Modern Savaşta Anti-Drone Teknolojilerinin Mevcut Rolü ve Olası Gelişmeler

Year 2019, , 691 - 711, 31.12.2019

Tolga Öz , Serkan Sert

https://doi.org/10.17752/guvenlikstrtj.668216

Cited By: 1

Abstract

Birçok bilim insanının belirttiği gibi, “Otonom dronlar, askeri teknolojide nükleer bombanın icadından bu güne en büyük buluş olarak nitelendirilmektedir. MAD doktrininin ardındaki fikir, iki tarafın da nükleer silahlarla büyük çaplı bir savaşta kazananın olmayacağı ve karşılıklı olarak yok olacağı yönündedir. Bu çıkmaz, göreceli olarak dünyayı, her şeyi kapsayan bir savaşa dönüşmekten alıkoymuştur. 1917 yılında tarihteki ilk insansız uçakla başlayan ve teknoloji ile birlikte sürekli gelişmeye devam eden dronlar 2006 yılında Amerikan Federal Havacılık Dairesi’nin ticari dron kullanılmasına ilk defa izin vermesi ile yaygınlaşmaya başladı. Buna paralel olarak akademik literatürde özellikle silahlı dronların uzun vadeli güvenlik ve istikrarı tehdit edebileceğine ilişkin dron kullanımı ile ilgili çok sayıda hipotez bulunmaktadır. Ancak, modern dronların hızla çoğalan kullanımı dünyayı hem sivil hem de askeri alanlarda açıkça daha çatışmalı bir yer haline getirme eğilimindedir. Bu husus, nükleer çatışmada MAD doktrinin aksine herhangi bir etkili çözüm bulunamamış evrensel düzeyde tanımlanamayan bir sorun olarak devam etmektedir. Bu sorunsal çerçevesinde, çalışma öncelikle giderek artan sayıda kabiliyetli dronların nasıl aşikar sorunlar yarattığı konusunda farkındalık sağlamakla birlikte literatüre en son anti-dron teknolojilerini ve araçlarını tanınması yönünde katkı yapmakta ve öngörülebilir karşı teknolojinin yol haritasını ana hatlarıyla belirlemektedir.

Keywords

Drone, Anti/Karşı Drone, Drone’ların Tespiti ve Etkisiz Hale Getirilmesi, Savunma Yönetimi

The Present Role of Anti-Drone Technologies in Modern Warfare and Projected Developments

Abstract

As by many scholars pointed out “Autonomous drones are being called the biggest thing in military technology since the nuclear bomb”. The idea behind MAD doctrine is that if both sides were to fight a full-scale war with nuclear weapons, there would be no winners and both would be mutually annihilated. This impasse has relatively kept the world from erupting into another all-encompassing war. In the matter of drones, continuing proliferation of them with their technological components that pioneered in 1917 with the first pilotless winged aircraft in history, ramped up by the first commercial drone permits by the FAA in the US recognizing the potential of non-military, non-consumer drone applications in 2006. Concordantly academic literature rather has been filled with the hypothesis of using drones; particularly armed ones can spark long term security and stability. But the snowballing use of contemporary drones is obviously inclined to make the world a more conflicting place both in civilian and military domains. This has been progressing as a worldwide pain point that there’s not been reached any forcible remedy like MAD doctrine in nuclear confrontation. Within this problematique margin, our study firstly provides awareness how growing number of increasingly capable drones in our skies poses obvious challenges. And as second, it enables the academics to familiarize recent types of counter drone technologies and instruments, and lastly outlines trajectory of counter-technology in times to come.

Keywords

Drone, Anti/Counter UAS/Drone, Detection & Neutralization of Drones, Defense Management

