Research Article
BibTex RIS Cite

Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan

Year 2017, Volume: 5 Issue: 1, 47 - 64, 20.10.2017

Makoto Tadakı Shogoro Yano

Abstract

The paper discusses issues of capacity for consent and effectiveness of consent within the context of Japanese and German criminal law and compares both legal systems hereto with each other. The discussion in Japan lacks, because legal requirements to give consent to certain treatments and certain medical care are not yet ascertained. The uncertainty is played out at the expense of physicians, practitioners, and medical doctors. The papers discusses the necessity to fix the requirements of consent to be effective in practice.

Keywords

consent capacity for consent effectiveness of consent Japanese criminal law medical criminal law

References

  • A. Tasaka, Capacity to Consent of Patient to Medical Treatment and Criterion for Judgment in England, Doshisha-hogaku (The Doshisha Law Review), No. 333, 2009, S. 417.
  • A. Tasaka, Capacity to Consent of Patient to Medical Treatment and Criminal Law, Doshisha-hogaku (The Doshisha Law Review), No.329, 2008, S. 221.
  • Das Oberste Gericht, Urt. v. 19. 6. 1981, Hanrei taimuzu, No. 447, S. 78.
  • F. Kitamura/T. Kitamura, Seisinn-ka-iryo ni okeru kanja no jiko-ketteiken to chiryo-doui-handannouryoku, 2000. S. 139ff..
  • F. Tokotani, Seinen-koken ni okeru sinjyo-hairyo-gimu, minshoho-zashi, Bd. 122, Heft 4-5, 2000, S. 547f..
  • K. Asada, Keiho-soron (Strafrecht AT), 2007, S. 197f..
  • K. Naito, Keihokogi-soron (Strafrecht AT Ⅱ), 1986, S. 531.
  • K. Kai, Iryo-koui to “higai-sha” no shoudaku, Gendaikeiji-ho, Bd. 6, Heft 3, 2004, S. 27.
  • K. Ohsugi, Einführung in die sog. „Fremdbestimmung bei der Einwilli-gung” in ärztlicher Heilbehandlung, Hogaku shinpo Bd.113 Heft 3- 4, 2007, S. 388.
  • K. Kai, Hikensha-hogo to keiho, ijikeiho-kenkyu, Vol. 3, 2005, S. 136ff.
  • K. Bai, Medico-legal Approach to Clinical Research, Journal of Medical Law, No. 13, 1998, S. 37ff..
  • K. Shinomiya=Y. Noumi, Minpo-sosoku, 2010, S. 57.
  • LG Sapporo, Urt. v. 29. 9. 1978, Hanrei-jiho, No. 914, S. 85.
  • M. Hirose, Problems of the substituted judgment to medical treatment in Japan, Waseda-daigaku-daigaku-in The Graduate School Law Review, No. 60, 1991, S. 259ff..
  • M. Isii, Consent to Medical Care of the Aged by the Family, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 104.
  • M. Hayasi, Iryo ni okeru isi-noryoku to isi-kettei, in: Makoto Arai/Akira Nisiyama (Hrsg.), Seinenkoken to isi-noryoku, 2002, S. 236.
  • M. Tadaki, Keijihogaku ni okeru gendai-teki kadai, Nihon-hikaku-ho-kenkyujo-sousho77, 2009, S. 112.
  • M. Isikawa, Iryo ni okeru daiko-handan no hori to kazoku―dare ga daiko-handan-sha ka―, in: Kouichi Bai, Minoru Ihikawa (Hrsg.), Kazoku to Iryo―sono hogaku-teki-kosatsu, 1995, S. 48.
  • M. Arai, Igirisu to doitsu ni okeru seinen-koken-ho no aratana tenkai, Jurisuto (Juristische Zeitung) No.972, 1991, S. 15.
  • N. Ienaga, Iryo to kodomo no jiko-kettei, Horitsu-jiho Bd. 75 Heft 9, 2003, S. 37.
  • Oberste Gerichtshof (Zivilsenat), am 29.2.2000, Minshu, Bd. 52, Heft 42, S. 582.
  • Oberster Gerichtshof (Strafsenat), am 7.12.2009, Keishu, Bd. 63, Heft 11, S. 1899.
  • Professor J.R. Wolff (Anatomiker aus Göttingen) in einem Gespräch am 3. März 2012.
  • R. Tatara, Shoni-iryo to infomudo konsento, in: Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.) , Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 270.
  • R. Jinnno, Seishinka-iryo to infomudo konsento, in: Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.), Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 256f..
  • Sammlung vom 7. Dezember 2008, Band 63, Nr.11, S. 1899.
  • H. Ogyu, Decision-Making Competency in Mental Health Care, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 85f..
  • S. Machino, Self-Determination and Surrogate Determination, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 50.
  • S. Machino, Kanja no jiko-kettei-ken to ho, 1986, S. 184ff..
  • S. Machino, „Tokaidaigaku-anrakusi-hanketsu’oboegaki“, Jurisuto Nr. 1072, S. 113.
  • S. Hayakawa, Miseinen-sha no doui, in: Tatsuo Kuroyanagi u.a. (Hrsg.), Know your law on medicine, 2008, S. 374.
  • S. Horiuchi, Keiho-soron (Strafrecht AT Ⅱ), 2004, S. 188ff..
  • S. Saito, Keiho-soron (Strafrecht AT), 6. Aufl. 2008, S. 167.
  • T. Awaji, Iryokeiyaku, in: Taniguchi/Kato u.a.(Hrsg.), Shinminpo-enshuu 4, 1968, S. 184.
  • T. Terasawa, Miseinen-sha heno iryo-koui to shoudaku (III), Minshoho-zashi, Bd.107, Heft 1, 1992, S. 58.
  • T. Terasawa, “hodaku-noryoku”no nai hito heno chiryo-koui no kettei to shodaku, in: Yosio Shiomi u.a. (Hrsg.), minpogaku no kiseki to tenbo, 2002, S. 116.
  • T. Terasawa, Kureisha iryo to infomudo konsento, in:Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.), Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 222ff..
  • T. Terasawa, Miseinen-sha heno iryo-koui to shodaku (I), Minshoho-zassi, Bd. 106, Heft 5, 1992, S. 657.
  • T. Watanabe, Present State of Clinical Trial in Japan, Journal of Medical Law, No. 13, 1998, S. 26ff..
  • T. Mitsuisi, Japanese System and it’s Related Issues, Journal of Medical Law, No. 13, 1998, S. 97ff..
  • T. Mitsuisi, Safeguarding the Rights of Research Subjects, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 61f..
  • Y. Oda, Miseinen-sha heno yuketsu, in: Tatsuo Kuroyanagi u.a. (Hrsg.), Know your law on medicine, 2008, S. 376.
  • Y. Hasimoto/K. Nakatani, Kanja no chiryou-kyohi wo meguru horitsu-mondai―”ehoba no shonin” no shinjya ni yoru yuketsu-kyohi-jiken wo keiki to shite―, Hanrei-taimuzu, No.569, 1986, S. 11f..
  • Y. Tejima, Introduction to Medical Law, 3. Aufl. 2011, S. 36f..
  • Y. Kamiyama, Kanja no doui ni kansuru hoteki mondaiten, in: Makoto Arai/Akira Nisiyama (Hrsg.), Seinenkoken to isi-noryoku, 2002, S. 127ff..
  • Y. Sato, Hitogenomu-kenkyu to infomudo konsento, In: Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.), Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 215f..

Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan

Year 2017, Volume: 5 Issue: 1, 47 - 64, 20.10.2017

Makoto Tadakı Shogoro Yano

Abstract

The paper discusses issues of capacity for consent and effectiveness of consent within the context of Japanese and German criminal law and compares both legal systems hereto with each other. The discussion in Japan lacks, because legal requirements to give consent to certain treatments and certain medical care are not yet ascertained. The uncertainty is played out at the expense of physicians, practitioners, and medical doctors. The papers discusses the necessity to fix the requirements of consent to be effective in practice.

Keywords

consent capacity for consent effectiveness of consent Japanese criminal law medical criminal law

References

  • A. Tasaka, Capacity to Consent of Patient to Medical Treatment and Criterion for Judgment in England, Doshisha-hogaku (The Doshisha Law Review), No. 333, 2009, S. 417.
  • A. Tasaka, Capacity to Consent of Patient to Medical Treatment and Criminal Law, Doshisha-hogaku (The Doshisha Law Review), No.329, 2008, S. 221.
  • Das Oberste Gericht, Urt. v. 19. 6. 1981, Hanrei taimuzu, No. 447, S. 78.
  • F. Kitamura/T. Kitamura, Seisinn-ka-iryo ni okeru kanja no jiko-ketteiken to chiryo-doui-handannouryoku, 2000. S. 139ff..
  • F. Tokotani, Seinen-koken ni okeru sinjyo-hairyo-gimu, minshoho-zashi, Bd. 122, Heft 4-5, 2000, S. 547f..
  • K. Asada, Keiho-soron (Strafrecht AT), 2007, S. 197f..
  • K. Naito, Keihokogi-soron (Strafrecht AT Ⅱ), 1986, S. 531.
  • K. Kai, Iryo-koui to “higai-sha” no shoudaku, Gendaikeiji-ho, Bd. 6, Heft 3, 2004, S. 27.
  • K. Ohsugi, Einführung in die sog. „Fremdbestimmung bei der Einwilli-gung” in ärztlicher Heilbehandlung, Hogaku shinpo Bd.113 Heft 3- 4, 2007, S. 388.
  • K. Kai, Hikensha-hogo to keiho, ijikeiho-kenkyu, Vol. 3, 2005, S. 136ff.
  • K. Bai, Medico-legal Approach to Clinical Research, Journal of Medical Law, No. 13, 1998, S. 37ff..
  • K. Shinomiya=Y. Noumi, Minpo-sosoku, 2010, S. 57.
  • LG Sapporo, Urt. v. 29. 9. 1978, Hanrei-jiho, No. 914, S. 85.
  • M. Hirose, Problems of the substituted judgment to medical treatment in Japan, Waseda-daigaku-daigaku-in The Graduate School Law Review, No. 60, 1991, S. 259ff..
  • M. Isii, Consent to Medical Care of the Aged by the Family, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 104.
  • M. Hayasi, Iryo ni okeru isi-noryoku to isi-kettei, in: Makoto Arai/Akira Nisiyama (Hrsg.), Seinenkoken to isi-noryoku, 2002, S. 236.
  • M. Tadaki, Keijihogaku ni okeru gendai-teki kadai, Nihon-hikaku-ho-kenkyujo-sousho77, 2009, S. 112.
  • M. Isikawa, Iryo ni okeru daiko-handan no hori to kazoku―dare ga daiko-handan-sha ka―, in: Kouichi Bai, Minoru Ihikawa (Hrsg.), Kazoku to Iryo―sono hogaku-teki-kosatsu, 1995, S. 48.
  • M. Arai, Igirisu to doitsu ni okeru seinen-koken-ho no aratana tenkai, Jurisuto (Juristische Zeitung) No.972, 1991, S. 15.
  • N. Ienaga, Iryo to kodomo no jiko-kettei, Horitsu-jiho Bd. 75 Heft 9, 2003, S. 37.
