Uludağ İlahiyat Dergisi

Publication Content
Uludag Journal of Theology contains original scientific publications. Except for editorial studies, all published articles are subject to a double-blind peer-review process.

Aim and Scope
Uludag Journal of Theology is an academic journal that aims to contribute to accumulating knowledge in theology and social sciences by publishing original scientific studies of national and international quality. The journal seeks to publish open-access works such as original research articles, book reviews, symposium evaluations, translations, obituaries, and research notes related to religious studies (Social and Human Sciences/Religion) and share them with the public. Manuscripts submitted to the journal are evaluated through a double-blind peer review system. In addition, it is confirmed that the articles have not been previously published or sent to another journal for publication and do not contain plagiarism through a particular program. Manuscripts should describe original data that have not been previously published or submitted elsewhere. Uludag Journal of Theology sends articles that comply with the submission rules and journal scope to at least two expert reviewers for scientific evaluation. After evaluating the compliance, the editorial board members of Uludag Journal of Theology consider the reviewers' comments on each submission. The final decision for all submissions belongs to the Editor-in-Chief. The Editorial Board of Uludag Journal of Theology commits to complying with the criteria of the International Council of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Types of Published Articles: Uludag Journal of Theology publishes academic studies in the categories of "research article", "research note", "book review", "scientific meeting review", "translation", "critical edition of text", and "tribute note".

Topic Categories:
Social Sciences: Sociology, Field Research/Sufism/Basic Islamic Sciences
Humanities: Philosophy, Religion & Theology, History, History and Philosophy of Science; Education and Educational Research, Psychology; Religion, Cultural Studies, Islamic History and Arts

Field of Study:
Philosophy and Religious Studies: Islamic Philosophy, Philosophy of Religion, History of Philosophy, Logic, Sociology of Religion, History of Religions, Religious Education, Religious Psychology
Basic Islamic Sciences: Qur'an and Modes of Recitation(Qirā'āt), Exegesis(Tafsîr), Hadith, Kalam(Theology), Islamic Jurisprudence, Sufism, History of Islamic Sects, Arabic Language and Literature
Islamic History and Arts: Islamic History, Religious Music, History of Islamic Art, Islamic Literature

Congress Library/LCC Subject Category: Philosophy. Psychology. Religion. Philosophy (General)

Keywords: Religion, Philosophy, History, Sociology, Education, Türkiye.

Publication Language
Full Text Publication Language:
                  • Primary Language: Turkish
                  • Secondary Languages: English and Arabic
Content Written in English and Latin Alphabet:
                 • Article Title: Turkish & English
                 • Author’s Name: Turkish (in Latin alphabet)
                 • Author’s Affiliation/ Address: Turkish (in Latin alphabet)
                 • Keywords: Turkish & English
                 • Bibliography:: Turkish (in Latin alphabet)
Full Text: Turkish (in Latin alphabet)

Article Submission
The submitted articles should align with the purpose and scope of the journal. Manuscripts that are original, unpublished, and not in the process of evaluation in another journal, Manuscripts that have been approved for content and submission by each author are accepted for evaluation.

Target Audience
The target audience of the journal consists of academicians, researchers, professionals, students, and relevant professional and academic institutions and organizations. Uludag Journal of Theology aims to contribute to the dissemination of continuous professional development and research culture.

Wage Policy
Publication and processing of articles in the journal are not subject to any fees. No processing fee or submission fee is charged for papers submitted to or accepted for publication in the journal under any circumstances. Uludag Journal of Theology does not accept sponsorships or advertisements as part of its publication policies. All expenses of Uludag Journal of Theology are covered by the Dean's Office of the Faculty of Theology at Bursa Uludag University.

Copyright
The copyright of the studies published in Uludag Journal of Theology belongs to their authors. Authors permit Uludag Journal of Theology to publish their intellectual work under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.

Originality of Articles
Uludag Journal of Theology does not accept previously published works. However, published articles in a foreign language (translated articles) may be considered for publication.

*** Manuscripts received outside of the acceptance dates (for June issue: 1st January - 1st March, and for December issue: 1st July - 1st September) will not be considered for publication.

