TY - JOUR T1 - 21. Yüzyılda BRIC Ülkelerinde Devlet Kapitalizminin Politik Ekonomisi TT - The Political Economy of State Capitalism in the BRIC Countries in the 21st Century AU - Cengiz, Orhan PY - 2021 DA - November DO - 10.20990/kilisiibfakademik.974095 JF - Akademik Araştırmalar ve Çalışmalar Dergisi (AKAD) PB - Kilis 7 Aralık Üniversitesi WT - DergiPark SN - 2149-1585 SP - 322 EP - 347 VL - 13 IS - 25 LA - tr AB - Amaç: Bu araştırmanın amacı, 21. yüzyıldaki devlet kapitalizminin BRIC ülkeleri için incelenmesidir. Tasarım/Yöntem: Araştırmada 21. yüzyıldaki devlet kapitalizminin yapısı ve bunun BRIC ülkelerinde işleyişi nicel verilerle ele alınmıştır. Devlet kapitalizminin iki önemli unsuru olan Devlet Mülkiyetli Şirketler (SOEs) ve Ulusal Varlık Fonları (SWFs) BRIC ülkeleri için ayrı ayrı analiz edilmiştir.Bulgular: Sadece ulusal piyasalara odaklanan klasik devlet kapitalizminin aksine, 21. yüzyıldaki devlet kapitalizmi modelinde devlet; petrol, doğal gaz, enerji, ulaşım ve finans gibi sektörlerde doğrudan küresel ekonomiye entegre olmaya başlamıştır. Özellikle BRIC ülkelerinde benimsenen devlet kapitalizmi modeli ile bu ülkelerin küresel sistemdeki etkilerinin artması birbiriyle yakın ilişkilidir. Bunun yanında, 21. yüzyılda yaşanan iki büyük krizle beraber (2008 küresel finans krizi ve Covid-19 krizi) devlete dönüş eğilimlerinin artması, devlet kapitalizmi politikalarını genişletecektir.Sınırlılıklar: Devlet kapitalizminin bütün unsurları yerine sadece en önemli iki unsuru olan Devlet Mülkiyetli Şirketler (SOEs) ve Ulusal Varlık Fonları’nın (SWFs) dikkate alınması çalışmanın sınırlılığını oluşturmaktadır.Özgünlük/Değer: Devlet kapitalizmi teması, yoğun olarak incelenmesine rağmen ülke özelinde kapitalizmi, 21. yüzyıldaki yapısıyla analiz eden çalışmalar oldukça sınırlıdır. Dolayısıyla devlet kapitalizminin 21. yüzyıldaki modelinin BRIC ülkelerinin her birisi için ayrı ayrı incelenmesi çalışmanın özgün yanını oluşturmaktadır. KW - Devlet Kapitalizmi KW - Devlet Mülkiyetli Şirketler KW - Ulusal Varlık Fonları KW - BRIC Ülkeleri KW - 21. Yüzyıl N2 - Purpose: The purpose of this research is to examine state capitalism in the 21st century for the BRIC countries.Design/Methodology: In the research, the structure of state capitalism in the 21st century and its functioning in the BRIC countries are discussed with quantitative data. Two essential factors of state capitalism, State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) and Sovereign Wealth Funds (SWFs) are analyzed for BRIC countries separately.Findings: Contrary to classical state capitalism, which focuses only on domestic markets, in the 21st-century state capitalism model, the state has begun to integrate directly into the global economy in sectors such as oil, natural gas, energy, transportation, and finance. The state capitalism model adopted especially in BRIC countries and the increasing importance of these countries in the global system is closely related. In addition, with the two major crises in the 21st century (the 2008 global financial crisis and the Covid-19 crisis), the increase in the tendency to return to the state will expand the policies of state capitalism.Limitations: The limitation of the study is to consider only State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) and Sovereign Wealth Funds (SWFs), which are the two most essential factors of state capitalism, instead of all aspects.Originality/Value: Although the theme of state capitalism has been largely examined, studies that analyze country-specific capitalism with its structure in the 21st century are very limited. Thus, examining the state capitalism model in the 21st century separately for each of the BRIC countries generates the original aspect of the study. CR - Aharoni, Y. (2018). The evolution of state-owned multinational enterprise theory. In A. Cuervo-Cazurra (Ed.), State-owned multinationals: Governments in global business (pp. 9-44). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-51715-5_2 CR - Ahrens, J., Hoen, H. W., & Spechler, M. C. (2016). State capitalism in Eurasia: A dual-economy approach to Central Asia. In M. Brusis, J. Ahrens, & M. S. Wessel (Eds.), Politics and legitimacy in Post-Soviet Eurasia (pp. 47-71). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137489449_3 CR - Alami, I., & Dixon, A. D. (2020). The strange geographies of the ‘new’ state capitalism. Political Geography, 82(102237), 1-12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2020.102237 CR - Alami, I., Dixon, A. D., & Mawdsley, E. (2021). State capitalism and the new global D/development regime. Antipode, 1-25. https://doi.org/10.1111/anti.12725 CR - Amar, J. (2016). Sovereign wealth funds: Major actors in the global economy. Working Paper, http://www.oee.fr/files/swfs_briefing_paper_oee_2016.pdf CR - Åslund, A. (2019). Russia’s crony capitalism: The path from market economy to kleptocracy. Yale University Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvgc61tr CR - Augustynowicz, P. (2014). State-owned enterprises in Russia-the origin, importance and principles of operation. In É. Voszka, & G. D. Kiss (Eds.), Crisis management and the changing role of the state (pp. 133-145). University of Szeged Doctoral School in Economics. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ruje.2017.02.001 CR - Barkhatov, V., Campa, A., Bents, D., & Kapkaev, I. (2018). The state capitalism in Russia: New economic ideology. In M. Cingula, D. Rhein, & M. Machrafi (Eds.), Economic and social development (pp. 512-517). Varazdin Development and Entrepreneurship Agency. https://www.proquest.com/openview/b7c5693822a5797c8cc159a3df25feb4/1?cbl=2033472&pq-origsite=gscholar. CR - Borst, N. (2021, April 15). Has China given up on state-owned enterprise reform?. Lowy Institute. https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/has-china-given-state-owned-enterprise-reform CR - Bremmer, I. (2009). State capitalism comes of age the end of the free market. Foreign Affairs, 88(3), 40-55. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298954130_State_Capitalism_Comes_of_Age_The_End_of_the_Free_Market CR - Bremmer, I. (2010). The end of the free market: Who wins the war between states and corporations?. Portfolio. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12290-010-0129-z CR - Bremmer, I. (2014). The new rules of globalization. Harvard Business Review, 92(1-2), 103-107. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298488717_The_New_Rules_of_Globalization CR - Brink, T. T. (2011). Institutional change in market-liberal state capitalism: An integrative perspective on the development of the private business sector in China. MPIfG Discussion Paper, (11/2), 1-22. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/254460403_Institutional_Change_in_Market-Liberal_State_Capitalism_An_Integrative_Perspective_on_the_Development_of_the_Private_Business_Sector_in_China CR - Capapé, J., Schena, P. J., Rose, P., & López, D. (2019). Sovereign wealth funds 2019. Center for the Governance of Change. https://docs.ie.edu/cgc/research/sovereign-wealth/SOVEREIGN-WEALTH-RESEARCH-IE-CGC-REPORT_2019.pdf CR - Castelli, M., & Scacciavillani, F. (2012). The new economics of sovereign wealth funds. John Wiley & Son. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119973478 CR - Chatterjee, E. (2017). Reinventing state capitalism in India: A view from the energy sector. Contemporary South Asia, 25(1), 85-100. https://doi.org/10.1080/09584935.2017.1290583 CR - Chenoy, A. M., & Kumar, R. (2017). Re-emerging Russia: Structures, institutions and processes. Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-5299-6 CR - China National Development and Reform Commission (2021). Report on the implementation of the 2020 plan for national economic and social development and on the 2021 draft plan for national economic and social development. https://www.caixinglobal.com/upload/china_national_economic_and_social_development_report_2021.pdf CR - De Castro Neves, J. A. (2013). Brazil as an emerging power in the twenty-first century. In V. Nadkarni, & N. C. Noonan (Eds.), Emerging powers in a comparative perspective: The political and economic rise of the BRIC countries (pp. 189-208). Bloomsbury Academic. https://www.amazon.com.tr/Emerging-Powers-Comparative-Perspective-Political/dp/1441119868 CR - Deng, Y., Morck, R., Wu, J., & Yeung, B. (2011). Monetary and fiscal stimuli, ownership structure, and China’s housing market. NBER Working Paper Series 16871, 1-62. https://www.nber.org/papers/w16871 CR - Department of Public Enterprises. (2020a). Public enterprises survey 2018-19: Volume-I. https://dpe.gov.in/public-enterprises-survey-2018-19 CR - Department of Public Enterprises. (2020b). Public enterprises survey 2018-19: Volume-II. https://dpe.gov.in/public-enterprises-survey-2018-19 CR - Di Bella, G., Dynnikova, O., & Slavov, S. (2019). The Russian state’s size and its footprint: Have they increased?. IMF Working Paper, (19/53), 1-28. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2019/03/09/The-Russian-States-Size-and-its-Footprint-Have-They-Increased-46662 CR - Djankov, S. (2015). Russia’s economy under Putin: From crony capitalism to state capitalism. Peterson Institute for International Economics Policy Brief, (PB15-18), 1-8. https://ideas.repec.org/p/iie/pbrief/pb15-18.html CR - Dolfsma, W., & Grosman, A. (2019). State capitalism revisited: A review of emergent forms and developments. Journal of Economic Issues, 53(2), 579-586. https://doi.org/10.1080/00213624.2019.1606653 CR - Elena, P. C. (2012). Liberal capitalism versus state capitalism. Revista Economică, (1), 589-595. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320690948_LIBERAL_CAPITALISM_VERSUS_STATE_CAPITALISM CR - Forbes. (2021, May 13). The list: 2021 Global 2000. https://www.forbes.com/lists/global2000/#4f62ba7e5ac0 CR - Fortune. (2021). Global 500. https://fortune.com/global500/2020/search/ CR - Garg, R., & Shukla, A. (2021). Sovereign wealth funds: A critical analysis. Business Analyst, 41(2), 25-47. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1477725 CR - Gazprom. (2020). Gazprom annual report 2020. https://www.gazprom.com/f/posts/13/041777/gazprom-annual-report-2020-en.pdf CR - Global SWF. (2021). 2021 annual report: State owned investors in a post pandemic age. https://investmentnews.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/3-SWF-Annual-Report.pdf CR - Grätz, J. (2014). Russia’s multinationals: Network state capitalism goes global. In A. Nölke (Ed.), Multinational corporations from emerging markets: State capitalism 3.0 (pp. 90-108). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137359506_6 CR - Grosman, A., Okhmatovskiy, I., & Wright, M. (2016). State control and corporate governance in transition economies: 25 years on from 1989. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 24(3), 200-221. https://doi.org/10.1111/corg.12145 CR - Guluzade, A. (2019, May 7). The role of China’s state-owned companies explained. World Economic Forum. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/05/why-chinas-state-owned-companies-still-have-a-key-role-to-play CR - Harris, J. (2009). Statist globalization in China, Russia and the Gulf States. Science & Society, 73(1), 6-33. https://doi.org/10.1163/156914909X423836 CR - Hsueh, R. (2011). China’s regulatory state a new strategy for globalization. Cornell University Press. https://doi.org/10.7591/9780801462856 CR - International Monetary Fund. (2008). Sovereign wealth funds-A work agenda. https://www.imf.org/external/np/pp/eng/2008/022908.pdf CR - International Monetary Fund. (2018). Russian Federation. Press Release (18/346). https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2018/09/12/pr18346-imf-executive-board-concludes- 2018-article-iv-consultation-with-the-russian-federation CR - International Monetary Fund. (2020). Fiscal monitor: Policies to support people during the COVID-19 pandemic. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/FM/Issues/2020/04/17/Fiscal-Monitor-April-2020-Policies-to-Support-People-During-the-COVID-19-Pandemic-49278 CR - Jiránková, M., & Proch, D. (2018). The role of state in the economy and state capitalism: The case of China and India. Journal of International Relations, 16(4), 347-375. https://econpapers.repec.org/article/brvjournl/v_3a16_3ay_3a2018_3ai_3a4_3ap_3a347-375.htm CR - Khalil, S. (2019, August 25). Sovereign funds to manage the wealth of countries…Who manages the wealth of Iraq?!. Rawabet Center. https://rawabetcenter.com/en/?p=7400 CR - Kiely, R. (2015). The BRICs, US ‘Decline’ and global transformations. Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137499974 CR - Klimina, A. (2014). Finding a positive vision for state capitalism. Journal of Economic Issues, 48(2), 421-430. https://doi.org/10.2753/JEI0021-3624480216 CR - Kurlantzick, J. (2016). State capitalism: How the return of statism is transforming the world. Oxford University Press. https://www.jstor.org/stable/48537581?seq=1#metadata_info_tab_contents CR - Lanoszka, A. (2016). Brazil’s challenges of post-interventionist bargaining: Emerging economy or state capitalism. Global Journal of Emerging Market Economies, 8(1), 60-78. https://doi.org/10.1177/0974910115613709 CR - Li, X., Liu, X., & Wang, Y. (2015). A model of China’s state capitalism. HKUST IEMS Working Paper No. 2015-12, 1-72. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2061521 CR - Liang, H., Ren, B., & Sun, S. L. (2015). An anatomy of state control in the globalization of state-owned enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 46, 223-240. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1057/jibs.2014.35 CR - Lin, K. J., Lu, X., Zhang, J., & Zheng, Y. (2020). State-owned enterprises in China: A review of 40 years of research and practice. China Journal of Accounting Research, 13, 31-55. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1755309119300437 CR - May, C., Nölke, A., & Brink, T. T. (2019a). Public-private coordination in large emerging economies: The case of Brazil, India and China. Contemporary Politics, 25(3), 276-291. https://doi.org/10.1080/13569775.2018.1555781.in CR - May, C., Nölke, A., & Schedelik, M. (2019b). Institutional complementarities in Brazilian industrial policies: The case of finance. In M. Balestro, & F. Gaitán (Eds.), Untangling industrial policy: Ideas and coordination between state and business (pp. 147-178). Verbena Editora. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333245347_Untangling_industrial_policy_ideas_and_coordination_between_state_and_business_Moises_Balestro_Flavio_Gaitan_Org CR - McNally, C. A. (2013a). The challenge of refurbished state capitalism: Implications for the global political economic order. Dms–der Moderne Staat-Zeitschrift für Public Policy, Recht und Management, 6(1), 33-48. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280559225_The_Challenge_of_Refurbished_State_Capitalism_Implications_for_the_Global_Political_Economic_Order CR - McNally, C. A. (2013b). How emerging forms of capitalism are changing the global economic order. Asia-Pacific Issues, Analysis from the East-West Center No. 107, 1-8. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/290159586_How_emerging_forms_of_capitalism_are_changing_the_global_economic_order CR - Meckling, J., Kong, B., & Madan, T. (2015). Oil and state capitalism: Government-firm coopetition in China and India. Review of International Political Economy, 22(6), 1159-1187. https://doi.org/ 10.1080/09692290.2015.1089303 CR - Mishra, R. K. (2014). Role of state-owned enterprises in India’s economic development. Workshop on State-Owned Enterprises in the Development Process, OECD Conference Centre. https://www.oecd.org/daf/ca/Workshop_SOEsDevelopmentProcess_India.pdf CR - Musacchio, A., & Lazzarini, S. G. (2014). State-owned enterprises In Brazil: History and lessons. Workshop on State-Owned Enterprises in the Development Process, OECD Conference Centre. https://www.oecd.org/daf/ca/workshop_soesdevelopmentprocess_brazil.pdf CR - Musacchio, A. & Lazzarini, S. G. (2016). The reinvention of state capitalism in Brazil, 1970-2012. In B. R. Schneider (Ed.), New order and progress: development and democracy in Brazil (pp. 107-133). Oxford University Press. https://oxford.