CONCEPTIONS OF THE EU AND ATTITUDES TO TURKEY'S ACCESSION IN FRENCH AND BRITISH DISCOURSE

Year 2010, Volume: 2 Issue: 2, 121 - 128, 01.12.2010

Catherine Macmillan

Abstract

In recent years, France has opposed full EU membership for Turkey while Britain has been one of
the staunchest supporters of Turkey's EU accession bid. This paper argues that this can be
explained by fundamentally different conceptions of the EU in the two countries, based in turn on
differences in national conceptions of state and nation.
The paper thus analyses recent French and British discourse on the EU and, particularly, on
Turkey's accession bid, according to Sjursen's (2007) framework of three idealised visions of the
EU. These are firstly, the EU as a problem-solving entity, secundly as a values-based community
based on a common cultural identity and finally as a post-national union underscored by
'universal' rights such as democracy and human rights

Keywords

European Union, membership, cultural identity, Turkey

References

• Aksoy, Sevilay (2009), ‘The Prospect of Turkey’s EU Membership as Represented in the British
• Newspapers The Times and The Guardian 2002-2005’, Journal of European Studies,Vol. 39, No. 4, pp. 506
• Bale, Timothy (2006), ‘Between a Soft and a Hard Place? The Conservative Party, Valence Politics and the Need for a New Eurorealism’, Parliamentary Affairs, vol 59, no. 3, pp. 385-400
• Blair, Tony (2000), Annual Speech to City Audience at Mansion House, 31 November 2000
• Blair, Tony (2005), Speech to the European Parliament, 23 June 2005 http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/4122288.stm [Accessed 3.2.2010]
• Blair, Tony, (200 6), Our Nation’s Future: Multculturalism and Integratio, Speech delivered to the Runnymede Trust, Downing Street, December 8 2006. http://www.number10.gov.uk/output/Page asp [Accessed 9.10.2009] Cameron,David(2009), http://www.conservatives.com/News/Speeches/2009/11/David_Cameron_A_Europe [Accessed 22. 2010]
• A Europe Policy that People can Believe In, European Council (1993), Presidency Conclusions of the Copenhagen European Council of 21-22 June, SN180/1/193, REV
• Fox,Liam (2006) ,Turkey Could be a Beacon to the Islamic World,, http://www.conservatives.com Accessed 17.12.2009]
• Fox, Liam (2009), Turkey and the EU, http://conservativehome.blogs.com/centreright/2008/02/turkey- and-the.html [Accessed 5.2.2009]
• Hague, William (2010), The Biggest Risk for Britain is Five More Years of Brown. http://www.conservatives.com [Accessed 11.3.2010]
• Larsen, Henrik (1997), Foreign Policy and Discourse Analysis: France, Britain and Europe. London: Routledge
• Larsen, Henrik (1999), ‘British and Danish European Policies in the 1990s: A Discourse Analysis
• Approach’ in European Journal of International Relations, 1999: 5, pp.451-483
• MacShane, Dennis (2002), ‘Europe Must Embrace Islam Too’, The Guardian, 24 November 2002
• Millibrand, David (2006), Speech to Turkish government, Cited in BBC, UK Vows to Back Turkey’s EU
• Bid.,. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/6980019.stm [Accessed 5.2.2010]
• Mitterand, Francois (1991), Interview with Radio France Internationale (RFI), 12 June 1991, cited in
• Sjursen, Helene and Borge Romsloe (2006), ‘Protecting the Idea of Europe: France and Enlargement’, p.145
• Mitterand, Francois (1994), Interview in La Depeche du Midi 20 October 1994, cited in Sjursen, Helene and Borge Romsloe (2006), ‘Protecting the Idea of Europe: France and Enlargement’, p.156
• Ruiz-Jimenez, Antonia. and Jose Torreblanca (2007), ‘European Public Opinion and Turkey’s
• Accession: Making Sense of Arguments For and Against’, European Policy Institutes Network Working Papers (16), http://www.epin.org [Accessed 9.10.2009]
• Sarkozy, Nicolas (2007a) Turkey is not European. Sabah, May 23 2007, http://arsiv.sabah.com.tr/2007/05/29haber,E4674A2DDA584E099E7D41326CB52B9C8.html Accessed 9.10.2009]
• Sarkozy, Nicolas (2007b) Testimony. New York: Harper
• Schmidt, Vivien (2009), ‘Envisioning a Less Fragile, More Liberal Europe’, European Political Science vol. 8 no.2, 212-224
• Sjursen, Helene (2006), ‘The European Union between Values and Rights’, (in Helene Sjursen (ed.), Questioning EU Enlargement: Europe in Search of Identity) London: Routledge, pp. 203-215
• Sjursen, Helene (2008), ‘Enlargement in Perspective: The EU’s Quest for Identity’, Arena Working Papers no.5.
• Sjursen, Helene and Borge Romsloe (2006), ‘Protecting the Idea of Europe: France and Enlargement’,
• (in Helene Sjursen (ed.), Questioning EU Enlargement: Europe in Search of Identity) London: Routledge, pp. 142-164
• Szymanski , Adam (2007), ‘Germany and the Question of Turkey’s Membership in the European
• Union’, PISM Research Papers no. 4, 2007, p. 23-40
• Thatcher, Margaret (1993), The Downing Street Years, New York: Harper and Collins
• Watts, Duncan and Colin Pilkington (2005), Britain in the European Union Today, Manchester:
• Manchester University Press Wæver, Ole (2002), ‘Identity, Communities and Foreign Policy: Discourse Analysis as Foreign Policy
• Theory’, (in: Lene. Hansen and Ole Wæver (eds.), European Integration and National Identity), London: Routledge, pp. 20-49
• Yılmaz, Hakan ( 2007), ‘Turkish Identity on the Road to the EU: Basic Elements of French and German Oppositional Discourses’, Journal of Southern Europe and the Balkans. 9 (3) pp. 293-305.