Comparison of the interobserver reliability of ultrasonography and radiography in diagnosis of developmental dysplasia of the hip

Abstract

We aimed to compare the interobserver reliability of ultrasonography (USG) and x-ray (XR) and to calculate the sensitivity and specificity of these tests in the diagnosis of developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH). This retrospective study was conducted among 150 USG and 300 XR images of infants examined for DDH between January 2013 and June 2015. The sonographic angle measurements and hip classifications of each USG and XR were carried out by five orthopedic surgeons specialized in pediatric orthopedics. Both USG and XR showed almost perfect agreement between five observers (κUSG=0.936, κXR=0.927, respectively, p<.0001). In patients under the age of 6 months, the interobserver reliability was almost perfect for USG and substantial for XR (κUSG=0.957, κXR=0.809, respectively, p<.0001). In patients older than 6 months, although interobserver agreement of both tests were almost perfect (κ>0.81), XR showed slightly higher agreement than USG (κXR=0.912, κUSG=0.885, respectively, p<.0001). In the diagnosis of DDH, both USG and plain x-rays are effective radiological tests because they offer high interobserver reliability. However, the surgeon's practical training and experience significantly affect the reliability in the evaluation of pediatric hip USG and XR.

Keywords

• developmental dysplasia of the hip
• ultrasonography
• plain x-ray
• interobserver reliability

References

1. AIUM practice guideline for the performance of an ultrasound examination for detection and assessment of developmental dysplasia of the hip. Journal of ultrasound in medicine : official journal of the American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine. 2009;28(1):114-9.
2. Bankaoğlu M. Three-dimensional Computerized Tomography and Multiplanar Imaging of Developmental Hip Dysplasia. Sisli Etfal Hastanesi tip bulteni. 2019;53(2):103-9.
3. Berman L, Klenerman L. Ultrasound screening for hip abnormalities: preliminary findings in 1001 neonates. British medical journal (Clinical research ed). 1986;293(6549):719-22.
4. Clarke NM, Clegg J, Al-Chalabi AN. Ultrasound screening of hips at risk for CDH. Failure to reduce the incidence of late cases. The Journal of bone and joint surgery British volume. 1989;71(1):9-12.
5. Copuroglu C, Ozcan M, Aykac B, Tuncer B, Saridogan K. Reliability of ultrasonographic measurements in suspected patients of developmental dysplasia of the hip and correlation with the acetabular index. Indian journal of orthopaedics. 2011;45(6):553-7.
6. Dezateux C, Rosendahl K. Developmental dysplasia of the hip. Lancet (London, England). 2007;369(9572):1541-52.
7. Dias JJ, Thomas IH, Lamont AC, Mody BS, Thompson JR. The reliability of ultrasonographic assessment of neonatal hips. The Journal of bone and joint surgery British volume. 1993;75(3):479-82.
8. Finne PH, Dalen I, Ikonomou N, Ulimoen G, Hansen TW. Diagnosis of congenital hip dysplasia in the newborn. Acta orthopaedica. 2008;79(3):313-20.

9. Graf R. The diagnosis of congenital hip-joint dislocation by the ultrasonic Combound treatment. Archives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery. 1980;97(2):117-33.
10. Harcke HT, Kumar SJ. The role of ultrasound in the diagnosis and management of congenital dislocation and dysplasia of the hip. The Journal of bone and joint surgery American volume. 1991;73(4):622-8
11. Ismiarto YD, Agradi P, Helmi ZN. Comparison of Interobserver Reliability between Junior and Senior Resident in Assessment of Developmental Dysplasia of The Hip Severity using Tonnis and International Hip Dysplasia Institute Radiological Classification. Malaysian orthopaedic journal. 2019;13(3):60-5.
12. John Lampignano LEK. Bontrager's Textbook of Radiographic Positioning and Related Anatomy. 2017
13. Kolb A, Benca E, Willegger M, Puchner SE, Windhager R, Chiari C. Measurement considerations on examiner-dependent factors in the ultrasound assessment of developmental dysplasia of the hip. International orthopaedics. 2017;41(6):1245-50.
14. Lee MC, Eberson CP. Growth and development of the child's hip. The Orthopedic clinics of North America. 2006;37(2):119-32, v.
15. Milligan DJ, Cosgrove AP. Monitoring of a hip surveillance programme protects infants from radiation and surgical intervention. The bone & joint journal. 2020;102-b(4):495-500.
16. Moraleda L, Albiñana J, Salcedo M, Gonzalez-Moran G. [Dysplasia in the development of the hip]. Revista espanola de cirugia ortopedica y traumatologia. 2013;57(1):67-77.
17. Mostofi E, Chahal B, Zonoobi D, Hareendranathan A, Roshandeh KP, Dulai SK, et al. Reliability of 2D and 3D ultrasound for infant hip dysplasia in the hands of novice users. European radiology. 2019;29(3):1489-95.
18. Omeroğlu H, Ozçelik A, Inan U, Seber S. Assessment of the correlation between commonly used radiographic parameters in normal, subluxated and dislocated hips. Journal of pediatric orthopedics Part B. 2006;15(3):172-7.
19. Omeroğlu H, Biçimoğlu A, Koparal S, Seber S. Assessment of variations in the measurement of hip ultrasonography by the Graf method in developmental dysplasia of the hip. Journal of pediatric orthopedics Part B. 2001;10(2):89-95
20. Orak MM, Onay T, Çağırmaz T, Elibol C, Elibol FD, Centel T. The reliability of ultrasonography in developmental dysplasia of the hip: How reliable is it in different hands? Indian journal of orthopaedics. 2015;49(6):610-4.
21. Roposch A, Graf R, Wright JG. Determining the reliability of the Graf classification for hip dysplasia. Clinical orthopaedics and related research. 2006;447:119-24.
22. Sadeghian M, Zarabi V, Noorbakhsh S, Taherinia L, Jafarv M, Ashouri S. Diagnostic value for imaging studies (radiography, ultrasound and CT scan) in pediatric appendicitis in compare with adults. Emerg Med. 2019;2:1-4
23. Sewell MD, Rosendahl K, Eastwood DM. Developmental dysplasia of the hip. BMJ (Clinical research ed). 2009;339:b4454.
24. Simon EA, Saur F, Buerge M, Glaab R, Roos M, Kohler G. Inter-observer agreement of ultrasonographic measurement of alpha and beta angles and the final type classification based on the Graf method. Swiss medical weekly. 2004;134(45-46):671-7
25. Singh KA, Ganjwala D, Gupta P, Vazhayil Kottamttavida I, Varma M, Shah H. Reliability of 3 Radiologic Classifications for the Severity of the Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip in Children Older Than 4 Years. Journal of pediatric orthopedics. 2021.
26. Sulaiman A, Yusof Z, Munajat I, Lee N, Zaki N. Developmental dysplasia of hip screening using ortolani and barlow testing on breech delivered neonates. Malaysian orthopaedic journal. 2011;5(3):13-6.
27. Terjesen T, Bredland T, Berg V. Ultrasound for hip assessment in the newborn. The Journal of bone and joint surgery British volume. 1989;71(5):767-73.
28. Terjesen T, Rundén TO, Tangerud A. Ultrasonography and radiography of the hip in infants. Acta orthopaedica Scandinavica. 1989;60(6):651-60.