Decapitation Applications and Interpretation in the Light of Archaeological Sources and Historical Data

Year 2024, Issue: 51, 199 - 220, 30.06.2024

Serdar Özbilen

https://doi.org/10.21497/sefad.1343627

Abstract

Decapitation refers to the deliberate or accidental separation of the head from the body. When attached to the body, the head is easily recognizable as an individual who probably has many roles and identities in society. The decapitation is obviously a complex phenomenon in many ways, as a transition into a symbolic space. The separation of the head from the body in a sense creates a new life for this part of the human form. For this reason, we can see that decapitation practices have existed starting from prehistory, and the meanings attributed to it have changed from society to society. It is really difficult to answer the questions of how to interpret the peri-mortem and post-mortem practices, which vary according to the place and geography they are exercised. In particular, it is much more difficult to interpret the decomposed prehistoric skulls in comparison to the examples from the same historical period. For this reason, archaeology should be in cooperation with disciplines such as anthropology, bio-archaeology and ethnography with an interdisciplinary method. This study presents an investigation of the available evidence about disembodied heads in the light of archaeological sources and historical data, both from prehistoric and historical periods to the present, as well as discussions about whatbeheading and disrupting the integrity of the human form in these cultures mean.

Keywords

Decapitation practices, Ancient Near East, Çatalhöyük, Neo-Assyria, violence

Arkeolojik Kaynaklar ve Tarihsel Veriler Işığında Kafa Kesme Uygulamaları ve Yorumlanması

Abstract

Dekapitasyon, başın vücuttan kasıtlı veya kazara ayrılmasını ifade eder. Vücuda eklendiğinde, kafa, toplumda muhtemelen birçok rol ve kimliğe sahip olan bir birey olarak kolayca tanınabilir. Başın kesilmesi, sembolik bir alana geçiş şeklinde pek çok açıdan karmaşık bir olgudur. Başın vücuttan ayrılması, bir anlamda insan formunun bu kısmı için yeni bir yaşam oluşturur. Bu nedenle baş kesme uygulamalarının tarih öncesinden başlayarak tarih boyunca var olduğunu ve buna dair yüklenilen anlamların toplumdan topluma değiştiğini görebilmekteyiz. Bağlı bulunan mekân ve coğrafyaya göre değişkenlik arz eden peri-mortem (ölüm öncesi) ve post-mortem (ölüm sonrası) uygulamaların nasıl yorumlanması gerektiği şeklindeki soruları yanıtlamak gerçekten de zordur. Özellikle bedenden ayrıştırılmış tarih öncesi kafataslarını tarihi devir örneklerine göre yorumlamak çok daha zordur. Sadece arkeolojik veriler ışığında, "kafatası kültü" olarak adlandırılan şey içinde, neyin cenaze ve neyin ganimet olduğunu ayırt etmek imkânsızdır. Bu nedenle arkeolojinin disiplinler arası metot ile antropoloji, biyo-arkeoloji ve etnografya gibi bilim dallarıyla iş birliği halinde olması gerekmektedir. Bu çalışma, arkeolojik kaynaklar ve tarihsel veriler ışığında hem tarih öncesi hem de tarihi devirlerden günümüze kadar bedensiz kafalar hakkında mevcut kanıtların bir araştırmasını, hem de bu kültürlerde kafa kesmenin ve böylece insan formunun bütünlüğünü bozmanın ne anlama geldiğine dair tartışmaları sunmaktadır.

