A comprehensive survey of the urban building energy modeling (UBEM) process and approaches

Year 2023, , 87 - 116, 24.03.2023

Melik Ziya Yakut , Sinem Esen

https://doi.org/10.58559/ijes.1228599

Cited By: 1

Abstract

Fossil fuels increase the emission values of greenhouse gases such as CO2 in the atmosphere and cause global warming and climate change. At the same time, fossil fuel reserves are facing depletion in the near future, and energy supply also has an important dimension such as national security and foreign dependency. All these show that turning to renewable energy sources and developing solutions and policies for energy saving has become a necessity both globally and locally. For such reasons, modeling of urban structures, which have a great contribution to energy consumption, and simulating the energy demand on an urban scale are of great importance for the effective use of energy. Research on this has shown that UBEM (Urban Building Energy Modeling) is an effective solution to these problems. However, UBEM contains different technical problems for implementation. Due to its versatility, various concepts related to this field lead to complexity. With this increasing complexity, there is a growing need to compile concepts from a holistic perspective. In this study, it is aimed to create a solution to these challenges. For this purpose, a comprehensive and up-to-date research of various modeling approaches and model creation process used in urban building energy modeling has been conducted. Studies on these approaches are summarized and a systematic review of the literature is made. At the same time, the study is in the nature of guiding and forming the general knowledge level with the basic concepts that should be known to those who will work on UBEM.

Keywords

Urban building energy modeling, UBEM, UBEM approches, Bottom-up approches, Urban energy modeling

Supporting Institution

YÖK

Project Number

YÖK100/2000

Thanks

This study is based on studies supported within the scope of Turkey The Council of Higher Education YÖK 100/2000 PhD project. We offer our gratitude.

