Taksim practice in Turkish music qanun education: An example of Hicaz Taksim by Hasan Ferid Alnar

Abstract

This study aims to produce written material for use in qanun education, focusing on taksim performances, which represent a form of improvised instrumental performance within the tradition of Turkish makam music. While the concept of improvisation generally suggests a free and unconstrained approach to musical creation, the taksim—though improvisatory in nature—is actually shaped by certain rules and structural limitations within the framework of Turkish makam music. Additionally, performers tend to reflect their individual styles during taksim, making each performance unique. The fact that taksim requires instantaneous creativity, and that the rhythmic groupings and makam-based melodic patterns existing in the performer’s mind are generally structured unmeasured and extemporaneously in the moment, is considered one of the main challenges encountered when studying such improvised musical performances on an individual basis. In this context, the use of recording technology to preserve the audio recordings of master performers’ taksims and to transcribe them into musical notation holds significant importance. In order to contribute to this field, the population of this study is defined as qanun taksim performances, while its sample consists of the Hicaz Taksim by qanun player Hasan Ferid Alnar, which, to the best of our findings, has not been previously transcribed into musical notation. The recording of the Hicaz Taksim was obtained through the radio program Semt-i Nihâvend, prepared by kemençe player Fikret Karakaya for Açık Radyo. First, Hasan Ferid Alnar’s Hicaz Taksim was transcribed into musical notation through dictation. The sections of the taksim were identified, and in each section, the ornamentation elements, two-hand performance styles, and playing techniques were determined. While identifying the playing techniques, the audio recordings and written works of Ferid Alnar’s other performances were used as references in order to determine the possible playing methods. In this study, which employs document analysis, one of the qualitative research methods, the rhythmic and melodic structures of the taksim were transcribed into musical notation. The ornamentation elements and possible playing techniques were analyzed, and it is believed that these qanun taksim performances will contribute to taksim practice within instrumental education.

Keywords

• Hasan Ferid Alnar
• qanun
• qanun playing techniques
• Taksim
• Turkish music

Supporting Institution

No funding

Ethical Statement

There is no conflict of interest in this article; therefore, ethical committee approval was not required.

References

1. Akdoğu, O. (1989). Taksim Nedir Nasıl Yapılır? (What is Taksim and how is it performed?). İhlas.
2. Alnar, F. (1987). Yaşam öyküm (My life story). Orchestra Monthly Music, 18(166), 30-39.
3. Balkarlı, S., Basmacıoğlu, B., Berkman, E., & Taşdelen, D. (2021). 40. vefat yılında Hasan Ferid Alnar sempozyumu Bildiri Kitabı (Proceedings Book of the Symposium on the 40th Anniversary of the Death of Hasan Ferid Alnar). Anadolu University.
4. Aslan, C. (2022). Türk Makam Müziği’nde taksim türü ve Mesut Cemil’in tanbur taksimlerinin incelenmesi (The Taksim genre in Turkish Makam Music and an analysis of Mesut Cemil’s Tanbur Taksims). Master thesis. Bursa Uludağ University. Bursa, Türkiye.
5. Ayangil, R. (1990). Kanun öğrenme metodu (Method for learning the Qanun) Unpublished lecture notes.
6. Ayangil, R. (2009). Bir Cumhuriyet çınarı Ferid Alnar (Ferid Alnar: a monument of the republic). Turkish Airlines-CD.
7. Bailey, D. (2011). Doğaçlama (Improvisation). Pan.
8. Behar, C. (2015). Osmanlı/Türk Musıkisinin kısa tarihi (A brief history of Ottoman/ Turkish music). Yapı Kredi.

