EXAMINING THE ROLE OF SOFT POWER IN TÜRKİYE AND INDIA’S RELATIONS WITH AFGHANISTAN

Abstract

This article explores how the soft power of Türkiye and India has been playing significant roles in their relationship with Afghanistan in the post-9/11 incident. After the US-led invasion of the Taliban in 2001, Türkiye, which has no land border with Afghanistan, engaged as a NATO stakeholder for post-war peacebuilding in the country. Türkiye also pursued non-military engagement through humanitarian and cultural institutions and achieved the confidence of the Afghan people. On the other hand, a diverse-natured regime at the doorstep, as well as the bitter relationship with Pakistan, triggered India to approach Afghanistan closely. India utilised its ‘Neighbourhood First’ policy through sheer civilian participation in delivering humanitarian aid and collaborating in educational and cultural fields, significantly strengthening its relationship with Afghanistan. However, the Taliban’s takeover of power has narrowed India’s engagement while Türkiye’s engagement has increased, though non-militarily, having significant impacts on both countries’ relationships with Afghanistan. This study, firstly, conceptualises the term ‘soft power.’ Secondly, it explains Türkiye’s historical relations with Afghanistan and the role of soft power after 9/11 to consolidate the relations. Thirdly, it explains India’s historical relations with Afghanistan and the role of soft power in expanding the relations after 9/11. Then, the article compares the roles of soft power by state and non-state actors of Türkiye with those of India in developing their relations with Afghanistan and the challenges and prospects that Türkiye and India may face in the future.

Keywords

• Soft power strategies
• Bilateral relations
• Türkiye
• India
• Afghanistan.

References

1. Ahmad, Peerzada Tufail (2019). “India’s Soft Power and Pakistan’s Hard Power Policy in Afghanistan”. Research Review International Journal of Multidisciplinary, 4(5): 1520-1524.
2. Ahmad, Peerzada Tufail (2022). “An Analysis of India’s Soft Power Policy in Afghanistan”. India Quarterly, 78(4): 634-653.
3. Ahmed, Zahid and Ali Akbar (2023). Iran’s Soft Power in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Edinburgh University Press.
4. Ali, Wajid (2019). “Historical Perspective of Indo-Afghan Relations”. International Journal of Political Science and Governance, 1(2): 26-29.
5. Anadolu Agency (2022). Turkey’s TIKA provides health care to 12M people in Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/politics/diplomacy/turkeys-tika-provides-health-care-to-12m-people-in-afghanistan. Accessed: 27.04.2024.
6. Anaz, Necati (2022). “An Assessment of Turkey’s Soft Power Resources in Asia: Potential and Limitations”. Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, 24(5): 755-771.
7. ANI (2022). India engaged with Afghanistan in over 500 projects: MoS Muraleedharan informs Lok Sabha. Retrieved from https://www.aninews.in/news/world/asia/india-engaged-with-afghanistan-in-over-500-projects-mos-muraleedharan-informs-lok-sabha20221209191400/. Accessed: 27.04.2024.
8. Aras, Bulent and Zulkarnain Mohammed (2019). The Turkish Government Scholarship Program is a Soft Power Tool. Turkish Studies, 20(3): 421-441.