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190462888.001.0001/acprof-9780190462888 CR - Musacchio, A., Lazzarini, S. G., & Aguilera, R. V. (2015). New varieties of state capitalism: Strategic and governance implications. Academy of Management Perspectives, 29(1), 115-131. https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/amp.2013.0094 CR - Naughton, B. (2015). The transformation of the state sector: SASAC, the market economy, and the new national champions. In B. Naughton, & K. S. Tsai (Eds.), State capitalism, institutional adaptation, and the Chinese miracle (pp. 46-71). Cambridge University Press. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/state-capitalism-institutional-adaptation-and-the-chinese-miracle/B22E95BADECE68CF04EC39682D8953C8 CR - NIIF. (2020). https://niifindia.in/our_funds/ CR - Nölke, A. (2014). Introduction: Toward state capitalism 3.0. In A. Nölke (Ed.), Multinational corporations from emerging markets: State capitalism 3.0 (pp. 1-12). Palgrave Macmillan. https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9781137359490 CR - Nölke, A., Brink, T. T., May, C., & Claar, S. (2020). State-permeated capitalism in large emerging economies. Routledge. https://www.routledge.com/State-permeated-Capitalism-in-Large-Emerging-Economies/Nolke-Brink-May-Claar/p/book/9780367777708 CR - OECD. (2013). Russia: Modernising the economy. OECD Publishing. https://www.oecd.org/publications/russia-modernising-the-economy-9789264207998-en.htm CR - OECD. (2016). Broadening the ownership of state-owned enterprises: A comparison of governance practices. CR - OECD Publishing. https://www.oecd.org/publications/broadening-the-ownership-of-state-owned-enterprises-9789264244603-en.htm CR - OECD. (2020). OECD review of the corporate governance of state-owned enterprises: Brazil. OECD Publishing. https://www.oecd.org/brazil/soe-review-brazil.htm CR - OECD. (2021). Indicators of product market regulation. https://www.oecd.org/economy/reform/indicators-of-product-market-regulation/ CR - Oktay, F. (2017). Çin: Yeni büyük güç ve değişen dünya dengeleri. İş bankası Yayınları. https://www.kitapyurdu.com/kitap/cin-yeni-buyuk-guc-ve-degisen-dunya-dengeleri/429729.html CR - Overbeek, H. (2012). Sovereign wealth funds in the global political economy: The case of China. H. Overbeek, & B. V. Apeldoorn (Eds.), Neoliberalism in crisis (pp. 138-160). Palgrave Macmillan. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9781137002471_7 CR - Pargendler, M. (2014). Governing state capitalism: The case of Brazil. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2493402 CR - Peaucelle, I. (2010). Sovereign wealth funds, BRIC and sustainable development. Working Paper for IV Forum. Environment, Innovation and Sustainable development, 1-25. https://doi.org/ 10.1007/978-3-319-44645-5_15 CR - Radygin, A. (2004, April 13). Russia en route to state capitalism?. Global Affairs, https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/articles/russia-en-route-to-state-capitalism/ CR - Radygin, A. D., Aksenov, I. V., Malyginov, G. N., Entov, R. M., Abramov, A. E., Ilyasova, G. U., & Chernova, M. I. (2018). Effective management of state property in 2018-2024 and up to 2035. Center for Strategic Research Analytical Report. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/effective-management-of-state-property-in-2018-2024-and-up-to-2035-analytical-report CR - Reddy, K. S. (2019). Pot the ball? Sovereign wealth funds’ outward FDI in times of global financial market turbulence: A yield institutions-based view. Central Bank Review, 19, 129-139. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cbrev.2019.08.003 CR - SASAC. (2020). SOEs in past 5 years. http://en.sasac.gov.cn/2020/12/22/c_6394.htm CR - SASAC. (2021). Directory. http://en.sasac.gov.cn/directory.html Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute. (2021). https://www.swfinstitute.org/ CR - Sperber, N. (2019). The many lives of state capitalism: From classical marxism to free-market advocacy. History of the Human Sciences, 32(3), 100-124. https://doi.org/ 10.1177/0952695118815553 CR - Sturesson, J., McIntyre, S., & Jones, N. C. (2015). State-owned enterprises catalysts for public value creation?. https://www.pwc.com/gr/en/publications/government/state-owned-enterprises-catalysts-for-public-value-creation.html CR - Sweidan, O. D. (2021). State capitalism and energy democracy. Geoforum, 125, 181-184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2021.04.008 CR - Szamosszegi, A., & Kyle, C. (2011). An analysis of state-owned enterprises and state capitalism in China. US-China Economic and Security Review Commission. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/290980301_An_Analysis_of_State- Owned_Enterprises_and_State_Capitalism_in_China CR - Şimşek, O. (2017). Küreselleşme ve yeni devlet kapitalizminin yükselişi. Türk Metal Sendikası Araştırma ve Eğitim Merkezi Yayınları-7. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/311558842_Yeni_Devlet_Kapitalizminin_Yukselisi_Kuresel_Ekonomi-Politik_Bir_Inceleme CR - Taylor, M. (2015). The unchanging core of Brazilian state capitalism, 1985-2015. School of International Service Research Paper Series, (2015-8), 1-32. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2674332 CR - The Heritage Foundation. (2021). Country rankings. https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking CR - Thomas, S., & Chen, J. (2018). The role of China’s sovereign wealth funds in president Xi Jinping’s ambitious Belt and Road Initiative. In W. Zhang, I. Alon, & C. Lattemann (Eds.), China’s Belt and Road Initiative changing the rules of globalization (pp. 289-303). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-75435-2 CR - Tsai, K. S., & Naughton, B. (2015). Introduction: State capitalism and the Chinese economic miracle. In B. Naughton, & K. S. Tsai (Eds.), State capitalism, institutional adaptation, and the Chinese miracle (pp. 1-24). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139962858 CR - UNCTAD. (2009). World investment report 2009: Transnational corporations, agricultural production and development. https://unctad.org/statistics CR - UNCTAD. (2015). World Investment Report 2015: Reforming international investment governance. https://unctad.org/statistics CR - UNCTAD. (2021). https://unctad.org/statistics CR - Woetzel, J., Seong, J., Leung, N., Ngai, J., Manyika, J., Madgavkar, A., Lund, S., & Mironenko, A. (2019). China and the world: Inside the dynamics of a changing relationship. McKinsey Global Institute Report. https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/china/china-and-the-world-inside-the-dynamics-of-a-changing-relationship CR - Wooldridge, A. (2012, January 21). The visible hand. The Economist. https://www.economist.com/special-report/2012/01/21/the-visible-hand CR - Xing, L., & Shaw, T. M. (2013). The political economy of Chinese state capitalism. JCIR, 1(1), 88-113. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/293569617_The_Political_Economy_of_Chinese_State_Capitalism CR - Yang, Y., & Lee, P. (2018). State capitalism, state-owned banks, and wto’s subsidy regime: Proposing an institution theory. Stanford Journal of International Law, 54(2), 117-158. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3202377 UR - https://doi.org/10.20990/kilisiibfakademik.974095 L1 - https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/1890505 ER -