*** a maximum of one article (research article) by the same author is published in one issue or two consecutive issues in a year.

Article Preparation

Language: Turkish, Arabic, and English
The language options for the article are Turkish of Türkiye, Arabic, and English.
Types of Articles: Research Article, Research Note, Book Review, Scientific Meeting Review, Translation, critical edition of text, and tribute note.
Article Format: MS Word Template
Visual Format: JPEG with a minimum of 300 dpi
Citation Style: ISNAD Citation System, 2nd Edition (author-title system)

Change of Authorship: This process will only be considered before the acceptance of the article. Authors should carefully review the list and order of authors before submitting their papers and provide a definitive list of authors at the time of the original submission.

Writing Rules:

1. Uludag Journal of Theology is a national, refereed, academic journal published twice a year, in June and December.

2. The journal includes original and translated articles, annotated text publications, research notes, memorial notes, book reviews, and evaluations of scientific events in all fields of social sciences, particularly religious studies, as well as politics, history, sociology, and philosophy.

3. Submitted articles must not have been previously published or accepted for publication elsewhere. Articles produced from doctoral theses and papers presented at scientific events but not yet published can be accepted for publication. In this case, the journal must be informed at the initial submission stage, and the bibliographic information of the thesis/paper should be indicated in the first footnote after the completion of the peer review process. As of 2023, articles derived from master's theses are not accepted for publication.

4. Uludag Journal of Theology endeavours to adhere to its publication schedule. For articles in the research and translation categories, it is expected that they will have been submitted four months prior to the publication date of the journal. Therefore, the deadline for the June issue is March 1st, and for the December issue, it is September 1st. For articles in other categories, it is possible to submit them up to 45 days prior to the publication date. However, following the announcements regarding the journal's article submission dates is recommended. Articles that have not completed the peer-review or editorial review processes by the journal's publication date will be postponed to the next issue.

5. Since the articles submitted to the journal will go through an evaluation process using a double-blind peer review system, no identifying information or information deciphering the name and identity of the author should be included in the articles added to the system. Additionally, file information should be deleted in Word Program (File/Info-Check for Issues - Inspect Document/Document Inspector/Inspect. Remove All).

6. Header-footer entries and page numbers should not be included in the articles submitted to the journal.

7. Although the publication language of the journal is Turkish, articles written in Arabic and English can also be published. Arabic and English articles should be submitted with Turkish translations prepared according to the journal's writing rules. Papers without Turkish translations will not be evaluated.

8. Translated articles should be submitted with their originals, and publications / reviews should be submitted along with the main text.
(Principles of Critical Edition Publicatons)

9. Only one article, either an original work or a translation, by the same author can be published in a particular issue.

10. Within a year, more than one article (research articles) by the same author is not published in consecutive issues.

11. Upon the request of TR Index, qualitative and quantitative research articles are required to have an ethics committee approval document. It is mandatory for authors to upload this document into the system.

12. Copyrighted and translated articles should not exceed 9,000 words, including the reference list, but excluding tables, figures, and supplementary sections, with a maximum of 35 pages according to the specified criteria, while articles related to the book and scientific event reviews should not exceed 2,500 words. The editorial board's evaluation determines if the word count exceeds the specified limits. Moreover, a Turkish and English abstract between 150-250 words should be included for copyrighted articles, and a reference list should be provided at the end of the article. For research articles decided to be published after the peer-review process, an extended Turkish and English summary of 750-1000 words is requested from the author.

13. Uludag Journal of Theology employs ISNAD Citation System (second edition with footnotes). For the ISNAD Citation System and Academic Writing Guide, please visit https://www.isnadsistemi.org/en/ . For Isnad Citation style with footnotes, please visit https://www.isnadsistemi.org/en/guide/isnad2-2/isnad-author-title-system/ 

14. Before submitting the article, the abstract, keywords, footnotes, bibliography, and tables should be completed.

15. The selection, ordering, and number of keywords should be in compliance with the ISNAD Reference System.

16. In Arabic articles, the bibliography should also be written in the Latin Alphabet.

17. Uludag Journal of Theology applies the transliteration method recommended by the ISNAD Reference System. Therefore, the articles are expected to be transliterated according to the ISNAD Reference System. Papers that are not fully transliterated according to the system will still be evaluated, but the deficiencies are expected to be completed by the author.

