Comparison of the Nutritional Value of Cow’s Milk and Plant-Based Milks

Year 2023, , 734 - 741, 01.11.2023

Rabia Talay Maraş

https://doi.org/10.47115/bsagriculture.1331725

Abstract

Malnutrition and micronutrient deficiencies are observed among people in many developing countries. The high cost of cow's milk and poverty make it difficult for people to access nutritious food. For this reason, low-cost foods that can be an alternative to cow's milk are important. In addition, the fact that cow's milk causes lactose intolerance, high cholesterol, constipation and bloating in some individuals has led people to other alternatives. Apart from these, alternatives for vegan individuals have begun to be considered. All these reasons have increased the demand for alternative milk of plant origin worldwide. Plant-based milks have been the subject of research with different names in the literature. For example: vegetable milk, non-dairy milk, imitation milk, dairy substitute. This review is focused on comparing nutrient composition of cow's milk and plant-based milk alternatives.

Keywords

Cow, Plant-based milk, Vegetable milk, Non-dairy milk

References

• Abadl MMT, Mohsin AZ, Sulaiman R, Abas F, Muhialdin BJ, Hussin ASM. 2022. Biological activities and physiochemical properties of low-fat and high-fat coconut-based kefir. Int j Gastron Food Sci, 30: 100624.
• Abdulfatai J, Saka AA, Afolabi AS, Diana K. 2013. Development and characterization of beverages from tigernut milk, pineapple and coconut fruit extracts. Appl Mechan Mater, 248: 304-309.
• Abou-Dobara M, Ismail M, Refaat N. 2016. Chemical composition, sensory evaluation and starter activity in cow, soy, peanut and rice milk. J Nutrit Health Food Engin, 5(3): 1-8.
• Aboulfazli F, Baba AS. 2015. Effect of vegetable milk on survival of probiotics in fermented ice cream under gastrointestinal conditions. Food Sci Technol Res, 21(3): 391-397.
• Aboulfazli F, Shori AB, Baba AS. 2016. Effects of the replacement of cow milk with vegetable milk on probiotics and nutritional profile of fermented ice cream. LWT, 70: 261-270.
• Al K, Oladimeji G. 2008. Production and quality evaluation of soy-corn milk. J Appl Biosci, 1(2): 40-45.
• Alozie Yetunde E, Udofia US. 2015. Nutritional and sensory properties of almond (Prunus amygdalu Var. Dulcis) seed milk. World J Dairy Food Sci, 10(2): 117-121.
• Aly E, Sanchez‐Moya T, Darwish AA, Ros‐Berruezo G, Lopez‐Nicolas R. 2022. In vitro digestion effect on CCK and GLP‐1 release and antioxidant capacity of some plant‐based milk substitutes. J Food Sci, 87(5): 1999-2008.
• Amponsah AS, Golly MK, Sarpong F, Derigubah B, Endeme M. 2017. Proximate and sensory evaluation of non-diary probiotic beverages made from tiger-nuts (Cyperus esculentus L.) and soybean (Glycine max). Int J Innov Food Sci Technol, 1: 9-17.
• Angelino D, Rosi A, Vici G, Dello Russo M, Pellegrini N, Martini D, Group SYW. 2020. Nutritional quality of plant-based drinks sold in Italy: the food labelling of Italian products (FLIP) study. Foods, 9(5): 682.
• Asres AM, Woldemariam HW, Gemechu FG. 2022. Physicochemical and sensory properties of ice cream prepared using sweet lupin and soymilk as alternatives to cow milk. Int J Food Propert, 25(1): 278-287.
• Atwaa E, Elmaadawy AA, Awaad EA. 2019. Production of fruit flavored probiotic rice milk beverage. J Food Dairy Sci, 10(12): 453-458.
