Social Capital and its Popularity

Abstract

The concept of ‘social capital’ has met with huge success among governmental agencies, including governments at all levels and transnational entities such as the World Bank. And yet the concept has been subjected to a devastating critique. This paper investigates a number of reasons given in the literature for its popularity. It starts with a brief overview of the social policy context in Australia, where the social capital framework has been influential. It goes on to discuss some of the reasons for the framework’s popularity, both admiring, e.g. it broadens our understanding of community well-being beyond the economic, and critical, e.g. it ignores the power of (real) capital. The paper concludes by suggesting that 'social capital' continues to prevail, despite its dubious epistemological status, because it serves a useful ideological function for (real) capital.

Keywords

• Social capital, social policy, capitalism, welfare state, academic standards

References

1. ABS (2000) Measuring Social Capital: Current Collections and Future Directions: Discussion Paper – http://www.abs.gov.au/
2. ABS (2001) Measuring Wellbeing: Frameworks for Australian Social Statistics 2001 Cat. No. 4160.0 – http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/
3. ABS (2002) Social Capital and Social Wellbeing: Discussion Paper – http://www.abs.gov.au/
4. ABS (2004) Measuring Social Capital, An Australian Framework and Indicators: Information Paper Cat. No.1378.0
5. ABS (2006) Aspects of Social Capital Australia 2006 Cat. No. 4911.0 –http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/subscriber.nsf/0/DAD0CFD697AE9B25CA2571AD0082E1C6/$File/49110_2006%20(Reissue).pdf
6. Australian Department of Family and Community Services (2000) Participation Support for a More Equitable Society: Final Report of the Reference Group on Welfare Reform Canberra: Australian Department of Family and Community Services
7. Baum, F., C. Palmer, C. Modra, C. Murray and R. Bush (2000) ‘Families, social capital and health’, in Winter, ed., 250-75
8. Bittman, M. and J. Wilkinson (2002) ‘Volunteering: the human face of democracy’ SPRC Discussion Paper No. 114. The Social Policy Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Sydney