18. Authors are required to adhere to the writing guidelines of the journal. Papers that do not comply with the writing guidelines will be returned to the author by the editorial board for necessary corrections.

19. Applications are made through DergiPark by using the website address https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/uluid 

Translation Article Template

1. For the translation to be considered for evaluation, the article must be newly published and current (preferably published within the last 5 years) and must have received a certain number of citations (at least 5) in its original language.

2. The translator must obtain written permission from the author(s) and publisher of the article (this should be stated in the first footnote). All copyright fees for translated articles belong to the translator.

3. If there is an abstract, keywords, or summary in the original text, they should be provided in the same way in the translation. The translator should prepare and add a summary and abstract (150-250 words) with 5-8 keywords according to the ISNAD Citation System (2nd Edition) if they are not in the original text. This should be indicated in a footnote at the beginning of the text.

4. Regardless of the citation system used in the original text, footnotes and references should be in accordance with the ISNAD Citation System (2nd Edition). If references are not given in the original text, they should be prepared according to the ISNAD Citation System (2nd Edition) and placed at the end of the translation in square brackets. This should be indicated in a footnote at the beginning of the text.

5. The translated article should be identified according to the ISNAD Citation System by adding an asterisk (*) to the end of the title.
Example: [This study is a translated version of the article titled "xxx xxx" written by xxx xxx (Journal name volume/issue (year), page range) with the permission of the author and publisher (xxx Publisher). The abstract, keywords, expressions in square brackets, and asterisk-marked footnotes were added by us, and the footnotes and bibliography were adapted to the ISNAD Citation System (2nd Edition).]

6. Additionally, the name of the article's author should be followed by an asterisk (*) indicating their position, institution/university, city, country, department/field of study, and date/year of death, if applicable. This and similar information about the author can also be presented in the footnote as a paragraph.

7. The journal's editorial board has decided to include a maximum of two translations per issue. Therefore, any translations beyond this number will be included in the next issue.

8. Translation articles should be submitted four months prior to publication due to the process of peer-review and publication timelines.

Journal Publication Guidelines for Book Reviews

1. Book review articles submitted to the journal should be about recently published works (preferably books published within the last five years) on current topics.

2. Book critiques/reviews should focus on the strengths and weaknesses of the book and examine its contribution to the field. Articles that merely summarize or advertise the book will not be accepted as book reviews.

3. The review article should include a Turkish and English abstract of at least 60-80 words and 5-8 keywords.

4. As of 2023, for articles submitted in the book promotion genre, The authors must be at least a PhD candidate.

5. Also see Book Review Writing Guide; What is Academic Book Reviewing and How to Do It?

Writing Guidelines for Uludag Journal of Theology
1. The papers submitted for publication in the journal should be prepared in accordance with the following format. (For detailed template, see "Article Writing Template").

2. The papers should be written in Microsoft Office Word program (Word 97 or a later version), in page size of 19x25, using ISNAD Font or Gentium Plus font style (both fonts can be downloaded from the ISNAD Citation System webpage), in "12 font size" and "single" line spacing, as justified text.The margins of the text should be set as follows: top 2.5 cm, bottom 2.5 cm, left 2.5 cm, right 2.5 cm and gutter 0 cm; paragraph spacing should be set as before and after 6 pt. Footnotes should be set as "10 font size"; "single" line spacing and “hanging indent of -0.5 cm”.

3. Traditional Arabic font style should be used for Arabic phrases.

Publication Ethics Principles

Publication ethics can be defined as a self-regulation mechanism that insists on honesty on behalf of authors, reviewers, and publishers to establish higher editorial processing standards. Ethical standards for publication are in place to ensure high-quality scientific publications, public confidence in scientific findings, and respect for people's ideas.
• Honest researchers do not engage in plagiarism.
• They do not misrepresent sources.
• They do not hide objections that they cannot refute.
• They do not distort opposing views.
• They do not destroy or conceal data.

