BANK COMPETITION, CONCENTRATION AND RISK-TAKING IN THE TURKISH BANKING INDUSTRY

Abstract

This paper addresses the impacts of bank competition on the risk-taking behaviors of banks in Turkey over the period 2002-2012. After estimating H-statistic as a measure of competition and regressing this measure and other explanatory variables on the bank risk indicators, this paper concludes that competition has a negative impact on the financial fragility of Turkish banks, indicating that banks in a more competitive market tend to take lower level of risk. This finding supports the arguments of the “competition-stability” hypothesis in the Turkish banking system. Furthermore, bank concentration is found to be inversely related to bank risk. On the one hand, bank size, lending, liquidity, off-balance sheet activities are essential factors in explaining this relationship. On the other hand, a few instrumental variables are employed to reflect the country’s overall macroeconomic condition.  In general, despite the negative impact of interest rate on bank risk-taking behavior in most of the models, in which different risk measures are used as dependent variables, the result highlights the empirical evidence of no significant association between economic growth and bank risk-taking. Overall, this paper aims to provide policy implications for bank management and consolidation policies and also the role of the Central Bank.

Keywords

• Bank competition,financial stability,behaviors of banks in Turkey over the period 2002-2012. After estimating Hbanking system fragility,statistic as a measure of competition and regressing this measure and other

References

1. • Aktan, B., and O. Masood, 2010, “The State of Competition of the Turkish Banking
2. Industry: An Application of the Panzar-Rosse Model,” Journal of Business and Management 11, 131-145. • Allen, F., and D. Gale, 2000, “Financial Contagion,” The Journal of Political Economy 108(1), 1-33.
3. • Allen, F., and D. Gale, 2004, “Competition and Financial Stability,” Journal of
4. Money, Credit and Banking 26(3), 453-480. • Altunbas, Y., S. Carbo, E. P. M. Gardener, and P. Molyneux, 2007, “Examining the Relationships Between Capital, Risk and Efficiency in European Banking,”
5. European Financial Management 13, 49–70. • Arellano, M., and S. Bond, 1991, “Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data:
6. Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations,” Review of Economic Studies 58, 277–297. • Arellano, M., and O. Bover, 1995, “Another Look at the Instrumental Variable
7. Estimation of Error-Components Models,” Journal of Econometrics 68, 29–51. • Ariss, R.T., 2010, “On the Implications of Market Power in Banking: Evidence from
8. Developing Countries,” Journal of Banking and Finance 34(4), 765–775. • Baltagi, B., 2001, Econometric Analysis of Panel Data UK: John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 2nd Ed.

