Bottle Shaped Vessels in Anatolia and the Syrian Bottle

Yıl 2018, Sayı: 21, 56 - 75, 20.12.2018

Esra Alp

Öz

3rd millennium BC is a very important period in which relations
between Anatolia and Syria-Mesopotamia intensified and impacted the development
of civilizations directly. With these relations, trade activities increased and
new pottery vessel types resulting from intercultural interaction appeared. One
of these vessel types consists of 'Bottle' shaped vessels used for keeping and
transporting liquid materials. In this period Syrian Bottles, which are
distinguished from these vessel types by their form and labeling, have been a
noteworthy group and in this context the issue of their import from N. Syria to
Anatolia and why they were labeled as such has often been discussed.

However, what is essentially thought-provoking about the
Anatolian bottle shape repertoire is that relevant publications discuss these
vessels using general definitions such as 'Bottle', 'Syrian bottle' or 'Alabastron'
without establishing a typology within the group; that is, whether Anatolia had
a bottle form of its own.

A secondary question about these vessel
forms that are generally considered to be imported is whether Anatolia was
familiar with bottle shaped vessels before Syrian bottles, or whether it also
had original forms within its own vessel repertoire that were used together
with the aforementioned imported forms.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Anatolia, Syria, Bottle, Syrian Bottle

