Pushback of Refugees Under International Law: A Conceptual Analysis

Öz

Pushback describes measures and actions taken by state authorities to intercept refugees from seeking asylum as they enter or attempt to enter the state’s territorial boundaries. There is no precise international law definition to help grasp pushback’s scope and consequences. Scholars and refugee activists have evaluated the term pushback with links to collective expulsion, torture, and crimes against humanity. This Article charts relevant international legal regulations on the mentioned legal terms. The aim is to reveal whether a legal explanation can be brought to the term pushback through these concepts. From a legal perspective, this Article points out that pushback operations conflict with the nonrefoulement principle and the prohibition on collective expulsion. The analysis further explains that certain elements must come together for the term pushback to be considered in a structure that will fall within the scope of international criminal law in its operational dimension. Keeping in mind the aspects described earlier, this Article will evaluate legal ways to make sense of a vague concept.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Pushback
• International law
• Collective expulsion
• Torture
• Crimes against humanity

Kaynakça

1. Agamben G, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life. (Daniel Heller-Roazen tr, Stanford University Press 1998). google scholar
2. Ahmed K, ‘Violence towards refugees at Libyan detention centers forces MSF to pull out’ (The Guardian, 24 June 2021) accessed 5 August 2021. google scholar
3. Amnesty International, ‘Greece: Violence, Lies, And Pushbacks Refugees and Migrants Still Denied Safety and Asylum at Europe’s Borders’ (2021) 12 accessed 6 September 2021. google scholar
4. Al-Dayel N, Anfinson A, and Anfinson G, ‘Captivity, Migration, and Power in Libya’ [2021] Journal of Human Trafficking accessed 18 May 2021. google scholar
5. Al Jazeera, ‘2016: Refugee Arrivals Fall as Deaths Hit Record’ (26 October 2016) accessed 6 September 2021. google scholar
6. Al Jazeera, ‘Caught on Camera: Libyan Coastguard Shoots at Migrant Boat’ Al Jazeera (1 July 2021) accessed 3 August 2021. google scholar
7. Al Jazeera, ‘Deaths at Sea Highlight Failings in Europe Immigration Policy’ (4 May 2021) www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/5/4/deaths-at-sea-highlight-failings-in-europe- migrationpolicy> accessed 21 June 2021. google scholar
8. Al Jazeera, ‘Greece: Four Afghan Migrants Jailed over Moria Camp Fire’ Al Jazeera (13 June 2021) accessed 15 June 2021. google scholar

9. Akkerman M, ‘Outsourcing Oppression How Europe Externalises Migrant Detention Beyond Its Shores’ (Niamh Ni Bhriain and Josephine Valeske eds, Transnational Institute and Stop Wapenhandel, 2021) accessed 7 October 2021. google scholar
10. Amnesty International, ‘Greece: Pushbacks and Violence against Refugees and Migrants Are de Facto Border Policy’ (23 June 2021) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
11. Amnesty International, ‘The Human Cost of Fortress Europe Human Rights Violations Against Migrants and Refugees at Europe’s Borders’ (2014) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
12. Bassiouni C M, Crimes Against Humanity Historical Evolution and Contemporary Application (Cambridge University Press 2011). google scholar
13. Brown W, Walled States, Waning Sovereignty (2010). google scholar
14. Bennoune K, ‘Terror/Torture’, Rutgers School of Law-Newark Research Papers Series Paper 032. google scholar
15. BBC News, ‘Denmark Asylum: Law Passed to Allow Offshore Asylum Centres’ (3 June 2021) accessed 16 August 2021. google scholar
16. BBC News, ‘Greece Erects Fence at Turkey Border amid Warnings of Afghan Migrant Surge’ (21 August 2021) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
17. Burchard H, ‘EU Plans Big Cash Offer for Afghanistan’s Neighbors to Host Refugees’ Politico (31 August 2021) accessed 6 September 2021. google scholar
18. Brabant M and Tolis D, ‘Migrants Left Adrift at Sea after Boat Pushback from Greek Coast Guard’ PBS News Hour (22 July 2021) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