9. Berkman, E. (2007). Kanun çalmayı otodidakt yöntemle öğrenmiş beş kanunçaların görüş ve yaklaşımları bağlamında XX. yüzyıl kanun sanatına bakış (A perspective on 20th century qanun art in the context of the opinions and approaches of five autodidact qanun players). Master thesis. Yıldız Technical University. Istanbul, Türkiye.
10. Boy, B., and Baloğlu, B.Ş. (2023). Türk Müziği taksim formunun nota ile ifâdesi için bir alternatif yöntem önerisi (An alternative method proposal for the notation of the Turkish Music taksim form). International Journal of Social and Human Sciences Research, 10(102), 3758–3770. https://doi. org/10.5281/zenodo.10480642
11. Erdoğan, E. (2020) Kanun icrâcılığı ve Türk müziği yönüyle Hasan Ferid Alnar (Hasan Ferid Alnar in terms of Qanun Performance and Turkish Music). Doctoral dissertation. Gazi University. Ankara, Türkiye.
12. Eruzun Özel, A. (2022, Ocak 27). İhsan Özgen ile söyleşi (Interview with İhsan Özgen). Saz ve Söz Dergisi. https://divanmakam.com/ yazilar/ihsan-ozgen-ile-soylesi-saz-ve-soz- dergisi-sayi-10.60/
13. Feldman, W. (1993). Ottoman Sources on the development of the taksîm. Yearbook for Traditional Music, 25, 1- 28. https://doi. org/10.2307/768680
14. Gazimihal M. R. (1961). Musıki sözlüğü (Music dictionary). Ministry of National Education of Türkiye.
15. Giray, M.Z. (2023). Göksel Baktagir’in kanun taksimlerinin makamsal analizi (Makamic analysis of Göksel Baktagir’s qanun taksims). Doctoral dissertation. İnönü University. Malatya, Türkiye.
16. Günaydın,N.(2018).TürkMakamMüziği’nde taksim ve çalışma yöntemi olarak şarkı formunun kullanım. (Taksim in Turkish Makam music and the use of song form as a study method). Master thesis. Istanbul Technical University. Istanbul, Türkiye.
17. Işıktaş, B. (2011). Şerif Muhittin Targan’ın oud tekniğine katkısı;6 oud taksiminin analizi (Şerif Muhittin Targan’s contribution to oud technique: an analysis of six oud taksims). Master thesis. Istanbul Technical University. Istanbul, Türkiye.
18. Karaduman, H. (2007). Kanun metodu (Qanun method). Alfa.
19. Taksim practice in Turkish music qanun education: An example of Hicaz Taksim by Hasan Ferid Alnar
20. Kazazoğlu, İ. (2018). Vecihe Darya’ın kanun taksimlerinin tahlili (Analysis of Vecihe Darya’s qanun taksims). Doctoral dissertation. Gazi University. Ankara, Türkiye.
21. Kılıç, T.V. (2022). Kanun eğitiminde taksim çalışmalarınayönelikajiliteiçerenalıştırma ve etütler (Exercises and etudes including agility for taksim practice in qanun education). Master thesis. Istanbul Technical University. Istanbul, Türkiye.
22. Kozak, İ.A. (2022). Ahmet Meter’in kanun taksimlerindeki teknik ve melodik özelliklerin tespiti aracılığıyla ileri icraya yönelik alıştırma önerileri (Exercise proposals for advanced qanun performance through the analysis of technical and melodic features in Ahmet Meter’s qanun taksims) Master thesis. Ankara University of Music and Fine Arts. Ankara, Türkiye.
23. Özdemir, E. (2022). Türk Halk Müziği’nde doğaçlama bir icrâ göstergesi olarak açış (Açış as an Indicator of improvisational performance in Turkish folk music). Journal of Ethnomusicology, 5(2), 225–243.
24. Özgen, İ. (2012). Avludaki ses (The sound in the courtyard). Pan.
25. Toksoy, A.K. (2018). Kanunda süsleme ve modern çalış teknikleri için alıştırmalar- etütler. (Exercises and etudes for ornamentation and modern playing techniques in qanun). Istanbul Technical University Turkish Music State Conservatory.
26. Torun, M. (2010). Türk Müziği formlarına analitik yaklaşım (An analytical approach to the forms of Turkish Music). Unpublished lecture notes.
27. Vural, F. (2019). Kanuni Hacı Arif Bey ve Kanuni Vecihe Daryal’ın Taksimlerinin icra tekniği analizleri (Performance technique analyses of the taksims by qanun players Hacı Arif Bey and Vecihe Daryal). Master thesis. Okan University. Istanbul, Türkiye.
28. Yavaşca, A. (2002). Türk Mûsıkîsi’nde kompozisyon ve beste biçimleri (Composition and musical forms in Turkish Music). FoundationfortheServicetoTurkishCulture.
29. Yıldırım, A. ve Şimşek, H. (2006). Sosyal Bilimlerde nitel araştırma yöntemleri (Qualitative research methods in social sciences). Seçkin Publishing.
30. Web sites Web1. https://www.facebook.com/profile. php?id=100053477396612&sk=photos
31. Web2.https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=FBph2EQ_9ac&t=1599s