References

• [1] http://www.demographia.com/db-worldua.pdf. Access date: 07.08.2022.
• [2] https://unhabitat.org/sites/default/files/2022/06/wcr_2022.pdf. Access date: 07.08.2022.
• [3] https://www.gensed.org/. Access date: 07.08.2022.
• [4] https://www2.deloitte.com. Access date: 07.08.2022.
• [5] Ang YQ, Berzolla ZM, Reinhart CF. From concept to application: A review of use cases in urban building energy modeling. Applied Energy 2020; 279: 1-15.
• [6] Ali U, Shamsi MH, Hoare C, Mangina E, O’Donnell J. Review of urban building energy modeling (UBEM) approaches, methods and tools using qualitative and quantitative analysis. Energy and buildings 2021; 246: 1-24.
• [7] Maccarini A, Mans M, Sørensen CG, Afshari A. Towards an automated generator of urban building energy loads from 3D building models. Proceedings of the 14th International Modelica Conference, Linköping, Sweden, 2021.
• [8] Ang YQ, Berzolla ZM, Letellier-Duchesne S, Jusiega V, Reinhart C. UBEM.io: A web-based framework to rapidly generate urban building energy models for carbon reduction technology pathways. Sustainable Cities and Society 2022; 77: 1-22.
• [9] Dahlström L, Broström T, Widén J. Advancing Urban Building Energy Modelling through new model components and applications: A review. Energy and Buildings 2022; 266: 1-17.
• [10] Hu Y, Cheng X, Wang S, Chen J, Zhao T, Dai E. Times series forecasting for urban building energy consumption based on graph convolutional network. Applied Energy 2022; 307: 1-12.
• [11] Yamagata Y, Yang PP, Chang S, Tobey MB, Binder RB, Fourie PJ, Jittrapirom P, Kobasi T, Yoshida T, Aleksejeva Y. Urban systems and the role of big data. Urban Systems Design 2020; 23-58.
• [12] Abbasabadi N, Ashayeri M. Urban energy use modeling methods and tools: A review and an outlook. Building and Environment 2019; 161: 1-16.
• [13] Mathur A, Fennell P, Rawal R, Korolija I. Assessing a fit-for-purpose urban building energy modelling framework with reference to Ahmedabad. Science and Technology for the Built Environment 2021; 27(8): 1075-1103.
• [14] Schiefelbein J, Rudnick J, Scholl A, Remmen P, Fuchs M, Müller D. Automated urban energy system modeling and thermal building simulation based on OpenStreetMap data sets. Building and environment 2019; 149: 630-639.
• [15] Wang C, Ferrando M, Causone F, Jin X, Zhou X, Shi X. Data acquisition for urban building energy modeling: A review”, Building and Environment 2022; 217: 1-20.
• [16] Abolhassani SS, Amayri M, Bouguila N, Eicker U. A new workflow for detailed urban scale building energy modeling using spatial joining of attributes for archetype selection. Journal of Building Engineering 2022; 46: 1-24.
• [17] Ferrando M, Causone F, Hong T, Chen Y. Urban building energy modeling (UBEM) tools: A state-of-the-art review of bottom-up physics-based approaches. Sustainable Cities and Society 2020; 62: 1-15.
• [18] Swan LG, Ugursal VI. Modeling of end-use energy consumption in the residential sector: A review of modeling techniques. Renewable and sustainable energy reviews 2009; 13(8): 1819-1835.
• [19] Li W, Zhou Y, Cetin K, Eom J, Wang Y, Chen G, Zhang X. Modeling urban building energy use: A review of modeling approaches and procedures. Energy 2017; 141: 2445-2457.
• [20] Ma R, Ren B, Zhao D, Chen J, Lu Y. Modeling urban energy dynamics under clustered urban heat island effect with local-weather extended distributed adjacency blocks. Sustainable Cities and Society 2020; 56: 1-13.
• [21] Ferrando M, Causone F. An overview of urban building energy modelling (UBEM) tools. Building Simulation 2019; 16: 3452-3459.
• [22] Hong T, Chen Y, Luo X, Luo N, Lee SH. Ten questions on urban building energy modeling”, Building and Environment 2020; 168: 1-47.
• [23] Yücel MA, Selçuk M. Üç Boyutlu Kent Modellerinde Ayrıntı Düzeyi LoD Kavramı. Jeodezi ve Jeoinformasyon Dergisi 2009; 101: 3-9.
• [24] Sokol J, Davila CC, Reinhart CF. Validation of a Bayesian-based method for defining residential archetypes in urban building energy models. Energy and Buildings 2017; 134: 11-24.
• [25] Nutkiewicz A, Jain RK. Exploring the integration of simulation and deep learning models for urban building energy modelling and retrofit analysis. Proceedings of the 16th IBPSA Conference, Rome, Italy, 2019.
• [26] Nageler P, Zahrer G, Heimrath R, Mach T, Mauthner F, Leusbrock I, Schranzhofera H, Hochenauera C. Novel validated method for GIS based automated dynamic urban building energy simulations. Energy 2017; 139: 142-154.
• [27] Mohammadiziazi R, Copeland S, Bilec MM. Urban building energy model: Database development, validation, and application for commercial building stock. Energy and Buildings 2021; 248: 1-15.