19. Bronsther J, ‘Criminal Law Torture and Respect’ (2019) 109 The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 3. google scholar
20. Bassiouni M C, ‘International Crimes: Jus Cogens and Obligation Erga Omnes’ (1996) 59 Law and Contemporary Problems 4. google scholar
21. Chatty D, ‘Has the Tide Turned? Refuge and Sanctuary in the Euro-Mediterranean Space’ (Borders, Migrations, Asylum and Refuge, 06 October 2020) accessed 25 January 2021. google scholar
22. Charter of Fundamental Rights of The European Union [2012] 326/02 395. google scholar
23. Cherry M, ‘Anger Can Build a Better World’ The Atlantic (25 August 2020) accessed 2 September 2021. google scholar
24. Cusumano E and Villa M, ‘Over Troubled Waters: Maritime Rescue Operations in the Central Mediterranean Route’ (IOM) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
25. Conka v Belgium App no 51564/99 (ECHR, 5 February 2002). google scholar
26. Chimni B S, ‘The Geopolitics of Refugee Studies: A View from the South’ (1998) 11 Journal of Refugee Studies 4. google scholar
27. Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (adopted 28 July 1951, entered into force 22 April 1954) 189 UNTS 137 (1951 Refugee Convention). google scholar
28. Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (European Convention on Human Rights, as amended) (ECHR), amended by Protocols nos 11 and 14, 4 November 1950, ETS 5. google scholar
29. Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, GA res 39/46, Annex, 10 Dec 1984 (UNCAT). google scholar
30. Crisp J and Maple N, ‘Relevant or Redundant? The Future of the International Refugee Protection Regime’ (Refugee Law Initiative Blog on Refugee Law and Forced Migration, 22 July 2021) accessed 4 August 2021. google scholar
31. Cherry M, ‘State Racism, State Violence, and Vulnerable Solidarity’ in Naomi Zack (ed), The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy and Race (2017) accessed 2 September 2021. google scholar
32. Dancy G T, ‘The Hidden Impacts of the ICC: An Innovative Assessment Using Google Data’ (2021) 34 Leiden Journal of International Law 729 accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
33. Davitti D, ‘Why Offshore Processing of Refugees Bound for Europe Is Such a Bad Idea’ The Conversation (28 July 2017) accessed 27 August 2021. google scholar
34. Death by Rescue, ‘Death by Rescue the Lethal Effects of The EU’s Policies of NonAssistance’ accessed 25 September 2021. google scholar
35. Declaration on the Protection of All Persons from Being Subjected to Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, GA res 3452 (XXX), Annex, 9 Dec 1975 (UN Declaration Against Torture). google scholar
36. Dorfman A, ‘The Tyranny of Terror Torture Inevitable in Our Century and Beyond?’ in Sanford Levinson (ed), Torture A Collection (Oxford University Press, 2004). google scholar
37. Doyle M and Macklin A, ‘Responsibility Sharing and the Global Compact on Refugees’, Experts Meeting on the Global Compact on Refugees (2017). google scholar
38. European Court of Human Rights, ‘Guide on Article 4 of Protocol No. 4 to the European Convention on Human Rights: Prohibition of Collective Expulsions of Aliens’ (Council of Europe, 30 April 2021) accessed 17 June 2021. google scholar
39. European Commission, ‘Migration and Asylum Package: New Pact on Migration and Asylum Documents Adopted on 23 September 2020’ (23 September 2020) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
40. Euronews, ‘Yunanistan’da Cezaevine Benzetilen Mülteci Kampı Açılıyor, STK’lar Tepkili’ (18 September 2021) accessed 18 September 2021. google scholar
41. Euronews, ‘Fishing Boat Crammed with over 500 Migrants Arrives in Lampedusa’ (28 August 2021) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
42. Euronews, ‘Avrupa Konseyi’nden Yunanistan’a: Göçmenleri Sınır Dışı Etme Yasa Tasarısını Değiştir’ (4 September 2021) accessed 6 September 2021. google scholar
43. Ergin A D, ‘What Happened at the Greece-Turkey Border in Early 2020? A Legal Analysis’ (VerfBlog, 30 September 2020) accessed 7 September 2021. google scholar
