TY  - JOUR
TT  - A Poor Haystack (Loda) Etymology Between Scholarship and Imagination, An Answer to My Young Colleague Ekrem Gül
AU  - Bläsing, Uwe
PY  - 2017
DA  - December
DO  - 10.26561/iutded.369175
JF  - Journal of Turkish Language and Literature
PB  - Istanbul University
WT  - DergiPark
SN  - 1015-2091
SP  - 65
EP  - 80
VL  - 57
IS  - 57
KW  - Loda
KW  - etimoloji
KW  - saman yığını
KW  - eleştiri
KW  - bilimsel metot
KW  - bilimsel metot
N2  - The article “Loda Sözcüğü Üzerine” (“On the Term Loda”) written by Ekrem Gül and published in the twenty-fifth volume of the journal Türk Dilleri Araştırmaları (Studies in Turkish Languages) is quite intriguing. In particular, the publication of this article almost simultaneously with the paper on the term “loda” by the author of this review is meaningful. On the following pages, the article penned by Ekrem Gül dealing with the origin of “loda” will be scrutinized under several aspects with a special focus on the thesis that have been put forward. Aim of this review is to reveal and correct, based on scholarly methods, the most significant shortcomings of Gül‘s etymological attempt concerning the historical roots of “loda”.
CR  - AHw = Bruno Meissner & Wolfram von Soden (1965-81), Akkadisches Handwörterbuch, 1-3, Wiesbaden.
CR  - BIELMEIER, Roland (1989), “Sarmatisch, Alanisch, Jassisch und Altossetisch”, Compendium Linguarum Iranicarum, hrsg. von Rüdiger Schmitt, Wiesbaden, s. 236-245.
CR  - BLÄSING, Uwe (2015), “Anadolu Saman Yığınları Hikayesi”, Türk Dili Araştırlamaları, Belleten, 63.2 (2015): s. 7-29.
CR  - BEEKES, Robert (2010), Etymological Dictionary of Greek, Leiden & Boston.
CR  - CABOLOV, Ruslan Lazarevič (1976), Očerk istoričeskoj fonetiki kurdskogo jazyka, Moskva.
CR  - CABOLOV, Ruslan Lazarevič (2001-2010), Ėtimologičeskij slovar› kurdskogo jazyka, 1-2, Moskva.
CR  - CAD (1956-2010) = The Assyrian Dictionary of the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, Chicago, s. 1-21.
CR  - CASTELL, Edmund (1669), Lexicon heptaglotton Hebraicum, Chaldaicum, Syriacum, Samaritanum, Æthiopicum, Arabicum, conjunctim; et Persicum, separatim ..., London.
CR  - DEVELLIOĞLU, Ferit (1978), Osmanlıca-Türkçe Ansiklopedik Lûgat, Eski ve Yeni Harflerle, Ankara.
CR  - EBELING, E. (1948), “Mittelassyrische Rezepte zur Bereitung von wohlriechenden Salben”, Orientalia, N.S. 17 (1948), s. 129-145.
CR  - DCH (1993-2011) = The Dictionary of Cassical Hebrew, editor Dawid C. A. Clines, 1-8, Sheffield.
CR  - ĖSIJa 2 = Vera Sergeevna Rastorgueva & Džoj Iosifovna Edel’man (2003), Etimologičeskij slovar’ iranskix jazykov, 2, Moskva.
CR  - ESUM (1982-) = Etymolohičnyj slovnyk ukrajins’koji movy, (6 cilt çıkmış), Kyjiv.
CR  - FZT (1969) = Farhangi Zaboni Toǰikī ‹Slovar’ tadžikskogo jazyka›, 1-2, Dušanbe.
CR  - FASMER bkz. Vasmer
CR  - GARKAVEC, Aleksandr Nikolaevič (2010), Kypčakskoe pis’mennoe nasledie, 3: Kypčakskij slovar’ po armjanopis’mennym pamjatnikam XVI-XVII vekov, Almaty.
CR  - GHARIB, B. (2004), Sogdian Dictionary, Sogdian-Persian-English, Tehran.