• Awasthi Y, Singh N. 2020. A comparative study on assessment of physiochemical properties of blended plant based yoghurt alongside commercial dairy yoghurt. Gujarat Agri Univ Res J, 2020: 229.
• Ayah M, Ahmed S, Sohair FN, El-Sawy N. 2022. Formulation and evaluation of some novel food products containing plant (vegan) milks. Alexandria J Food Sci Technol, 18(2): 13-22.
• Aydar EF, Tutuncu S, Ozcelik B. 2020. Plant-based milk substitutes: Bioactive compounds, conventional and novel processes, bioavailability studies, and health effects. J Funct Foods, 70: 103975.
• Azlin-Hashim S, Siang QL, Yusof F, Zainol MK, Yusof HM. 2019. Chemical composition and potential adulterants in coconut milk sold in Kuala Lumpur. Malaysian Appl Biol, 48(3): 27-34.
• BeMiller JN. 2010. Carbohydrate analysis. In Food analysis. Springer, Berlin, Germany, pp: 147-177.
• Bernat N, Chafer M, Chiralt A, Gonzalez-Martinez C. 2014. Vegetable milks and their fermented derivative products. Int J Food Stud, 3(1).
• Bhat AR, Shah AH, Ayoob M, Ayoob MF, Saleem F, Ali MM, Fayaz M. 2022. Chemical, rheological, and organoleptic analysis of cow and buffalo milk mozzarella cheese. Ankara Üniv Vet Fak Derg, 69: 51-60.
• Bocker R, Silva EK. 2021. Innovative technologies for manufacturing plant-based non-dairy alternative milk and their impact on nutritional, sensory and safety aspects. Future Foods, 2021: 100098.
• Bucker ER, Mitchell JR, Johnson MG. 1979. Lactic fermentation of peanut milk. J Food Sci, 44(5): 1534-1538.
• Campos V, Tappy L, Bally L, Sievenpiper JL, Le KA. 2022. Importance of carbohydrate quality: what does it mean and how to measure it? J Nutrit, 152(5): 1200-1206.
• Cardello AV, Llobell F, Giacalone D, Roigard CM, Jaeger SR. 2022. Plant-based alternatives vs dairy milk: Consumer segments and their sensory, emotional, cognitive and situational use responses to tasted products. Food Qual Prefer, 100: 104599.
• Ceballos LS, Morales ER, de la Torre Adarve G, Castro JD, Martínez LP, Sampelayo MRS. 2009. Composition of goat and cow milk produced under similar conditions and analyzed by identical methodology. J Food Compos Analy, 22(4): 322-329.
• Çetiner M, Ersus Bilek S. 2018. Bitkisel protein kaynakları. Çukurova Tarım Gıda Bil Derg, 33(2): 111-126.
• Ceylan MM, Özer EA. 2020. Optimisation of almond milk producing using response surface method. J Agri, 3(1): 6-32.
• Chalupa-Krebzdak S, Long CJ, Bohrer BM. 2018. Nutrient density and nutritional value of milk and plant-based milk alternatives. Int Dairy J, 87: 84-92.
• Chiewchan N, Phungamngoen C, Siriwattanayothin S. 2006. Effect of homogenizing pressure and sterilizing condition on quality of canned high fat coconut milk. J Food Eng, 73(1): 38-44.
• Clegg ME, Ribes AT, Reynolds R, Kliem K, Stergiadis S. 2021. A comparative assessment of the nutritional composition of dairy and plant-based dairy alternatives available for sale in the UK and the implications for consumers’ dietary intakes. Food Res Int, 148: 110586.
• Codina-Torrella I, Guamis B, Zamora A, Quevedo J, Trujillo A. 2018. Microbiological stabilization of tiger nuts’ milk beverage using ultra-high pressure homogenization. A preliminary study on microbial shelf-life extension. Food Microbiol, 69: 143-150.
• Costa Neto JJ, Gomes TL, Justo TF, Pereira KS, Amaral PF, Leão MHR, Sant'Ana GCF. 2019. Microencapsulation of tiger nut milk by lyophilization: Morphological characteristics, shelf life and microbiological stability. Food Chem, 284: 133-139.
• Coyle DH, Ndanuko R, Singh S, Huang P, Wu JH. 2019. Variations in sugar content of flavored milks and yogurts: a cross-sectional study across 3 countries. Curr Devel Nutrit, 3(6).
• Craig WJ, Brothers CJ. 2021. Nutritional content and health profile of non-dairy plant-based yogurt alternatives. Nutrients, 13(11): 4069.
• Devnani B, Ong L, Kentish S, Gras S. 2020. Heat induced denaturation, aggregation and gelation of almond proteins in skim and full fat almond milk. Food Chem, 325: 126901.
• Drewnowski A. 2022. Most Plant-based milk alternatives in the USDA branded food products database do not meet proposed nutrient standards or score well on nutrient density metrics. Nutrients, 14(22): 4767.
• Elgazouly HMM, Mohamed Ahmed Idris Y, Mohamed Kabeir Baraka B. 2018. Prebiotication with gum arabic on growth of Bifidobacterium longum BB536 during fermentation of peanut milk. SUST J Agri Vet Sci, 19(2): 12-24.
• Elsamani MO. 2016. Probiotics, organoleptic and physicochemical properties of vegetable milk based bio-ice cream supplemented with skimmed milk powder. Int J Nutrit Food Sci, 5(5): 361-366.
• Erfanian A, Rasti B. 2019. Effects of soy milk on physical, rheological, microbiological and sensory properties of cake. Int Food Res J, 26(1): 237-245.
• Fawzi NY, Abdelghani DY, Abdel-Azim MA, Shokier CG, Youssef MW, El-Rab MKG, Abou-Taleb KA. 2022. The ability of probiotic lactic acid bacteria to ferment Egyptian broken rice milk and produce rice-based yoghurt. Annals Agri Sci, 67(1): 107-118.
• Gamlı ÖF, Atasoy AF. 2018. Physico-chemical and sensorial properties of groundnut milk and it’s yoghurt. J Food Measur Character, 12(3): 1997-2004.
• George O, Awopetu B. 2017. Comparative nutritive and sensory qualities of Bambara groundnut and soybean milks. Sci Eng Perspect, 12: 30-36.
• Guetouache M, Guessas B, Medjekal S. 2014. Composition and nutritional value of raw milk. Biol Sci Pharmaceut Res, 2(10): 115-122.
• Guthausen A, Guthausen G, Kamlowski A, Todt H, Burk W, Schmalbein D. 2004. Measurement of fat content of food with single-sided NMR. J American Oil Chem Soc, 81(8): 727-731.
• Hardy Z, Jideani VA. 2018. Effect of spray drying compartment and maltodextrin concentration on the functional, physical, thermal, and nutritional characteristics of Bambara groundnut milk powder. J Food Proces Preserv, 42(2): 1-14.
• Isanga J, Zhang G. 2009. Production and evaluation of some physicochemical parameters of peanut milk yoghurt. LWT-Food Sci Technol, 42(6): 1132-1138.
• Jain P, Yadav DN, Rajput H, Bhatt DK. 2013. Effect of pressure blanching on sensory and proximate composition of peanut milk. J Food Sci Technol, 50(3): 605-608.
• Jebb SA. 2015. Carbohydrates and obesity: from evidence to policy in the UK. Proc Nutrit Soc, 74(3): 215-220.
• Jemaa MB, Gamra R, Falleh H, Ksouri R, Beji RS. 2021. Plant-based milk alternative: nutritional profiling, physical characterization and sensorial assessment. Curr Perspect Medic Arom Plants, 4(2): 108-120.
• Kundu P, Dhankhar J, Sharma A. 2018. Development of non dairy milk alternative using soymilk and almond milk. Curr Res Nutrit Food Sci J, 6(1): 203-210.
• Lalic J, Denic M, Sunaric S, Kocic G, Trutic N, Mitic S, Jovanovic T. 2014. Assessment of thiamine content in some dairy products and rice milk. CyTA-J Food, 12(3): 203-209.
• Lunn J, Buttriss J. 2007. Carbohydrates and dietary fibre. Nutrit Bull, 32(1): 21-64.
• Maghsoudlou Y, Alami M, Mashkour M, Shahraki MH. 2016. Optimization of ultrasound‐assisted stabilization and formulation of almond milk. J Food Proces Preserv, 40(5): 828-839.