44. Fargues P, ‘Four Decades of Cross-Mediterranean Undocumented Migration to Europe A Review of the Evidence’ (International Organization for Migration, 2017), 11 accessed 17 September 2021. google scholar
45. Farzan NA, ‘As Greece Installs “Sound Cannons” on Border, Denmark Passes Law AllowingAsylum Seekers to Be Sent Overseas’ [2021] The Washington Post accessed 16 June 2021. google scholar
46. Fallon K, ‘Greece Accused of Refugee “Pushback” after Family Avoid Being Forced off Island’ (29 June 2021) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
47. Frontex European Border and Coast Guard Agency accessed 16 June 2021. google scholar
48. Frouville O, ‘The Influence of the European Court of Human Rights’ Case Law on International Criminal Law of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment’ (2011) 9 Journal of International Criminal Justice. google scholar
49. FRA European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, ‘Fundamental Rights at Europe’s Southern Sea Borders’ (2013), 46 accessed 17 September 2021. google scholar
50. Ghezelbash D, ‘Hyper-legalism and Obfuscation: How States Evade Their International Obligations Towards Refugees’ [2020] American Journal of Comparative Law 2. google scholar
51. Gleeson M and Yacoub N, ‘Policy Brief 11 Cruel, Costly and Ineffective: The Failure of Offshore Processing in Australia’ (Kaldor Centre for International Refugee Law 2021) Policy Brief 11 accessed 16 August 2021. google scholar
52. Gutierrez-Rodriguez E, ‘The Coloniality of Migration and the “Refugee Crisis” On the AsylumMigration Nexus, the Transatlantic White European Settler Colonialism- Migration and Racial Capitalism’ (2018) 34 Refugee 1. google scholar
53. Guzman M M, ‘Gravity and the Legitimacy of the International Criminal Court’ (2008) 32 Fordham International Law Journal accessed 19 August 2021. google scholar
54. Goodwin-Gill G, ‘Refugee Identity and Protection’s Fading Prospects’ in Frances Nicholson and Patrick Twomey (eds), Refugee Rights and Realities: Evolving International Concepts and Regimes (Cambridge University Press 1999). google scholar
55. Guy Goodwin-Gill, ‘The International Refugee Regime and the Challenges Today’ (Kaldor Center for International Refugee Law, 27 August 2021) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
56. Hathaway J C, ‘Is ‘Ageing Gracefully?’ an Ageist Critique?”’ accessed 5 August 2021. google scholar
57. Hathaway J C, ‘The Emerging Politics of Non-Entrée’ (1992) 91 Refugees 40. google scholar
58. Hathaway J C, The Rights of Refugees Under International Law (Cambridge University Press 2005) 280. google scholar
59. Hausmann R, ‘Why Are Rich Countries Democratic?’ (Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-Rahmani Center for Business and Government, 26 March 2014) accessed 14 September 2021. google scholar
60. Hirsi Jamaa and Others v Italy App no. 27765/09 (ECHR, 23 February 20I2) para 81. google scholar
61. Human Rights Watch, ‘Human Rights Watch Submission to the Special Rapporteur’s Report on Pushback Practices and Their Impact on the Human Rights of Migrants’ (Human Rights Watch, 1 February 2021) accessed 9 August 2021. google scholar
62. Human Rights Watch, ‘Greece: Violence Against Asylum Seekers at Border Detained, Assaulted, Stripped, Summarily Deported’ (17 March 2020) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
63. Human Rights Watch, ‘Pushed Back, Pushed Around Italy’s Forced Return of Boat Migrants and Asylum Seekers, Libya’s Mistreatment of Migrants and Asylum Seekers’ (2009) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
64. Human Rights Watch, ‘Frontex Failing to Protect People at EU Borders Stronger Safeguards Vital as Border Agency Expands’ (2021) accessed 17 September 2021. google scholar
65. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976) 999 UNTS 171 (ICCPR). google scholar
66. International Criminal Court the Office of the Prosecutor, (Ref OTP-CR-322/14/001, 12 February 2020) accessed 21 May 2020. google scholar
67. International Criminal Court (ICC), ‘Elements of Crimes’ (2011) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
68. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976) 999 UNTS 171 (ICCPR). google scholar