Kaynakça

• Abay, E.: 1997 Keramik der Frühbronzezeit in Anatolien mit Syrichen Affinitäten, Münster. Al-Maqdissi, M. and M. Yabroudi.: 1987 ‘Chronique Archéologique Syria. Poterie du Bronze Ancien IV de la Vallée de l’Oronte’, Syria 64 : 291-295. Algaze, G. et al.: 1995 Titriş Höyük. A Small EBA Urban Center in Southeastern Anatolia: The 1994 Season’, Anatolica 21/XXI: 13-64. Algaze,G., M. A. Evins, M. L. Ingraham, L. Marfoe and K ., A., Yener: 1990 Town and Country inSoutheastern Anatolia II: The Stratigraphic sequence at Kurban Höyük. Chicago. Ay, E., M. Kibaroğlu and C. Berthold: 2014 ‘A multi-analytical approach to characterize an Early Bronze Age cosmetic material from Müslümantepe, Southeastern Anatolia, Springer, june, vol. 6/2, 125-131. Blegen, C., and Caskey, J. L. et al: 1951 Troy. The Third, Fourth And Fifth Settlements, II, Princeton. Braidwood, R. J. and L. S. Braidwood: 1960 Excavations in the Plain of Antioch I: The Earlier Assemblages, Phases A-J. Chicago. Conti, A., M. and C. Persiani: 1993 ‘When Worlds Collide. Cultural Developments in Eastern Anatolia in the Early Bronze Age’, M. Frangipane et al. (eds.), Between the Rivers and over the Mountains. Archaeologica Anatolica et Mesopotamica. Alba Palmieri Dedicata. Rome: 361-413. Duru, R.: 2003 Unutulmuş Bir Başkent: Tilmen, İstanbul. 2010 Gedikli Karahöyük II. Prof. Dr. U. Bahadır Alkım’ın Yönetiminde 1964–1967 Yıllarında Yapılan Kazıların Sonuçları (The Results of Excavations Directed by Prof.Dr. U. Bahadır Alkım Between 1964–1967), Ankara. Efe, T.: 1999 ‘Küllüoba 1997 Yılı Kazısı XX’, KST I Ankara, 165-181. Emre, K.: 1999 ‘Syrian Bottles From the Karum of Kanish. In: H.I.H. Prince Takahito Mikasa (ed.), Essays on Ancient Anatolia. Bulletin of the Middle Eastern Culture Center in Japan 11, Wiesbaden, 39-50. Engin, A. : 2007 “The Carchemish region as a ceramic province in the Early Bronze Age: analysis of the ceramics from the Carchemish Dam focusing on the material of Gre Virike”, Euphrates Valley Settlement. The Carchemish Sector in the Third Millennium BC (ed. E. Peltenburg), Oxford, 267-285.
• Ensert, H., K.: 1995 ‘Erken Tunç Çağı Güneydoğu Anadolu ve Kuzey Suriye Bölgesi Ölü Gömme Gelenekleri Işığında Oylum Höyük Mezarları’ Ankara (Hacettepe University, Unpublished PhD thesis). Erkanal, A.: 1993 Anadolu’da Bulunan Suriye Kökenli Mühürler ve Mühür Baskıları, Ankara. Falb, C., A., Porter ve A. Pruß: 2014 “North Mesopotumian Metallic Ware, Jezirah Stone Ware, North Mesopotamian Grey Ware and Euphrates Banded Wares”, Associated Regional Chronologies for the Ancient Near East and Eastern Mediterranean, Interregional vol. I: Ceramics (ed: M. Lebeau), Turnhout, 171-200.
• Fielden, K.: 1977 'Tell Brak 1976: The Pottery', Iraq 39: 245-55. Fugmann, E.: 1958 Hama II/1. Fouilles et Recherches 1931-1938. L’architecture des Periods Pre-Hellenistiques. Copenhague. Goldmann, H.: 1956 Excavations at Gözlükule,Tarsus Vol I-II. From the Neolithic through the Bronze Age, Princeton. Hauptmann, H.: 1969/70 ‘Norşuntepe. Historische Geographie und Ergebnisse der Grabungen 1968/69’, Ist. Mitt. 19/20: 21-78. 1981 ‘Lidar Höyük 1981’ TAD XXVI-2: 93-110. 2000 ‘Zur Chronologie des 3. Jahrtausends v. Chr. Am oberen Euphrat Aufgrund der Stratigraphie des Norşuntepe’, Chronologies des Pays du Causase et de L’euphrate aux IV-III Millenaries. Paris. 419-438. Holland, T., A.: 1976 ‘ Preliminary Report on Excavations at Tell Sweyhat, Syria, 1973–4’, Levant 8: 36–70. Kampschulte, I. and W. Orthmann: 1984 Gräber des 3. Jt.v. Chr. im Syrischen Euphrattal.Ausgrabungen bei Tawi 1975 und 1978. Bonn. Kepinski-Lecomte, C. and R. Ergeç: 2000 ‘Tilbeshar 1999. Occupations de la vallée du Sajour de la fin du Chalcolithique au Bronze Moyen’, Anatolia Antiqua 8, 215-225. Kıcı, M.: 1999 ‘Tilmen Höyük Çanak Çömleği II 2. Binyıl ve Daha Geç Dönemler’, İstanbul (Istanbul University, Unpublished M.A. thesis). Kontani, R.: 1995 ‘Relations Between Kültepe and Northern Syria During the Third Millennium BC’, BAOM XVI: 109-142. Kühne, H.: 1976 Die Keramik vom Tell Chūera und ihre Beziehungen zu Funden aus Syrien-Palästina, der Türkei un dem Iraq, Berlin. Lebeau, M.: 2000 ‘Stratified Archaeological Evidence and Compared Periodizations in the Syrian Jezirah During the Third Millennium BC’, Chronologies des Pays du Causase et de L’euphrate aux IVͤͤ ͤ -IIIͤ Millenaries, Paris, 167-192. Lesthakov, K.: 2002 ‘Galabovo Pottery and a New Synchronisation for the Bronze Age in Upper Thrace with Anatolia’ Anatolica 28, 171-211. 1996 ‘Trade Centres in the Early Bronze Age III and Middle Bronze Age in Upper Thrace (On the Interpretation of Baa dere - Konstantia - Galabovo)’, RPRP, Vol.1, Part2, Sofia, 239-287. Lloyd, S.and J. Mellaart: 1962 Beycesultan. I , The Chalcolithic and Early Bronze Age Levels, London. Mallowan, M., E.: 1937 ‘The Excavations at Tell Chagar Bazar and an Archaeological Survey of the Habur Region. Second Campaign’, Iraq 4: 91-177. Mazzoni, S. : 1985 ‘Elements of the Ceramic Culture of Early Syrian Ebla in Comparison with Syro-Palestinian EB IV’, BASOR 257: 1-18. Mellink, M., J.: 1965 “Anatolian Chronology”, Chronologies in Old World Archaeology, (Ed. R. W. Ehrich): 101-131. 