No Special Pleading: Abolitionism, Orientalism, and Identity Politics
Abstract
American abolitionists during the nineteenth century invoked slavery in the Ottoman Empire as a means by which to criticize American slavery. In the resulting comparison of slaveholding powers, America did not come off well. Abolitionists mercilessly, and, this essay suggests, ironically, described slavery in the Orient as less oppressive than slavery in the West. This aspect of American abolitionist discourse is significant because, according to Edward Said, any suitably large body of Western discourse that describes the East should be orientalist; that is, it should exist for the purpose of essentializing the East as a means of preparation for military, material, and moral domination by the West. Given that Said’s work Orientalism portrays itself as a valid descriptor of all Eastern-facing discourse from the late seventh century onwards, it is instructive to see how the great theoretical progenitor of post-colonial studies fails in being able to account for the conceptual relationship between abolitionists and Ottoman Islam.
Keywords
References
- Abdy, Edward Strutt. American Whites and Blacks: In Reply to a German Orthodermist. London: Charles Gilpin, 1842.
- Adger, John Bailey. Christian Missions and African Colonization. Columbia, South Carolina: Steam Power Press of E. H. Britton, 1857.
- Al-Ghazali. Deliverance from Error. Trans. R. J. McCarthy. Louisville: Fons Vitae, 1980.
- Ames, Julius Rubens. Liberty. New York: American Anti-Slavery Society, 1837.
- Annual Report of the American Anti-Slavery Society, 1854. New York: William S. Dorr, 1854.
- Armistead, Wilson. Five Hundred Thousand Strokes for Freedom: A Series of Anti-Slavery Tracts. London: W. and F. Cash, William Tweedie, 1853.
- Brown, James. A Lecture on Education: Delivered Before the Mechanics’ and Manufacturers’ Association of Oswego, July 12, 1841. Oswego: John Carpenter, 1841.
- Clark, Rufus Wheelright. Review of the Reverend Moses Stuart’s Pamphlet on Slavery. Boston: C.C.P. Moody, 1850.
- Coleman, Elihu. Testimony Against That Anti-Christian Practice of Making Slaves of Men. New Bedford: Abraham Shearman, 1825.
- Crandall, Prudence. Report of the Arguments of Counsel: In the Case of Prudence Crandall, Plaintiff in Error, vs. State of Connecticut, Before the Supreme Court of Errors, at Their Session at Brooklyn, July Term, 1834. Boston: Garrison and Knapp, 1834.