References

• NİKOLİĆ, Slavimir S., An innovative response to commercial UAV Menace – anti-UAV Falconry, VOJNO DELO, 4/2017, http://www.odbrana.mod.gov.rs/odbrana-stari/vojni_casopisi/arhiva/VD_2017-4/69-2017-4-14-Nikolic.pdf (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• TØNNESSEN, Truls Hallberg, “Islamic State and Technology – A Literature Review”, Perspectives on Terrorism, Vol. 11, No. 6 (December 2017), pp. 101-111.
• Agence France-Presse, “Drones becoming ‘real’ threat to commercial aviation: IATA”,
• Anti-Drone Website “Anti-drone system overview and technology comparison”, https://anti-drone.eu/blog/anti-drone-publications/anti-drone-system-overview-and-technology-comparison.html (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• ASHOK, India, “Drone crash: Rogue UAV knocks out power line causing widespread blackout”, https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/drone-crash-rogue-uav-knocks-out-power-line-causing-widespread-blackout-1625876 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• BEEL, Joseph J., Anti-Uav Defense Requirements For Ground Forces And Hypervelocity Rocket Lethality Models”, March 1992, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California. http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a252727.pdf (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• CLARKE, Colin P., “A Terrorist's Dream: How Twitter and Toy Drones Could Kill a Lot of People”, https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/terrorists-dream-how-twitter-toy-drones-could-kill-lot-26288 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• Dedrone Website, “Worldwide Drone Incidents”, https://www.dedrone.com/resources/incidents/all (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• Haber46 Website, “Anıtkabir töreninde drone paniği, askerler çekim yapan aracı vuracaktı”, https://www.haber46.com.tr/politika/anitkabir-toreninde-drone-panigi-askerler-cekim-yapan-araci-vuracakti-h116581.html (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• HEGNARES, Jon, “The Past, Present And Future Of Anti-Drone Tech”, https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2018/01/26/the-past-present-and-future-of-anti-drone-tech/ (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• HEIDEN, Rene Van Der, “NCI Agency helps protect NATO operations against drone attacks”, https://www.ncia.nato.int/NewsRoom/Pages/180529-Drone.aspx (Access Date:17.01.2019)
• HENNİGAN, W.J., ”Experts Say Drones Pose a National Security Threat — and We Aren’t Ready”, www.time.com/5295586/drones-threat/ (Access Date:17.01.2019)
• http://2016.mb.com.ph/2016/02/15/drones-becoming-real-threat-to-commercial-aviation-iata/#rbZIqrCDIsztMMKl.99 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• Hürriyet Daily News Website “PKK’s bomb-laden drone seized in Turkey’s east”, http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/pkks-bomb-laden-drone-seized-in-turkeys-east-122299 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• Hürriyet Website, “Atatürk Havalimanı’nda Drone için tabelalı önlem”, www.hurriyet.com.tr/video/ataturk-havalimaninda-drone-icin-tabelali-onlem-122501 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• JOULİA, Antoine, Thomas Dubot ve Judicael Bedouet, “Towards a 4D Traffic Management Of Small UAS Operating At Very Low Level”, www.icas.org/ICAS_ARCHIVE/ICAS2016/data/papers/2016_0064_paper.pdf (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• KELLY, Erin, “Venezuela drone attack: Here's what happened with Nicolas Maduro”, https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/08/06/venezuela-drone-attack-nicolas-maduro-assassination-attempt-what-happened/913096002/ (Access Date:17.01.2019)
• KMIA, Oliver, “The Technical and Legal Challenges of Anti-Drone Systems”, https://fstoppers.com/aerial/technical-and-legal-challenges-anti-drone-systems-193666 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• MARTİN, David, “New Generations of Drones set to Revolutionize Warfare”, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-autonomous-drones-set-to-revolutionize-military-technology/ (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• MİCHEL, Arthur Holland, “Counter-Drone Systems.”, Center for the Study of the Drone at Bard College, February 20, 2018, http://dronecenter.bard.edu/counter-drone-systems/ (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• NCI Agency, “Notification of Intent to Invite Bids”, https://www.ncia.nato.int/Industry/Documents/NOI-IFB-CO-14685-UAS_Notification%20of%20Intent.pdf (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• PR News Wire Website "Counter-Drone Market & Technologies – 2018-2023", published by Homeland Security Research Corp., https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/the-global-counter-drone-market-is-forecast-to-grow-at-a-2018-2023-cagr-of-37-2-300710320.html (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• RT Website, “Unidentified drones flying over French nuclear power plants, probe launched”, https://www.rt.com/news/200887-france-drones-nuclear-plants/ (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• SZOLDRA, PAUL, “This is everything Edward Snowden revealed in one year of unprecedented top-secret leaks”, https://www.businessinsider.com/snowden-leaks-timeline-2016-9 (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• The Economist, “Home-made drones now threaten conventional armed forces”, https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2018/02/08/home-made-drones-now-threaten-conventional-armed-forces (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• The Guardian Website, “Pakistan releases 'father' of nuclear bomb from house arrest”, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/feb/06/nuclear-pakistan-khan (Access Date: 17.01.2019).
• UK Progressive Website, “The flying of unauthorized drones at stadiums prompts safety concerns”, https://ukprogressive.co.uk/the-flying-of-unauthorized-drones-at-stadiums-prompts-safety-concerns/article32097.html (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• VANIAN, Jonathan, “Drones Are Still Flying Dangerously Close to Airplanes and Airports”, http://fortune.com/2016/03/28/drones-flying-too-close-airplanes-airports/ (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• Yeniçağ Gazetesi Website, “Yeniçağ: IŞİD, Drone ile Mehmetçiğe saldırdı!”, http://www.yenicaggazetesi.com.tr/isid-drone-ile-mehmetcige-saldirdi-147012h.htm (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• YYVER, Kelly, “A Future Full of Drones — and the Advanced Threats They Present”, https://securityintelligence.com/a-future-full-of-drones-and-the-advanced-threats-they-present/ (Access Date:17.01.2019).
• ZWİJNENBURG, Wim, “Terrorist Drone Attacks Are Not a Matter of ‘If’ but ‘When’”, https://www.newsweek.com/drones-isis-terrorist-attacks-453867 (Access Date:17.01.2019).