Early Independence Fears and the Romanian Commercial Treaties Crisis: Great Power Diplomacy in the Balkans, 1874–1875

Abstract

This article examines the diplomatic crisis of 1874–1875 surrounding Romania’s attempt to conclude commercial treaties independently of the Ottoman Empire. Although initially framed as a trade issue, the dispute raised broader questions about Ottoman suzerainty, Great Power oversight, and the premature recognition of Romanian independence. Drawing on British diplomatic correspondence alongside Ottoman and European archival sources, the article analyses how Romania expanded its external autonomy by presenting commercial agreements as administrative rather than political acts and by exploiting rivalries among the Great Powers. It argues that the controversy reflected wider European anxieties about altering Romania’s status before a collective settlement had been achieved. Austria-Hungary supported the treaties to secure its economic interests in the Danube region, Germany adopted a cautious stance, Russia remained restrained, while Britain and France defended the post-1856 Paris settlement. The Austro-Romanian commercial convention of June 1875 marked a significant step in Romania’s growing international agency.

Keywords

• Eastern Question
• Great Power Diplomacy
• Ottoman Empire
• Balkans
• Romania

References

1. The National Archives (NA), Foreign Office (FO)
2. FO, 27/2047, No. 293, Very Confidential.
3. FO, 27/2054, No. 646.
4. FO, 27/2059, No. 968, Confidential.
5. FO, 27/2061, No. 1121, No. 1090, Confidential.
6. FO, 27/2103, No. 31.
7. FO, 424/33, No. 38, No. 108, No. 15, Confidential, No. 89, Confidential, No. 89, Confidential, No. 3B. Confidential, No. 17, No. 52, No. 34, No. 30, Confidential, No. 60, Confidential, No. 71, No. 70, No. 78, No. 50, Confidential, No. 76, No. 75, Particuliere, No. 3, Confidential, No. 51, No. 99, No. 126, Secret, No. 125, Secret, No. 163, Confidential, No. 187, No. 159, Confidential, No. 169, Confidential, No. 121, No. 143, Confidential, No. 129, No. 130, Confidential, No. 139, No. 133, Confidential, No. 173, No. 136, Confidential, No. 184, No. 65, Inclosure in No. 65. Extract from the “Pressa”, No. 160, No. 161, No. 223.
8. FO, 45/242, No. 105, Confidential, No. 99, No. 120, Confidential.

