Labels, Stigma Management and Social Identity Formation of a Mountain People in Central Panay, Philippines

Abstract

Throughout history, mountain dwellers in the Philippines have been attributed with a range of pejorative labels that came to stereotype and spoil the identities of mountain people collectively, including the indigenous groups in the highlands of central Panay. This paper looks into the landscape of labels and names accorded to the people and the process foregrounding the role played by “outsiders” (i.e., colonial scholars, local anthropologists, and state agencies) in the construction of identities. Ethnohistory is employed to examine the people’s social identity formation—that complex and continuous dialogue of externally-driven label constructions and articulation of internally-ascribed constructs of identities. Local narratives revealed that social identity formation in this mountain community was borne out of the locals’ need to manage the stigma of past labeling and redress misrecognition. This paper hopes to contribute to the current discourse on the sociopolitical dimension of identity formation, assertion and recognition as well as to the pool of literature on the historical experience of the mountain people of the Philippines.

Keywords

• Identity formation,labels,stigma,banditry,Panay Island

Etiketleme, Stigma Yönetimi ve Sosyal Kimlik Oluşturma: Filipinler’de Cenrtal Panay

Abstract

Tarih boyunca, Filipin dağlarında yaşayanlara, özellikle Cantral Panay’ın tepelerinde yaşayan yerel halkın içinde olduğu dağ insanlarının tamamının kimliklerini tek tipleştirip bozacak birçok küçük düşürücü ifade atfedilmiştir. Bu çalışma, bu insanlara yapıştırılan yaftaların ve isimlerin incelenmesinden ve bu süreçte “dışarıdan gelenlerin” (örn. Sömürgeci akademisyenler, yerel antropolojistler ve devlet temsilcileri) bu kimlik oluşturma sürecinde oynadıkları rolleri ön plana çıkarır. Kişilerin sosyal kimlik oluşturmalarının incelenmesinde etnik tarihten faydalanılmıştır ve kişilerin daimi olarak dışarıdan gelen etiketleme ve kendi içlerinde oluşturdukları kimliklerin çatışması incelenmiştir. Yerel anlatılar, bu dağ topluluğunda sosyal kimlik oluşumunun, yerlilerin onlara atfedilen eski etiketlerin stigma’sını yönetme ve yanlış tanımlanmayı değiştirme isteğinden ortaya çıktığını göstermiştir. Bu çalışmada hedef, kimlik oluşumu, ifadesi ve tanınması ile ilgili sosyo-politik açıdan güncel söylemlere ve Filipinlerde yaşayan dağ insanlarının tarihsel deneyimini anlatan edebi eserlere katkıda bulunmaktır. 

Keywords

• Kimlik oluşumu
• etiketleme
• stigma
• eşkıyalık
• Panay Adası

References

1. Agoncillo, Teodoro. History of the Filipino People. Quezon City: Garotech Publishing, 1990.
2. Arquiza, Yasmin. “On the Trail of the Tribal Barangay.” A Journey of Hope: Implementing the Indigenous People's Rights At of the Philippines III. 2005.
3. Barth, Fredrik. Ethnic Groups and Boundaries. Boston: Little Brown, 1969. Blair, Emma, and James Alexander Robertson. The Philippine Islands 1493-1898. Vol. 18. Cleveland: Arthur Clark Co., 1911.
4. Colin, Francisco. “Native Races and their Customs: Of the Origins of National and the People who Inhabit these Islands.” In The Philippines at the Spanish Contact. Ed. Jocano, F. Landa. Manila: MCS Enterprises, Inc., 1975. 147-187.
5. Deriada, Leoncio. “Literature Engineering in West Visayas.” UP Forum. 29 March 2000. .
6. Foreman, John. The Philippine Islands: A Political, Geographical, Social and Commercial History of the Philippine Archipelago. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1906.
7. Francisco, Mariel, and Fe Maria Ariola. History of the Burgis. Quezon City: GCF Books, 1987.
8. Jocano, F. Landa. Anthropology of the Philipino People Vo. 1. Quezon City: Punlad Research House, 2000.

9. Scott, William Henry. Barangay. Sixteenth Century Philippine Culture and Society. Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila University Press, 1994.
10. Philippine Statistics Authority. 2015.
11. Greenberg, Lawrence. “The HUKBALAHAP Insurrection: A Case Study of Successful Anti-Insurgency Operation in the Philippines, 1946-1955.” Historical Analysis Series. 1987.
12. “Indigenous People's Rights Act.” 1997. Section 1.
13. Jocano, F. Landa. Sulud Society: A Study in the Kinship System and Social Organization of a Mountain People in Central Panay. Quezon City: University of the Philippines Press, 1968.
14. Keesing, Roger. The Ethnohistory of Northern Luzon. California: Stanford University Press, 1962.
15. Loarca, Miguel de. “Relacion de Las Islas de Filipinas.” In The Philippines Island, 1493-1898. Ed. Blair, Emma, and Robertson J. Cleveland: Arthus H. Clark Co., 1903. 121-125.
16. Magos, Alicia. “Sea Episodes in Suguidanon (epic) and Boat-building Tradition in Central Panay, Philippines.” Danyag (UP Visayas Journal of the Social Sciences and the Humanities) IV.1. 1999: 5-29.
17. Manalo, Flaviano. "Tales of the Revolt from the Foot of Mt. Madia-as." Maaram Studies on Antique. 2003: 24-25.
18. Maza, R. Morales. "Antique Becomes a Province." Maaram Studies on Antique. 2003.
19. Scott, William Henry. The Discovery of the Igorot. Quezon City: New Day Publisher, 1974.
20. Smith, Robert. The HUKBALAHAP Insurgency: Economic, Political, and Military Factors. Washington, DC: Office of the Chief of Military History, 1963.
21. Taylor, Charles. Politics of Recognition. n.d. May 2019. .
22. Uckung, Peter. “The War and the General.” 4 September 2012. National Historical Commission of the Philippines. April 2019.
23. Warren, James. Iranun and Balangigi: Globalization, Maritime Raiding, and the Birth of Ethnicity. Quezon City: New Day Publisher. 2002.
24. “What the Archives Say about the Situation of the Church in 1906.” Mill Hill Digest III.2. 2005: 9.