Keywords

Kafa kesme uygulamaları, Eski Yakın Doğu, Çatalhöyük, Yeni Asur, şiddet

References

• Agoston, G. & Masters, B. (2009). Encyclopedia of the Ottoman empire. Infobase Publishing.
• Aguilar-Moreno, M. (2006). Handbook to life in the Aztec world. Facts on File.
• Ataç, M. A. (2018). Art and immortality in the ancient near east. Cambridge University Press.
• Bahrani, Z. (2003). The graven image: representation in Babylonia and Assyria. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
• Bahrani, Z. (2004). The king’s head. Iraq, 66, 115-119.
• Breniquet, C. (2002). Animals in Mesopotamian art. J. Collins (Ed.), History of the animal world in the ancient near east içinde (s. 145-168). Leiden-Boston-Köln: Brill.
• ARAB II: D. D. Luckenbill. (1926-1927). Ancient records of Assyrian and Babylonia II, Chicago.
• Bonatz, D. (2005). Ashurbanipal’s headhunt: an anthropological perspective. Iraq, 66, 93-101.
• Bonatz, D. (2017). Der stumme schrei – kritische überlegungen zu emotionen als untersuchungsfeld der altorientalischen bildwissenschaft. S. Kipfer (Ed.), Visualizing emotions in the ancient near east içinde (s. 55-74). Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht Göttingen: Academic Press Fribourg.
• Barjamovic, G. (2012). Mesopotamian empires. P. F. Bang & W. Scheidel (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of the state in the ancient near east and mediterranean içinde (s. 120-160). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Borger, R. (1956). Die inschriften Asarhaddons, königs von Assyrien. Archiv für orientforschung, beiheft.
• Carrasco, D. & Sessions, S. (1998). Daily life of the Aztecs: people of the sun and earth. The Greenwood Press.
• Clare, L., Dietrich, O. & Gresky, J. (2019). Ritual practices and conflict mitigation at early neolithic Körtik tepe and Göbekli tepe, upper Mesopotamia: a mimetic theoretical approach. I. Hodder (Ed.), Violence and the sacred in the ancient near east: girardian conversation at Çatalhöyük içinde (s. 96-128). Cambridge University Press.
• Collins, P. (2016). The face of the Assyrian empire: mythology and the heroic king. J. Aruz & M. Seymour (Ed.), Assyria to Iberia: art and culture in the iron age içinde (s. 42-53). New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
• Curtis, J. E. & Reade, J. E. (1995). Art and empire: treasures from Assyria in the British Museum. British Museum Press.
• Deacy, S., Hanesworth, P. & Hawes, G. (2016). Beheading the gorgon: myth, symbolism and appropriation. S. Goffredo & Z. Dubinsky (Ed.), The cnidaria, past, present and future: the world of medusa and her sisters içinde (s. 823-834). Springer.
• Deal, W. E. (2006). Handbook to life in medieval and early modern Japan. Facts On File Publishing.
• Dicesare, C. R. (2009). Sweeping the way: divine transformation in the Aztec festival of ochpaniztli. University Press of Colorado.
• Dolce, R. (2004). The head of the enemy in the sculptures from the palaces of Nineveh: an example of "cultural migration"?. Iraq, 66, 121-132.
• Dolce, R. (2016). The “losing one’s head”. Some hints on procedures and meanings of decapitation in the ancient near east. L. Battini (Ed.), Making pictures of war: realia et imaginaria in the iconology of the ancient near east içinde (s. 45-56). Archaeopress.
• Dolce, R. (2018). “Losing one’s head” in the ancient near east interpretation and meaning of decapitation. Routledge.
• Elayi, J. (2017). Sargon II, king of Assyria. Abs no 22, Atlanta: SBL Press.
• Erdal, Y. S. (2014). Bone or flesh: defleshing and post-depositional treatments at Kortik tepe (southeastern Anatolia, ppna period). European Journal of Archaeology, 18, 4–32.
• Fetvacı, E. (2018). Ottoman author portraits in the early-modern period. K. Rizvi (Ed.), Affect, emotion, and subjectivity in early modern muslim empires: new studies in Ottoman, Safavid, and Mughal art and culture içinde (s. 66-94). Leiden-Boston: Brill.
• Fitzsimmons, J. L. (2009). Death and the classic Maya kings. University of Texas Press.
• Foster, L. V. (2002). Handbook to life in the ancient Maya world. Facts On File.