9. Black, A. and P. Hughes (2001) The Identification and Analysis of Indicators of Community Strength and Outcomes: Occasional Paper No.3 FaCS – http://www.facs.gov.au/internet/facsinternet.nsf/research/ops-ops3.htm
10. Bryson, L. and Mowbray, M. (1981) ‘“Community”: the spray-on solution’ The Australian Journal of Social Issues 16(4), 255-66
11. Bullen, P. and J. Onyx (1998) ‘Measuring social capital in five communities in NSW: overview of a study’ Management Alternatives – http://www.mapl.com.au/
12. Coleman, James S. (1988) ‘Social capital in the creation of human capital’ American Journal of Sociology 94, Supplement, S95-S120
13. Cox, E. (1995) A Truly Civil Society: The 1995 Boyer Lectures Sydney: The Australian Broadcasting Corporation – http://www.ldb.org/evacox.htm
14. Cox, E. and P. Caldwell (2000) ‘Making policy social’, in I. Winter, ed., 43-73
15. Edwards, B. and M. W. Foley (1997) ‘Social capital and the political economy of our discontent’ American Behavioral Scientist 40(5), 669-78
16. FaCSIA (nd) ‘Stronger Families and Communities Strategy Overview Booklet’ – http://www.facsia.gov.au/internet/facsinternet.nsf/aboutfacs/programs/sfsc- publications.htm [accessed 14.4.07]
17. Fine, B. (2001) Social Capital versus Social Theory: Political Economy and Social Science at the Turn of the Millennium London and New York: Routledge
18. Hopkins. L. (2002) ‘What is social capital?’ Working Paper No.2, Institute for Social Research, Swinburne University, Melbourne – www.sisr.net/publications/workingpapers
19. Hughes, J. and W. Stone (2002) Families, Social Capital and Citizenship Project: Fieldwork Report Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies – http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/research/progC-2005.html#pubscapital
20. Johnson, C. (2003) A Model of Social Capital Formation Social Research and Demonstration Corporation Working Paper Series 03-01; Ottawa, Vancouver and Sydney, Nova Scotia – http://www.srdc.org/en_default.asp
21. Johnson, D., B. Headey and B. Jensen (2003) Communities, Social Capital and Public Policy: Literature Review Melbourne Institute Working Paper No. 26/03 – http://www.melbourneinstitute.com
22. Labonte, R. (1999) ‘Social capital and community development: practitioner emptor’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 23(4), 430-3
23. Leeder, S. (1998) ‘Social capital and its relevance to health and family policy’ – http://www.ahpi.health.usyd.edu.au/staff/leeder/speech.php
24. Leeder, S. and A. Dominello (1999) ‘Social capital and its relevance to health and family policy’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 23(4), 424-9
25. Lowndes, V. (2004) ‘Getting on or getting by? Women, social capital and political participation’ British Journal of Politics and International Relations 6, 45-64
26. Lyons, M. (2000) ‘Non-profit organisations, social capital and social policy in Australia’, in I. Winter, ed., 165-91
27. Mayer, Margit (2003) ‘The onward sweep of social capital: causes and consequences for understanding cities, communities and urban movements’ International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 27(1), March, 110-32
28. Mowbray, M. (2004a) ‘Community development the Third Way: Mark Latham’s localist policies’ Urban Policy and Research 22(1), March 107-15
29. Muntaner, C., J. Lynch and G. D. Smith (2000) ‘Social capital and the third way in public health’ Critical Public Health 10(2), 107-24
30. Navarro, V. (2002) ‘Politics, power, and quality of life: a critique of social capital’ International Journal of Health Services 32(3), 423-32
31. OECD (2001) The Well-Being of Nations: The Role of Human and Social Capital Centre for Educational Research and Innovation, OECD – http://www.oecd.org/
32. Onyx, J. and P. Bullen (1997) Measuring Social Capital in Five Communities in NSW: An Analysis Working Paper Series No.41, Centre for Australian Community Organisations and Management (CACOM), University of Technology Sydney
33. Onyx, J. and P. Bullen (2000a) ‘Measuring social capital in five communities’ Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 3(1), March, 23-42
34. Onyx, J. and P. Bullen (2000b) ‘Sources of social capital’, in I. Winter, ed., 105-35
35. Onyx, J., M. Edwards and A. Dale (2005) Maleny: Social Capital and the Development Paradox Working paper Series No. 70, Centre for Australian Community Organisations and Management (CACOM), University of Technology Sydney – http://www.business.uts.edu.au/cacom/publications/index.html
36. Pope, J. (2006a) Indicators of Community Strength at the Neighbourhood Level: Shire of Melton Strategic Policy and Research Division, Department for Victorian Communities – http://www.dvc.vic.gov.au/
37. Pope, J. (2006b) Indicators of Community Strength – A Framework and Evidence Strategic Policy and Research Division, Department for Victorian Communities – http://www.dvc.vic.gov.au/
38. Pope, J. and D. Warr (2005) Strengthening Local Communities: An Overview of Research Examining the Benefits of Neighbourhood Houses Strategic Policy and Research Division, Department for Victorian Communities – http://www.dvc.vic.gov.au/
39. Portes, A. (1998) ‘Social capital: its origins and applications in modern sociology’ Annual Review of Sociology 24(1), 1-24
40. Productivity Commission (2003) Social Capital: Reviewing the Concept and its Policy Implications Research Paper, Ausinfo, Canberra – http://www.pc.gov.au
41. Roberts, W. (2005) ‘Taking stock of social capital: where is social policy heading?’ a paper presented at the Australian Social Policy Conference, ‘Looking back, looking forward: a quarter century of social change’, 20-22 July – http://www.sprc1.sprc.unsw.edu.au/aspc2005/abstract.asp?PaperID=66
42. Saunders, P. and I. Winter (1999) ‘Social capital and social policy’ Family Matters No.52, Autumn, 49-50
43. Skocpol, T. (1996) ‘Unravelling from above’ The American Prospect 1 March – http://www.prospect.org/web/printfriendly-view.ww?id=4959
44. Stewart-Weeks, M. (2000) ‘Trick or treat? Social capital, leadership and the new public policy’, in I. Winter, ed., 276-309
45. Stone, W. (2001) Measuring Social Capital: Towards a Theoretically Informed Measurement Framework for Researching Social Capital in Family and Community Life Research Paper No.24. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies – http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/pubs/stone.html
46. Stone, W., M. Gray and J. Hughes (2003) Social Capital at Work: How Family, Friends and Civic Ties Relate to Labour Market Outcomes Research Paper No.31. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies – http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/pubs/respaper/stone3.html
47. Stone, W. and J. Hughes (2000) ‘What role for social capital in family policy - and how does it measure up?’ Family Matters No.56, 20-7
48. Stone, W. and J. Hughes (2002) Social Capital: Empirical Meaning and Measurement Validity Research Paper No.27. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies – http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/pubs/stone2.html
49. Wall, E., G. Ferrazzi and F. Schryer (1998) ‘Getting the goods on social capital’ Rural Sociology 63(2), June, 300-22
50. Western, J., R. Stimson, S. Baum and Y. van Gellecum (2005) ‘Community strength and social capital’ Regional Studies 39(8), 1095-109
51. Winter, I. (2000a) Towards a Theorised Understanding of Family and Social Capital Working Paper 21, April. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies – www.aifs.org.au/
52. Winter, I. (2000b) ‘Major themes and debates in the social capital literature: The Australian connection’, in I. Winter, ed., 17-42
53. Winter, I. (2000c) ‘Major themes and debates in the social capital literature: The Australian connection’, in I. Winter, ed., 17-42
54. Winter, I., ed. (2000) Social Capital and Public Policy in Australia Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies
55. Woolcock, M. (2000a) ‘Why should we care about social capital?’ Canberra Bulletin of Public Administration 98, December, 17-19
56. Woolcock, M. (2000b) ‘Preface’, in Winter, ed., xviii-xx