69. International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (adopted 21 December 1965, entered into force on 4 January 1969) 660 UNTS 195 (CERD). google scholar
70. Islam A, ‘South Asian Migrants Accuse Croatian Police of Brutal Beatings at Border’ DW Made for Minds (26 October 2020) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
71. James D, ‘Listening to the Refugee: Valeria Luiselli’ s Sentimental Activism’ (2021) 67 MFS -Modern Fiction Studies 390
72. James_Luiselli_MFS_67.2 _2021_AAM.pdf> accessed 7 September 2021. google scholar
73. Joung M, ‘What Is Happening at Migrant Detention Centers? Here’s What to Know’ (12 July 2019) accessed 2 September 2021. google scholar
74. Kalir B, ‘Departheid: The Draconian Governance of Illegalized Migrants in Western States’ (2019) 5 Conflict and Society: Advances in Research 19. google scholar
75. Kingsley P and Shoumali K, ‘Taking Hard Line, Greece Turns Back Migrants by Abandoning Them at Sea’ The New York Times (27 April 2021) accessed 3 May 2021. google scholar
76. Kallergis K, ‘Pushbacks: Migrants Accuse Greece of Sending Them Back out to Sea’ BBC News (12 December 2020) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
77. Keady-Tabbal N and Mann I, ‘“Pushbacks” as Euphemism’ accessed 14 April 2021. google scholar
78. Khlaifia and Others v Italy App No 16483/12 (ECHR, 15 December 2016). google scholar
79. Lynott L, ‘“I’m Not a Hero but I’m Not a Criminal” - Trinity Graduate Sean (24) Returns Home after 100 Days in Greek Jail’ INDEPENDENT.IE (16 December 2018) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
80. Legido A S, ‘The Walls of Fortress Europe: Externalization of Migration Control and the Rule of Law’ (2019) 23 The Spanish Yearbook of International Law 345. google scholar
81. Luban D, ‘A Theory of Crimes Against Humanity’ (2004) 29 Yale Journal of International Law. google scholar
82. Legal Centre Lesvos, ‘Crimes Against Humanity in the Aegean’ (2021) accessed 17 May 2021. google scholar
83. Mann I and Keady-Tabbal N, ‘Torture by Rescue: Asylum-Seeker Pushbacks in the Aegean How Summary Expulsions From Greece Have Continued With Impunity’ (Just Security, 26 October 2020) accessed 25 January 2021. google scholar
84. Mann I, ‘The Right to Perform Rescue at Sea: Jurisprudence and Drowning’ [2020] German Law Journal 609. google scholar
85. Mann I, ‘Attack by Design: Australia’s Offshore Detention System and the Literature of Atrocity’ [2021] European Journal of International Law 429 accessed 14 April 2021. google scholar
86. Médecins Sans Frontières, ‘Out of Sight, out of Mind: Refugees in Libya’s Detention Centres’ (12 July 2019) accessed 18 May 2021. google scholar
87. McAdam J, ‘Australia and Asylum Seekers’ (2013) 25 International Journal of Refugee Law 3. google scholar
88. McAdam J, ‘An Intellectual History of Freedom of Movement in International Law: The Right to Leave as A Personal Liberty’ (2011) 12 Melbourne Journal of International Law 2. google scholar
89. McDonald-Gibson C, ‘Europe Sees a Migration Crisis in the Making in Afghanistan. Have the Lessons of the 2015 Surge Been Learned?’ Time (18 August 2021) accessed 27 August 2021. google scholar
90. Morales F G, ‘Report on Means to Address the Human Rights Impact of Pushbacks of Migrants on Land and at Sea’ (UN Human Rights Council Forty-seventh session, 21 July 2021), 4 accessed 18 September 2021. google scholar
91. ND & NT v Spanish App nos 8675/15 and 8697/15 (ECHR, 13 February 2020). google scholar
92. Neuman G L, ‘What Counts as a Crime Against Humanity?’ (Harvard International Law Journal) accessed 2 September 2021. google scholar
93. Nicholson F and Kumin J, ‘A Guide to International Refugee Protection and Building State Asylum Systems Handbook for Parliamentarians N° 27, 2017’ (UNHCR, 2017) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
94. Okafor O C, Refugee Law After 9/11 Sanctuary and Security in Canada and The United States (UBC Press 2020) 3-10. google scholar
95. Protocol 4 to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, securing certain Rights and Freedoms other than those already included in the Convention and in the First Protocol thereto 16 September 1963, ETS 46. google scholar
96. Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (adopted 31 January 1967, entered into force 4 October 1967) 606 UNTS 267 (The 1967 Protocol). google scholar
97. Patrick S M, ‘The U.N. Refugee Convention Is Under Pressure—and Showing Its Age’ (World Politics Review, 9 August 2021) accessed 16 August 2021. google scholar
98. Plucinska J and Pempel K, ‘On the EU’s Eastern Border, Poland Builds a Fence to Stop Migrants’ Reuters (26 August 2021) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
99. Prosecutor v Kunarac, Kovac and Vukovic Kunarac, IT-96-23-T & IT-96-23/1-T, Judgement, 22 February 2001, para 542 (Kunarac Trial Judgement). google scholar
100. Prosecutor v Furundlija IT-95-17/1-T (ICTY, 10 December 1998). google scholar
101. Perce H, ‘An Examination of the International Understanding of Political Rape and the Significance of Labelling it Torture’ (2003) 14 International Journal of Refugee Law 4. google scholar
102. Press Unit, ‘Factsheet -Collective Expulsions of Aliens’ (European Court of Human Rights, 2020) accessed 17 May 2021. google scholar
103. Radio Free Europe, ‘Bulgaria Sends Troops to Border as EU Braces for Afghan Migrant Flows’ (27 August 2021) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
104. Ramsay G and Fiske L, ‘Election Factcheck: Are Many Refugees Illiterate and Innumerate?’ The Conversation (18 May 2016) accessed 2 September 2021. google scholar
105. Ramji-Nogales J, ‘Prohibiting Collective Expulsion of Aliens at the European Court of Human Rights’ (American Society of International Law, 4 January 2016) accessed 27 August 2021. google scholar
106. Relief web, ‘UN Human Rights Council: Ending Collective Pushbacks of Migrants at Borders’ (28 June 2021) accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
107. Rejali D, Torture and Democracy (Princeton University Press, 2009). google scholar
108. Rothman L, ‘The Long, Sad History of Migrant Ships Being Turned Away from Ports’ Time (9 June 2015) accessed 21 September 2021. google scholar
109. Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, 17 July 1998, 2187 UNTS 90. google scholar
110. Sussman D, ‘What’s Wrong with Torture?’ (2005) 33 Philosophy and Public Affairs 1. google scholar
111. Sir Lauterpacht E and Bethlehem D, ‘The Scope and Content of the Principle of NonRefoulement’ in UNHCR (eds) Refugee Protection in International Law: UNHCR’s Global Consultations on International Protection (Cambridge University Press 2003), 149-163 accessed 16 September 2021. google scholar
112. SyalR,‘PritiPateltoSendBoatsCarryingMigrantstoUKBackacrossChannel’ The Guardian (9September 2021) accessed 16 September 2021. google scholar
113. Specia M, ‘U.K. Proposes Moving Asylum Seekers Abroad While Their Cases Are Decided’ The New York Times (6 July 2021) accessed 16 August 2021. google scholar
114. Smith H, ‘Why Greece’s Expensive New Migrant Camps Are Outraging NGOs’ The Guardian (19 September 2021) accessed 20 September 2021. google scholar
115. Stuber S, ‘What’s behind the Housing Crisis for Asylum Seekers in France?’ (The New Humanitarian, 27 April 2021) accessed 17 May 2021. google scholar
116. Stahn C, A Critical Introduction to International Criminal Law (Cambridge University Press 2019). google scholar
117. Sztucki J, ‘Who Is a Refugee? The Convention Definition: Universal or Obsolete?’ in Frances Nicholson and Patrick Twomey (eds) Refugee Rights and Realities (Cambridge University Press 1999). google scholar
118. Schulke-Gill B and Bayer J, ‘Greece: Refugees Attacked and Pushed Back in the Aegean’ DW Made for Minds (29 June 2020) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
119. Schabas W, Unimaginable Atrocities: Justice, Politics, and Rights at the War Crimes Tribunals (New York, Oxford University Press, 2012). google scholar
120. Strickland P, ‘Why Is the World Afraid of Young Refugee Men?’ Al Jazeera (20 June 2016) accessed 6 October 2021. google scholar
121. Stahn C, A Critical Introduction to International Criminal Law (Cambridge University Press 2019). google scholar
122. Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, art. 2 February 2008, 32 I.L.M 1192. google scholar
123. Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment of Punishment Report of the Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment of Punishment, Human Rights Council Forty-third session, 24 February-20 March 2020 Agenda item 3. google scholar
124. Taylor D, ‘French Police Clear Migrant Camp at Launch Point for Britain’ The Guardian (29 September 2020) accessed 25 January 2021. google scholar
125. The Visual Journalism Team, ‘Afghanistan: Where Will Refugees Go after Taliban google scholar
126. Takeover?’ BBC News (26 August 2021) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
127. The Global Detention Project (The Global Detention Project) accessed 27 August 2021. google scholar
128. The Global Detention Project, ‘Country Report. Immigration Detention in Libya: A Human Rights Crisis’ (2018) accessed 18 May 2021. google scholar
129. Tondo L, ‘Revealed: 2,000 Refugee Deaths Linked to Illegal EU Pushbacks’ The Guardian (5 May 2021) accessed 26 August 2021. google scholar
130. Tondo L, ‘Croatian Police Accused of “Sickening” Assaults on Migrants on Balkans Trail’ google scholar
131. The Guardian (21 October 2020) accessed 13 August 2021. google scholar
132. Tindale C W, ‘The Logic of Torture a Critical Examination’ (1996) 22 Social Theory and Practice 3. google scholar
133. UN News and Global Perspective Human Stories, ‘Libya Shipwreck Claims 130 Lives Despite SOS Calls, as UN Agencies Call for Urgent Action’ (23 April 2021) accessed 21 June 2021. google scholar
134. UNHCR, ‘World at War - Forced Displacement in 2014’ (UNHCR Global Trends, 2015) www.unhcr.org/statistics/country/556725e69/unhcr-global-trends-2014.html> accessed 6 September 2021. google scholar
135. Universal Declaration of Human Rights GA Res 217 A (III), UN GAOR, 3rd Sess., 183rd plen mtg, UN Doc A/810,10 December 1948 (UDHR). google scholar
136. United Kingdom Government, ‘Nationality and Borders Bill 2021’ accessed 31 August 2021. google scholar
137. United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, ‘Deadly Practice of Migrant “Pushbacks” Must Cease - UN Special Rapporteur’ (23 June 2021) accessed 14 September 2021. google scholar
138. UNHCR, ‘Legal Considerations Regarding Access to Protection and a Connection between the Refugee and the Third Country in the Context of Return or Transfer to Safe Third Countries’ (UN High Commissioner for Refugees, 2018) accessed 30 September 2021. google scholar
139. UNHCR, ‘UNHCR Concerned by Pushback Reports, Calls for Protection of Refugees and AsylumSeekers’ (UNHCR The UN Refugee Agency, 21 August 2020) accessed 5 August 2021. google scholar
140. UNHCR, ‘Handbook on Procedures and Criteria for Determining Refugee Status and Guidelines on International Protection Under The 1951 Convention and The 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees’ (UNHCR, 2019) accessed 25 May 2021. google scholar
141. United Nations Meetings Coverage and Press Releases, ‘Refugees, Migrants Branded “Threats”, Dehumanized in Campaigns Seeking Political Gain, High Commissioner Tells Third Committee, Appealing for Return to Dignity’ (31 October 2018) accessed 27 August 2021. google scholar
142. United Nations, ‘Detained and Dehumanised: Report on Human Rights Abuses Against Migrants in Libya’ (Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, 2016) www.ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/LY/ DetainedAndDehumanised_en.pdf> accessed 18 May 2021. google scholar
143. UN Human Rights Committee (HRC), ‘CCPR General Comment No. 29: Article 4: Derogations During a State of Emergency’ 31 August 2001, CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.11, para 13(d) www.refworld.org/docid/453883fd1f.html> accessed 9 September 2021. google scholar
144. Zois C, ‘Frontex’ Involvement in Illegal Pushbacks and EU’s Possible International Responsibility’ (Jean Monnet Project EURIS, 17 March 2021) < https://www.jm-euris.eu/frontex-involvement-in-illegal-pushbacks/> accessed 19 October 2022. google scholar
145. Wesel B, ‘Turkey Migration Deal a “Stain on EU Rights Record”’ DW Made for Minds (17 March 2021) accessed 16 June 2021. google scholar
146. Wolfendale J, ‘Training Torturers: A Critique of the “Ticking Bomb” Argument’ (2006) 32 Social Theory and Practice 270. google scholar