Comparison of conventional high speed railway, maglev and hyperloop transportation systems

Abstract

Increasing the speed of transportation has been a subject that human beings have been working on for many years. Because of insufficient traffic corridors, the interest of more passenger in limited time and the advancement of railway technology, the high-speed ground transportation systems have developed. Nowadays, these time-saving transportation systems are becoming important increasingly and systems that will ensure these are implemented and new ones are being researched. High speed ground transportation systems can be divided into three categories: Conventional high-speed railway, Maglev and Hyperloop transportation system. Within the scope of this study, it is aimed to investigate the advantages and disadvantages aspects of high speed transportation systems by comparing in terms of speed, capacity, energy consumption, cost and environmental effects. Conventional high-speed railways can provide high capacity, comfort and safety and reliability thanks to enormous operational experience as regards other systems. The Maglev technology can offer more remarkable travel times, energy efficient and better operational performance. However, high investment cost and incompatibility with other modes are seen the disadvantage features of this technology. The Hyperloop technology is a considerable innovative transportation system which is popularized with publishing design document by Elon Musk in 2013. Projected high-speed and appealing travel times can be evaluated as the advantages of the Hyperloop transportation system. However, there are safety, reliability, comfort and engineering design challenges to overcome in this technology. Taking everything into consideration, the Hyperloop transportation system has potential to be an alternative mode to other systems.

Keywords

• Conventional high-speed railway
• Maglev
• Hyperloop

References

1. 1. Liu, R., Deng,Y. Comparing Operating Characteristics of High-Speed Rail and Maglev Systems:Case Study of Beijing-Shanghai Coridor. Transportation Research Record, 2004. 1863(1): p. 19-27.
2. 2. UIC High Speed Rail Report.[cited 2020 6 July]; Available from: https://uic.org/IMG/pdf/uic_high_speed_2018_ph08_web.pdf.
3. 3. Van Goerverden, K., Milakis, D., Janic, M., & Konings, R. Analysis and modelling of performances of the HL (Hyperloop) transport system.European Transport Research Review, 2018. 10(2): p. 1-17.
4. 4. Gieras, J. Ultra high-speed ground transportation systems:Current status and a vision for the future.Przeglad Elektrotechniczny, 2020 : p.1-7.
5. 5. Tesla, Hyperloop Alpha Report. [cited 2020 20 July]; Availablefrom: https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/blog_images/hyperloop-alpha.pdf
6. 6. Ziemke, D. Comparison of High-Speed Rail Systems for the United States. Msc Thesis, Georgia Institute of Technology, 2010.
7. 7. Riviera, M. High-Speed Trains Comparison to Hyperloop: Energy and Sustainability. Msc Thesis, Politechnico Di Torino, 2017.
8. 8. Çodur, M. Türkiye’de Maglev Trenlerinin Uygulanabilirliğinin Araştırılması. Journal of the Institute of Science and Technology, 2017. 7(1) : p. 207-215.

9. 9. Gonzalez-Gonzales, E., Nogues-Linares, S.Railways of the future: Evolution and Prospects of High-speed, Maglev and Hyperloop (1st Part). DYNA, 2017. 92 (4): p. 371-373.
10. 10. Janić, M. Multicriteria Evaluation of the High Speed Rail, Transrapid Maglev and Hyperloop Systems. Transportation Systems and Technology, 2018. 4(4) :p. 5-31.
11. 11. Contreras, M. HSGT Systems: HSR, Maglev and Hyperloop. The Journal, 2018.
12. 12. Armağan, K. The fifth mode of transportation: Hyperloop.Journal of Innovative Transportation, 2020. 1(1): p. 1105.
13. 13. UIC High Speed Lines in the World Report. [cited 2020 6 July]; Available from: https://uic.org/IMG/pdf/20200227_high_speed_lines_in_the_world.pdf
14. 14. Yadav, M., Mehta, N., Gupta, Aman., Chaudhary,A., Mahindru, D. Review of Maglev Levitation (MAGLEV):A Technology to propel Vehicles with Magnets.Global Journal of Researches in Engineering Mechanical & Mechanics, 2013, 13 (7-A).
15. 15. Solak, K. Raylı Sistemlerin Alternatifleri ile Manyetik Yastık Üzerinde Hareket Eden Trenlerin (Maglev) Çok Ölçütlü Değerlendirme Yöntemi ile Karşılaştırılası. Msc Thesis, Gazi University, 2011.
16. 16. Jahan, F., Parveen, Aasiya., Bisht, S. Feasibility Study of Maglev Trains on Existing Indian Railways Infrastructure. International Journal on Emerging Technologies, 2014. 5(2): p. 106-109.
17. 17. [cited 2020 10 July]; Available from: https://www.maglev.net/all-existing-and-under-construction-maglev-lines.
18. 18. Lee, H., Kim, K., Lee, J. Review of Maglev Train Technologies. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2006. 42:p.1917-1925.
19. 19. Virgin Hyperloop. [cited 2020 20 July]; Available from: https://virginhyperloop.com/project/devloop
20. 20. [cited 2020 20 July]; Available from: https://www.sciencealert.com/there-s-a-new-record-for-travelling-at-the-speed-of-hyperloop
21. 21. MaglevBoard. [cited 2020 10 July]; Available from: https://www.maglevboard.net/en/facts/systems-overview/transrapid-maglev/transrapid-maglev-shanghai
22. 22. Witt, M., Herzberg, S. Technical-economical System Comparison of High Speed Railway Systems.[cited 2020 10 July]; Available from: http://www.maglev.ir/eng/documents/papers/conferences/maglev2004/topic1/IMT_CP_M2004_T1_11.pdf
23. 23. [cited 2020 20 July]; Available from: https://pwayblog.com/2016/09/07/maglev-guideway-design/
24. 24. Campos, J., De Rus, G., Barron, I. Economic Analysis of High Speed Rail in Europe. BBVA Foundation, 2009.
25. 25. [cited 2020 18 October]; Available from: https://www.khaleejtimes.com/technology/abu-dhabi-hyperloop-to-cost-up-to-40-million-per-kilometre--
26. 26. Monorails Australia. [cited 2020 20 July]; Available from: https://www.monorailsaustralia.com.au/Maglev.pdf
27. 27. [cited 2020 20 October]; Available from: https://www.wpxi.com/news/top-stories/study-how-much-would-hyperloop-ticket-cost-pittsburgh/LOBFEAVJFRF7HL5WMHL6BXOY6Y/
28. 28. [cited 2020 20 October]; Available from: http://www.smtdc.com/en/jszl.html
29. 29. Fritz, E., Blow, L., Klühspies, J., Kircher, R. Energy Consumption of Track-Based High-Speed Trains: Maglev Systems in Comparison with Wheel-Rail Systems. The International Maglev Board, 2018. 4 (3 suppl 1):p.134-155.
30. 30. Wang C., Wang K. A Study on Environmental Impact of High Speed Maglev Traffic Engineering.International Conference on Management and Service Science, 2010, p.1-3.
31. 31. Van Goeverden, K., Milakis, D., Janic, M., Konings, R. Performances of the HL(Hyperloop) Transport System.Proceedings of the BIVEC-GIBET Transport Research Days 2017: Toward an Auotonomous and Interconnected Transport Future, 2017, p. 29-43.