Göçmen Suçluluğu: Doğru Soruları Sormak

Abstract

Bu makale, göçmen suçluluğuna ilişkin mevcut literatürü değerlendirerek, bu alandaki araştırmaların yöntemsel zorluklarını ve bulgularını incelemektedir. Göçmen suçluluğuna dair ilk çalışmalar genellikle göçmenlerin suç oranlarını yerlilerle karşılaştırarak yapılan araştırmalardır. Bu çalışmalar, göçmenlerin suç oranlarının yerli nüfustan daha yüksek olup olmadığını anlamaya yönelik olmuştur. Ancak bulgular coğrafi bölge ve döneme göre değişiklik göstermektedir. ABD'deki araştırmalar, göçmenlerin suç oranlarının genellikle yerli nüfustan düşük olduğunu göstermekteyken, Avrupa’daki bulgular daha karmaşık bir tablo sunmaktadır. Makale, göçmen suçluluğunu araştırmanın zorluklarına dikkat çekmektedir; bu zorluklar arasında güvenilir veri bulma, ayrımcı muamele, ve suçun karanlık sayıları yer almaktadır. Göçmen suçluluğu konusundaki en önemli literatür çalışmaları, göçmenlerin suç eğilimleri ile ilgili farklı veri kaynaklarından elde edilen bulguları analiz ederek, göçmenlerin suç oranlarının artışını veya azalışını etkileyen faktörleri ele almaktadır. Ayrıca, Avrupa’daki göçmen suçluluğu üzerine yapılan son sistematik derlemeler, çeşitli metodolojik sınırlılıkları ve uluslararası karşılaştırmaların zorluklarını da vurgulamaktadır.

Keywords

• Göçmen suçluluğu
• Yöntemsel zorluklar
• Suç oranları karşılaştırması
• Veri güvenilirliği
• Avrupa ve ABD Araştırmaları

Ethical Statement

Bu makale "Avrupa’da Göçmen Suçluluğu Üzerine Yapılan Ampirik Araştırmaların Sistematik Derlemesi" başlıklı yüksek lisans tezimden üretilmiştir.

Migrant Criminality: Asking The Right Questions

Abstract

This article presents a review of the existing literature on the topic of immigrant criminality, with a particular focus on the methodological challenges and findings of research in this area. The initial studies on immigrant criminality were predominantly conducted through a comparative approach, whereby the crime rates of immigrants were juxtaposed against those of the native population. The objective of these studies was to as certain whether the crime rates of immigrants are higher than those of the native population. However, the findings of these studies vary depending on the geographical region and period under examination. While studies conducted in the United States indicate that immigrants' crime rates are generally lower than those of the native population, findings in Europe present a more complex picture. The article identifies the challenges inherent in researching immigrant criminality, including the sourcing of reliable data, the issue of discriminatory treatment and the difficulty of quantifying the extent of criminality among migrants. The most significant studies in this field address the factors influencing the increase or decrease of migrants' crime rates by analysing findings from a range of data sources on migrants' crime trends. Furthermore, recent systematic reviews on migrant criminality in Europe also highlight various methodological limitations and the difficulties of international comparisons.

Keywords

• Immigrant Criminality
• Methodological Challenges
• Crime Rates Comparison
• Data Reliability
• European vs. American Studies

Ethical Statement

This article is derived from my master thesis titled “Systematic Review of Empirical Studies on Immigrant Criminality in Europe”.