9. • Beck, T., and R. Levin, 2004, “Stock Markets, Banks, and Growth: Panel Evidence,”
10. Journal of Banking and Finance 28(3), 423 – 442. • Beck, T., A. Demirguc-Kunt, and R. Levine, 2006, “Bank Concentration,
11. Competition, and Crises: First Results,” Journal of Banking and Finance 30(5), 1581-1603.
12. • Berger, A. N., L. Klapper,,and R. Turk-Ariss, 2009, “Bank Competition and Financial
13. Stability,” Journal of Financial Services 35( 2), 99-118. • Besanko, D., and A.V. Thakor, 1993, “Relationship Banking, Deposit Insurance and Bank Portfolio,” In: Capital Market and Financial Intermediation, edited by
14. Mayer, C., and X. Vives, 262–265. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. • Bikker, J. A., and K. Haaf, 2002, “Competition, Concentration and Their
15. Relationship: An Empirical Analysis of the Banking Industry,” Journal of Banking and Finance 26, 2191–2214.
16. • Blundell, R., and S. Bond, 1998, “Initial Conditions and Moment Restrictions in
17. Dynamic Panel Data Models,” Journal of Econometrics 87, 115–143. • Bofondi, M., and G. Gobbi, 2004, “Bad Loans and Entry Into Local Credit Markets,”
18. Temi di Discussione del Servizio Studi 509, Bank of Italy. • Bongini, P., L. Laeven,and G. Majnoni, 2002, “How Good is the Market at
19. Assessing Bank Fragility? A Horse Race Between Different Indicators,” Journal of Banking and Finance 26, 1011–1028.
20. • Boyd, J. H., and G. De Nicolo, 2005, “The Theory of Bank Risk Taking and Competition Revisited,” Journal of Finance 60, 1329–1343.
21. • Boyd, J.H., G. De Nicolo, and A. Al Jalal, 2006, “Bank Risk Taking and Competition
22. Revisited: New Theory And New Evidence,” International Monetary Fund Working Paper 06/297. • Boyd, J.H., G. De Nicoló, and B.D. Smith, 2004, “Crises in Competitive Versus
23. Monopolistic Banking Systems,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36, 487- 50
24. • Brewer, E.III., and M.R. Saidenberg, 1996, “Franchise Value, Ownership Structure, and Risk at Savings Institutions” Federal Reserve Bank of New York Research Paper 96
25. • Carbo, S., D. Humphrey, J. Maudos, and P. Molyneux, 2009, “Cross-Country
26. Comparisons of Competition and Pricing Power in European Banking,” Journal of International Money and Finance 28, 115–34. • Carletti, E., (2005), Competition and Regulation in Banking. Center for Financial Studies.
27. • Casu, B., and C. Girardone, 2006, “Bank Competition, Concentration and Efficiency
28. In The Single European Market,” The Manchester School 74, 441–468. • Chan, Y.S., S. Greenbaum, and A. Thakor, 1986, “Information Reusability,
29. Competition and Bank Asset Quality,” Journal of Banking and Finance 10, 243-53. • Chang, R., and A. Velasco. 2001, “A Model of Financial Crises In Emerging
30. Markets,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 116 (2), 489–517. • Cho, Y.J, 1986, “Inefficiencies from Financial Liberalization in the Absence of Well
31. Functioning Equity Markets,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 26(2), 341– 3 • Claessens, S., and L. Laeven. 2004, “What Drives Bank Competition? Some
32. International Evidence,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36, 563–84. • Cordella, T., and E. L. Yeyati, 2002, “Financial Opening, Deposit Insurance, and Risk in A Model of Banking Competition,” European Economic Review 46, 471-485.
33. • De Bandt, O., and E. P. Davis, 2000, “Competition, Contestability and Market
34. Structure in European Banking Sectors on the Eve of EMU,” Journal of Banking and Finance 24, 1045–1066.
35. • De Nicolo, G., 2000, “Size, Charter Value and Risk in Banking: An International
36. Perspective,” International Finance Discussion 689, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. • De Nicolo, G., P. Bartholomew, J. Zaman, and M. Zephirin, 2004, “Bank
37. Consolidation, Internationalization and Conglomeration: Trends and Implications for Financial Risk,” Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments 13, 173–217. • De Nicolo, G., and E. Loukoianova, 2007, “Bank Ownership, Market Structure and Risk,” Monetary Fund Working Paper: 07/215.
38. • Demirguc-Kunt, A., L. Laeven, and R. Levine, 2004, “Regulations, Market
39. Structure, Institutions, and the Cost of Financial Intermediation,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36, 593–622. • Demsetz, R. S., and P. E. Strahan, 1997, “Diversification, Size, and Risk at Bank
40. Holding Companies,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 29, 300–313. • Demsetz, R.S., M.R. Saidenberg, and P.E. Strahan, 1996, “Banks with Something to
41. Lose: the Disciplinary Role of Franchise Value,” FRBNY Economic Policy Review October,1–14. • Dick, A., 2006, “Nationwide Branching and Its Impact on Market Structure, Quality and Bank Performance,” Journal of Business 79, 567–592.
42. • Dickey, D. A., and W.A. Fuller, 1979, “Distribution of The Estimators for
43. Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root,” Journal of the American Statistical Association 74, 427–431. • Dornbush, R., and A. Reynoso, 1989, “Financial Factors in Economic
44. Development,” American Economic Review 79(2), 204–209. • Foos, D., L. Norden, and M. Weber, 2010, “Loan Growth and Riskiness of Banks,”
45. Journal of Banking and Finance 34(12), 2929-2940.