• Makinen OE, Uniacke-Lowe T, O’Mahony JA, Arendt EK. 2014. Physicochemical and acid gelation properties of commercial UHT-treated plant-based milk substitutes and lactose free bovine milk. Food Chem, 168: 630-638.
• Makinen OE, Wanhalinna V, Zannini E, Arendt EK. 2016. Foods for special dietary needs: Non-dairy plant-based milk substitutes and fermented dairy-type products. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutrit, 56(3): 339-349.
• Maria MF, Victoria AT. 2018. Influence of processing treatments on quality of vegetable milk from almond (Terminalia catappa) kernels. Acta Sci Nutrit Health, 2(6): 37-42.
• Masia C, Jensen PE, Buldo P. 2020. Effect of Lactobacillus rhamnosus on physicochemical properties of fermented plant-based raw materials. Foods, 9(9): 1182.
• Mauro CSI, Fernandes MTC, Farinazzo FS, Garcia, S. 2022. Characterization of a fermented coconut milk product with and without strawberry pulp. J Food Sci Technol, 59(7): 2804-2812.
• Mepba HD, Achinewhu SC, Pillay M. 2006. Stabilised cocosoy beverage: physicochemical and sensory properties. J Sci Food Agri, 86(12): 1839-1846.
• Mohamed SA, Awad RA, Elbatawy OI, Salama WM. 2019. Production of vegetable yoghurt like from lupin milk. Arab Univ J Agri Sci, 27(4): 2155-2165.
• Mollakhalili-Meybodi N, Arab M, Zare L. 2022. Harmful compounds of soy milk: characterization and reduction strategies. J Food Sci Technol, 59(10): 3723-3732.
• Mori F, Serranti D, Barni S, Pucci N, Rossi ME, de Martino M, Novembre E. 2015. A kwashiorkor case due to the use of an exclusive rice milk diet to treat atopic dermatitis. Nutrit J, 14(1): 1-2.
• Muhammad AI, Li Y, Liao X, Liu D, Ye X, Chen S, Ding T. 2019. Effect of dielectric barrier discharge plasma on background microflora and physicochemical properties of tiger nut milk. Food Cont, 96: 119-127.
• Muralidharan J, Galie S, Hernandez-Alonso P, Bullo M, Salas-Salvado J. 2019. Plant-based fat, dietary patterns rich in vegetable fat and gut microbiota modulation. Front Nutrit, 6: 157.
• Naliapara V, Cholera VSP. 2017. Effect of process variables on drum drying of peanut milk. Trends Biosci, 10(30): 6358-6364.
• Neto J, Amaral P, Leao M, Gomes T, Sant’Ana G. 2017. Optimization of the extraction and nutritional value of tiger nut milk by sequential design strategy. J Food Stud, 6(10): 14-30.
• Ng C, Loh S. 2018. Effect of selected cereal grains on in vitro bioaccessibility of isoflavones in soy milk. Int Food Res J, 25(1): 303-309.
• Ntukidem V, Ukwo P, Udoh I, Umoinyang E. 2019. Influence of different pre-treatments on the nutritional and organoleptic properties of vegetable milk produced locally from tiger-nut (Cyperus esculentus) tubers. IOSR J Environ Sci Toxicol Food Technol, 13(6): 55-61.
• Okyere AA, Odamtten GT. 2014. Physicochemical, functional and sensory attributes of milk prepared from irradiated tiger nut (Cyperus esculentus L.). J Radiat Res Appl Sci, 7(4): 583-588.
• Opeyemi AF, Obuneme OS. 2020. Bacteriological and nutritional assessment of tiger nut milk (kunun-aya) consumed by students of Nasarawa State University, Keffi Nigeria. World J Adv Res Rev, 6(3): 059-068.
• Oyeyinka AT, Odukoya JO, Adebayo YS. 2019. Nutritional composition and consumer acceptability of cheese analog from soy and cashew nut milk. J Food Proces Preserv, 43(12): e14285.