References

1. Aebi, Marcelo F. ve Antonia Linde. “Is There a Crime Drop in Western Europe?” European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 16, sy 4 (2010): 251-277.
2. Agnew, Robert. “General Strain Theory: Current Status and Directions for Further Research”. Taking stock: The status of criminological theory içinde, düzenleyen: J. P. Wright, & K. R. Blevins F. T. Cullen, 101–123. Transaction Publishers., 2006.
3. Alonso-Borrego, César, Nuno Garoupa, Marcelo Perera, ve Pablo Vázquez. “Immigration and Crime in Spain, 1999-2006.” Fundación de Estudios de Economía Aplicada, sy 34 (2008).
4. Alonso-Borrego, César, Nuno Garoupa, ve Pablo Vázqu. “Does Immigration Cause Crime? Evidence from Spain.” American Law and Economics Review 14, sy 1 (2012): 165-191.
5. Andersen, Synøve Nygaard, ve Torbjørn Skardhamar. “Age at immigration and crime: Findings for male immigrants in Norway.” Discussion Papers 728 (Statistics Norway, Research Department.), 2012.
6. Aoki, Yu ve Yasuyuki Todo. “Are Immigrants More Likely to Commit Crimes? Evidence from France.” Applied Economics Letters 16, sy 15 (2009): 1537-1541.
7. Atak, İdil ve James C. Simeon. “Introduction: The Criminalization of Migration: Context and Consequences”. The Criminalization of Migration: Context and Consequences içinde, McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2018, 3-34.
8. Barbagli, Marzio ve Asher Colombo. “Immigrants as Authors and Victims of Crimes: the Italian Experience”. Immigration, Crime and Justice (Sociology of Crime, Law and Deviance, vol. 13 ed. W. F. Mcdonald, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 2009, 69-94.