• [28] Davila CC, Reinhart CF, Bemis JL. Modeling Boston: A workflow for the efficient generation and maintenance of urban building energy models from existing geospatial datasets. Energy 2016; 117: 237-250.
• [29] Zarrella A, Prataviera E, Romano P, Carnieletto L, Vivian J. Analysis and application of a lumped-capacitance model for urban building energy modelling. Sustainable Cities and Society 2020; 63: 1-17.
• [30] Ali U, Shamsi MH, Hoare C, O'Donnell J. GIS-based residential building energy modeling at district scale. BSO 2018: 4th IBPSA-England Conference on Building Simulation and Optimization, Cambridge, UK, 2018.
• [31] Vermeulen T, Kämpf JH, Beckers B. Urban form optimization for the energy performance of buildings using Citysim. CISBAT, Lausanne, Switzerland, 2013.
• [32] Polly B, Kutscher C, Macumber D, Schott M, Pless S, Livingood B, Geet OV. From zero energy buildings to zero energy districts. Proceedings of the 2016 American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings (ACEEE), Pacific Grove, CA, USA, 2016.
• [33] Lu Y, Scott A, Kim J, Curi CB, McCarty J, Pardy A. Integration of an energy–economy model with an urban energy model. Buildings and Cities 2021; 2(1): 115-133.
• [34] Hong T, Chen Y, Lee SH, Piette MA. CityBES: A web-based platform to support city-scale building energy efficiency. Urban Computing 2016; 14: 1-10.
• [35] Madrazo L, Sicilia A, Gamboa G. SEMANCO: Semantic tools for carbon reduction in urban planning. Proceedings of the 9th European Conference on Product and Process Modelling, Barcelona, Spain, 2012.
• [36] Li W. Quantifying the Building Energy Dynamics of Manhattan, New York City, Using an Urban Building Energy Model and Localized Weather Data. Energies 2020; 13(12): 1-20.
• [37] Reinhart C, Dogan T, Jakubiec JA, Rakha T, Sang A. Umi-an urban simulation environment for building energy use, daylighting and walkability. 13th Conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association, Chambery, France, 2013.
• [38] Fonseca JA, Nguyen TA, Schlueter A, Marechal F. City Energy Analyst (CEA): Integrated framework for analysis and optimization of building energy systems in neighborhoods and city districts. Energy and Buildings 2016; 113: 202-226.
• [39] Heidarinejad, M., Mattise, N., Dahlhausen, M., Sharma, K., Benne, K., Macumber, D., Brackney L, Srebric J. Demonstration of reduced-order urban scale building energy models. Energy and Buildings 2017; 156: 17-28.
• [40] Prataviera E, Romano P, Carnieletto L, Pirotti F, Vivian J, Zarrella A. EUReCA: An open-source urban building energy modelling tool for the efficient evaluation of cities energy demand. Renewable Energy 2021; 173: 544-560.
• [41] Nouvel R, Brassel KH, Bruse M, Duminil E, Coors V, Eicker U, Robinson D. SimStadt, a new workflow-driven urban energy simulation platform for CityGML city models. Proceedings of International Conference CISBAT 2015 Future Buildings and Districts Sustainability from Nano to Urban Scale, Lausanne, Switzerland, 2015.
• [42] Muehleisen R, Bergerson J. Coupling a Reduced Order Building Energy Model to UrbanSim. Proceedings of the 15th IBPSA Conference, San Francisco, CA, USA, 2017.
• [43] Kaden R, Kolbe TH. City-wide total energy demand estimation of buildings using semantic 3D city models and statistical data. Proc. of the 8th International 3D GeoInfo Conference, Istanbul, Turkey, 2013.
• [44] Li Q, Quan SJ, Augenbroe G, Yang PPJ, Brown J. Building energy modelling at urban scale: Integration of reduced order energy model with geographical information. Proceedings of BS2015: 14th Conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association, Hyderabad, India, 2015.
• [45] Baetens R, De Coninck R, Jorissen F, Picard D, Helsen L, Saelens D. Openideas-an open framework for integrated district energy simulations. Proceedings of BS2015: 14th Conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association, Hyderabad, India, 2015.
• [46] https://ssrn.com/abstract=4161873. Access date: 07.08.2022.
• [47] Remmen P, Lauster M, Mans M, Fuchs M, Osterhage T, Müller D. TEASER: an open tool for urban energy modelling of building stocks. Journal of Building Performance Simulation 2018; 11(1): 84-98.
• [48] Nutkiewicz A, Yang Z, Jain RK. Data-driven Urban Energy Simulation (DUE-S): A framework for integrating engineering simulation and machine learning methods in a multi-scale urban energy modeling workflow. Applied energy 2018; 225: 1176-1189.
• [49] Nutkiewicz A, Yang Z, Jain RK. Data-driven Urban Energy Simulation (DUE-S): Integrating machine learning into an urban building energy simulation workflow. Energy Procedia 2017; 142: 2114-2119.
