Thermohydraulic comparison of PA12 and high temp resin lung-inspired plate heat exchangers

Abstract

This study experimentally compares the thermo-hydraulic performance of two different plastic plate heat exchangers (PPHEs) manufactured by additive manufacturing with a lung-inspired channel geometry. One heat exchanger made from PA12 material was produced using Multi Jet Fusion (MJF) technology, while the other heat exchanger was produced from High Temp. Resin material using stereolithography (SLA) technology with additive manufacturing. Both exchangers were tested in a specially designed experimental setup. Boundary conditions were established in the experimental setup with a hot side of 60 °C and a cold side of 30 °C. The tests were performed with water flow rates of 0.05 and 0.1 kg/s. The average heat transfer of the heat exchanger made from PA12 was found to be 1504.8 W and 3887.4 W, while the required pump power was 4.37 W and 27.44 W. The COP values ​​of the heat exchanger made from PA12 material were obtained as 345.1 and 141.7, respectively. In the heat exchanger produced with High Temp. Resin, pressure losses of 7.9 kPa at a flow rate of 0.05 kg/s and 40 kPa at a flow rate of 0.1 kg/s were measured. The researcher adopted the view that this pressure loss is due to channel narrowing caused by the manufacturing process, and the COP values ​​were calculated to decrease to 19.1 and 3.9, respectively. These results confirm that the heat exchanger produced with SLA from High Temp. Resin material provides high thermal resistance, but in practical application in microchannel heat exchangers, it can be operated at a lower efficiency due to pressure loss when compared to the heat exchanger produced with MJF technology using PA12 material.

Keywords

• Plastic plate heat exchanger
• Lung-inspired channel pattern
• Additive manufacturing
• Thermo hydraulic performance

References

1. [1] Gürel B, Akkaya VR, Göltaş M, Şen ÇN, Güler OV, Koşar Mİ, Keçebaş A. Investigation on flow and heat transfer of compact brazed plate heat exchanger with lung pattern. Applied Thermal Engineering 2020; 175: 115309.
2. [2] Gürel B, Keçebaş A, Akkaya VR, Göltaş M, Güler OV, Kurtuluş K. Modeling and assessment of the thermo-hydraulic performance for a fish gill patterned plate heat exchanger in biomimetic approach. Heat Transfer Engineering 2023; 44(11–12): 987-1001.
3. [3] Göltaş M, Gürel B, Keçebaş A, Akkaya VR, Güler OV. Improvement of thermo-hydraulic performance with plate surface geometry for a compact plate heat exchanger manufactured by additive manufacturing. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 2022; 188: 122637.
4. [4] Borjigin S, Zhao W, Fu W, Liang W, Bai S, Ma J, Meng K, Baoyin H. Review of plate heat exchanger utilized for gases heat exchange. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2025; 210: 115224.
5. [5] T’Joen C, Park Y, Wang Q, Sommers A, Han X, Jacobi A. A review on polymer heat exchangers for HVAC&R applications. International Journal of Refrigeration 2009; 32(5): 763-779.
6. [6] Arie MA, Hymas DM, Singer F, Shooshtari AH, Ohadi M. An additively manufactured novel polymer composite heat exchanger for dry cooling applications. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 2020; 147: 118889.
7. [7] Acır A, Canlı ME, Ata İ, Tanürün HE. Effects of a circular-shaped turbulator having varying hole numbers on energy and exergy efficiencies of a solar air heater. International Journal of Ambient Energy 2018; 41(3): 271-280.
8. [8] Acır A, Canlı ME, Ata İ, Uzun S, Tanürün HE. Experimental investigation of thermal energy storage efficiency using fin application with phase change material (PCM) under solar radiation. Heat Transfer Research 2021; 52(6): 21-39.

9. [9] Bohacek J, Raudensky M, Astrouski I, Karimi-Sibaki E. An optimal design for hollow fiber heat exchanger: A combined numerical and experimental investigation. Energy 2021; 229: 120571.
10. [10] Kakaç S, Liu H, Pramuanjaroenkij A. Heat exchangers: selection, rating, and thermal design. CRC press; 2012.
11. [11] Bejan A, Lorente S. Design with constructal theory. John Wiley & Sons; 2008.
12. [12] Emerson DR, Cieslicki K, Gu X, Barber RW. Biomimetic design of microfluidic manifolds based on a generalised Murray's law. Lab on a Chip 2006; 6(3): 447-454.
13. [13] Hein LL, Mortean MVV. Theoretical and experimental thermal performance analysis of an additively manufactured polymer compact heat exchanger. International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer 2021; 124: 105237.
14. [14] Ahmadi B, Bigham S. Performance evaluation of hi-k lung-inspired 3D-printed polymer heat exchangers. Applied Thermal Engineering 2022; 204: 117993.
15. [15] Ahmadi B, Cesarano J, Nawaz K, Ninos N, Bigham S. A high-performance lung-inspired ceramic 3D-printed heat exchanger for high-temperature energy-efficient systems. Applied Thermal Engineering 2023; 219: 119378.
16. [16] Niknam SA, Mortazavi M, Li D. Additively manufactured heat exchangers: a review on opportunities and challenges. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 2021; 112: 601-618.
17. [17] Goshayeshi HR, Mousavi SB, Heris SZ, Chaer I. Insights into two-phase flow dynamics in closed-loop pulsating heat pipes utilizing Fe3O4/water: Experimental visualization study. Scientific Reports 2024; 14: 16497.
18. [18] Khouri O, Goshayeshi HR, Mousavi SB, Nami SH, Heris SZ. Heat transfer enhancement in industrial heat exchangers using graphene oxide nanofluids. ACS Omega 2024; 9: 24025-24038. [19] Heris SZ, Zolfagharian N, Mousavi SB, Nami SH. Enhancing the synergistic properties of plate heat exchangers using nanohybrid MWCNTs–SiO2 EG-based nanofluids. Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry 2025; 150: 6225-6244.
19. [20] Incropera FP, DeWitt DP. Fundamentals of heat and mass transfer. New York: Wiley; 1990.
20. [21] Ning J, Wang X, Sun Y, Zheng C, Zhang S, Zhao X, Liu C, Yan W. Experimental and numerical investigation of additively manufactured novel compact plate-fin heat exchanger. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 2022; 190: 122818.
21. [22] Genceli OF. Heat exchangers. 4th ed. Istanbul: Birsen Publishing House; 2009.