9. Barbara, Hudson. “Discrimination and Disparity: The Influence of Race on Sentencing.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 16, sy 1 (2010): 23-34.
10. Bassetti, Thomas, Luca Corazzini ve Darwin Cortes. “Crime, Immigration and the Labor Market: A General Equilibrium Model.” ISLA Working Papers (Centre for research on Latin American Studies and Transition Economies, Universita' Bocconi), 2010.
11. Becker, Amber L. “Correlates of War? Towards An Understanding Of Nativity-Based Variation in Immigrant Offending”. European Journal of Criminology 10, sy 4 (2013): 408-423.
12. Beckley, Amber L. “Age At Immigration And Crime in Stockholm Using Sibling Comparisons.” Social Science Researh 53 (2015): 239-251.
13. Beckley, Amber L. “Deterrence Versus Marginalization: Evidence From Immigrant Offending.” Race and Justice 5, sy 3 (2015): 278-300.
14. Beckley, Amber L. “Foreign Background and Criminal Offending Among Young Males in Stockholm”. (Doktora Tezi) Stockholm: Number 37, Stockholm University, Department of Criminology, 2015.
15. Bell, Brian, Francesco Fasani ve Stephen Machin. “Crime and immigration: evidence from large immigrant waves”. The Review of Economics and Statistics 95, sy 4 (2013): 1278-1290.
16. Bell, Brian, Francesco Fasani ve Stephen Machin. “Crime and Immigration: Evidence From Large Immigrant Waves”. Review of Economics and Statistics 95, sy 4 (2013): 1278-1290.
17. Bell, Brian ve Stephen Machin. “Immigrant Enclaves And Crime”. Journal of Regional Science 53, sy 1 (2013): 118-141.
18. Bernat, Frances. Immigration and Crime. Oxford Research Encyclopedias, 2017.
19. Berry, John W. “Immigration, Acculturation, and Adaptation”. Applied Psychology (John Wiley ve Sons Ltd.) 46, sy 1 (1997): 5-34.
20. Bianchi, Milo, Paolo Buonanno ve Paolo Pinotti. “Do Immigrants Cause Crime?” Journal of the European Economic Association 10, sy 6 (2012): 1318-1347.
21. Bircan, Tuba ve Marc Hooghe. “Immigration, Diversity and Crime: an Analysis of Belgian National Crime Statistics, 2001-2006”. European Journal of Criminology 8, sy 3 (2011): 198-212.
22. Bleakley, Hoyt ve Aimee Chin. “Age at Arrival, English Proficiency, and Social Assimilation Among US Immigrants”. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 2, sy 1 (2010): 165–92.
23. Bloch, H. A. “Crime Causation: Research and Its Application”. Federal Probation 21 (1957): 11-20.
24. Blom, Martine ve Roel Jennissen. “The Involvement of Different Ethnic Groups in Various Types of Crime in the Netherlands”. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 20, sy 1 (2014): 51-72.
25. Bonifazi, Corrado ve Dante Sabatino. “Albanian Migration to Italy: What Official Data and Survey Results Can Reveal”. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 29, sy 6 (2003): 967-995.
26. Bovenkerk , Frank F. ve Tineke Fokke. “Crime Among Young Moroccan Men in the Netherlands: Does Their Regional Origin Matter?”. European Journal of Criminology 13, sy 3 (2015): 352-371.
27. Böhlmark, Anders. “Integration of Childhood Immigrants in the Short and Long Run – Swedish Evidence.” International Migration Review 43, sy 2 (2009): 387-409.
28. Butcher, Kristin F. ve Anne Morrison Piehl. “ Cross-City Evidence on the Relationship Between Immigration and Crime”. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management (1998): 457–493.
29. Butt, Junaid Sattar. “The Shadow Side of Migration—Relation Between Crime and Illegal Immigration in the Nordic Countries”. Relationes Internationales (Acta Universitatis Danubius) 17, sy 1 (2024): 47-79.
30. Büyükcoşkun Atsızelti, Nur Şirin. Avrupa'da Göçmen Suçluluğu Araştırmaları: Sistematik Derleme. Cilt İstanbul Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Arşivi Yayın No: 52. On İki Levha, 2022.
31. Card, Noel A. Applied Meta-Analysis for Social Science Research. Guilford Press, 2012.
32. Coccia, Mario, Ellen G. Cohn ve Suman Kakar. “How Immigration, Level of Unemployment and Income Inequality Affect Crime in Europe”. Crime, Law and Social Change (Advance online publication) 82 (2024): 363–385.