• [50] Nutkiewicz A, Choi B, Jain RK. Exploring the influence of urban context on building energy retrofit performance: A hybrid simulation and data-driven approach. Advances in Applied Energy 2021; 3: 1-17.
• [51] Papadopoulos S, Kontokosta CE. Grading buildings on energy performance using city benchmarking data. Applied Energy 2019; 233: 244-253.
• [52] Wang Y, Wu T, Li H, Skitmore M, Su B. A statistics-based method to quantify residential energy consumption and stock at the city level in China: The case of the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area cities. Journal of Cleaner Production 2020; 251: 1-13.
• [53] Fonseca JA, Schlueter A. Integrated model for characterization of spatiotemporal building energy consumption patterns in neighborhoods and city districts. Applied Energy 2015; 142: 247-265.
• [54] Ma J, Cheng JC. Estimation of the building energy use intensity in the urban scale by integrating GIS and big data technology. Applied Energy 2016; 183: 82-192.
• [55] Kontokosta CE, Tull C. A data-driven predictive model of city-scale energy use in buildings. Applied energy 2017; 197: 303-317.
• [56] Alhamwi A, Medjroubi W, Vogt T, Agert C. Modelling urban energy requirements using open source data and models. Applied Energy 2018; 231: 1100-1108.
• [57] Abbasabadi N, Ashayeri M, Azari R, Stephens B, Heidarinejad M. An integrated data-driven framework for urban energy use modeling (UEUM). Applied energy 2019; 253: 1-19.
• [58] Ali U, Shamsi MH, Bohacek M, Hoare C, Purcell K, Mangina E, O’Donnell J. A data-driven approach to optimize urban scale energy retrofit decisions for residential buildings. Applied Energy 2020; 267: 1-21.
• [59] Perwez U, Yamaguchi Y, Ma T, Dai Y, Shimoda Y. Multi-scale GIS-synthetic hybrid approach for the development of commercial building stock energy model. Applied Energy 2022; 323: 1-24.
• [60] Li X, Ying Y, Xu X, Wang Y, Hussain SA, Hong T, Wang W. Identifying key determinants for building energy analysis from urban building datasets. Building and Environment 2020; 181: 1-12.
• [61] Pasichnyi O, Wallin J, Kordas O. Data-driven building archetypes for urban building energy modelling. Energy 2019; 181: 360-377.
• [62] Kristensen MH, Hedegaard RE, Petersen S. Long-term forecasting of hourly district heating loads in urban areas using hierarchical archetype modeling. Energy 2020; 201: 1-16.
• [63] Real JP, Møller JK, Li R, Madsen H. A data-driven framework for characterising building archetypes: A mixed effects modelling approach. Energy 2022; 254: 1-12.
• [64] Dall’O’ G, Galante A, Torri M. A methodology for the energy performance classification of residential building stock on an urban scale. Energy and Buildings 2012; 48: 211-219.
• [65] Yang Z, Roth J, Jain RK. DUE-B: Data-driven urban energy benchmarking of buildings using recursive partitioning and stochastic frontier analysis. Energy and Buildings 2018; 163: 58-69.
• [66] Ali U, Shamsi MH, Hoare C, Mangina E, O’Donnell, J. A data-driven approach for multi-scale building archetypes development. Energy and buildings 2019; 202: 1-15.
• [67] Wang W, Lin Q, Chen J, Li X, Sun Y, Xu X. Urban building energy prediction at neighborhood scale. Energy and Buildings 2021; 251: 1-14.
• [68] Pasichnyi O, Levihn F, Shahrokni H, Wallin J, Kordas O. Data-driven strategic planning of building energy retrofitting: The case of Stockholm. Journal of cleaner production 2019; 233: 546-560.
• [69] Wang W, Liu K, Zhang M, Shen Y, Jing R, Xu X. From simulation to data-driven approach: A framework of integrating urban morphology to low-energy urban design. Renewable Energy 2021; 179: 2016-2035.
• [70] Zhao F, Martinez-Moyano IJ, Augenbroe G. Agent-based modeling of commercial building stocks for policy support. 12th Conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association, Sydney, Australia, 2011.
• [71] Robinson C, Dilkina B, Hubbs J, Zhang W, Guhathakurta S, Brown MA, Pendyala RM. Machine learning approaches for estimating commercial building energy consumption. Applied energy 2017; 208: 889-904.
• [72] Rahman A, Srikumar V, Smith AD. Predicting electricity consumption for commercial and residential buildings using deep recurrent neural networks. Applied energy 2018; 212: 372-385.
• [73] Williams KT, Gomez JD. Predicting future monthly residential energy consumption using building characteristics and climate data: A statistical learning approach. Energy and Buildings 2016; 128: 1-11.