Peer-reviewed studies are works that support and implement the scientific method. At this point, it is of great importance for all parties involved in the publication process (authors, readers and researchers, publisher, referees and editors) to adhere to ethical principles. Uludag Journal of Theology adheres to national and international standards on research and publication ethics. Uludag Journal of Theology complies with the Press Law (a), Intellectual and Artistic Works Low (b), and the Higher Education Institutions Scientific Research and Publication Ethics Directive (c). Additionally, it has adopted the International Ethical Publishing Principles (d) published by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA), and World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and commits to complying with the Turkish Editors Workshop Decisions (e).
      a) Press Law (National Legislation)
      b) Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works (National Legislation)
      c) Higher Education Institutions Scientific Research and Publication Ethics Directive (National Legislation)
      d) Transparency and Best Practice Principles in Academic Publishing (International Criteria)
      e) Turkish Editors Workshop Decisions (National Criteria)

Republication
Republication is the publication of the same article or substantially similar articles in more than one journal. The editor will return such articles without review. After that, the editor may impose an embargo on the author attempting republication for a certain period, announce to the public (perhaps as a simultaneous announcement with the editor of the journal that previously published the article) that the author has published the same work before, or apply all of these measures together.


Simultaneous Submission of the Same Work to Multiple Journals
Authors cannot submit the same article to multiple journals at the same time. If the editor becomes aware of possible simultaneous submissions, they reserve the right to consult with other editors who have received the article. Additionally, the editor may return the article without review, reject it without considering the reviews, or make this decision by discussing it with the relevant other editor(s) and may decide not to accept article submissions from the authors for a certain period. They may also write to the authors' employers or implement all of these measures together.

Plagiarism Prevention:
Plagiarism is presenting someone else's ideas, methods, data, practices, writings, figures, or works as one's own without proper attribution according to scientific rules.
Uludag Journal of Theology scans all submitted articles to prevent plagiarism. The studies submitted for review are checked for plagiarism using the iThenticate software, and a similarity rate of less than 15% is expected. The main measure of similarity is the author's compliance with the citation and referencing rules. Even if the similarity rate is 1%, plagiarism may still be possible if citations and references are not properly made. In this respect, authors should be aware of and carefully follow citation and referencing rules: www.isnadsistemi.org. 

Plagiarism, duplication, false authorship/ denied authorship, research/data fabrication, article slicing, slicing for publication, copyright infringement, and concealment of conflicts of interest are considered unethical behaviours. All articles that do not comply with accepted ethical standards are removed from publication. This includes articles with possible irregularities and inconsistencies detected after publication.

Forgery
Forgery involves generating non-research-based data, creating or modifying a presented or published work based on simulated data, reporting or publishing them, and portraying uncompleted research as completed.

Manipulating research records and obtained data, presenting methods, devices, and materials not used in the research as if they were used, not considering data that does not fit the research hypothesis, manipulating data and/or results to fit the relevant theory or assumption, and distorting or shaping research results in line with the interests of supported individuals and organizations are considered forgery.

Protection of Participants' Personal Data
Uludag Journal of Theology requires all research containing personal or sensitive data or materials related to non-public human participants to undergo formal ethical review.

Handling Allegations of Research Misconduct
Uludag Journal of Theology complies with COPE's Ethics Toolkit for a Successful Editorial, https://publicationethics.org/files/cope-ethics-toolkit-journal-editors-publishers.pdf . The editors of the Uludag Journal of Theology will take measures to prevent the publication of articles that involve plagiarism, citation manipulation, data falsification, data fabrication, and other forms of research misconduct. Under no circumstances will the editors of Uludag Journal of Theology knowingly allow such misconduct to take place. If the editors of Uludag Journal of Theology become aware of an allegation of research misconduct related to an article published in their journal, they will follow COPE's guidelines regarding the allegations.

Reporting Ethical Violations
Readers who notice a significant error or mistake in an article published in the Uludag Journal of Theology, or who have any complaints related to editorial content (such as plagiarism, reproduced publication, etc.), may report their concerns by sending an email to ilahiyatdergisi@uludag.edu.tr. We welcome such submissions as an opportunity for growth and will respond promptly and constructively.

Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
Editors may consider issuing a correction if minor errors are detected in the published article that do not affect the findings, interpretations, and conclusions. Editors should consider retracting the article in case of major errors/violations that invalidate the findings and conclusions. If there is a possibility of research or publication misconduct by the authors, or if there is evidence that the findings are not trustworthy and the authors' institution has not investigated the matter or the investigation seems unfair or inconclusive, the editors should consider issuing an expression of concern. COPE and ICJME guidelines are followed regarding corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern.

Publication of Studies Based on Survey and Interview
Uludag Journal of Theology adopts the "Code of Conduct and Best Practice Guidelines for Journal Editors" and the "Code of Conduct for Journal Publishers" principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) to ensure ethical assurance in scientific publishing. Accordingly, the following points should be followed in the studies submitted to the journal:

1) Ethics committee approval should be obtained for research conducted in all disciplines that require ethics committee approval, and this approval should be stated and documented in the article.
2) In research requiring ethics committee approval, information about the permission (committee name, date, and number) should be included in the methodology section, and in case reports, information about signed informed consent form should be given on the first/last pages of the article.

Special Issue Publication Policy
A special issue may be published once a year in our journal upon the request of the Publication Board. Articles submitted to be included in the special issue are first subjected to editorial pre-review. Then, they are evaluated in terms of compliance with the journal's writing rules, and a similarity scan is performed to prevent plagiarism. After these stages, they are subject to the peer review process using the double-blind review model.

Editorial Confidentiality Obligation
The editors of Uludag Journal of Theology treat all submitted articles as confidential documents, meaning that they will not disclose information about an article without the author's permission. During the article review process, the following people can access the articles: Editors, Reviewers, Editorial Board Members. The only situation in which details about a manuscript may be passed on to a third party without the consent of the authors is when the editor suspects serious research misconduct.

Scientific Misconduct Allegations-Suspicions
There are different definitions of scientific misconduct. While following the guidance created by major publication ethics organizations, Uludag Journal of Theology handles these problems on a case-by-case basis. If the editor suspects an ethical violation or there is an allegation of misconduct, the editor is obliged to take action. This duty covers both published and unpublished articles. The editor should not simply reject articles that raise possible ethical issues. They must follow up on the alleged ethical violations. When appropriate, the editor should follow COPE flowcharts. Editors should first seek a response from those suspected of misconducts. If they are not satisfied with the response, they should request that the relevant employer or institution conduct an investigation. The editor should make every reasonable effort to ensure that an appropriate investigation is conducted regarding the alleged misconduct; if not, the editor should persist in making every reasonable effort to find a solution to the problem. This is a laborious but essential task.

Uludag Journal of Theology adheres to the ethical guidelines set forth by COPE for successful manuscript management. The editors of the Journal will take measures to prevent the publication of articles containing plagiarism, citation manipulation, data falsification, data fabrication, and other forms of research misconduct. Under no circumstances will the editors of the Journal knowingly permit such misconduct to occur. If the editors of Uludag Journal of Theology become aware of any allegations of research misconduct related to an article published in their journal, they will follow the guidelines of COPE.

When referees suspect research or publication misconduct, they must inform the editor. The editor is responsible for taking necessary actions in accordance with COPE guidelines.
Uludag Journal of Theology commits to applying COPE flowcharts when faced with allegations of misconduct in the following or similar areas:

     • Suspected duplicate publication
     • Suspected plagiarism
     • Suspected data fabrication
     • Requests for changes in authorship
     • Suspected undisclosed conflict of interest
     • Suspected false or ghost authorship
     • Suspected ethical problem in an article
     • When a suspicion of ethical violation is directly reported via email or other means
     • When a suspicion of ethical violation is announced via social media

Complaint Procedure
This procedure applies to complaints related to content, procedures, or policies for which Uludag Journal of Theology or our editorial team is responsible. We aim to respond quickly, kindly, and constructively to complaints, which can provide an opportunity for improvement and encouragement.

Complaints must be related to content, procedures, or policies for which Uludag Journal of Theology or our editorial team is responsible. They should be sent directly to ilahiyatdergisi@uludag.edu.tr and will be treated confidentially. The editor will respond to complaints promptly and follow the procedures outlined in the COPE flowchart regarding complaints.