33. Corazzini, Luca, Darwin Cortes ve Thomas Bassetti. “Crime, Immigration and the Labor Market: A General Equilibrium Model”. ISLA Working Papers. Milano: Centre for research on Latin American Studies and Transition Economies, Universita' Bocconi, 2010.
34. Damm, Anna Piil ve Christian Dustmann. “Does Growing Up in a High Crime Neighborhood Affect Youth Criminal Behavior?”. American Economic Review 104, sy 6 (2014): 1806-1832.
35. Dustmann, Chriatian ve Ian Preston. “Comment: Estimating the Effect of Immigration on Wages”. Journal of European Economic Association 10, sy 1 (2012): 216-223.
36. Dustmann, Christian, Tommaso Frattini ve Ian P. Prest. “Christian Dustmann, Tommaso Frattini, Ian P. Preston, The Effect of Immigration along the Distribution of Wages”. The Review of Economic Studies 80, sy 1 (2013): 145–173.
37. Echauri, José Antonio, Javier Fernández-Montalvo, María Martínez ve Juana Ma Azkarate. “Effectiveness of a Treatment Programme for Immigrants Who Committed Gender-Based Violence Against Their Partners”. Psicothema 25, sy 1 (2013): 49-54.
38. Engbersen, Godfried, Joanne Van Der Leun ve Leerkes Arjen. “The Dutch Migration Regime And the Rise in Crime Among Illegal Immigrants”. Fourth Annual Conference of the European Society of Criminology, Global Similarities, Local Differences. Amsterdam. Ağustos 25-28, 2004.
39. Eraliev, Sherzod. “The Shadow Side of Migration: Exploring the Nexus between Undocumentedness, Informality and Crime among Uzbek Migrants in Sweden”. Nordic Journal of Criminology 24, sy 2 (2023): 5-24.
40. Fasani, Francesco, Giovanni Mastrobuoni, Emily G. Owens ve Paolo Pinotti. “Immigration and Crime in the United Kingdom”. Does Immigration Increase Crime? içinde, ed. F., Mastrobuoni, G., Owens, E. G., Pinotti, S., Bocconi, M. L, Fasani, Cambridge University Press, 2019, 54-90.
41. Fernández-Molina, Esther ve Raquel Bartolomé Gutiérrez. “Juvenile Crime Drop: What is Happening With Youth in Spain and Why?”. European Journal of Criminology 17, sy 3 (2018): 306-331.
42. Gottfredson, Michael R., ve Travis Hirschi. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford University Press., 1990. Hagan, John, Ron Levi ve Ronit Dinovitzer. “The Symbolic Violence of the Crime-Immigration Nexus: Migrant Mythologies in the America”. Criminology & Public Policy 7, sy 1 (2008): 95-112.
43. Hällsten, Martin, Ryszard Szulkin, ve Jerzy Sarnecki. “Crime as a Price of Inequality?: The Gap in Registered Crime between Childhood Immigrants, Children of Immigrants and Children of Native Swedes.” British Journal of Criminology 53, sy 3 (2013): 456-481.
44. Hooghe, Marc ve Thomas de Vroome. “The Relation Between Ethnic Diversity and Fear of Crime: An Analysis of Police Records and Survey Data in Belgian Communities”. International Journal of Intercultural Relations 50 (2016): 66-75.
45. Huang, Yue ve Michael Kvasnick. “Immigration and Crimes Against Natives: The 2015 Refugee Crisis in Germany”. IZA Discussion Paper Series (Institute of Labor Economics) 12469, 2019.
46. Hudson, Barbara. “Discrimination and Disparity: The Influence of Race on Sentencing”. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 16, sy 1 (2010): 23-34.
47. Ignatans, Dainis ve Roger Matthews. “Immigration and the Crime Drop”. European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice 25, sy 3 (2017): 205-229.
48. Ignatans, Dainis ve Timothy Roebuck. “Do More Immigrants Equal More Crime? Drawing a Bridge Between First Generation Immigrant Concentration and Recorded Crime Rates”. Crime, Security and Society 1, sy 1 (2018).
49. Jaitman, Laura ve Stephen Machin. “Crime and Immigration: New Evidence From England and Wales”. IZA Journal of Migration 2, sy 1 (2013): 1-23.
50. Junger-Tas, Josine. “Ethnic Minorities, Social Integration and Crime”. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 9 (2001): 5–29 .
51. Kardel, Johan ve Peter L. Martens. “Are Children of Immigrants Born in Sweden More Law-Abiding Than Immigrants? A Reconsideration”. Race and Justice 3, sy 3 (2013): 167-189.
