholar
CR  - Frankfurt HG, ‘Alternate Possibilities and Moral Responsibility’ 66 Journal of Philosophy 829 google scholar
CR  - Gardiner SM, ‘A core precautionary principle’ 14 Journal of Political Philosophy 33 google scholar
CR  - Giddens A, ‘Risk and Responsibility’ [[Modern Law Review, Wiley]] 62 The Modern Law Review 1 google scholar
CR  - Gold S, ‘Causation in Toxic Torts: Burdens of Proof, Standards of Persuasion, and Statistical Evidence’ [The Yale Law Journal Company, Inc.] 96 The Yale Law Journal 376 google scholar
CR  - Hare RM, ‘Rawls' "a theory of justice" - I’ 23 Philosophical Quarterly google scholar
CR  - Harsanyi JC, ‘Can the Maximin Principle Serve as a Basis for Morality? A Critique of John Rawls's Theory’ [Cambridge University Press] 69 American Political Science Review 594 google scholar
CR  - –––, ‘Bayesian decision theory, subjective and objective probabilities, and acceptance of empirical hypotheses’ 57 Synthese 341 google scholar
CR  - Hempel CG, ‘Inductive inconsistencies’ 12 Synthese 439 google scholar
CR  - Hopster J, ‘Climate Uncertainty, Real Possibilities and the Precautionary Principle’ Erkenntnis google scholar
CR  - Hsu S-L, ‘The Accidental Postmodernists: A New Era of Skepticism in Environmental Policy’ 3 Vermont Law Review google scholar
CR  - Landes WM and Posner RA, ‘Causation in Tort Law: An Economic Approach’ [[University of Chicago Press, University of Chicago Law School]] 12 The Journal of Legal Studies 109 google scholar
CR  - Levi I, ‘On the Seriousness of Mistakes’ [Cambridge University Press] 29 Philosophy of Science 47 google scholar
CR  - Mastrandrea MD and others, ‘The IPCC AR5 guidance note on consistent treatment of uncertainties: a common approach across the working groups’ 108 Climatic Change 675 google scholar
CR  - Misumi Y and Sato Y, ‘Estimation of average hazardous-event-frequency for allocation of safety-integrity levels’ 66 Reliability Engineering & System Safety 135 google scholar
CR  - Morag-Levine N, ‘The History of Precaution’ [Oxford University Press] 62 The American Journal of Comparative Law 1095 google scholar
CR  - Neumann JE and others, ‘Climate Damage Functions for Estimating the Economic Impacts of Climate Change in the United States’ 14 google scholar
CR  - Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 25 google scholar
CR  - Oates WE, ‘Book Review: The Uncertain Search for Environmental Quality’ 124 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 864 google scholar
CR  - Ord T, Hillerbrand R and Sandberg A, ‘Probing the Improbable: Methodological Challenges for Risks with Low Probabilities and High Stakes’ 13 Journal of Risk Research 191 google scholar
CR  - Ove hansson S, ‘Weighing Risks and Benefits’ 23 Topoi 145 google scholar
CR  - Pattyn F, Ritz C and Hanna E, ‘The Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets under 1.5 °C Global Warming’ 8 Nature Climate Change 1053 google scholar
CR  - Peterson M, ‘What Is a de Minimis Risk?’ [Palgrave Macmillan Journals] 4 Risk Management 47 google scholar
CR  - Powell R, ‘What's the Harm? An Evolutionary Theoretical Critique of the Precautionary Principle’ 20 Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 181 google scholar
CR  - Rizzo MJ and Arnold FS, ‘Causal Apportionment in the Law of Torts: An Economic Theory’ 80 Columbia Law Review 1399 google scholar
CR  - Rosenberg D, ‘The Causal Connection in Mass Exposure Cases: A “Public Law” Vision of the Tort System’ 97 Harvard Law Review 851 google scholar
CR  - Roser D, ‘The Irrelevance of the Risk-Uncertainty Distinction’ 23 Science and Engineering Ethics 1387 google scholar
CR  - Rowell A, ‘Time in Cost-Benefit Analysis’ 4 UC Irvine Law Review 1215 google scholar
CR  - Thompson PB, ‘Risking or being willing: Hamlet and the DC-10’ 19 The Journal of Value Inquiry 301 google scholar
CR  - Trakman L, ‘Ex Aequo et Bono: De-mystifying an Ancient Concept ’ 8 Chicago Journal of International Law 621 google scholar
CR  - van Aaken A, ‘Behavioral International Law and Economics’ 55 Harvard International Law Journal 421 google scholar
CR  - Viñuales JE, ‘Legal Techniques for Dealing with Scientific Uncertainty in Environmental Law’ 43 Vanderbilt Law Review 437 google scholar
CR  - Wolff J, ‘Risk, Fear, Blame, Shame and the Regulation of Public Safety’ [Cambridge University Press] 22 Economics & Philosophy 409 google scholar
CR  - Yntema HE, ‘Rational Basis of Legal Science’ 31 Columbia Law Review 925 google scholar
CR  - Draft articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, with Commentaries (2 edn, Yearbook of the International Law Commission 2001) google scholar
CR  - Türk Borçlar Kanunu (2011) google scholar
CR  - Commission IL, Draft Articles on Prevention of Transboundary Harm from Hazardous Activities (Yearbook of the International Law Commission 2001) google scholar
CR  - –––, Draft Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (Yearbook of International Law Commission 2001) google scholar
CR  - PCA, Permanent Court of Arbitration Optional Rules for Arbitration of Disputes Relating to Natural Resources and/or the Environment (2001) google scholar
CR  - Insurance Contract Law Issues Paper 2 Warranties (2006) google scholar
CR  - NCRP, Statement No. 7 (1992) google scholar
CR  - Sonnemann GW, ‘Environmental Damage Estimations in Industrial Process Chain’ (Universitat Rovira i Virgili 2002) google scholar
UR  - https://doi.org/10.26650/mecmua.2025.83.2.0003
L1  - https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/5317650
ER  -