Avrupa Futbol Kulüplerinde Yönetim Kurullarının Mesleki Yapısı İle Sportif Başarı Arasındaki Stratejik İlişki

Year 2025, Volume: 8 Issue: 4 , 217 - 237 , 31.12.2025

İsmail Öner , Emine Öztürk Karataş , Özgür Karataş

https://izlik.org/JA87JK43PW

Abstract

Amaç: Bu araştırmanın amacı, Avrupa futbol kulüplerinde yönetim kurullarının mesleki yapısı ile sportif başarı arasındaki stratejik ilişkiyi incelemektir.
Yöntem: Araştırma, nitel araştırma desenlerinden karşılaştırmalı durum analizi kapsamında yürütülmüştür. Real Madrid, FC Bayern Münih, Manchester City, Borussia Dortmund, Olympique Lyonnais, Paris Saint-Germain, Manchester United, AFC Ajax, SSC Napoli ve SL Benfica olmak üzere on kulüp seçilmiştir. Veriler, kulüplerin resmî raporları ile UEFA, CIES Football Observatory, Deloitte ve Transfermarkt gibi uluslararası kaynaklardan doküman analizi yoluyla derlenmiş, tematik analizle sınıflandırılarak yorumlanmıştır.
Bulgular: İncelenen kulüplerde, yönetim kurullarında finans, hukuk, pazarlama, iletişim, veri bilimi, insan kaynakları ve altyapı-akademi yönetimi gibi alanlarda ağırlık kazanmış mesleki yapıların, sportif başarıyla doğrudan ilişkili olduğu ve bu başarıyı daha istikrarlı kıldığı belirlenmiştir. Mesleki çeşitliliğin; kriz yönetimi, finansal planlama, sponsorluk ve medya stratejileri ile veri temelli oyuncu ve akademi politikalarını güçlendirdiği tespit edilmiştir. Başarıyı kalıcı kılan üç temel unsur saptanmıştır: stratejik uyum, fonksiyonel dağılım ve kültürel bütünleşme. PSG ve Manchester United örneklerinde profesyonel kapasiteye rağmen stratejik uyum ve kültürel entegrasyondaki yetersizliklerin Avrupa düzeyinde istikrarlı başarıyı sınırladığı tespit edilmiştir. Buna karşılık Borussia Dortmund, Ajax, Napoli ve Benfica’da veri odaklı karar süreçleri ile altyapı yatırımlarının yönetim kademesine kurumsal olarak dahil edilmesi sayesinde sınırlı bütçelere rağmen rekabetçiliğin sürdürülebildiği belirlenmiştir.
Sonuç: Mesleki çeşitlilik, tek başına yeterli olmayıp stratejik uyum, fonksiyonel dağılım ve kültürel bütünleşme ile desteklendiğinde sportif performansın yanı sıra finansal sürdürülebilirlik ve kurumsal itibar da güçlenmektedir. Veri temelli karar alma, altyapı yatırımlarının yönetime kurumsal düzeyde dâhil edilmesi ve liyakat esaslı yönetişim yapıları, kalıcı rekabet üstünlüğü üreterek Türkiye’deki kulüpler için uygulanabilir politika önerileri sunmaktadır.

Keywords

Mesleki Çeşitlilik , Sportif Başarı , Finansal sürdürülebilirlik , Avrupa Futbolu , Veri Temelli Yönetim , Altyapı Stratejisi

The Strategıc Relatıonshıp Between The Professıonal Structure Of Boards Of Dırectors In European Football Clubs And Sportıng Success

https://izlik.org/JA87JK43PW

Abstract

Purpose: The objective of this study is to examine the strategic relationship between the professional structure of management boards and sporting success in European football clubs.
Method: The study was conducted within the scope of comparative case analysis, one of the qualitative research designs. Ten clubs were selected: Real Madrid, FC Bayern Munich, Manchester City, Borussia Dortmund, Olympique Lyonnais, Paris Saint-Germain, Manchester United, AFC Ajax, SSC Napoli, and SL Benfica. Data were collected through document analysis from the clubs' official reports and international sources such as UEFA, CIES Football Observatory, Deloitte, and Transfermarkt, then classified and interpreted using thematic analysis.
Results: In the clubs examined, it has been determined that professional structures with a strong presence in areas such as finance, law, marketing, communications, data science, human resources, and infrastructure-academy management within the boards of directors are directly related to sporting success and make this success more stable. It was found that professional diversity strengthens crisis management, financial planning, sponsorship and media strategies, as well as data-driven player and academy policies. Three key elements were identified as essential for sustaining success: strategic alignment, functional distribution and cultural integration. In the cases of PSG and Manchester United, it was found that despite professional capacity, shortcomings in strategic alignment and cultural integration limited consistent success at the European level. In contrast, at Borussia Dortmund, Ajax, Napoli, and Benfica, it was determined that competitiveness could be sustained despite limited budgets thanks to data-driven decision-making processes and the institutional integration of infrastructure investments into management.
Conclusion: Professional diversity alone is not sufficient; when supported by strategic alignment, functional distribution and cultural integration, it strengthens not only sporting performance but also financial sustainability and corporate reputation. Data-driven decision-making, the inclusion of infrastructure investments in management at the corporate level, and merit-based governance structures offer feasible policy recommendations for clubs in Turkey by generating lasting competitive advantage.

Keywords

Professional Diversity , Sporting Success , Financial Sustainability , European Football , Data-Driven Management , Infrastructure Strategy

References

• Alk Adediran, F., and Ishola, A. (2025). How to buy a football club with no money; Manchester United as a case study of the leveraged buyout. Manchester United.
• Baroncelli, A., and Lago, U. (2006). Italian football. Journal of Sports Economics, 7(1), 13–28.
• Blanco Callejo, M., and Forcadell, F. J. (2006). Real Madrid football club: A new model of business organization for sports clubs in Spain. Global Business and Organizational Excellence, 26(1), 51–64.
• Borussia Dortmund Annual Report. (2024). Annual report 2023/2024: Performance diagnostics and injury prevention via data analysis [PDF]. the Borussia Dortmund website: https://report.bvb.de/annual-report/2023-2024/_assets/downloads/gesamt-bvb-gb2324.pdf?h=8D6P2LzG Erişim: 14.04.2025
• Bridgewater, S. (2010). Football management. Palgrave Macmillan.
• Budzinski, O., and Kunz Kaltenhäuser, P. (2020). Promoting or restricting competition? The 50plus1-rule in German football. Ilmenau Economics Discussion Papers, 26(141).
• Chadwick, S., Burton, N., Widdop, P., and Bond, A. J. (2023). Networks, strategy and sport: The case of City Football Group. Journal of Strategy and Management, 1–30.
• CIES Football Observatory. (2022). Demographic profiling of players, clubs and leagues across Europe (Monthly Report No. 79). https://football-observatory.com/IMG/sites/mr/mr79/en/ Erişim: 14.04.2025
• Deloitte. (2025). Deloitte Football Money League 2025. https://www.deloitte.com/uk/en/services/consulting-financial/analysis/deloitte-football-money-league.html Erişim: 08.08.2025
• Dietl, H. M., and Franck, E. (2007). Governance failure and financial crisis in German football. Journal of Sports Economics, 8(6).
• European Club Association. (2019). ECA insights: Edwin van der Sar on Ajax's model for success. European Club Association.
• FC Bayern München AG. (2025). Stockholders. https://fcbayern.com/en/club/company/teaser-stockholder Erişim: 10.08.2025
• Ferkins, L., Shilbury, D., & McDonald, G. (2005). The role of the board in building strategic capability: Towards an integrated model of sport governance research. Sport Management Review, 8(3), 195-225.
• Financial Times. (2025). Qatar-owned Paris Saint-Germain crush Inter Milan to win Champions League. https://www.ft.com/content/86ef7585-2a07-4645-baf9-26e8a55b68e4 Erişim: 10.04.2025
• Gabor, M. (2023). Bayern Munich: Really a club with a sporting concept? Football Development Institute. https://football-development-institute.net/en/artykul/bayern-munich-really-a-club-with-a-sporting-concept/ Erişim: 11.08.2025
• Gammelsæter, H., and Senaux, B. (2011). The organisation and governance of top football across Europe: An institutional perspective. Londra: Routledge.
• García, J., and Rodríguez, P. (2003). From sports clubs to stock companies: The financial structure of football in Spain, 1992–2001. European Sport Management Quarterly, 3(4), 253–269.
• Get Football News France. (2023). OL ranked second in Europe’s top five leagues for academy trained players. https://www.getfootballnewsfrance.com/2023/ol-ranked-second-in-europes-top-five-leagues-for-academy-trained-players-on-their-roster/ Erişim: 01.08.2025
• Goyal, R., Kakabadse, N., and Kakabadse, A. (2019). Improving corporate governance with functional diversity on FTSE 350 boards: directors’ perspective. Journal of Capital Markets Studies, 3(2), 113-136.
• Hamil, S., Walters, G., and Watson, L. (2010). The model of governance at FC Barcelona: Balancing member democracy, commercial strategy, corporate social responsibility and sporting performance. Soccer and Society, 11(4), 475–504.
• Hampel, R. (2024). FC Bayern surpasses €1 billion in revenue for 2023/24, marking a record financial year. Football Business Journal. https://www.footballbusinessjournal.com/post/fc-bayern-surpasses-1-billion-in-revenue-for-2023-24-marking-a-record-financial-year Erişim: 14.08.2025
• Hogan, V., and Massey, P. (2021). Soccer clubs and diminishing returns: The case of Paris Saint-Germain. International Journal of Sport Finance, 16(3), 127–138.
• Johan Cruyff Institute. (2024). Herman Kruis: “Creating an optimal environment where everyone can flourish is the essence of coaching” – Part II. https://johancruyffinstitute.com/en/blog-en/coaching-en/herman-kruis-essence-of-coaching/ Erişim: 02.08.2025
• Kuper, S., and Szymanski, S. (2014). Soccernomics: Why European clubs succeed and fail. New York: Nation Books.
• Kuper, S. (2024). Women’s football boss Michele Kang: ‘I want the next generation to compete on an equal playing field’. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/b7bb32ea-44ef-49cb-bf72-b78f6cffb1be Erişim: 06.08.2025
• Lambridis, N. (2025). From the football pitch to the boardroom: A comparative analysis of talent coaching through neuroscience and its application in business leadership. Frontiers in Organizational Psychology, 3, 1420038.
• Larsen, C. H., Storm, L. K., Sæther, S., Christensen, N. P., and Henriksen, K. (2020). The ecology of talent development in football: The case of Ajax Amsterdam. The Sport Psychologist.
• Mendes-Neves, T., Meireles, L., Mendes-Moreira, J., and de Almeida, N. (2025). The geostrategy of youth player recruitment in Portuguese clubs. arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.05858.
• Olympique Lyonnais. (2020). Training center presentation and European ranking. https://www.ol.fr/en/academy/training-center/presentation Erişim: 03.08.2025
• Oprisor, T., and Cordos, G. S. (2024). Numbers beyond the pitch: A conceptual review concerning the impact of data analysis on football club valuation. European Financial and Accounting Journal, 19(2), 1–19. Player Development Project. (2016). Ajax academy: Building for the future – youth development philosophy. https://playerdevelopmentproject.com/ajax-academy-building-future/ Erişim: 12.08.2025
• Qatar Sports Investments. (2025). QSI marks 14 years of ownership of PSG. https://www.qsi.com.qa/qsi-marks-14-years-ownership-of-psg/ Erişim: 04.08.2025
• Ronay, B. (2025). Qatar bid to complete football with PSG project’s crowd-pleasing third act. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/football/2025/may/29/qatar-bid-to-complete-football-psg-project-champions-league-final Erişim: 10.08.2025
• Reuters. (2025). List of European Cup winners. https://www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/list-european-cup-winners-2025-05-31/ Erişim: 12.08.2025
• Sayılkan, Ö. E., Cansaran, O. E., and Sağlam, M. (2021). Representation of football fan identity in the context of participatory culture. Gümüşhane Üniversitesi İletişim Fakültesi Elektronik Dergisi, 9(1), 425-444.
• SoccerTAKE. (2024). Ajax's player development approach and TIPS model. https://www.soccertake.com/player-development/ajaxs-player-development-approach Erişim: 25.07.2025
• SportsPro. (2019). Ajax are still churning out stars but now incubate technology too. https://www.sportspro.com/insights/interviews/afc-ajax-training-scouting-technology-max-reckers-interview/ Erişim: 28.07.2025
• Szymanski, S. (2022). Is there evidence of softness in the budget constraint in football? Some evidence from English clubs. In Professional team sports and the soft budget constraint (pp. 155–171). Edward Elgar Publishing.
• Taylor, E. (2014). Allianz takes 8.33 percent stake in Bayern Munich football club. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/business/allianz-takes-833-percent-stake-in-bayern-munich-football-club-idUSBREA1A1SY/ Erişim: 20.07.2025
• The Football Business Academy. (2019). Strategic partnership between The FBA and Olympique Lyonnais. https://the-fba.com/blog/partnership-the-fba-ol/ Erişim: 13.07.2025
• The Guardian. (2014). How Manchester City embraced the Barcelona blueprint. https://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2014/feb/17/how-manchester-city-embraced-the-barcelona-blueprint Erişim: 10.08.2025
• The Guardian. (2025a). Luis Enrique completes PSG transformation with Champions League glory. https://www.theguardian.com/football/2025/may/31/luis-enrique-completes-psg-transformation-with-champions-league-glory Erişim: 18.07.2025
• The Guardian. (2025b). Twenty years of Borussia Dortmund: Watzke on near-bankruptcy, selling players and Klopp. https://www.theguardian.com/football/2025/mar/24/twenty-years-of-borussia-dortmund-watzke-on-near-bankruptcy-selling-players-and-klopp Erişim: 19.07.2025
• Times of London. (2025). Inside the real European talent factory (and it’s not Barcelona). https://www.thetimes.com/sport/football/article/inside-the-real-european-talent-factory-and-its-not-barcelona-8x0vl66zs Erişim: 11.08.2025
• Transfermarkt. (2012). Ferran Soriano profile. https://www.transfermarkt.us/ferran-soriano/profil/trainer/41525 Erişim: 12.08.2025
• Transfermarkt. (2024). Club data, squad values and management boards. https://www.transfermarkt.com Erişim: 13.08.2025
• UEFA. (2023). UEFA Club Licensing and financial sustainability regulations 2023 (Edition 2023) [PDF]. Nyon: UEFA. https://fcl.uaf.ua/files/documents/uefa-club-licensing-and-financial-sustainability-regulations-edition-2023.pdf Erişim: 28.07.2025
• VoyMedia. (2025). Real Madrid’s sponsorship strategy. https://voymedia.com/real-madrid-marketing-strategy/ Erişim: 02.08.2025
• Wikipedia. (2025). Glazer ownership of Manchester United. In Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glazer_ownership_of_Manchester_United Erişim: 04.08.2025
• Yıldırım, A., and Şimşek, H. (2018). Sosyal bilimlerde nitel araştırma yöntemleri (11. baskı). Ankara: Seçkin Yayıncılık.
• Young Talents Group. (2025). The best soccer academies in the world 2025. International Football Academy. https://internationalfootball.academy/the-best-soccer-academies-in-the-world/ Erişim: 09.08.2025.