52. Kauff, Mathias, Frank Asbrock, Christian Issmer, Stefan Thörner ve Ulrich Wagner. “When Immigrant Groups ‘Misbehave’: The Influence of Perceived Deviant Behavior on Increased Threat and Discriminatory Intentions and the Moderating Role of Right-Wing Authoritarianism”. European Journal of Social Psychology 45, sy 5 (2015): 641-652.
53. Killias, Martin, Almir Maljević ve Sonia Lucia. “Imported Violence? Juvenile Delinquency Among Balkan Youths in Switzerland and in Bosnia-Herzegovina”. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 16, sy 3 (2010): 183-189.
54. Killias, Martin ve Anastasia Lukash. “Migration, not Migrants, is the Problem: Delinquency Among Migrants and Non-Migrants in Switzerland and ex-Yugoslavia”. European Journal of Criminology (2019): 1-22.
55. Killias, Martin. “Paradise Lost? New Trends in Crime and Migration in Switzerland”. Immigration, Crime and Justice:13 (Sociology of Crime, Law and Deviance, c. 13), 2009: 33-45.
56. Kirkegaard, Emil O. W. ve Arthur Jensen In. “Crime Among Dutch Immigrant Groups is Predictable From Country-Level Variables”. Open Differential Psychology, 2015.
57. Klement, Christian. “Studies of immigrant crime in Denmark”. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention, 2019.
58. Knortz, Heike. Gastarbeiter: Bilinenin Ötesinde. İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 2011.
59. Krieg, Yvonne. “The Role of the Social Environment in the Relationship Between Group-Focused Enmity Towards Social Minorities and Politically Motivated Crime”. Köln Z Soziol 74 (2022): 65–94.
60. Kubrin, Charis E. ve Graham C. Ousey. “Exploring the Connection between Immigration and Violent Crime Rates in U.S. Cities, 1980–2000”. Social Problems 56, sy 3 (2009): 447–473.
61. Kubrin, Charis ve Graham Ousey. “Immigration and Crime: What We Know and What Remains Unknown”. Immigration and Crime: Taking Stock (2023): 47–69.
62. Lange, Martin ve Katrin Sommerfeld. “Do Refugees Impact Crime? Causal Evidence From Large-Scale Refugee Immigration to Germany”. SSRN Electronic Journal, 2023.
63. Langström, Niklas. “Accuracy of Actuarial Procedures for Assessment of Sexual Offender Recidivism Risk May Vary Across Ethnicity”. Sex Abuse 16, sy 2 (2004): 107-120.
64. Lee, Matthew T. ve Ramiro Martinez. “Immigration Reduces Crime: An Emerging Scholarly Consensus”. Immigration, Crime and Justice (Sociology of Crime, Law and Deviance, Vol. 13) ed. W.F Mcdonald, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 2009, 3-16.
65. Lee, Sharon M. ve Barry Edmonston. “Age-at-Arrival’s Effects on Asian Immigrants’ Socioeconomic Outcomes in Canada and the U.S.”. International Migration Review 45, sy 3 (2011): 527-561.
66. Leerkes, Arjen, Godfried Engbersen ve Joanne van der Leun. “Crime Among Irregular Immigrants and the Influence of Internal Border Control”. Crime, Law and Social Change 58, sy 1 (2012): 15-38.
67. Leerkes, Arjen, Ramiro Martinez ve Pim Groeneveld. “Minority Paradoxes: Ethnic Differences in Self-reported Offending and Official Crime Statistics”. The British Journal of Criminology 59, sy 1 (2019): 166-187.
68. Leerkes, Arjen, Tineke Fokkema ve Roel Jennissen. “Community Multiculturalism and Immigrant Crime”. European Journal of Criminology 20, sy 4 (2021): 1568-1593.
69. Maghularia, Rita, ve Silke Uebelmesser. “Do Immigrants Affect Crime? Evidence For Germany”. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 211 (2023): 486-512.
70. Martens, Peter ve Stina Holmberg. Crime Among Persons Born in Sweden and Other Countries. National Council for Crime Prevention, 2005, 70-77.
71. Martinez, Ramiro, Pim Groeneveld ve Arjen S. Leerkes. “Minority Paradoxes: Ethnic Differences in Self-Reported Offending and Official Crime Statistics”. The British Journal of Criminology 59, sy 1 (2019): 166-185.
72. Maxfield, Michael. “Measuring Crime”. Research Methods for Criminal Justice and Criminology içinde, Stamford: Cengage Brain, 2014, 137-166.
73. McDonald, William F. “New Takes on an Old Problematic” in Immigration, Crime and Justice (Sociology of Crime, Law and Deviance, Vol. 13) ed. W.F.. Mcdonald, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 2009, xv-xxiv.