Complaints will be reviewed by the relevant member of the editorial team, and if they cannot be resolved, the following processes will be followed:
     • If the initial response is deemed inadequate, the complainant may request that the complaint be forwarded to a more senior member of the journal.
     • If the complainant is still dissatisfied, the complaint may be forwarded to the chief editor.
     • A full response will be provided within two weeks, if possible.

COPE publishes a code of practice for editors of scientific journals. This will facilitate the resolution of disputes between editors, journals, and publishers, but recourse to COPE can only be sought after exhausting the journal's own complaint procedures.

Appeal Process
We welcome serious objections to the evaluations made by editors and referees. If you believe that we rejected your article because we misunderstood its scientific content, please send an appeal message to our editorial team at ilahiyatdergisi@uludag.edu.tr. At this stage, please do not try to submit a revised version of your article. If we understand that your objection is justified after reading your appeal letter, we may invite you to submit a revised version of your article. Your work will then be resubmitted to the external referee process. Please include as many details as possible in your appeal letter. Finally, we can only consider one appeal per article, so please take the time and effort to write the letter in detail and make your objection clear. We have seen that prolonged discussions of rejected articles are generally not satisfactory for both authors and editors, so we do not consider multiple appeals for the same work.

Conflicts of Interest
Conflict of interest arises when professional judgment regarding a primary interest may be affected by a secondary interest (such as financial gain or personal competition). We believe that in order to make the best decision on how to handle an article, we need to know the competing interests of the authors, and readers should also know them if we publish the article.
It is important to disclose any financial or other interests that could potentially create conflicts of interest, compromising objectivity or providing an unfair advantage to any person or organization. Disclosure should include all sources of financial support received and the role of sponsors in conducting the research and preparing the article. If no funding was received, this fact should also be stated. Examples of potential conflicts of interest requiring disclosure include consultancies, salary receipt, and grants. Potential conflicts of interest should be disclosed at the earliest possible stage.

Uludag Journal of Theology has a process established to handle submissions from editors, staff, or board members to ensure unbiased review. Such submissions are primarily directed to other journals. If this is not possible, the submission owner's duty to the journal is suspended. These submissions are reviewed through the double-blind review process.
The editor should not be involved in decisions about articles written by themselves or their family members. Additionally, such work should be subject to all ordinary procedures of the journal. The editor should follow ICMJE guidelines on disclosure of potential conflicts of interest by authors and referees.

Principles of Research Ethics
Uludag Journal of Theology upholds the highest standards of research ethics and adheres to the internationally recognized principles of research ethics described below. These principles include protecting the rights and dignity of research participants, ensuring research integrity, transparency and accountability, and protecting intellectual property rights. Compliance with ethical rules in articles is the responsibility of the authors.  

   • Principles of integrity, quality and transparency should be ensured in designing the research, reviewing the design, and conducting the research.
     • The research team and participants should be fully informed about the purpose, methods, and anticipated uses of the research, as well as the requirements and risks of participating in the research.
     • The confidentiality of the information provided by research participants and the anonymity of respondents must be ensured. The research must be designed to protect the autonomy and dignity of the participants.
     • Research participants should participate voluntarily and should not be under any coercion.
     • Harm to participants should be avoided. The research must be planned in a way that does not put participants at risk.
     • Transparency should be maintained regarding research independence, and any conflicts of interest should be disclosed.
     • In experimental studies involving human subjects, written informed consent must be obtained from participants who decide to participate in the research. The consent of the legal guardian must be obtained for children, custodians, or those with diagnosed mental illness.
     • If the study is to be conducted in any institution or organization, approval must be obtained from that institution or organization.
     • In studies involving human subjects, the "method" section must indicate that “informed consent” has been obtained from the participants and that the study has been approved by the ethics committee of the institution where it was conducted.

All expenses of Uludağ Journal of Theology are covered by the Publisher. The publication of articles in the journal and the execution of article processes are not subject to any fee. No processing or submission fee is charged under any name for articles submitted to the journal or accepted for publication.