  • Oberste Gerichtshof (Zivilsenat), am 29.2.2000, Minshu, Bd. 52, Heft 42, S. 582.
  • Oberster Gerichtshof (Strafsenat), am 7.12.2009, Keishu, Bd. 63, Heft 11, S. 1899.
  • Professor J.R. Wolff (Anatomiker aus Göttingen) in einem Gespräch am 3. März 2012.
  • R. Tatara, Shoni-iryo to infomudo konsento, in: Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.) , Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 270.
  • R. Jinnno, Seishinka-iryo to infomudo konsento, in: Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.), Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 256f..
  • Sammlung vom 7. Dezember 2008, Band 63, Nr.11, S. 1899.
  • H. Ogyu, Decision-Making Competency in Mental Health Care, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 85f..
  • S. Machino, Self-Determination and Surrogate Determination, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 50.
  • S. Machino, Kanja no jiko-kettei-ken to ho, 1986, S. 184ff..
  • S. Machino, „Tokaidaigaku-anrakusi-hanketsu’oboegaki“, Jurisuto Nr. 1072, S. 113.
  • S. Hayakawa, Miseinen-sha no doui, in: Tatsuo Kuroyanagi u.a. (Hrsg.), Know your law on medicine, 2008, S. 374.
  • S. Horiuchi, Keiho-soron (Strafrecht AT Ⅱ), 2004, S. 188ff..
  • S. Saito, Keiho-soron (Strafrecht AT), 6. Aufl. 2008, S. 167.
  • T. Awaji, Iryokeiyaku, in: Taniguchi/Kato u.a.(Hrsg.), Shinminpo-enshuu 4, 1968, S. 184.
  • T. Terasawa, Miseinen-sha heno iryo-koui to shoudaku (III), Minshoho-zashi, Bd.107, Heft 1, 1992, S. 58.
  • T. Terasawa, “hodaku-noryoku”no nai hito heno chiryo-koui no kettei to shodaku, in: Yosio Shiomi u.a. (Hrsg.), minpogaku no kiseki to tenbo, 2002, S. 116.
  • T. Terasawa, Kureisha iryo to infomudo konsento, in:Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.), Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 222ff..
  • T. Terasawa, Miseinen-sha heno iryo-koui to shodaku (I), Minshoho-zassi, Bd. 106, Heft 5, 1992, S. 657.
  • T. Watanabe, Present State of Clinical Trial in Japan, Journal of Medical Law, No. 13, 1998, S. 26ff..
  • T. Mitsuisi, Japanese System and it’s Related Issues, Journal of Medical Law, No. 13, 1998, S. 97ff..
  • T. Mitsuisi, Safeguarding the Rights of Research Subjects, Journal of Medical Law, No. 15, 2000, S. 61f..
  • Y. Oda, Miseinen-sha heno yuketsu, in: Tatsuo Kuroyanagi u.a. (Hrsg.), Know your law on medicine, 2008, S. 376.
  • Y. Hasimoto/K. Nakatani, Kanja no chiryou-kyohi wo meguru horitsu-mondai―”ehoba no shonin” no shinjya ni yoru yuketsu-kyohi-jiken wo keiki to shite―, Hanrei-taimuzu, No.569, 1986, S. 11f..
  • Y. Tejima, Introduction to Medical Law, 3. Aufl. 2011, S. 36f..
  • Y. Kamiyama, Kanja no doui ni kansuru hoteki mondaiten, in: Makoto Arai/Akira Nisiyama (Hrsg.), Seinenkoken to isi-noryoku, 2002, S. 127ff..
  • Y. Sato, Hitogenomu-kenkyu to infomudo konsento, In: Katsunori Kai (Hrsg.), Informed Consent and Medical Law, A Series of Medical Law VOL. 2, 2010, S. 215f..
There are 46 citations in total.