74. Melossi, Dario, Alessandro De Giorgi ve Ester Massa. “The ‘Normality’ of ‘Second Generations’ in Italy and the Importance of Legal Status: a Self-Report Delinquency Study.” Sociology of Crime, Law and Deviance, Vol. 13) içinde, düzenleyen: W. F. Mcdonald, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 2009, 47-65.
75. Miş, Nebi. “Güvenlikleştirme Teorisi ve Siyasal Olanın Güvenlikleştirilmesi”. Akademik İncelemeler Dergisi 6, sy 2 (2014): 345-281.
76. Mohn, Sigmund Book ve Dag Ellingsen. “Unregistered Residents and Registered Crime: an Estimate for Asylum Seekers and Irregular Migrants in Norway”. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention 17, sy 2 (2016): 166-176.
77. Morenoff, Jeffrey D. ve Avraham Astor. “Immigrant Assimilation and Crime: Generational Differences in Youth Violence in Chicago”. Immigration and Crime: Race, Etnicity and Violance içinde, ed. Ramiro Martinez ve Abel Valenzuela, 2006, 36-63.
78. Nistad, Anette. “Welfare Against Crime: Can the Absence of Crime Among the Second Generation Immigrants in Sweden Bring Forward New Insights to Public Policy?”. Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Norveç: Norway Technology and Science University, 2014.
79. Nunziata, Luca. “Immigration and Crime: Evidence from Victimization Data”. Journal of Population Economics 28, sy 3 (2015): 697-736.
80. O'Nolan, Caroline. “New boundaries of justice in a world in motion : assessing the impact of global citizens in the Irish District Court”. Doktora Tezi, Dublin, Ireland: Trinity College, School of Social Work and Social Policy, 2011.
81. Ousey, Graham C. ve Charis E. Kubrin. “Immigration and Crime: Assessing a Contentious Issue”. Annual Review of Criminology 1, sy 1 (2018): 63-84.
82. Papadopoulos, Georgios. “Immigration Status and Property Crime: an Application of Estimators for Underreported Outcomes.” IZA Journal of Migration 3, sy 12 (2014).
83. Papandreou, Pericles. “Children of Immigrants in Central Athens at the Turn of the 21st Century: A study of Inferiorisation, Ethnicised Conflict, Criminalisation, and Substance Misuse.” Doktora Tezi. London School of Economics and Political Science, 2009. No: U615964.
84. Passevant, Estefanía Ocáriz ve Fernando Bermejo Marco. “Unaccompanied Foreign Minors and Delinquency: A Retrospective Study of Influence of Psychosocial Variables”. International E-Journal of Criminal Sciences 2 (2008).
85. Pereira, Miguel Basto, David P. Farrington P. Farrington ve Laura Maciel. “Unraveling the Sequences of Risk Factors Underlying the Development of Criminal Behavior”. Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology 10 (2024): 242–264.
86. Pinotti, Paolo. “Clicking on Heaven’s Door: The Effect of Immigrant Legalization on Crime”. American Economic Review 107, sy 1 (2017): 138-168.
87. Piopiunik, Marc ve Jens Ruhose. “Immigration, Regional Conditions, and Crime: Evidence from an Allocation Policy in Germany”. European Economic Review 92 (2017): 258-282.
88. Pisarevskaya, Asya, Nathan Levy, Peter Scholten ve Joost Jansen. “Mapping Migration Studies: An Empirical Analysis of The Coming of Age of A Research Field”. Migration Studies 2020: 455–481.
89. Platzer, Michael. “The Arrested Black Men in Europe: Criminal or Victim?” Rivista di Criminologia, 2007: 66-79.
90. Ring , Jonas , ve Robert Svensson. “Social Class and Criminality Among Young People: A Study Considering the Effects of School Achievement as a Mediating Factor on the Basis of Swedish Register and Self‐Report Data”. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention 8, sy 2 (2007): 210–233.
91. Roché, Sebastian ve Mike Hough. Minority Youth and Social Integration (The ISRD-3 Study in Europe and the US). Springer Cham, 2018.
92. Rumbaut, Ruben ve Walter Ewing. The Myth of Immigrant Criminality and the Paradox of Assimilation: Incarceration Rates Among Native and Foreign-Born Men. Immigration Policy Center, American Immigration Law Foundation, 2007.
93. Salmi, Venla, Janne Kivivuori ve Mikko Aaltonen. “Correlates of immigrant youth crime in Finland”. European Journal of Criminology 12, sy 6 (2015): 681-699.
