Bikameralizm Prototipi Olarak Lordlar Kamarası

Year 2025, Volume: 10 Issue: 2, 453 - 500, 30.09.2025

Hüseyin Özcan

https://doi.org/10.58733/imhfd.1729312

Abstract

Çift meclisli sistemler, siyasal ve toplumsal temsili artırmaları, yasama süreçlerinde denge ve denetimi güçlendirmeleri ve yürütme karşısında dengeleyici bir rol üstlenmeleri nedeniyle önemli anayasal modeller arasında yer almaktadır. Bu sistemlerin en köklü ve prototip örneklerinden biri olan Lordlar Kamarası, tarihsel gelişimi, kurumsal yapısı ve anayasal işlevleriyle dikkat çekmektedir. Lordlar Kamarası, yalnızca bir yasama organı olmanın ötesinde, aynı zamanda çift meclisli sistemlerin evrimini ve günümüz demokrasilerindeki sürdürülebilirliğini ortaya koyan önemli bir örnektir. Bu makale, Lordlar Kamarası’nın tarihsel dönüşümünü ve geçirdiği reformları ayrıntılı şekilde ele alarak, bu kurumun güncel işlevlerini analiz etmektedir. Bu bağlamda makale, genel anlamda çift meclisli sistemleri; Lordlar Kamarası’nın tarihsel gelişimi ve kurumsallaşması, Lordlar Kamarası’nın üye yapısı (özellikle 1999 Lordlar Kamarası Yasası öncesi ve sonrası üye yapısı) ve sosyal ve mesleki yapısındaki değişimler, anayasal düzende üstlendiği görevler ve fonksiyonlar ile bunların zaman içindeki dönüşümü, ayrıca Lordlar Kamarası’nın gelecekteki konumu gibi başlıkları ele alacaktır. Bu çerçevede, Lordlar Kamarası’nın siyasi partilerin aşırı etkisinden görece bağımsız yapısı ve popülist eğilimlere karşı dengeleyici rolü ön plana çıkarılmaktadır. Ayrıca, tek meclisli sistemlerin karşılaştığı temsil sorunu, lider etkisinin yoğunluğu ve denetim eksikliklerine karşı Lordlar Kamarası’nın işlevsel bir alternatif sunduğu vurgulanmaktadır. Sonuç olarak, Lordlar Kamarası’nın kurumsal yapısı ve anayasal rolü, çift meclisli sistemlerin günümüzde de geçerli ve etkili bir model olabileceğini göstermektedir.

Keywords

Çift meclisli sistemler , Lordlar Kamarası , Birleşik Krallık , Lordlar Kamarasının Üye Yapısı , Lordlar Kamarasının Fonksiyonları

The House of Lords as a Prototype of Bicameralism

Abstract

Bicameral systems are considered among the important constitutional models due to their ability to enhance political and social representation, strengthen checks and balances in legislative processes, and play a counterbalancing role against the executive. One of the most established and prototypical examples of such systems is the House of Lords, which stands out with its historical development, institutional structure, and constitutional functions. The House of Lords is not only a legislative body but also a significant example demonstrating the evolution of bicameral systems and their sustainability in modern democracies. This article analyzes the current functions of the House of Lords by examining its historical transformation and the reforms it has undergone in detail. In this context, the article will address topics such as: bicameral systems in general; the historical development and institutionalization of the House of Lords; its membership structure (particularly before and after the House of Lords Act 1999) and the changes in its social and professional composition; the roles and functions it undertakes within the constitutional order and their transformation over time; and the potential future position of the House of Lords. Within this framework, the House of Lords’ relatively independent structure from the excessive influence of political parties and its balancing role against populist tendencies are emphasized. Additionally, it is underlined that the House of Lords offers a functional alternative to the problems of representation, the dominance of leadership, and the lack of oversight often encountered in unicameral systems. In conclusion, the institutional structure and constitutional role of the House of Lords demonstrate that bicameral systems can still be a valid and effective model today.