• Padma M, Rao PJ, Edukondalu L, Aparna K, Babu GR. 2022. Determining the effects of spray drying conditions on water absorption index, water solubility index, solubility and water activity (aw) of rice milk powder. Curr Adv Geogr Environ Earth Sci, 9: 16-36.
• Pahane MM, Tatsadjieu LN, Bernard C, Njintang NY. 2017. Production, nutritional and biological value of bambara groundnut (Vigna subterranea) milk and yoghurt. J Food Measur Character, 11(4): 1613-1622.
• Rasika DM, Vidanarachchi JK, Rocha RS, Balthazar CF, Cruz AG, Sant’Ana AS, Ranadheera CS. 2021. Plant-based milk substitutes as emerging probiotic carriers. Curr Opin Food Sci, 38: 8-20.
• Şahan N, Say D. 2001. Siyah Alaca inek sütlerinin enerji değeri ve mineral madde miktarı. Çukurova Üniv Zir Fak Derg, 16(1): 1-8.
• Silva LR, Velasco JI, Fakhouri FM. 2023. Use of rice on the development of plant-based milk with antioxidant properties: From raw material to residue. LWT, 173: 114271.
• Singh S, Singh S, Dubey RP. 2018. Chemical analysis of peanut milk. Pharma Innov J, 7(10): 1-2.
• Stanhope KL, Goran MI, Bosy‐Westphal A, King JC, Schmidt LA, Schwarz JM, Bray G. 2018. Pathways and mechanisms linking dietary components to cardiometabolic disease: thinking beyond calories. Obesity Rev, 19(9): 1205-1235.
• Sulistyaningtyas AR, Lunggani A, Kusdiyantini E. 2019. Kefir produced from red rice milk by Lactobacillus bulgaricus and candida kefir starter. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, August 29, Bogor, West Java, Indonesia.
• Sumner O, Burbridge L. 2020. Plant-based milks: the dental perspective. British Dental J, 2020: 1-7.
• Szparaga A, Tabor S, Kocira S, Czerwinska E, Kubon M, Plociennik B, Findura P. 2019. Survivability of probiotic bacteria in model systems of non-fermented and fermented coconut and hemp milks. Sustainability, 11(21): 6093.
• Tamuno ENJ, Monday AO. 2019. Physicochemical, mineral and sensory characteristics of cashew nut milk. Int J Food Sci Biotechnol, 4(1): 1.
• Tangyu M, Muller J, Bolten CJ, Wittmann C. 2019. Fermentation of plant-based milk alternatives for improved flavour and nutritional value. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 103(23): 9263-9275.
• Tulashie SK, Amenakpor J, Atisey S, Odai R, Akpari EEA. 2022. Production of coconut milk: A sustainable alternative plant based milk. Case Stud Chem Environ Eng, 6: 100206.
• USDA. 1984. Coconut Milk. URL: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/170172/nutrients (February 10, 2023).
• USDA. 2019. Unsweetened Original Cashewmilk. URL: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/636172/nutrients (February 10, 2023).
• USDA. 2021a. Almond milk. URL: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/2257045/nutrients (February 10, 2023).
• USDA. 2021b. Soy milk. URL: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/2257044/nutrients (February 10, 2023).
• Vanga SK, Raghavan V. 2018. How well do plant based alternatives fare nutritionally compared to cow’s milk? J Food Sci Technol, 55(1): 10-20.
• Wakil SM, Ayenuro OT, Oyinlola KA. 2014. Microbiological and nutritional assessment of starter-developed fermented tigernut milk. Food Nutrit Sci, 5(6): 495-506.
• Yadav DN, Singh KK, Bhowmik SN, Patil RT. 2010. Development of peanut milk-based fermented curd. Int J Food Sci Technol, 45(12): 2650-2658.
• Yılmaz-Ersan L, Topcuoglu E. 2022. Evaluation of instrumental and sensory measurements using multivariate analysis in probiotic yogurt enriched with almond milk. J Food Sci Technol, 59(1): 133-143.