Effect of Rib Shape on Flow Regime and Heat Transfer

Abstract

In current study, flow behavior and heat transfer properties in a square channel roughened with square, right triangle, isosceles triangle and circular ribs were examined. The validation test was performed for an experimental square rib case with a pitch ratio (P/e) of 9 and a blockage ratio (e/H) of 0.1. Only to examine the rib shape factor; height, base width, and rib spacing were taken the same in all cases. The study investigated the effect of various rib shapes on flow characteristics, overall thermal performances, normalized heat transfer distributions, and friction factors (pressure losses) at Reynolds numbers of 30,000 and 60,000. As a result of the numerical study, it was found that the rib shape effect did not cause as big differences in the flow properties as the blockage ratio (rib height) and pitch ratio (rib spacing) effect. In terms of the average Nusselt number enhancement, the right triangular ribbed case performed best, circular ribbed case performed worst, while the isosceles ribbed case performed better than square ribbed case. The isosceles ribbed case and right triangular ribbed case cause higher friction factor and pressure loss, while minimum friction is obtained in circular ribbed case and then in square ribbed case. As a result, in terms of overall thermal performances, right triangular ribbed case provided the best performance, followed by isosceles triangular ribbed case. The circular ribbed case produced less friction than the square ribbed case. The thermal performance of the square ribbed case was slightly higher than that of circular ribbed case.

Keywords

• Rib shape
• Rib-roughened channels
• Convective heat transfer
• Cooling ducts
• CFD

References

1. Ahn SW. 2001. The effect of roughness type on friction factors and heat transfer in roughened rectangular duct. Int Comm Heat Mass Transfer, 28(7): 933-942.
2. Al-Hadhrami LM, Griffith TS, Han JC. 2002. Heat transfer in two-pass rotating rectangular channels (AR=2) with parallel and crossed 45o V-shaped rib turbulators. AIAA 2002: 2002-0789.
3. Chandra PR, Fontenot ML, Han JC. 1998. Effect of rib profiles on turbulent channel flow heat transfer. AIAA J Thermoph and Heat Transfer, 12(1): 116-118.
4. Cho HH, Wu SJ, Kwon HJ. 2000. Local heat/mass transfer measurements in a rectangular duct with discrete ribs. J Turbomachinery, 122: 579-586.
5. Chyu MK. 1989. Regional heat transfer and pressure drop in two-pass and three-pass flow passages with 180-degree sharp turns. In ASME 1989 International Gas Turbine and Aeroengine Congress and Exposition (pp. V004T08A024-V004T08A024). American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
6. Ekiciler R. 2021. Effects of novel hybrid nanofluid (TiO 2–Cu/EG) and geometrical parameters of triangular rib mounted in a duct on heat transfer and flow characteristics. J Thermal Anal and Calorimetry, 143(2): 1371-1387.
7. Han JC, Huang JJ, Lee CP. 1993. Augmented heat transfer in square channels with wedge-shaped and delta-shaped turbulence promoters. Enhanced Heat Transfer, 1(1): 37-52.
8. Han JC, Datta S, Ekkad S. 2013. Gas turbine heat transfer and cooling technology, CRC Press, pp: 887, Ohio, USA.

9. Keshmiri A, Cotton MA, Addad Y. 2002. Numerical simulations of flow and heat transfer over rib-roughened surfaces. Int J Heat and Fluid Flow, 23(6): 750-757.
10. Kumar R, Kumar A. 2017. Computational fluid dynamics-based study for analyzing heat transfer and friction factor in semi-circular rib-roughened equilateral triangular duct. Int J Numerical Methods for Heat & Fluid Flow, 27(4): 941-957.
11. Lee E, Wright LM, Han JC. 2003. Heat transfer in rotating rectangular channels (AR=4:1) with V-shaped and angled rib turbulators with and without gaps. ASME 2003: GT2003-38900.
12. Liu YH, Wright LM, Fu WL, Han JC. 2006. Rib spacing effect on heat transfer and pressure loss in a rotating two-pass rectangular channel (AR=1:2) with 45-degree angled ribs. ASME, 2006: GT2006-90368.
13. Moon SW, Endley S, Lau SC. 2002. Local heat transfer distribution in a two-pass trapezoidal channel with a 180 turn via the transient liquid crystal technique. J Energy Heat Mass Transfer, 24: 103-121.
14. Rau G, Cakan M, Moeller D, Arts T. 1998. The effect of periodic ribs on the local aerodynamic and heat transfer performance of a straight cooling channel. J Turbomach, 120(2): 368-375.
15. Rhee DH, Lee DH, Cho HH, Moon HK. 2003. Effects of duct aspect ratios on heat/mass transfer with discrete V-shaped ribs,” ASME, 2003: GT2003-38622.
16. Sleiti AK, Kapat JS. 2004. Comparison between EVM and RSM turbulence models in predicting flow and heat transfer in rib-roughened channels. In ASME 2004 Heat Transfer/Fluids Engineering Summer Conference (pp. 531-542). American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
17. Su G, Chen HC, Han JC, Heidmann D. 2004. Computation of flow and heat transfer in two-pass rotating rectangular channels (AR=1:1, AR=1:2, AR=1:4) with 45-deg Angled ribs by a reynolds stress turbulence model. ASME, 2004: GT2004-53662.
18. Wang L, Sunden B. 2007. Experimental investigation of local heat transfer in a square duct with various-shaped ribs. Heat and Mass Transfer, 43: 759-766.