9. Aydogan, Merve (2021). Turkey’s long involvement in NATO mission in Afghanistan. Anadolu Agency. Retrieved from https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/turkey-s-long-involvement-in-nato-mission-in-afghanistan/2279062. Accessed: 15.12.2023.
10. Bose, Sohini (2020). Bridging the Healthcare Gap in Afghanistan: A Primer on India’s Role. ORF Issue Brief, No. 355, April 2020.
11. Business Standard (2022). India delivers fresh batch of medical supplies to Afghanistan as aid: MEA. Retrieved from https://www.business-standard.com/article/international/india-delivers-fresh-batch-of-medical-supplies-to-afghanistan-as-aid-mea-122082000976_1.html. Accessed: 27.04.2024.
12. Daily Sabah (2019). Turkish Red Crescent feeds 300 families in Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/turkey/2018/10/08/turkish-red-crescent-feeds-300-families-in-afghanistan. Accessed: 10.02.2023.
13. Daily Sabah (2021). More than 165,000 apply for Turkey’s most popular scholarship. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/turkey/education/more-than-165000-apply-for-turkeys-most-popular-scholarship. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
14. Daily Sabah (2021). Turkish institute seeks to boost literacy in Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/education/2019/09/21/turkish-institute-seeks-to-boost-literacy-in-afghanistan. Accessed: 10.04.2024.
15. Daily Sabah (2022). Afghanistan continues to watch Turkish TV series amid restrictions. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/arts/afghanistan-continues-to-watch-turkish-tv-series-amid-restrictions/news. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
16. Daily Sabah (2022). Turkish Red Crescent plans rebuilding in quake-hit Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/turkey/turkish-red-crescentplans-rebuilding-in-quake-hit-afghanistan/news. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
17. Daily Sabah (2023). 7th ‘Kindness Train’ carrying aid from Türkiye reaches Afghanistan (2023, January 24). Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/politics/diplomacy/7th-kindness-train-carrying-aid-from-Türkiye-reaches-afghanistan. Accessed: 15.12.2023.
18. Daily Sabah (2023). University in Afghanistan opens Department of Turkish language. Retrieved from https://www.dailysabah.com/turkiye/university-in-afghanistan-opens-department-of-turkish-language/news. Accessed: 15.12.2023.
19. Devan, Pamela (2012). “Cricket and the Global Indian Identity”. Sport in Society, 15(10): 1413-1425.
20. Dogan, Salih (2011). “Turkey’s Presence and Importance in Afghanistan”. USAK Yearbook of Politics and International Relations, 4: 367-370.
21. Embassy of India in Afghanistan (n.d). India Afghanistan Foundation. Retrieved from https://eoi.gov.in/kabul/?4833?005. Accessed: 05.10.2023.
22. Embassy of India, Kabul, Afghanistan (n.d.). ICCR Scholarships. Retrieved from https://eoi.gov.in/kabul/?0359?000. Accessed: 06.09.2023.
23. Embassy of India, Kabul, Afghanistan (n.d.). India Culture Centre. Retrieved from https://eoi.gov.in/kabul/?0364?000. 10.03. 2023. Accessed: 05.10.2023.
24. Erman, Aydemir (2010). “How Turkey’s Soft Power Can Aid NATO in Afghanistan”. New Perspectives Quarterly, 27(2): 39-41.
25. Global Health Security Index (2021). 2021 GHS Index Country Profile for Turkey. Retrieved from https://www.ghsindex.org/country/turkey/. Accessed: 07.09.2023.
26. Gupta, Kanika (2023). India Builds Soft Power in Afghanistan, Bypassing Pakistan. Retrieved from https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/India-builds-soft-power-in-Afghanistan-bypassing-Pakistan. Accessed: 27.04.2024.
27. Hajimineh, Rahmat, Reza Dehghani and Fariborz Mohammadkhani (2020). “Turkey’s Cultural Diplomacy in Afghanistan during the AKP Era”. Iranian Review of Foreign Affairs, 11(31): 303-332.
28. Hindustan Times (2020). India, Afghanistan sign 5 pacts for developing educational infra in Afghan provinces. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/india-afghanistan-sign-5-pacts-for-developing-educational-infra-in-afghan-provinces/story-lrCdMSCtOMQzWBL4OCRVAM.html. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
