ON TURNING THE NEGATIVE RELATIONSHIP FORMED BETWEEN UMAR AND ALI INTO POSITIVE AND THE SUNNI-SHI’I FRATERNITY

Yıl 2005, Cilt: 5 Sayı: 3, 299 - 332, 31.12.2005

Kamil Güneş

Öz

In some respects, history of Islamic thought means history of conflicts of opinion.
The fundamental conflict between Ahl as-Sunnah and Shia is around the subject of
Imamat. According to Shia, where begun the subject of Imamat, Omar's function was
extremely negative. So, It's impossible to find in the Shiite books any good expression
about Omar. Whereas Omar is one of the nearest persons to the Prophet Muhammad
according to Ahl as-Sunnah. Besides, relationship between Omar and Ali was exceedingly
positive. In fact, Shia is distorting the historical realities and is showing events
that never happened as if they happened. In this point we have to say that those rumors
never exist in any source book except Shiite books. Naturally, Ahl as-Sunnah never
accept Shiite rumors that contain very bad expressions about Omar. So, this article deals
with some subjects such as the matter of Fedek Territory, Omar's marriage with Ali's
daughter Umm al-Kulthum, how is the Shi’ite approach to the character of Omar and the
fact that Ahl al-Bayt mention Omar only in an auspicious manner. In spite of some troubles
between Omar and Ali as a usual fact, the relationship between them was always
positive. Finally, this article aims to contribute to the fraternity between Ahl as-Sunnah
and Shia.

HZ. ÖMER İLE HZ. ALİ ARASINDA OLUŞTURULAN MENFİ İLİŞKİNİN MÜSPETE DÖNÜŞTÜRÜLMESİ ÜZERİNE

Öz