1982 ‘Archaeology in Asia Minor’, AJA 86: 557-576. Ökse, A., T.: 2001 ‘Gre Virike 1999 Kazısı’, N.Tuna et al (eds.), Ilısu ve Karkamış Baraj Gölleri Altında Kalacak Arkeolojik ve Kültür Varlıklarını Kurtarma Projesi 1999 Yılı Çalışmaları. Ankara: 263-307. 2004 ‘Suriye Şişeleri ‘nin Taşınma Biçimlerine İlişkin Yeni Bir Bulgu’ Belleten LXVIII, 599-612. Orthmann, W. : 1981 Halawa 1977-1979. Vorläufiger Bericht über die 1.bis 3. Grabungskampagne, Bonn. Orthmann, W. and E. Rova: 1991 Gräber des 3. Jt.v. Chr. im Syrischen Euphrattal 2.Ausgrabungen in Wreide, Bonn. Özgen, E., B. Helwing and H. Tekin: 1997 ‘Vorläufiger Bericht über die Ausgrabungen auf dem Oylum Höyük’, Ist. Mitt. 47: 39-90. Özgüç, T.: 1986 ‘New Observations on the Relationship of Kültepe with Southeast Anatolia and North Syria during the Third Millenium B.C.’, In: Canby, J. V., Porada,E., Sismondo Ridgway, B., Stech , T. (Eds.), Ancient Anatolia. Aspects of Change and Cultural Development. Essays in Honour of Machteld J. Mellink, Wisconsin, 31-47. Parrot, A.: 1956 Le Temple D’Ishtar. Mission Archéologique de Mari 1. Paris. Parzinger, H.: 1993 Studien zur Chronologie und Kulturgeschichte des Jungstein-Kupfer- und Frühbronzezeit zwischen Karpaten und Mittlerem Taurus, Mainz. Podzuweit, C.: 1979 Trojanische Gefäßformen der Frühbronzezeit inAnatolien, der Ägäis und angrenzenden Gebieten, Mainz. Porter, A.: 1995 ‘Tell Banat-Tomb I’, Damazsener Mitteilungen 8: 1-50. Prag, K.: 1970 ‘The Deep Sounding at Harran in Turkey’ Levant 2: 63-94. Pruß, A.: 2000 ‘The Metallic Ware of Upper Mesopotamia: Definition Chronology and Distribution’, C. Marro ve H. Hauptmann (eds.), Chronologies des Pays du Causase et de L’euphrate aux IVͤͤ ͤ -IIIͤ Millenaries, Paris, 193-203. Roodenberg, J., J.: 1979-80 ‘Premiers Resultats des Recherches Archeologıques a Hayaz Höyük’, Anatolica VII: 3-19. Sagona, A., M., Erkmen, C. Sagona, and I. Thomas: 1996 ‘Excavations at Sos Höyük, 1995. Second Preliminary Report’, AS 46: 27-52. Sayit, F. N.: 2006 ‘1959-1972 Dönemi Tilmen Höyük Kazılarında Bulunmuş Olan İlk Tunç Çağı Çanak Çömleği [The Early Bronze Age Pottery of Tilmen Höyük, Excavated in 1959-1972]’, İstanbul (Istanbul University, Unpublished M.A. thesis). Schachner, Ş. and A. Schachner: 1995 ‘Eine ‘Syrische’ Flasche aus Fara’, MDOG 127: 83-96. Sconzo, P.: 2007 “Plain and luxury wares of the third millennium BC in the Carchemish region: two case-studies from Tell Shiyukh Tahtani’ in Peltenburg, E. (ed.), Euphrates River Valley Settlement: The Carchemish sector in the third millennium BC, Oxford, 250-266. 2014 “Syrian Bottles”, Associated Regional Chronologies for the Ancient Near East and Eastern Mediterranean, Interregional vol. I: Ceramics (ed: M. Lebeau), Turnhout, 215-236.
• Schwartz, G., M.: 1988 A Ceramic Chronology from Tell Leilan: Operation 1, New Haven/London. Spanos, P., Z.: 1972 Untersuchung über den bei Homer 'depas amphikypellon' genannten Gefäßtypus, Tübingen. Spanos, P., Z. and E. Strommenger: 1993 ‘Zu den Beziehungen zwischen Nordwest Anatolien und Nordsyrien / Nordmesopotamien im III. Jahrtausend vor Christus’, M. J. Mellink, E. Porada ve T. Özgüç (eds.), Aspects of Art and Iconography: Anatolia and its Neighbours. Studies in Honor of N. Özgüç, Ankara, 573-578. Strommenger, E.: 1970 ‘Keramik’, E. Heinrich et al. ‘Zweiter Vorläufiger Bericht über die von der Deutschen Orientgesellschaft und Mitteln der Stiftung Volkswagenwerk in Habuba Kabira und in Mumbagat unternommenen archäologischen Untersuchungen’, MDOG 102: 45-50. Suleiman, A.: 1984 ‘Excavations at Ansari-Aleppo for the Seasons 1973-1980 Early and Middle Bronze Age’, Akkadica 40: 1-16. Thureau-Dangin, F. and M., Dunand: 1936 Til Barsip, Paris. Umurtak, G. and R. Duru: 2012 ‘Hacılar’ın İkinci Höyüğünde Kazılara Başlandı/ Work Has Begun at the Second Höyük at Hacılar, Hacılar Büyük Höyük Excavations 2011’ Müze 5: 45-48. 2015 ‘Hacılar Büyük Höyük Kazıları/ Excavations at Hacılar Büyük Höyük in 2014, Anmed 13: 30-35. Van Loon, M.: 1979 ‘1974 and 1975 Preliminary Results of the Excavations at Selenkahiye Near Meskene, Syria’, Annual of the Schools of Oriental Research 44: 97-112. Van Loon, M., N. and D., J., M., Meijer: 2001 ‘Graves and Their Contents’, In van Loon M.N. (eds.), ‘Selenkahiye’, Leiden. Von der Osten, H., H.: 1937 The Alishar Hüyük I: Seasons of 1930-32, Chicago. Woolley, C., L.: 1914 ‘Hittite Burial Customs’ , AAA 6: 87-98. 1955 Alalakh An Account of the excavations at Tell Atchana in the Hatay, 1937-1949, Oxford. Woolley, C., L. and R., D., Barnett: 1952 Carchemish III: The Excavations in the Inner Town, London. Yener, K., A.: 1995 ‘Göltepe 1993 Kazı Sonuçları’, KST XVI, Ankara, 177-188. 2010 Tell Atchana, Ancient Alalakh/ the 2003-2004 Excavations, Vol:1, İstanbul. Zimmermann, T.: 2005 ‘Perfumes and Policies, A ‘Syrian Bottle’ from Kinet Höyük and Anatolian Trade Patterns in the Advanced Third Millennium BC’, Anatolica XXXI, 161-169.