• [74] Pedersen L, Stang J, Ulseth R. Load prediction method for heat and electricity demand in buildings for the purpose of planning for mixed energy distribution systems. Energy and Buildings 2008; 40(7): 1124-1134.
• [75] Mastrucci A, Baume O, Stazi F, Leopold U. Estimating energy savings for the residential building stock of an entire city: A GIS-based statistical downscaling approach applied to Rotterdam. Energy and Buildings 2014, 75: 358-367.
• [76] Johari F, Peronato G, Sadeghian P, Zhao X, Widén J. Urban building energy modeling: State of the art and future prospects. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2020; 128: 1-16.
• [77] Rakha T, El Kontar R. Community energy by design: A simulation-based design workflow using measured data clustering to calibrate Urban Building Energy Models (UBEMs). Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science 2019; 46(8): 1517-1533.
• [78] Deng Z, Chen Y, Pan X, Peng Z, Yang J. Integrating GIS-based point of interest and community boundary datasets for urban building energy modeling. Energies 2021; 14(4): 1-17.
• [79] Chen Y, Hong T, Luo X, Hooper B. Development of city buildings dataset for urban building energy modeling. Energy and Buildings 2019; 183: 252-265.
• [80] Jusuf SK, Mousseau B, Godfroid G, Soh JHV. Path to an integrated modelling between IFC and CityGML for neighborhood scale modelling. Urban Science 2017; 1(3): 1-20.
• [81] Gröger G, Kolbe TH, Czerwinski A, Nagel C. OpenGIS city geography markup language (CityGML) encoding standard 1st ed. Open Geospatial Consortium, Berlin, Germany, 2008.
• [82] Kolbe TH. CityGML-3D geospatial and semantic modelling of urban structures. GITA/OGC Emerging Technology Summit 4, Washington D.C., USA, 2007.
• [83] Nouvel R, Bahu JM, Kaden R, Kaempf J, Cipriano P, Lauster M, Häfele K, Munoz E, Tournaire O, Casper E. Development of the CityGML application domain extension energy for urban energy simulation. 14th Conference of the International Building Performance Simulation Association, Hyderabad, India, 2015.
• [84] Laat RD, Berlo LV. Integration of BIM and GIS: The development of the CityGML GeoBIM extension. Advances in 3D geo-information sciences, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2011.
• [85] Malhotra A, Raming S, Frisch J, van Treeck C. Open-Source Tool for Transforming CityGML Levels of Detail. Energies 2021; 14(24): 1-26.
• [86] Ramos F, Siret D, Musy M. A 3D GIS for managing building rehabilitation process. Geoinformatics, Gävle, Sweden, 2004.
• [87] Reinhart CF, Davila CC. Urban building energy modeling-A review of a nascent field. Building and Environment 2016; 97: 196-202.
• [88] Cerezo C, Sokol J, AlKhaled S, Reinhart C, Al-Mumin A, Hajiah A. Comparison of four building archetype characterization methods in urban building energy modeling (UBEM): A residential case study in Kuwait City. Energy and Buildings 2017; 154: 321-334.
• [89] Risch S, Remmen P, Müller D. Influence of data acquisition on the Bayesian calibration of urban building energy models. Energy and Buildings 2021; 230: 1-15.
• [90] Artiges N, Rouchier S, Delinchant B, Wurtz F. Bayesian Inference of Dwellings Energy Signature at National Scale: Case of the French Residential Stock. Energies 2021; 14(18): 1-26.
• [91] Cerezo Davila, C. Building archetype calibration for effective urban building energy modeling. PhD Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2017.
• [92] Prataviera E, Vivian J, Lombardo G, Zarrella A. Evaluation of the impact of input uncertainty on urban building energy simulations using uncertainty and sensitivity analysis. Applied Energy 2022; 311: 1-19.
• [93] Oraiopoulos A, Howard B. On the accuracy of urban building energy modelling. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2022; 158: 1-14.
• [94] Cardinali M, Pisello AL, Piselli C, Pigliautile I, Cotana F. Microclimate mitigation for enhancing energy and environmental performance of Near Zero Energy Settlements in Italy. Sustainable Cities and Society 2020; 53: 1-13:.
• [95] Mauree D, Naboni E, Coccolo S, Perera ATD, Nik VM, Scartezzini JL. A review of assessment methods for the urban environment and its energy sustainability to guarantee climate adaptation of future cities. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2019; 112: 733-746.
• [96] Katal A, Mortezazadeh M, Wang LL. Modeling building resilience against extreme weather by integrated CityFFD and CityBEM simulations. Applied Energy 2019; 250: 1402-1417.
• [97] Hong T, Luo X. Modeling building energy performance in urban context. Proceedings of the 2018 Building Performance Analysis Conference and SimBuild Co-Organized by ASHRAE and IBPSA-USA, Chicago, IL, USA, 2018.