Keywords

Bicameral systems , House of Lords , United Kingdom , Composition of the House of Lords , Functions of the House of Lords

References

• ‘A Smaller House of Lords: The Report of the Lord Speaker’s Committee on the Size of the House - Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee - House of Commons’ <https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmpubadm/662/66204.htm> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘Addressing Members of the Lords’ <https://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/whos-in-the-house-of-lords/how-to-address-a-lord/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Arsel İ, Anayasa Hukuku (Demokrasi) (Doğuş Matbaacılık 1964)
• Baldwin N, ‘The Membership and Work of the House of Lords’ in Brice Dickson and Paul Carmichael (eds), The House of Lords: its parliamentary and judicial roles (Hart Publishing 1999)
• Brader C, ‘Lords Spiritual in the House of Lords Explained’ <https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/lords-spiritual-in-the-house-of-lords-explained/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Clarke M and others, Politics UK (Bill Jones, Philip Norton and Isabelle Hertner eds, Tenth edition, Routledge 2022)
• Coakley J, ‘The Strange Revival of Bicameralism’ (2014) 20 The Journal of Legislative Studies 542
• ‘Criteria Guiding the Assessment of Nominations for Non-Party Political Life Peers – House of Lords Appointments Commission’ <https://lordsappointments.independent.gov.uk/how-to-apply-2/criteria-guiding-the-assessment-of-nominations-for-non-party-political-life-peers-2> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Davies JM, ‘The House of Lords: Britain’s Second Chamber in Transition’ in Rajya Sabha (ed), Second Chambers: Bicamaralism Today
• Gebauer B, ‘Das Britische Oberhaus: Aufdem Weg Zu Mehr Demokratie?’ in Gisela Riescher, Sabine Ruß and Christoph M Haas (eds), Zweite Kammern (Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag GmbH 2010) <https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1524/9783486710106.23/html> Erişim 17 Nisan 2025
• Gneist R von, Der Rechtsstaat (Springer Berlin / Heidelberg 1872)
• Görgen N, ‘The Survival Of British Monarchy: Transition From Absolute Monarchy To Constitutional Monarchy’ (2024) 28 Ankara Hacı Bayram Veli Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 399
• ——, ‘THE NATURE AND PROBLEMS OF THE ROYAL PREROGATIVE IN THE ENGLISH LEGAL SYSTEM’ [2024] Selçuk Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi <https://dergipark.org.tr/en/doi/10.15337/suhfd.1410591> Erişim 23 Nisan 2025
• ——, ‘The Evolution of the British Executive: Cabinet, Prime Minister and Core Executive Model’ (2024) 30 Marmara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Hukuk Araştırmaları Dergisi 155
• Haas CM, ‘Sein Oder Nicht Sein: Bikameralismus Und Die Funktion Zweiter Kammern’ in Gisela Riescher, Sabine Ruß and Christoph M Haas (eds), Zweite Kammern (Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag GmbH 2010) <https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1524/9783486710106.1/html> Erişim 17 Nisan 2025
• ——, ‘Zweite Kammer Erster Klasse: Der US-Senat’ in Gisela Riescher, Sabine Ruß and Christoph M Haas (eds), Zweite Kammern (Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag GmbH 2010) <https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1524/9783486710106.23/html> Erişim 17 Nisan 2025
• Hatschek J, Handbuch der mittelalterlichen und neueren Geschichte: Englische Verfassungsgeschichte bis zum Regierungsantritt der Königin Victoria (Georg von Below ed, Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag 1913)
• ‘Hereditary Peers Removed’ <https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/evolutionofparliament/houseoflords/house-of-lords-reform/overview/hereditarypeersremoved/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘House of Lords - Annual Report and Accounts 1999-2000’ <https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld199900/ldbrief/10402.htm> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill - Parliamentary Bills - UK Parliament’ <https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3755> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘House of Lords: MPs Back Ending All Hereditary Peers’ <https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0rg98rl9p2o> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Hübner E and Münch U, Das politische System Großbritanniens: eine Einführung (Originalausgabe, 2, aktualisierte Auflage, Verlag C H Beck 1999)
• ‘Inter Parliamentary Union, National Parliaments’ <https://www.ipu.org/national-parliaments> Erişim 17 Nisan 2025
• İlhan A, ‘ÇİFT MECLİS SİSTEMİNİN MEMLEKETİMİZDE TATBİKİ HUSUSUNDA BAZI DÜŞÜNCELER’ (1955) 12 Ankara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 1
• Jackson A, ‘Ireland, the Union, and the Empire, 1800–1960’ in Kevin Kenny (ed), Ireland and the British Empire (Oxford University Press 2005) <https://academic.oup.com/book/8371/chapter/154057494> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Jahn D, Einführung in die vergleichende Politikwissenschaft (2. Aufl. 2013, VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften 2013)