29. Human Rights Watch (2022). Turkey Pushes Afghans Back at Iran Border. Retrieved from https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/11/18/turkey-pushes-afghans-back-iran-order#:~:text=Turkey%20hosts%20the%20largest%20number, January%202021%20and%20April%202022. Accessed: 08.12.2023.
30. Hurriyet Daily News (2019). More than 145,000 foreigners applied for ‘Turkey Scholarships’ program in 2019. Retrieved from https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/more-than-145-000-foreigners-applied-for-turkey-scholarships-programin-2019-141757. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
31. International Cricket Council (2018). The rise of Afghanistan cricket. Retrieved from https://www.icc-cricket.com/news/877810. Accessed: 06.09. 2023.
32. Kalin, Ibrahim (2011). “Soft Power and Public Diplomacy in Turkey. Perceptions”. Journal of International Affairs, 16(3): 5-23.
33. Kasap, Selma (2021). Girls in Afghanistan starting education at Turkey’s Maarif Foundation schools. Anadolu Agency. Retrieved from https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/girls-in-afghanistan-starting-education-at-turkeys-maarif-foundation-schools/2416283. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
34. Kiran, Afifa (2009). “Indian Quest for Strategic Ingress in Afghanistan and its Implications for Pakistan”. Issra Papers, 1(1): 12-29.
35. Kugiel, Patryk (2017). India’s soft power: A new foreign policy strategy. Taylor & Francis.
36. Ministry of External Affairs of India (2016). India and Afghanistan: A Development Partnership. Retrieved from https://mea.gov.in/Uploads/Publication-Docs/176_india-and-afghanistan-a-development-partnership.pdf. Accessed: 22.06.2023.
37. Ministry of External Affairs (n.d.). India and Afghanistan: A Development Partnership. https://mea.gov.in/Uploads/PublicationDocs/176_india-and-afghanistan-a-development-partnership.pdf. Accessed: 16.09.2023.
38. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Turkey (2012). Retrieved from https://www.mfa.gov.tr/interview-by-mr_-ahmet-davuto%C4%9Flu-publishedin-auc-cairo-review-_egypt_-on-12-march-2012.en.mfa. Accessed: 10.10.2022.
39. Ministry of Interior Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency, Türkiye (n.d.). About Us. Retrieved from https://en.afad.gov.tr/about-us. Accessed: 19.06.2023.
40. Minority Rights (2023). Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://minorityrights.org/country/afghanistan/. Accessed: 27.04.2024.
41. Nazary, Khudayberdy (2018). “Afganistan’da Turkce Egitimi”. Uluslararası Yabancı Dil Olarak Türkçe Öğretimi Dergisi, 1(1): 17-32. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/ijotfl/issue/39377/464576. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
42. Nye Jr, Joseph S. (2008). “Public Diplomacy and Soft Power”. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 616(1): 94-109.
43. Nye, Joseph S. (2004). Soft power: The means to success in world politics. Public Affairs.
44. Ozoglu, Murat, Bekir S. Gür and Ipek Coskun (2015). “Factors Influencing International Students’ Choice to Study in Turkey and Challenges They Experience in Turkey”. Research in Comparative and International Education, 10(2): 223-237.
45. Pate, Tanvi (2018). “Soft Power, Strategic Narratives, and State Identity: Re-Assessing India-Afghanistan Relations Post-2011”. India Review, 17(3): 320-351.
46. Prabhu, Swati (2021). The future of India’s development cooperation in Afghanistan. Observer Research Foundation. Retrieved from https://www.orfonline.org/research/the-future-of-indias-development-cooperation-in-afghanistan/. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
47. Qazi, Shereena (2019). Afghanistan’s only yoga studio: A calm oasis for war-weary women. Aljazeera. Retrieved from https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2019/2/25/afghanistans-only-yoga-studio-a-calm-oasis-for-war-wearywomen. Accessed: 01.03.2024.
48. Rahmani, Abdul Rahman (2019). India’s soft power is very effective in Afghanistan. Hindustan Times. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/analysis/india-s-soft-power-is-very-effective-in-afghanistan/story-1db4KfSkgo-QYO7xM08LaVP.html. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
49. Reuters (2021). Turkish Red Crescent sending aid to feed displaced Afghans. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/turkish-red-crescentsending-aid-feed-displaced-afghans-2021-10-01/. Accessed: 15.12.2023.