CR  - GÜL, Ekrem (2015), “Loda Sözcüğü Üzerine”, Türk Dilleri Araştırmaları, 25.1 (2015), s. 57-80.
CR  - HARRISON, R. K. (1966), Healing herbs of the Bible, Leiden.
CR  - JOHNSON, Francis (1852), A Dictionary, Persian, Arabic and English, London.
CR  - KARIMI, Hadi (1995), Plants of Iran; Scientific, English and Persian Names, Tehran.
CR  - KOEHLER, Ludwig; BAUMGARTNER, Walter (1967-96), Hebräisches und Aramäisches Lexikon zum Alten Testament, 1-5, Leiden, New York, Køvenhavn, Köln.
CR  - KURTULUŞ, Rıza (2003), “Lugatnâme: Ali Ekbcr Dihhudâ’nın Fars diliyle ilgili büyük ansiklopedik sözlüğü”, Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı İslâm Ansiklopedisi 27: s. 220-221.
CR  - LAZARD, Gilbert (1990), Dictionnaire Persan-Français, Leiden.
CR  - Lûġat-i Nâcî = Muallim Nâci, Lugat-i Nâcî, [? 4. Baskı, İstanbul H1322/M1906].
CR  - Lûġat-i Remzî = Hüseyn Remzi (H1305/M1887-1888), Lûġat-i Remzî, Tabirat-ı Umûmîye-i Arabîye ve Farsîyeden Ma‘ada Fünûn ve Ulûm Istılahâtını ve İki Yüz Ḳırḳ Beşkali Havidir, 1-2, İstanbul.
CR  - MENINSKI, Franciscus à Mesgnien (1680), Thesaurus linguarum orientalium Turcicae, Arabicae, Persicae ..., 1-4, Viennae Austriae.
CR  - (2000), Thesaurus linguarum Orientalium Turcicae-Arabicae-Persicae = Lexicon Turcico-Arabico-Persicum (aynı eserin tıpkıbasımı), Mit Einleitung und mit einem türkischen Wortindex von Stanisław Stachowski, sowie einem Vorwort von Mehmet Ölmez, İstanbul.
CR  - Migne PL [Patrologia Latina] = Patrologiae Cursus Completus, sive bibliotheca universalis, integra, uniformis, commoda, oeconomica, omnium ss. patrum, doctorum scriptorumque ecclesiasticorum qui ab aevo apostolico ad Innocentii III tempora floruerunt..., Series latina, Accurante J.-P. Migne; Tomus 178, Paris 1885.
CR  - NORRIS, H. T. (1994), “Edmund Castell (1606-86) and his Lexicon Heptaglotton (1669)”, The ‘Arabick’ Interest of the Natural Philosophers in Seventeenth-Century England; edited by G. A. Russell, Leiden: 70-87.
CR  - PAYNE SMITH, Robert (1879-1901), Thesaurus Syriacus, 1-2, Oxford.
CR  - REDHOUSE, Sir James W. (1890), A Turkish and English Lexicon, Constantinople.
CR  - SLH (2011) = The Semitic Language: An International Handbook, edited by Stefan Weninger, in collaboration with Geoffrey Khan, Michael P. Streck, Janet C. E. Watson, Berlin/Boston.
CR  - STEINGASS, Francis (1892), A Comprehensive Persian-English Dictionary, London.
CR  - THOMPSON, Reginald Campbell (1949), A Dictionary of Assyrian Botany, London.
CR  - TULUM, Mertol (2011), XVII. Yüzyıl Türkçesi ve Söz Varlığı. Ankara.
CR  - VASMER, Max [Fasmer, M.] (1964-73), Ėtimologičeskij slovar› russkogo jazyka, 1-4, perevod s nemeckogo i dopolnenija O. N. Trubačeva, Moskva.
CR  - ZIMMERN, Heinrich (1917), Akkadische Fremdwörter als Beweis für babylonischen Kultureinfluss, Zweite, durch vollständige Wörterverzeichnisse vermehrte Ausgabe, Leipzig.
UR  - https://doi.org/10.26561/iutded.369175
L1  - https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/387827
ER  -