94. Sandner, Malte ve Pia Wassmann. “The Effect of Changes in Border Regimes on Border Regions Crime Rates: Evidence from the Schengen Treaty”. Kyklos 71, sy 3 (2018): 482-506.
95. Siddaway, Andy P., Alex M. Wood, ve Larry V. Hed. “How to Do a Systematic Review: A Best Practice Guide for Conducting and Reporting Narrative Reviews, Meta-Analyses, and Meta-Syntheses”. Annual Review of Psychology 70 (2019): 747-770.
96. Sides, John, ve Jack Citrin. “European Opinion About Immigration: The Role of Identities, Interests and Information”. British Journal of Political Science 37, sy 3 (2007): 477-504.
97. Skardhamar, Torbjørn, Mikko Aaltonen ve Martti Lehti. “Immigrant Crime in Norway and Finland”. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention 15, sy 2 (2014): 107-127.
98. Solbak, Kristine Stubø. “Do Larger Immigrant Populations Increase Homicide Rates? A Global Study, 1995-2014”. Norway Technology and Science University, Yüksek Lisans Tezi. NTNU, 2017.
99. Solivetti, Luigi M. “Old and New Criminality: Territory, Society and Immigration in Italy”. Organized Crime, Corruption and Crime Prevention içinde, düzenleyen: Stefano Caleppele ve Francesco Calderoni, Cham: Springer, 2014, 103-114.
100. Solivetti, Luigi. “Criminality in the Countries of Western Europe.” Immigration, Social Integration and Crime içinde, Oxon: Routledge, 2010, 69-114.
101. Solivetti, Luigi. “Looking for a Fair Country: Features and Determinants of Immigrants’ Involvement in Crime in Europe”. The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 5172 (2012): 133-159.
102. Solivetti, Luigi. Immigration, Social Integration and Crime: A Cross-National Approach. Cilt 1. baskı. Oxon: Routledge-Cavendish, 2010.
103. Sporer, Karyn Sporer, Amy L. Anderson ve Johanna Peterson. “Macro- and Micro-approaches to Crime Prevention and Intervention Programs”. Preventing Crime and Violence içinde, ed. B., Bradley, M. Teasdale, Cham: Springer, 2016, 169–176.
104. Stansfield, Richard. “Reevaluating the Effect of Recent Immigration on Crime”. Crime ve Delinquency 62, sy 11 (2016): 1426-1447.
105. Tajfel, Henri ve John C. Turner. “An Integrative Theory of İntergroup Conflict”. Ed. W. G. Austin ve S. Worchel, The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations, Monterey CA: Brooks/Cole. 1979: 33-37.
106. Tidefors, Inga, Sara Ingevaldson ve Anneli Goulding. “Recidivism in Criminal Behavior-A 10 Year Follow-up Study of 45 Adolescent Boys Identified as Sex Offenders”. Nordic Psychology 71, sy 2 (2018): 93-103.
107. Tufail, Muhammad, Lin Song, Sher Ali, Salman Wahab ve Taimoor Hassan. “Does More İmmigration Lead to More Violent and Property Crimes? A Case Study of 30 Selected OECD Countries”. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja 36, sy 1 (2022): 1867–1885.
108. Uddin, Rokon. “Explaining Adolescent Offending Variety in Sweden By Parental Country Of Birth: A Test Of Situational Action Theory”. Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Malmö: Malmö University, Degree Project in Criminology, 2017.
109. Van der Gaag, Renske S. “The Crime–Immigration Nexus: Cultural Alignment and Structural Influences in Self-Reported Serious Youth Delinquent Offending Among Migrant and Native Youth”. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 35, sy 4 (2019): 431-460.
110. Veen, Violaine C., Gonneke Stevens, Theo Doreleijers ve Wilma Vollebergh. “Moroccan Adolescent Suspect Offenders in the Netherlands: Ethnic Differences in Offender Profiles”. Psychology, Crime ve Law 17, sy 6 (2011): 545-561.
111. Webb, Roger T., Sussie Antonsen, Pearl L. H. Mok, Esben Agerbo, ve Carsten B. Pedersen. “National Cohort Study of Suicidality and Violent Criminality among Danish Immigrants”. PLoS One 10, sy 6 (2015): 13-19 .
112. Wikström, Per-Olof H. “The Social Origins of Pathways in Crime. Towards a Developmental Ecological Action Theory of Crime Involvement and its Changes”. Integrated Developmental and Life-course Theories of Offending içinde, ed. D. S., Farrington, New Brunswick: Routledge, 2005.