Cover Image
e-ISSN: 2458-9179

Article Withdrawal and Rejection Policy

Article Withdrawal

Preliminary Evaluation Stage

Manuscripts at this stage may be withdrawn by the author(s). The withdrawal request must be submitted in writing to the journal editorial office by the corresponding author. All authors are expected to be informed of the withdrawal request and to agree to the withdrawal.

Peer Review Stage

Authors who wish to withdraw their manuscript and publish it elsewhere due to delays in the evaluation process or for similar reasons may request withdrawal by submitting a written request to the journal editorial office. In order for the withdrawal request to be processed, all authors must be informed of the request and provide a written statement confirming their agreement to the withdrawal.

The withdrawal request is evaluated by the journal editorial office, taking into consideration the stage of the manuscript evaluation, the ongoing peer review process, and the reason for the request. If it is determined that the manuscript has been simultaneously submitted to another journal or published elsewhere while the evaluation process is still ongoing, the journal reserves the right to take the necessary editorial actions.

After Acceptance of the Manuscript

As a general rule, requests by authors to withdraw a manuscript after its acceptance will not be accepted. However, if there is a justified and exceptional scientific, ethical, or legal reason, the withdrawal request may be separately evaluated by the Editorial Board.

After acceptance of the manuscript, requests for changes in authorship, including the addition or removal of authors, will be considered subject to the written consent of all authors and an evaluation of the justification for the request. Requests for an author to withdraw from the manuscript require the written agreement of all existing authors and the author(s) affected by the proposed change.

Retraction of a Published Article

A published article may be retracted if an error or problem is identified that seriously affects the reliability of its results or conclusions. Retraction may be considered in circumstances including, but not limited to, the following:

  • The findings are unreliable due to a serious error;
  • Fabrication or falsification/manipulation of data;
  • Misleading manipulation of images or other scientific materials;
  • Plagiarism;
  • Substantial duplicate or redundant publication;
  • Unethical research practices;
  • Failure to obtain the required ethics committee approval or research permissions, or a determination that the research was ethically unacceptable;
  • Copyright infringement or other serious legal issues;
  • An undisclosed serious conflict of interest that has significantly affected the interpretation or results of the article;
  • Manipulation of or serious compromise to the peer review process;
  • Other circumstances that seriously affect the results or scientific validity of the article.

The decision to retract an article is made by the Editorial Board based, as far as possible, on the relevant evidence and necessary investigations. If there is a suspicion of research misconduct, the journal may, when necessary, request investigation and information from the relevant institution(s) or organization(s).

When an article is retracted, its bibliographic record and electronic archival record are not completely removed. The title, author information, DOI, and bibliographic details of the article are retained; however, all electronic versions of the article, including the abstract and full text, are clearly marked as “Retracted Article.”

A retraction notice is published separately and clearly, stating the reason for the retraction. An electronic link is established between the retraction notice and the original article. The retraction notice is associated with the article record in a manner that enables the article to be properly identified and indexed as a retracted publication.

Correction and Expression of Concern

If an error identified in an article does not invalidate the results or conclusions of the study but affects the accuracy of the scientific record, a Correction/Erratum may be published instead of retracting the article.

If there is a serious concern regarding a scientific or ethical issue, but the available evidence is insufficient to reach a definitive conclusion, or an investigation conducted by a relevant institution or organization has not yet been completed, an Expression of Concern may be published when deemed necessary.

Corrections and Expressions of Concern are clearly linked to the relevant article to ensure that readers are informed of changes to the scientific record or existing concerns regarding the article.

Article Rejection

Manuscripts that are not accepted for publication are communicated to the authors, with the reasons for rejection provided where possible.

A maximum of 15 days is granted for manuscripts requiring revisions during the preliminary evaluation stage.

A maximum of 30 days is granted for manuscripts requiring revisions following the evaluation process. If the authors fail to submit the required revisions within the specified periods or do not request a justified extension, the manuscript may be rejected.

A manuscript may be rejected on the basis of its lack of suitability for the journal's scope, methodological or scientific deficiencies, ethical concerns, issues regarding originality, peer review recommendations, or other editorial considerations.

Manuscript Evaluation and Acceptance Process

All manuscripts submitted to the Adıyaman University Journal of Health Sciences are handled through three stages: preliminary evaluation, scientific evaluation, and editing/typesetting. The overall process for each manuscript takes approximately 90 days, including all stages.

During the preliminary evaluation, manuscripts deemed suitable for peer review by the Editor-in-Chief and the Section Editor are evaluated by at least two experts in the relevant field.

If both reviewers provide favorable evaluations and the Section Editor approves the manuscript, the manuscript is forwarded to the Editorial Board for consideration for acceptance for publication.

If revisions are deemed necessary during the evaluation process, the requested revisions must be completed by the authors within 30 days, after which the manuscript is re-evaluated. Spelling and grammatical errors may be corrected by the Editorial Board without altering the scientific content of the manuscript.

If the manuscript is accepted, an acceptance letter is sent to the corresponding author within two weeks. The typeset PDF of the manuscript prepared prior to electronic publication is sent to the authors for final proofreading and corrections.

The journal owner and the Editorial Board are authorized to determine the issue in which an accepted manuscript will be published.

Any errors or omissions arising from the journal during the final publication process may, when deemed necessary, be corrected in the Correction (Erratum/Correction) section of a subsequent issue. This section does not cover errors that were identified by the author during the final proofreading stage but were not corrected by the author.

 

Last Update Time: August 22, 2026