• Kama S, ‘Parlamenter Hükümet Sistemi Olarak “Westminster Modeli” Britanya Örneği Üzerine Bir Deneme’ (2016) 22 Marmara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Hukuk Araştırmaları Dergisi 161
• Kluxen K, Geschichte Englands: von den Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart (Kröner 1968)
• Lijphart A, Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries (2nd edn, Yale University Press 2012)
• Loewenstein K, Staatsrecht und Staatspraxis von Grossbritannien: Parlament · Regierung · Parteien (Springer Berlin Heidelberg 1967)
• Longford FP, A History of the House of Lords (Sutton Pub Ltd 1999)
• ‘Lords Membership - by Peerage - MPs and Lords - UK Parliament’ <https://members.parliament.uk/parties/lords/by-peerage> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘Lords Select Committees’ <https://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/work-of-the-house-of-lords/lords-select-committees/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘Majority of Public Support House of Lords Appointments Reform | The Constitution Unit - UCL – University College London’ <https://www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/news/2022/oct/majority-public-support-house-lords-appointments-reform> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘Making Laws: House of Lords Stages’ <https://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/work-of-the-house-of-lords/making-laws/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Marschall S, Parlamentarismus: eine Einführung (2nd edn, Nomos 2016)
• Merritt EC, ‘Who Is in the House of Lords? Members with Backgrounds and Professional Experience in Public Life’ <https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/house-of-lords-backgrounds-in-public-life/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Norton P, Reform of the House of Lords (Manchester University Press 2017)
• Renwick A and others, ‘Public Preferences for Integrity and Accountability in Politics Results of a Second Survey of the UK Population Third Report of the Democracy in the UK after Brexit Project’ (The Constitution Unit 2023) <https://www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/sites/constitution_unit/files/ucl_cu_report3_digital_final.pdf>
• ‘Role and Work of the House of Lords’ <https://www.parliament.uk/about/faqs/house-of-lords-faqs/role/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Russell M, The Contemporary House of Lords: Westminster Bicameralism Revived (Oxford University Press, Incorporated 2013)
• Schwarz-Liebermann von W, Struktur Und Funktion Der Sogenannten Zweiten Kammer, Mohr Siebeck (Mohr Siebeck 1958)
• ‘Select Committees’ (Institute for Government, 23 May 2024) <https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/select-committees> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘Select Committees’ <https://www.parliament.uk/about/how/committees/select/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Shell D, The House of Lords (Manchester University Press 2007)
• Stephen J, Scottish Presbyterians and the Act of Union 1707 (Edinburgh University Press 2007)
• Strauch S, House of Lords: Geschichte und Stellung des höchsten Gerichts im Vereinigten Königreich (LIT 2003)
• Sturm R SS, ‘Wozu Zweite Kammern? Zur Repräsentation Und Funktionalität Zweiter Kammern in Westlichen
• Demokratien’ [1992] Deutschen Vereinigung für Parlamentsfragen
• ‘The Avalon Project : Magna Carta’ <https://avalon.law.yale.edu/medieval/magframe.asp> Erişim 21 Nisan 2025
• ‘The Commission – House of Lords Appointments Commission’ <https://lordsappointments.independent.gov.uk/the-commission-2> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘The Parliament Acts - UK Parliament’ <https://www.parliament.uk/about/how/laws/parliamentacts/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘The Second Chambers of Parliaments and Their Functions in the 21st Century’ <https://www.parlament.ch/de/reden/Seiten/reden-archiv/reden-2006/rede-buettiker-2006-09-29/Seiten/default.aspx> Erişim 17 Nisan 2025
• Torrance D, ‘How Are Life Peers Created?’ <https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/how-are-life-peers-created/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Tsebelis G and Money J, Bicameralism (Cambridge University Press 1997)
• Uran Murphy P, Yasama İşlevinin Yerine Getirilmesinde Çift Meclis Sistemi ve Türk Siyasal Tarihindeki Yeri (Yetkin Yayınları 2008)
• ‘What Does the House of Lords Do? | The Constitution Unit - UCL – University College London’ <https://www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/explainers/what-does-house-lords-do> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• ‘What Does the House of Lords Do? - UK Parliament’ <https://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/work-of-the-house-of-lords/what-the-lords-does/> Erişim 22 Nisan 2025
• Zink W, ‘Der Belgische Senat — Institution Unter Denkmalschutz?’ in Gisela Riescher, Sabine Ruß and Christoph M Haas (eds), Zweite Kammern (Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag GmbH 2010) <https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1524/9783486710106.211/html> Erişim 17 Nisan 2025