9. FO, 64/777, No. 442. Confidential.
10. FO, 64/802, No. 80
11. FO, 64/806, No. 237, No. 255.
12. FO, 64/807, No. 291, Confidential, No. 261, Secret, No. 312, Secret, No. 347, Confidential, No. 348, Confidential
13. FO, 65/882, No. 15.
14. FO, 7/827, No. 22, Most Confidential, No. 27, Confidential.
15. FO, 7/830, No. 178, Confidential, No. 23, Confidential.
16. FO, 7/831, No. 223, No. 255. Confidential,
17. FO, 7/832, No. 239, Confidential, No. 317, Confidential, No. 326, Confidential.
18. FO, 7/833, No. 340.
19. FO, 7/848, No. 32, Confidential, No. 57, Confidential.
20. FO, 78/2273, No. 428.
21. FO, 78/2327, No. 83.
22. FO, 78/2328, No. 183, No. 185, No. 203, No. 255, Confidential, No. 280, Confidential
23. FO, 78/2331, No. 35, No. 145, No. 96, No. 28, No. 115, Confidential, No. 80, Confidential.
24. FO, 78/2332, No. 190, No. 191, No. 176, No. 257, Confidential, No. 228, Confidential, No. 256, No. 156, Confidential, No. 147, Confidential, No. 259, Confidential.
25. FO, 78/2333, No. 272, Confidential, No. 320, Confidential, No. 319, Confidential, No. 365, No. 340, Most Confidential, No. 333, Confidential, No. 314, Confidential, No. 321, Confidential, No. 317, Confidential, No. 309, Confidential, No. 381.
26. Republic of Turkey Presidential State Archives-Ottoman Archives (BOA)
27. Bab-ı Asafi Divan-ı Hümayun Name-i Hümayun Kalemi (A.DVN.NMH),17/4.
28. Hariciye Nezareti Londra Sefareti Belgeleri (HR.SFR.3), 220/22.
29. Hariciye Nezareti Petersburg Sefareti Belgeleri (HR.SFR.1), 49/51, 52/10.
30. Hariciye Nezareti Siyasi (HR.SYS), 1043/1, 1048/1, 158/91, 1890/11.
31. Hariciye Nezareti Tercüme Odası Evrakı (HR.TO), 6/71.
32. İrade Hariciye (İ.HR), 223/13014, 222/12960.
33. Parliament of the United Kingdom
34. House of Commons Debates (HC Deb) 18 June 1875 vol 225 cc181-219.
35. House of Lords Debates (HL Deb) 26 July 1875 vol 226 cc10-32.
36. Research and Review works
37. Anderson, Matthew Smith. Doğu Sorunu 1774-1923, Uluslararası İlişkiler Üzerine Bir İnceleme. çev. İdil Eser, İstanbul: Yapı Kredi Yay., 2001.
38. Antonescu, Cornelius. Die rumänische Handelspolitik von 1875-1910. Schunke, 1915.
39. Archives Diplomatiques, Recueil de Diplomatie et d’Histoire, I. Librairie Diplomatique d’Amyot, Paris, 1867.
40. Archives Diplomatiques, Recueil de Diplomatie et d’Historie, II. Paris: Librairie Diplomatique d’Amyot, 1866.
41. Blake, Robert. Disraeli. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1967.
42. Botond, Nagy. “Az Osztrák-Magyar és Monarchiaés Románia utolsó kereskedelmi és vámegyezménye.” Magyar Gazdaságtörténeti Évkönyv 1, (Válság-Kereskedelem), (2016): 379-412.
43. Bridge, F. R. From Sadowa to Sarajevo, The Foreign Policy of Austria-Hungary. London and Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1972.
44. Clute, Robert E. and Wilson, Robert R. “The Commonwealth and Favored-Nation Usage,” The American Journal of International Law, 52/3 (1958): 455-468.
45. Constantinesco, Nicholas. “The Achievement of Romanian Independence: The Struggle, the Victory, the Aftermath.” Unpublished Master’s Thesis, University of Ottawa, 1970.
46. Dağ, Ahmet Emin. Uluslararası İlişkiler ve Diplomasi Sözlüğü. İstanbul: Vadi Yay., 2016.
47. Damean, Sorin Liviu. România și Congresul de Pace de la Berlin (1878). București: Editura Mica Valahie, 2011.
48. Florescu, Ștefan-Cristian. “Russia and the Romanian Independence (1875-1878).” Anuarul Institutului de Cercetări Socio-Umane „ CS Nicolăescu-Plopșor”, XXII (2021): 93–103.
49. Hillgruber, Andreas. Bismarcks Außenpolitik 1871–1890. Rombach, 1972.
50. Hitchins, Keith. Romanians, 1774-1866. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1966.
51. Isar, Nicolae. Istoria Moderna A Romanilor, Partea a II-a: 1848-1878. Bucureşti: Editura Romania de Maine, 2005.
52. Jelavich, Barbara. A Century of Russian Foreign Policy 1814-1914. Philadelphia: Lippincott Company, 1964.
53. Jelavich, Barbara. “Russia and the Rumanian Commercial Convention of 1876.” Rumanian Studies, 3 (1976): 39–60.
54. Jelavich, Barbara. Russia and the Formation of the Romanian National State 1821-1878. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984.
55. Jelavich, Charles and Barbara. The Establishment of the Balkan National States, 1804-1920. Seattle and London: University of Washington Press, 2012.
56. Kellogg, Frederick. “Convenţia comercială din 1875: Un pas către independenţă?.” Studii. Revistă de istorie, 25 (1972): 989-1003.
57. Kellogg, Frederick. The Road to Romanian Independence. Indiana: Purdue University Press, 1984.
58. Kremnitz, Mite. Aus dem Leben, König Karls von Rumänien. Volume II, Stuttgart: J. G. Cotta’schen Buchhandlung, 1894.
59. Kurdakul, Necdet. “Ticaret Antlaşmaları.” Tanzimat’tan Cumhuriyet’e Türkiye Ansiklopedisi, C. III (İstanbul: 1985), 666–667.
60. Macfie, A. L. The Eastern Question 1774-1923. London and New York: Routledge, 2014.
61. Millman, Richard. Britain and the Eastern Question 1875-1878. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1939.
62. Mosse, W. E. “The End of the Crimean System: England, Russia and the Neutrality of the Black Sea, 1870-1.” The Historical Journal, 4/2 (1961): 164-190.
63. Nouveau Recueil général de traités et autres actes relatifs aux rapports de droit international, ed. Georg Friedrich von Martens, rev. Charles Samwer and Jules Hopf, Tome II, Gottingue: 1878.
64. Pahre, Robert. Politics and Trade Cooperation in the Nineteenth Century: The “Agreeable Customs” of 1815–1914. Cambridge University Press, 2007.
65. Pflanze, Otto. Bismarck and the Development of Germany, Volume II: The Period of Consolidation, 1871-1880. Princeton University Press, 1990.
66. Pop, Ioan Aurel. Romanians and Romania: A Brief History. East European Monographs, 1999.
67. Schumacher, Leslie Rogne. The Eastern Question in 1870s Britain: Democracy and Diplomacy, Orientalism and Empire. Palgrave Macmillan, 2023.
68. Seton-Watson, Robert William. Disraeli, Gladstone and the Eatern Question, A Study in Diplomacy and Party Politics. New York: The Norton Library, 1972.
69. Stavrianos, Leften Stavros. The Balkans Since 1453. New York: Rinehart, 1958.
70. Taylor, A. J. P. The Habsburg Monarchy 1809-1918, A History of the Austrian Empire and Austria-Hungary. London: Hamish Hamilton, 1948.