50. Roy, Shubhajit (2017). India steps up development partnership with Afghanistan. The Indian Express. Retrieved from https://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-steps-up-development-partnership-with-afghanistan-4839291/. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
51. Sadat, Sayed Khodaberdi (2019). Turkish TV series set rating records on Afghan channels. Anadolu Agency. Retrieved from https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/turkish-tv-series-set-rating-records-on-afghan-channels/1655351. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
52. Sahin, Savas (2016). “Afganistan’daki Turkmen Varligi ve Kultürü Uzerine”. International Journal of Turkish Literature Culture Education, 5(5/3): 1144-1144.
53. Shah, Minaam (2023). “For Afghan refugees, India is far from a safe haven”. Foreign Policy. Retrieved from https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/07/06/india-afghan-refugees-unhcr-modi-politics-caa/. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
54. Statista (2020). Breakdown of Afghan population as of 2020, by ethnic group. Retrieved from https://www.statista.com/statistics/1258799/afghanistan-share-of-population-by-ethnic-group/. Accessed: 18.09.2023.
55. Tandon, Bhairvi (2019). India’s soft power advantage in the great game of Afghanistan. Observer Research Foundation. Retrieved from https://www.orfonline. org/expert-speak/indias-soft-power-advantage-in-the-great-game-of-afghanistan-52624/. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
56. Tang, Song (2021). “Scholarship Diplomacy and India’s Neighbourhood First Strategy”. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 27(7): 905-919.
57. The Guardian (2021). Afghan health system ‘close to collapse due to sanctions on Taliban. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/dec/13/afghan-health-system-close-to-collapse-due-to-sanctionson-taliban. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
58. TIKA (2024). History. Retrieved from https://tika.gov.tr/en/institutional/history/Accessed: 15.12.2024.
59. Tolonews (2019). Indian companies invest in Afghanistan’s healthcare. Retrieved from https://tolonews.com/business/indian-companies-invest-afghanistan%E2%80%99s-healthcare. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
60. Trivedi, Anjani (2021, August 30). India’s Soft Power, Investments in Afghanistan Lead to Diplomatic Dead End. Business Standard. Retrieved from https://www.business-andard.com/article/international/india-s-soft-power-investmentsin-afghanistan-lead-to-diplomatic-dead-end-121083000047_1.html. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
61. TRT World (2021). Türkiye, Qatar sign deal to jointly operate Kabul airport. Retrieved from https://www.trtworld.com/turkey/Türkiye-qatar-sign-deal-to-jointly-operate-kabul-airport-52930. Accessed: 12.09.2023.
62. Turkish Diyanet Foundation (2021). TDV provided cash aid to orphaned children in Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://tdv.org/en-EN/tdv-provided-cashaid-to-orphaned-children-in-afghanistan/. Accessed: 22.06.2023.
63. Turkish Diyanet Foundation (2022). TDV opened 5 water wells and fountains in Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://tdv.org/en-EN/tdv-opened-5-water-wellsand-fountains-in-afghanistan/ Accessed: 22.06.2023.
64. Turkish Maarif Foundation (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.afganturkmaarif.org/Home/en. Accessed: 22.10.2022.
65. Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2010). Turkey’s Contributions to Afghanistan. Retrieved from https://www.mfa.gov.tr/data/DISPOLITIKA/Bolgeler/Turkiyenin_Afganistana_Katkilari_Haziran_2010.pdf. Accessed: 26.04.2024.
66. Türkiye Diyanet Foundation (2024). About US/Türkiye Diyanet Foundation. Retrieved from https://tdv.org/en-EN/aboutus/. Accessed: 20.02.2024.
67. Yunus Emre Institute (2024). Yunus Emre Institute. Retrieved from https://www.yee.org.tr/en/corporate/yunus-emre-institute. Accessed: 26.03.2024.
68. Tanrisever, Oktay F. (2013). “Turkey’s Evolving Role in the Security of Afghanistan and Central Asia since 9/11: Sources and Limitations of Ankara’s Soft Power”. In Afghanistan and Central Asia: NATO’s Role in Regional Security since 9/11 (pp. 155-170). IOS Press