Details

Subjects Law in Context
Journal Section Makaleler
Authors

Makoto Tadakı This is me

Shogoro Yano This is me

Publication Date October 20, 2017
Submission Date October 20, 2017
Published in Issue Year 2017 Volume: 5 Issue: 1

Cite

APA Tadakı, M., & Yano, S. (2017). Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan. Ceza Hukuku Ve Kriminoloji Dergisi, 5(1), 47-64.
AMA Tadakı M, Yano S. Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan. Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Dergisi. October 2017;5(1):47-64.
Chicago Tadakı, Makoto, and Shogoro Yano. “Einwilligungsfähigkeit Und Wirksamkeit Der Einwilligung – Die Lage in Japan”. Ceza Hukuku Ve Kriminoloji Dergisi 5, no. 1 (October 2017): 47-64.
EndNote Tadakı M, Yano S (October 1, 2017) Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan. Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Dergisi 5 1 47–64.
IEEE M. Tadakı and S. Yano, “Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan”, Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Dergisi, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 47–64, 2017.
ISNAD Tadakı, Makoto - Yano, Shogoro. “Einwilligungsfähigkeit Und Wirksamkeit Der Einwilligung – Die Lage in Japan”. Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Dergisi 5/1 (October 2017), 47-64.
JAMA Tadakı M, Yano S. Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan. Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Dergisi. 2017;5:47–64.
MLA Tadakı, Makoto and Shogoro Yano. “Einwilligungsfähigkeit Und Wirksamkeit Der Einwilligung – Die Lage in Japan”. Ceza Hukuku Ve Kriminoloji Dergisi, vol. 5, no. 1, 2017, pp. 47-64.
Vancouver Tadakı M, Yano S. Einwilligungsfähigkeit und Wirksamkeit der Einwilligung – die Lage in Japan. Ceza Hukuku ve Kriminoloji Dergisi. 2017;5(1):47-64.