• Frame, G. (2007). Babylonia 689-627 BC: a political history. Leiden.
• Frayne, D. & Stuckey, J. H. (2021). A handbook of gods and goddesses of the ancient near east: three thousand deities of Anatolia, Syria, Israel, Sumer, Babylonia, Assyria, and Elam. Pennsylvania: Eisenbrauns.
• Gilibert, A. (2018). Teʾumman’s last supper. Geburtstags herausgegeben von Kai Kaniuth, Daniel Lau und Dirk Wicke marru 1 içinde (s. 289-308). Münster.
• Glassner, J. J. ( 2004). Mesopotamian chronicles. Atlanta.
• Grayson, A. K. (2006). The Assyrian and Babylonian empires and other states of the near east, from the eighth to the sixth centuries BC. The Cambridge ancient history. Vol. III part 2. Cambridge University Press.
• Gresky, J., Haelm, J. & Clare, L. (2017). Modified human crania from Göbekli Tepe provide evidence for a new form of Neolithic skull cult. Sci. Adv., 2017; 3, 1-10.
• Hodder, I. (2009). An archaeological response. Paléorient, 35 (1), 109-111.
• Hodder, I. (2010). Probing religion at Çatalhöyük: an interdisciplinary experiment. I. Hodder (Ed.), Religion in the emergence of civilization: Çatalhöyük as a case içinde (s. 1–31). Cambridge University Press..
• Hodder, I. & Meskell, L. (2010). The symbolism of Çatalhoyuk in its regional context. I. Hodder (Ed.), Religion in the emergence of civilization: Çatalhöyük as a case içinde (s. 32–72). Cambridge University Press.
• Hodder, I. & Meskell, L. (2011). A curious and sometimes a trifle macabre artistry: some aspects of symbolism in neolithic Turkey. Current Anthropology, 52 (2), 235–263.
• Houston, S., Stuart, D. & Taube, K. (2006). The memory of bones: body, being, and experience among the classic Maya. University of Texas Press.
• Hunt, A. M. W. (2015). Palace ware across the Neo-Assyrian imperial landscape. Social value and semiotic meaning. Culture and history of the ancient near east. Volume 78. Leiden, Boston.
• Inman, T. (2004). Ancient pagan and modern Christian symbolism. Celephaïs Press.
• İnalcık, H. (1994). An economic and social history of the Ottoman empire Vol I. Cambridge University Press.
• Kanjou, Y., Kujit, I. & Erdal, Y. S. (2015). Early human decapitation, 11,700–10,700 cal bp, within the pre-pottery neolithic village of Tell Qaramel, North Syria. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 743–752.
• Kaçmaz Levent, E. (2022). Yeni Assurda bir şiddet politikası unsuru olarak “kafa kesme” üzerine bir değerlendirme. 2nd International Archeology, Art,History And Cultural Heritage Congress (The Proceedıngs Book) (September 09-11, 2022) Şanlıurfa, 60-77.
• Kuijt, I. (2009). Neolithic skull removal: enemies, ancestors, and memory, Paléorient, 35(1), 117– 120.
• Liverani, M. (2004). Myth and politics in ancient near eastern historiography. London: Equinox Publishing Ltd.
• Liverani, M. (2014). The ancient near east. History, society and economy. Routledge.
• Livingstone, D. N. (2008). Adam’s ancestors: race, religion, and the politics of human origins. The Johns Hopkins University Press.
• López Austin, A. (1988). The human body and ideology: concepts of the ancient Nahuas. Vol. 1. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
• Mellaart, J. (1967). Çatal Hüyük: a neolithic town in Anatolia. McGraw-Hill Company. Thames and Hudson.
• Meskell, L. (2017). The archaeology of figurines and the human body in prehistory. The Oxford Handbook of Prehistoric Figurines, 1-21.
• Moses, S. (2012). Sociopolitical implications of neolithic foundation deposits and the possibility of child sacrifice: a case study at Çatalhöyük, Turkey. A. M. Porter & G. M. Schwartz (Ed.), Sacred killing the archaeology of sacrifice in the ancient near east içinde (s. 57-77). Winona Lake, Indiana: Eisenbrauns.
• Nikolic, V., Savic, S. & Antunoviç, V. (2017). Decapitation in reality and fine art: a review. Forensic Science International, 280, 103–112.
• Novotny, J. & Watanabe, C. E. (2008). After the fall of Babylon: a new look at the presentation scene on Assurbanipal relief bmme 124945-6. Iraq, 70, 105-125.
• Ocak, A. Y. (1989). Türk folklorunda kesik baş. Ankara: Türk Kültürünü Araştırma Enstitüsü Yayınları.
