Recent Advances in Chaos and Bifurcation Analysis of Sub-Synchronous Resonance and Voltage Collapse in Power Systems

Abstract

This paper presents a comprehensive review and extension of the author’s work over the past three decades on two key power system phenomena, namely voltage collapse and sub-synchronous resonance (SSR), using advanced nonlinear analysis methods such as bifurcation and chaos theory. Voltage collapse is treated as a dynamic instability that arises when the grid can no longer sustain acceptable voltage levels under increasing load or reactive power demand. In contrast, SSR is described as an interaction between the electrical network and the turbine, generator shaft at frequencies below the nominal synchronous frequency, which can induce harmful torsional vibrations and potential mechanical damage. In the study of voltage collapse, nonlinear methods were applied to a three-bus system by developing a model comprising four nonlinear differential equations, with load power ($P_L$ or $Q_L$) serving as the control parameter. The findings indicate that as these load parameters increase, the inherent nonlinear characteristics of the system trigger a gradual loss of stability. A comparable modeling strategy was used to analyze SSR. A real-world system, the Mohave Power Station in Nevada, is examined, in which power is transmitted over a long line equipped with a series capacitor ($X_C$) to minimize AC losses ($I^2 X_L$). Despite these measures, catastrophic failures occurred at the station in 1970 and 1971 owing to turbine, generator shaft fractures, resulting in total system breakdown. For SSR analysis, a nonlinear model with 28 differential equations was created, using $X_C$ as the control parameter. The results show that increasing $X_C$ pushes the system toward instability, and surpassing a certain threshold leads to system collapse, aligning with documented shaft failures. Overall, the research highlights how modern nonlinear theories, such as bifurcation and chaos analysis, are essential for uncovering and anticipating complex dynamic behaviors in power systems.

Keywords

• Modern nonlinear theory
• Chaos and bifurcation
• Power system stability
• Voltage collapse
• Sub- Synchronous resonance (SSR)

References

1. Ajjarapu, V. and C. Christy, 1991 The continuation power flow: A tool for steady state voltage stability analysis. In IEEE PICA Conference Proceedings, pp. 304–311.
2. Chen, G. and X. Dong, 1998 From chaos to order: Methodologies, perspectives and applications. World Scientific.
3. Cheng, Y., L. Fan, J. Rose, F. Huang, J. Schmall, et al., 2022 Realworld subsynchronous oscillation events in power grids with high penetrations of inverter-based resources. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems .
4. Damas, R. N., Y. Son, M. Yoon, S. Y. Kim, and S. Choi, 2020 Subsynchronous oscillation and advanced analysis: A review. IEEE Access 8: 224020–224032.
5. Edris, A. A., 1990 Series compensation schemes reducing the potential of resonance. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems pp. 219–226.
6. Fouad, A. and K. T. Khu, 1978 Subsynchronous resonance zones in the ieee benchmark power system. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems 97.
7. Framer, R. G., E. Katz, and A. L. Schwalb, 1985 Navajo project on subsynchronous resonance analysis and solutions. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems 104: 1057–1066.
8. Harb, A. M., 1996 Application of bifurcation theory to subsynchronous resonance in power systems. Ph.D. thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.

9. Iravani, M. R. and A. A. Edris, 1994 Eigen analysis of series compensation schemes reducing the potential of subsynchronous resonance. In IEEE Power System Summer Meeting.
10. Kundur, P., 1981 A survey of utility experiences with power plant response during partial load rejections and system disturbances. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems 100: 2471– 2475.
11. Kundur, P., 1994 Power system stability and control. McGraw-Hill.
12. Kundur, P., D. C. Lee, J. P. Bayne, and P. L. Dandeno, 1985 Impact of turbine generator controls on unit performance under system disturbance conditions. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems 104.
13. Li, S., C. Zhang, and J. Zuo, 2023 Long-term voltage stability bifurcation analysis and control considering oltc adjustment and photovoltaic power station. Energies 16.
14. Mokred, S., Y.Wang, and T. Chen, 2023 A novel collapse prediction index for voltage stability analysis and contingency ranking in power systems. Protection and Control of Modern Power Systems 8.
15. Moradi-Shahrbabak, Z., 2025 A genetic approach to design an ssr damping controller in a hybrid photovoltaic-battery system by considering the state of charge. Journal of Energy Storage 108.
16. Nayfeh, A. H., A. M. Harb, and C. M. Chin, 1996 Bifurcations in a power system model. International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos 6: 497–512.
17. Nguyen, N. N., M. T. Nguyen, D. Q. Vu, and P. T. Vu, 2023 Study on sub-synchronous resonance in vietnam power system. In International Symposium on Electrical and Electronics Engineering (ISEE).
18. Padiyar, K. R., 1999 Analysis of subsynchronous resonance in power systems. Kluwer Academic Publishers.
19. Rana, R. D., S. W. Huff, R. M. Hayes, E. N. Fromholtz, and R. P. Schulz, 1991 Aep’s kanawha river 345kv series capacitor installations: Subsynchronous resonance studies and torsional measurements. In Proceedings of the American Power Conference, pp. 300–305.
20. Rouche, N., P. Habets, and M. Laloy, 1977 Stability theory by Liapunov’s direct method. Springer.
21. Rumyantsev, V. V. and A. S. Osiraner, 1987 Stability and stabilization of motion with respect to a part of the variables. Nauka.
22. Steinmetz, C. P., 1920 Power control and stability of electric generating stations. AIEE Transactions 39: 1215–1287.
23. Tung, D. D., L. V. Dai, and L. C. Quyen, 2019 Subsynchronous resonance and facts: Novel control strategy for its mitigation. International Journal of Engineering .
24. Vassell, G. S., 1991 Northeast blackout of 1965. IEEE Power Engineering Review pp. 4–8.
25. Zhu,W., R. R. Mohler, R. Spce,W. A. Mittelstadt, and D. Maratukulam, 1996 Hopf bifurcation in a smib power system with ssr. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems 11: 1579–1584.
26. Zhu, W., R. Spee, R. R. Mohler, G. G. Alexander, W. A. Mittelstadt, et al., 1995 An emtp study of ssr mitigation using the thyristorcontrolled series capacitor. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery.