Sendikaların Yeniden Canlanması İçin İki Rakip Strateji: Paydaşlık ve Örgütlenme

Abstract

Bu çalışmanın amacı, endüstri ilişkileri teorisi ve uygulaması bağlamında birbirinin tezadı olan iki stratejinin dinamiklerini ve ortaya çıkardığı sonuçları ve sorunları analiz etmektir. Bu amaçla yapılan incelemede, öncelikle, paydaşlık ilişkilerinin nasıl geliştirildiği, söylem düzeyinde işçiler ve sendikalar için ne tür vaatler içerdiği ve gerçekte ne gibi sonuçlar ortaya çıkardığı saptanmaktadır. Daha sonra örgütlenme stratejisine niçin ihtiyaç duyulduğu ve ne tür teorik temeller üzerinde inşa edildiği tartışılmakta ve ortaya çıkardığı sonuçlar irdelenmektedir. Çalışmanın sonunda iki temel çıkarımda bulunulmaktadır. Birincisi, paydaşlık ilişkilerinin sendikalar için bir yeniden canlanma stratejisi olmasının önünde ciddi teorik ve pratik zorluklar bulunmaktadır, hatta paydaşlık ilişkileri sendikaların zayıflamasına neden olmaktadır. İkincisi, örgütlenme modeli, sendikaların elindeki en önemli strateji tercihi olmasına ve oldukça güçlü teorik temellere dayanmasına rağmen, gerek teoriye uygun olarak uygulanamamasından gerekse bazı ilave stratejilerle desteklenememesinden beklenen hedeflerin uzağında kalmış gibi görünmektedir

Keywords

• Paydaşlık, Örgütlenme, Sendikaların Yeniden Canlanması

Two Rival Strategies for Union Revitalisation: Partnership Versus Organising

Abstract

The objective of this study is to analyse the dynamics and outcomes of partnership and organising, which are two contradictory trade union strategies in the context of industrial relations theory and practice. For this purpose, in the first place, issues like how the partnership relations are developed, the content of the promises for unions and workers which have been made during this period in the discourse, and the outcomes of partnership relations in reality have been determined in this study. In the next step, the reasons, which make the disquisition of organizing strategies essential, its theoretical foundations and consequences have been discussed and examined. As a conclusion, two main inferences have been drawn. The first inference is that, there are huge theoretical and practical obstacles in partnership strategy’s way to be a union revitalisation strategy. Moreover, partnership relations cause to weaken trade unions. The second inference is that, although organising model has still been the strongest strategy in the hand of trade unions and it has been constructed on robust theoretical bases, it seems that the strategy has not been applied successfully enough to provide union revitalisation. It is assumed that the reasons of this phenomenon are the lack of implementation of the strategy as envisaged in the theory and being not supported sufficiently by some other union strategies

Keywords

• Partnership, Organising, Union Revitalisation

References

1. Ackers, P. (2002). Reframing Employment Relations: The Case for Neo-Pluralism. Industrial Relations Journal, 33(1), 2-19.
2. Ackers, P., & Payne, J. (1998). British Trade Unions and Social Partnership: Rhetoric, Reality and Strategy. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 9(3), 529-550.
3. Atkinson, J. (1984). Manpower Strategies for Flexible Organisations. Personnel Management(August), 28-37.
4. Avgar, A., & Kuruvilla, S. (2011). Dual Alignment of Industrial Relations Activity: From Strategic Choice to Mutual Gains. Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations, 18, 1-39.
5. Bacon, N. (1999). Union Derecognition and the New Human Relations: A Steel Industry Case Study. Work Employment Society, 13(1), 1-17.
6. Bacon, N., & Storey, J. (2000). New Employee Relations Strategies in Britain: Towards Individualism and Collectivism. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 38(3), 407-427.
7. Badigannavar, V. (2009). Does Labor-Management Partnership Deliver Mutual Gains? Evidence from the UK Public Sector. Advances in Industrial & Labor Relations, 16, 407-427.
8. Badigannavar, V., & Kelly, J. (2004). Labour-Management Partnership in the UK Public Sector. J. Kelly, & P. Willman içinde, Union Organization and Activity (s. 110-128). London: Routledge.

9. Badigannavar, V., & Kelly, J. (2005a). Why Are Some Uinon Organizing Compaigns More Succesful Than Others. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 43(3), 515-535.
10. Badigannavar, V., & Kelly, J. (2005b). Labour-Management Partnership in the Non-union Retail Sector. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 16(8), 1529-1544.
11. Badigannavar, V., & Kelly, J. (2011). Partnership and Organizing: An Empirical Assessment of Two Contrasting Approaches to Union Revitalization in the UK. Economic and Industrial Democracy, 32(1), 5-27.
12. Baruch, Y. (1998). The Rise and Fall of Organizational Commitment. Human Systems Management, 17(2), 135-143.
13. Behrens, M., Hamann, K., & Hurd, R. (2004). Conceptualizing Labour Union Revitalization. C. Frege, & J. Kelly içinde, Varieties of Unionism: Strategies for Union Revitalization in a Globalizing Economy (s. 11-30). New York: Oxford University Press.
14. Bender, K. A., & Sloane, P. J. (1999). Trade Union Membership, Tenure and the Level of Job Insecurity. Applied Economics, 31, 123-135.
15. Blyton, P., & Turnbull, P. (2004). The Dynamics of Employee Relations (3 b.). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
16. Boxal, P., & Haynes, P. (1997). Strategy and Trade Union Effectiveness in a Neo- liberal Environment. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 35(4), 567-591.
17. Braverman, H. (1998). Labor and Monopoly Capital (25th Anniversary Edition b.). New York: Monthly Review Press.
18. Bronfenbrenner, K. (1997). The Role of Union Strategies in NLRB Certification Elections. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 50(2), 195-212.
19. Bronfenbrenner, K. (2009). No Holds Barred: The Intensification of Employer Opposition to Organizing. Washington: Economic Policy Institute.
20. Brown, W. (2000). Putting Partnership into Practice in Britain. Cambridge: ESRC Centre for Business Research, University of Cambridge.
21. Bryson, A., Gomez, R., & Willman, P. (2004). The End of Affair? The Decline in Employers' Propensity to Unionize. J. Kelly, & P. Willman içinde, Union Organization and Activity (s. 129-149). London: Routledge.
22. Cam, E. (2013). İşyerinde Sosyal Diyalog. Ankara: Çalışma ve Sosyal Güvenlik Bakanlığı.
23. Charlwood, A. (2002). Why Do Non-union Employees Want to Unionize? Evidence from Britain. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 40(3), 463-491.
24. Charlwood, A. (2003). Willingness to Unionize amongst Non-union Workers. H. Gospel, & S. Wood içinde, Representing Workers: Trade Union Recognition and Membership in Britain (s. 51-71). London: Routledge.
25. Clark, A. E. (2005). Your Money or Your Life: Changing Job Quality in OECD Countries. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 43(3), 377-400.
26. Cohen, S. (2009). Opening Pandora's Box: The Paradox of Institutionalised Organising. G. Gall içinde, The Future of Union Organising: Building for Tomorrow (s. 28-44). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
27. Cranford, C. J., & Ladd, D. (2003). Community Unionism: Organising for Fair Employment in Canada. Just Labour, 3, 46-59.
28. Cregan, C. (2013). Does Workplace Industrial Action Increase Trade Union Membership? An Exchange Relationship Approach to Union Joining and Leaving Behavior. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 24(1), 3363-3377.
29. Cullinane, N., & Dundon, T. (2014). Unitarism and Employer Resistance to Trade Unionism. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 25(18), 2573-2590.
30. Cully, M., Woodland, S., O'Reilly, A., & Dix, G. (1999). Britain at Work: As Depicted by the 1998 Workplace Employee Survey. London: Routledge.
31. Çoban, B. (2013). Sendikal Örgütlenmede Yeni Deneyimler ve Değişen Stratejiler. Çalışma ve Toplum, 38, 3375-412.
32. Danford, A., Richardson, M., Steward, P., Tailby, S., & Upchurch, M. (2005). Partnership and the High Performance Workplace: Work and Employment Relations in the Aeurospace Industry. London: Palgrave MacMillan.
33. Danford, A., Richardson, M., Tailby, S., & Upchurch, M. (2009). Union Organising and Partnership in Manufacturing, Finance and Public Services in Britain. G.Gall içinde, Union Revitalisation in Advanced Economies: Assessing the Contribution of Union Organising (s. 56-82). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
34. D'Art, D., & Turner, T. (2002). The Decline of Worker Solidarity and the End of Collectivism? Economic and Industrial Democracy, 23, 7-34.
35. D'Art, D., & Turner, T. (2003). Independent Collective Representation: Providing Effectiveness, Fairness, and Democracy in the Employment Relationship. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 15(4), 169-181.
36. Davis-Blake, A., Broschak, J. P., & George, E. (2003). Happy Together? How Using Nonstandard Workers Affects Exit, Voice, and Loyalty among Standard Employees. Academy of Management Journal, 46(4), 475-485.
37. Davy, J. A., Kinicki, A. J., & Scheck, C. L. (1997). A Test of Job Security's Direct and Mediated Effects on Withdrawal Cognitions. Journal of Organizational Behaviour, 18, 323-349.
38. Dickens, L., & Hall, M. (2003). Labour Law and Industrial Relations: A New Settlement? P. Edwards içinde, Industrial Relations: Theory and Practice (s. 124- 156). London: Blackwell Publishing.
39. Doeringer, P. B. (1991). Turbulance in the American Workplace. New York: Oxford University Press.
40. Dundon, T. (2001). Put Up and Shut Up: Social Mobilisation and Employee Attitudes in Non-union Firms. British Universities Industrial Relations Association Conference (s. 1-18). Manchester : Manchester Metropolitan University.
41. Dunn, S. (1990). Root Methaphor in the Old and New Industrial Relations. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 28(1), 1-31.
42. Eapen, G. (2010). Flexibility: Flexible Companies for the Uncertain World. Boca Raton: CRC Press.
43. Fairbrother, P. (2005). Review Article: G. Gall, Union Organizing. Campaining for Trade Union Recognition. Capital & Class, 87, 257-262.
44. Fairbrother, P. (2008). Social Movement Unionism or Trade Unions as Social Movements. Employee Responsibilities Rights Journal, 20(4), 213-220.
45. Fiorito, J. (2004). Union Renewal and the Organising Model in the United Kingdom. Labor Studies Journal, 29(2), 21-53.
46. Freeman, R. B. (1995). The Limits of Wage Flexibility to Curing Unemployment. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 11(1), 63-72.
47. Freeman, R. B. (2007). Do Workers Still Want Union? More Than Ever. Washington: Economic Policy Institute.
48. Freeman, R. B., & Rogers, J. (2002). Open Source Unionism: Beyond Exclusive Collective Bargaining. WorkingUSA, 5(4), 8-40.
49. Frege, C. M., & Kelly, J. (2003). Union Revitalization Strategies in Comparative Perspective. European Journal of Industrial Relations, 9(1), 7-24.
50. Frege, C. M., & Kelly, J. (2004). Union Strategies in Comparative Context. C. M. Frege, & J. Kelly içinde, Varieties of Unionism: Strategies for Union Revitalization in a Globalizing Economy (s. 31-44). New York: Oxford University Press.
51. Gall, G. (2003). Introduction. G. Gall içinde, Union Organizing: Campaigning for Trade Union Recognition (s. 1-18). London: Routledge.
52. Gall, G. (2004). British Employer Resistance to Trade Union Recognition. Human Resorce Management Journal, 14(2), 36-53.
53. Gall, G. (2009a). 'Union Organising' - Past, Present and Future. G. Gall içinde, The Future of Union Organising: Building for Tomorrow (s. 1-9). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
54. Gall, G. (2009b). What is to be Done with Union Organising? G. Gall içinde, Union Revitalisation in Advanced Economies: Assessing the Contribution of Union Organising (s. 1-16). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
55. Gall, G., & Fiorito, J. (2011). The Backward March of Labour Halted? Or, What Is To Be Done with 'Union Organising'? The Cases of Britain and the USA. Capital & Class, 35(2), 233-251.
56. Gall, G., & McKay, S. (2001). Facing 'Fairness at Work': Union Perception of Employer Opposition and Response to Union Recognition. Industrial Relations Journal, 32(2), 94-113.
57. Gallie, D., Felstead, A., & Green, F. (2001). Employer Policies and Organizational Commitment in Britain 1992-97. Journal of Management Studies, 38(8), 1083- 1101.
58. Geare, A., Edgar, F., & McAndrew, I. (2009). Workplace Values and Beliefs: An Empirical Study of Ideology, High Commitment Management and Unionisation. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 20(5), 1146-1171.
59. Geary, J. F. (2003). New Forms of Work Organization: Still Limited, Still Controlled But Still Welcome? P. Edwards içinde, Industrial Relations: Theory and Practice (s. 338-367). Malden: Blackwell Publishing.
60. Goos, M., & Manning, A. (2007). Lousy and Lovely Jobs: The Rising Polarization of Work in Britain. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 89(1), 118-133.
61. Greenwood, M. R. (2002). Ethics and HRM: A Review and Conceptual Analysis. Journal of Business Ethics, 261-278.
62. Guest, D. E., & Peccei, R. (2001). Partnership at Work: Mutuality and Balance of Advantage. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 39(2), 207-236.
63. Haynes, P., & Allen, M. (2001). Partnership as Union Strategy a Preliminary Evaluation. Empoyee Relations, 23(2), 164-187.
64. Heery, E. (2002). Partnership versus Organising: Alternative Futures for British Trade Unionism. Industrial Relations Jourrnal, 33(1), 20-35.
65. Heery, E., Kelly, J., & Waddington, J. (2003). Union Revitalization in Britain. European Journal of Industrial Relations, 9(1), 79-97.
66. Heery, E., Simms, M., Delbridge, R., Salmon, J., & Simpson, D. (2000). Organising Unionism Comes to the UK. Employee Relations, 22, 38-57.
67. Hyman, R. (2002). The Future of Unions. Just Labour, 1, 7-15.
68. ILO. (2015). Global Wage Report 2014-2015: Wages and Income Inequality. Geneva: ILO.
69. Jerrard, M., Cockfield, S., & Buttigieg, D. (2009). The 'Servicing-Organising- Community Continuum': Where Are Australian Unions Today? G. Gall içinde, The Future of Trade Unions: Building for Tomorrow (s. 97-113). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
70. Kalleberg, A. L. (2003). Flexible Firms and Labor Market Segmentation. Work and Occupations, 30(2), 154-175.
71. Kalleberg, A. L. (2009). Precarious Work, Insecure Workers: Employment Relations in Transition. American Sociological Review, 74, 1-22.
72. Kaufman, B. E. (2008). Paradigms in Industrial Relations: Original, Modern and Versions In-between. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 46(2), 314-339.
73. Kelly, J. (1997). The Future of Trade Unionism: Injustice, Identity and Attribution. Employee Relations, 19(5), 400-414.
74. Kelly, J. (1998). Rethinking Industrial Relations: Mobilization, Collectivism and Long Waves. London: Routledge.
75. Kelly, J. (2004). Social Partnership Agreements in Britain: Labor Cooperation and Compliance. Industrial Relations, 43(1), 267-292.
76. Kelly, J., & Badigannavar, V. (2004). Union Organizing. J. Kelly, & P. Willman içinde, Union Organization and Activity (s. 32-50). London: Routledge.
77. Kessler, I., & Purcell, J. (2003). Individualism and Collectivism in Industrial Relations. P. Edwards içinde, Industrial Relations: Theory and Practice (2 b., s. 313-337). Malden: Blackwell Publishing.
78. Kılıç, S. (2014). Endüstri İlişkileri Teorisi ve İnsan Kaynakları Yönetimi. Çalışma ve Toplum, 42, 111-136.
79. Kılıç, S., & Yıldız, K. (2015). İş Arayanların Sendika Talebi ve Sendika Algısı: Türkiye'deki Temsil Boşluğu Hakkında Bazı İşaretler. Siyaset Ekonomi ve Yönetim, Özel Sayı, 191-204.
80. Kochan, T. A., & Osterman, P. (1994). Mutual Gains Enterprise: Forging a Winning Partnership among Labour, Management and Government. Boston: Harvard University Press.
81. Kochan, T., Katz, H. C., & McKersie, R. (1995). Transformation of American Industrial Relations (3 b.). New York: Basic Books.
82. Machin, S. (2003). Trade Union Decline, New Workplaces and New Workers. H. Gospel, & S. Wood içinde, Representing Workers: Trade Union Recognition and Membership in Britain (s. 15-28). London: Routledge.
83. MacKenzie, R., Stuart, M., Forde, C., Greenwood, I., Gardiner, J., & Perrett, R. (2006). 'All that is Solid?': Class, Identity and the Maintenance of a Collective Orientation amongst Redundant Steelworkers. Sociology, 40(5), 833-852.
84. Martin, R. (1999). Mobilization Theory: A New Paradigm for Industrial Relations. Human Relations, 52(9), 1205-1216.
85. Martinez-Lucio, M., & Stuart, M. (2004). Swimming againt the Tide: Social Partnership, Mutual Gains and the Revival of 'tired' HRM. International Journal of Human Resources Management, 15(2), 410-424.
86. McAdam, D. (1988). Micromobilization Context and Recruitment to Activism. International Social Movement Research, 1, 125-154.
87. McCarthy, N. (2009). Union Organising in a Recognised Environment: A Case Study of Mobilisation. G. Gall içinde, Union Revitalisation in Advanced Economies: Assessing the Contribution of Union Organising (s. 107-130). London: Palgrave MacMillan.
88. Metcalf, D. (2002). British Unions: What Future. A. Bryson içinde, Future of Unions in Modern Britain (s. 5-16). London: LSE, The Leverhulme Trust.
89. Moody, K. (2009). Union Organising in the US: New Tactics, Old Barriers. G. Gall içinde, The Future of Union Organising: Building for Tomorrow (s. 10-27). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
90. Nickell, S. (1997). Unemployment and Labor Market Rigidities: Europe versus North America. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 11(3), 55-74.
91. Noon, M. (1992). HRM: A Map, Model or Theory? P. Blyton, & P. Turnbull içinde, Reassessing Human Resource Management (s. 16-32). London: SAGE Publication.
92. O'Grady, F., & Nowak, P. (2004). Beyond New Unionism. J. Kelly, & P. Willman içinde, Union Organization and Activity (s. 150-163). London: Routledge.
93. Oxenbridge, S., & Brown, W. (2002). The Two Faces of Partnership? An Assessment of Partnership and Co-operative Employer/Trade Union Relationships. Emploee Relations, 24(3), 262-276.
94. Peetz, D. (2002). Sypathy for the Devil? Australian Unionism and Public Opinion. Australian Journal of Political Science, 37(1), 57-80.
95. Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the Twenty - First Century. (A. Goldhammer, Çev.) The USA: Harvard University Press.
96. Pollert, A. (2010). Spheres of Collectivism: Group Action and Perspectives on Trade Unions among the Low-Paid Unorganized with Problems at Work. Capital & Class, 34(1), 115-125.
97. Quinlan, M., & Johnstone, R. (2009). The Implications of De-Collectivist Industrial Relations Laws and Associated Developments for Worker Health and Safety in Australia, 1996-2007. Industrial Relations Journal, 40(5), 426-443.
98. Robinson, I. (2008). What Explains Unorganized Worker's Growing Demand for Unions? Labor Studies Journal, 33(3), 235-243.
99. Rose, M. (2005). Job Satisfaction in Britain: Coping with Complexity. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 43(3), 455-467.
100. Selamoğlu, A. (2004). Örgütlenme Sorunu ve Sendikal Yapıda Değişim Arayışı. Çalışma ve Toplum(2004-2), 39-54.
101. Tapia, M. (2013). Marching to Different Tunes: Commitment and Culture as Mabilizing Mechanisms of Trade Unions and Community Organizations. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 51(4), 666-688.
102. Thompson, P., & Harley, B. (2007). HRM and the Worker: Labor Process Perspective. P. Boxal, J. Purcell, & P. Wright içinde, The Oxford Handbook of Human Resource Management (s. 147-165). New York: Oxford University Press.
103. Tilly, C. (1978). From Mobilization to Revolution. New York: Random House.
104. Towers, B. (1997). The Representation Gap: Change and Reform in the British and American Workplace. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
105. Tufts, S. (1998). Community Unionism in Canada and Labor's (Re)Organization of Space. Antipode, 30(3), 227-250.
106. Turner, L. (2004). Why Revitalize? Labour's Urgent Mission in a Contested Global Economy. C. Frege, & J. Kelly içinde, Varieties of Unionism: Strategies for Union Revitalization in a Globalizing Economy (s. 1-10). New York: Oxford University Press.
107. Turner, L., & Hurd, R. W. (2001). Building Social Movement Unionism: The Transformation of American Labor Movement. L. Turner, H. C. Katz, & R. W. Hurd içinde, Rekindling the movement: Labor’s quest for relevance in the twenty- first century (s. 9-26). New York: Cornell University Press.
108. Turner, T., & D'Art, D. (2012). Public Perceptions of Trade Unions in Countries of the European Union: A Casual Analysis. Labor Studies Journal, 37(1), 33-55.
109. Urhan, B. (2005). Türkiye'de Sendikal Örgütlenmede Yaşanan Güven ve Dayanışma Sorunları. Çalışma ve Toplum, 4, 57-88.
110. Urhan, B. (2012). İşçilerin Sendikaya Üye Olma Nedenleri ve Sendikaların Yeni Üye Kazanmaya Yönelik Stratejileri. 'İş, Güç' Endüstri İlişkileri ve İnsan Kaynakları, 14(2), 33-56.
111. Visser, J. (2006). Union Membership Statistics in 24 Countries. Monthly Labor Review, January, 38-49.
112. Waddington, J. (2003). Trade Union Organization. P. Edwards içinde, Industrial Relations: Theory and Practice (s. 214-254). Malden: Blackwell Publishing.
113. Wills, J. (2001). Community Unionism and Trade Union Renewal in the UK: Moving beyond the Fragments at Last? Transactions of the Institute of British Gegraphers, 26(4), 464-483.
114. Yıldırım, E., & Uçkan, B. (2010). İşverenlerin Sendikasızlaştırma Modelleri ve Türkiye Örneği. Çalışma ve Toplum, 25, 163-184.
115. Zeytinoğlu, I. U., Yılmaz, G., Keser, A., İnelmen, K., Uygur, D., & Özsoy, A. (2013). Job Satisfaction, Flexible Employment and Job Security among Turkish Service Sector Workers. Economic and Industrial Democracy, 34(1), 123- 144.