• Parıltı, U. & Yücel, Ç. (2019). Anadolu prehistoryasinda insan kurbanı ve mitolojik hikayelere yansıması. International Symposium on Mythology, Ardahan, 920-938.
• Parpola, S. (1997). Assyrian prophecies. State archives of Assyria IX. Helsinki University Press.
• Pearson, M. P. (1982). Mortuary practices, society and ideology: an ethnoarchaeological study. I. Hodder (Ed.), Symbolic and structural archaeology içinde (s. 99-113). Cambridge University Press.
• Pongratz-Leisten, B. (2007). Ritual killing and sacrifice in the ancient near east. K. Finsterbusch, A. Lange & K. F. D. Römheld (Ed.), Human sacrifice in Jewish and Christian tradition (içinde (s. 3-33). Leiden-Boston: Brill.
• Rede, M. (2018). The image of violence and the violence of the image: war and ritual in Assyria (ninth - seventh centuries bce). Varia Historia, Belo Horizonte, 34 (64), 81-121.
• RIMA II; Grayson, A. K. (1991). Assyrian rulers of the first millenium (1114-859 BC). Toronto-Buffalo-London.
• RIMA III; Grayson, A. K. (1996). Assyrian rulers of the early first millenium BC II (858-745 BC). Toronto-Buffalo-London.
• Schaudig, H. (2012). Death of statues and rebirth of gods. N. N. May (Ed.), Iconoclasm and text destruction in the ancient near east and beyond içinde (s. 123-149). Chicago, Illinois.
• Scherer, A. K. (2015). Mortuary landscapes of the classic Maya: rituals of body and soul. University of Texas Press.
• Schulting, R. J. (2015). Mesolithic skull cults?. K. von Hackwitz & R. Peyroto-Stjerna (Ed.), Ancient death ways: proceedings of the workshop on archaeology and mortuary practices içinde (s. 19-46). Uppsala Universitet.
• Seri, A. (2012). The role of creation in enūma eliš. Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions, 12((1), 4-29.
• Sugiyama, S. (2005). Human sacrifice, militarism, and rulership: materialization of state ideology at the feathered serpent pyramid, Teotihuacan. Cambridge University Press.
• Sugie, T. (2014). The reception of the Marduk prophecy in seventh-century b.c. Nineveh. Orient, 49, 107-113.
• Suarez, A. C. & George, J. J. (2011). Handbook to life in the Inca world. Facts On File.
• Talalay, L. (2004). Heady business: skulls, heads and decapitation in neolithic Anatolia and Greece. Journal of Mediterannean Archaeology, 17(2), 139–163.
• Testart, A. (2008). Des crânes et des vautours ou la guerre oubliée. Paléorient, 34(1), 35–58.
• Thomas, J. (2000). Death, identity, and the body in neolithic Britain. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 6, 653-68.
• Tiesler, V. (2007). Funerary or nonfunerary? new references in identifying ancient Maya sacrificial and postsacrificial behaviors from human assemblages. V. Tiesler & A. Cucina (Ed.), New perspectives on human sacrifice and ritual body treatments in ancient Maya society içinde (s. 14-44). Springer Publishing.
• Toro, B. (2014). The pax Assyiıaca: an example of historical evolution of civilisations. A Thesis Submitted to the University of Birmingham for the Degree of PhD Classics, Ancient History and Archaeology FT.
• Tracy, L. & Massey, J. (2012). Introduction. L. Tracy & J. Massey (Ed.), Heads will roll: decapitation in the medieval and early modern imagination içinde (s. 3-13). Leiden-Boston: Brill.
• Ünal, A. (2005). Hititler devrinde Anadolu III. İstanbul: Arkeoloji ve Sanat Yayınları.
• Watanabe, C. E. (2004). The "continuous style" in the narrative scheme of Assurbanipal's Reliefs. Iraq, 66, 103-114.
• Watanabe, C. E. (2008). A compositional analysis of the battle of Til-Tuba. H. Kühne, R. M. Czichon & F. J. Kreppner (Ed.), Proceedings of the 4. international congress of the archaeology of the ancient near east içinde (s. 601-612). Harrasowitz Verlag-Wiesbaden.
• Watanabe, C. E. (2014). Styles of pictorial narratives in Assurbanipal’s Reliefs. B. A. Brown & M. H. Feldman (Ed.), Critical approaches to ancient near eastern art içinde (s. 345-367). De Gruyter.
• Winter, I. J. (2010). On art in the ancient near east vol. II from the third millennium b.c.e. Leiden-Boston: Brill.
• Wiseman, R. (2021). Extreme justice: decapitations and prone burials in three late Roman cemeteries at Knobb’s farm Cambridgeshire. Britannia, 119-173.