46. • Fry, M.J., 1988, “Money. Interest and Banking in Economic Development,”
47. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, • Fungáčová, Z., and L. Weill, 2009, “How Market Powers Influences Bank Failures:
48. Evidence from Russia,” Working Paper, Bank of Finland. • Furlong, F.T., and M.C. Keeley, 1989, “Bank Capital Regulation and Risk Taking: A
49. Note,” Journal of Banking and Finance 13, 883–891. • Gelos, R. G., and J. Roldos, 2004, “Consolidation and Market Structure in
50. Emerging Banking Systems,” Emerging Markets Review 5, 39–59. • Goddard, J., and J. O. S. Wilson, 2009, “Competition in Banking: A Disequilibrium
51. Approach,” Journal of Banking and Finance 32, 2282-2292.
52. • Gonzalez, F., 2005, “Bank Regulation and Risk-Taking Incentives: An International
53. Comparison of Bank Risk” Journal of Banking and Finance 29, 1153–1184.
54. • Hellmann, T.F., K.C. Murdock, and J.E. Stiglitz, 2000, “Liberalization, Moral Hazard in Banking, and Prudential Regulation: Are Capital Requirements Enough?”
55. American Economic Review 90(1), 147–165. • Hong L., and J.O.S. Wilson, 2012, Competition and Risk in Japanese Banking,” The European Journal of Finance, DOI:10.1080/1351847X.2011.633614.
56. • Hong L., P. Molyneux, and L. H. Nguyen, 2012, “Competition and Risk in South
57. East Asian Commercial Banking,” Applied Economics 44(28), 3627-3644.
58. • Im, K. S., M. H. Pesaran, and Y. Shin, 2003, “Testing for unit roots in heterogeneous panels,” Journal of Econometrics 115(1), 53-74.
59. • Jayaratne, J., and P.E. Strahan, 1998, “Entry Restrictions, Industry Evolution, and Dynamic Efficiency: Evidence from Commercial Banking,” Journal of Law and Economics April (XLI), 239–273.
60. • Jensen, K., 1989, “Monetary policy and financial development”, In: Financing
61. Economic Development: A Structural Approach of Economic Development, edited by E.V.K.Fitzgerald, and R.Vos. Gower. Brookfield: .Publishing Company Ltd. • Jimenez, G., J.A. Lopez, and J. Saurinaa. 2013, “How Does Competition Affect Bank
62. Risk-taking?” .Journal of Financial stability 9, 185-195. • Jimenez, G., J.A. Lopez, and J. Saurina, 2008, “How Does Competition Impact
63. Bank Risk Taking” Working Paper. Bank of Spain. • Kashyap, A.K., J.C. Stein, and D.W Wilcox. 1993. “Monetary Policy and Credit
64. Conditions: Evidence from the Composition of External Finance.” The American Economic Review 83(1): 78-98. • Keeley, M.C., 1990, “Deposit Insurance, Risk and Market Power in Banking,”
65. American Economic Review 80, 1183–1200.
66. • Koetter, M., and T. Poghosyan, 2009, “The Identification of Technology Regimes in
67. Banking: Implications for the Market Power-Financial Fragility Nexus,” Journal of Banking and Finance 33, 1413-1422.
68. • Köhler, M., 2012, “Which Banks are More Risky? The Impact of Loan Growth and Business Model on Bank Risk-taking,” Deutsche Bundesbank Discussion Paper: 33/20
69. • Laven, L., 2006, “Banking Sector Performance in East Asian Countries: The Effects of Competition, Diversification, And Ownership. A background paper for ‘East
70. Asian Finance: The Road to Robust Markets,” Mimeo, World Bank. • Laven, L., and G. Majoni, 2003, “Loan Loss Provisioning and Economic
71. Slowdowns: Too Much, Too Late?,” Journal of Financial Intermediation 12, 178- 1
72. • Levin, A., C. Lin, and C. James Chu., 2002, “Unit Root Tests in Panel Data:
73. Asymptotic and Finite-Sample Properties,” Journal of Econometrics 108(1), 1-24. • Marcus, A.J., 1984, “Deregulation and Bank Financial Policy,” Journal of Banking and Finance 8, 557–565.
74. • Marquez, R. 2002, “Competition, Adverse Selection, and Information Dispersion in the Banking Industry,” Review of Financial Studies 15, 901–926.
75. • Martinez-Miera, D., and R. Repullo, 2010, “Does Competition Reduce the Risk of
76. Bank Failure?,” Review of Financial Studies 23(10), 3638–3664.
77. • Matutes, C., and X. Vives, 1996, “Competition for Deposits, Fragility, and Insurance,” Journal of Financial Intermediation 5, 184-216.
78. • Matutes, C., and X. Vives, 2000, “Imperfect Competition, Risk Taking and Competition in Banking,” European Economic Review 44, 1–34.
79. • Nash, R. C., and J. F. Sinkey, 1997, “On Competition, Risk, and Hidden Assets in the Market for Bank Credit Cards,’ Journal of Banking and Finance 21, 89–112.
80. • O'Hara, M., and S. Wayne, 1990, “Deposit Insurance and Wealth Effects: The Value of Being `Too Big To Fail,'” Journal of Finance 45, 1587-1600.
81. • Özcan, A, 2012, “Türkiye’de Ticari Bankacılık Sektöründe Rekabet Düzeyinin
82. Belirlenmesi (2002-2009),” Cumhuriyet Üniversitesi, İktisadi ve İdari Bilimler Dergisi 13(1), 195-211.
83. • Panzar, J.C., and J.N. Rosse, 1987, “Testing for Monopoly Equilibrium,” Journal of
84. Industrial Economics 35, 443–456. • Rhoades, S.A., and R.D. Rutz, 1982, “Market Power and Firm Risk. A Test of the ‘Quiet Life’ Hypothesis,” Journal of Monetary Economics 9, 73–85.
85. • Ruckes, M. 2004, “Bank Competition and Credit Standards,” The Review of
86. Financial Studies 17(4), 1073-1102.
87. • Sáez, L., and X. Shi, 2004, “Liquidity Pools, Risk Sharing, and Financial Contagion”
88. Journal of Financial Services Research 25(1), 5-23. • Salas, V., and J. Saurina, 2003, “Deregulation, Market Power and Risk Behavior in
89. Spanish Banks,” European Economic Review 47, 1061–1075.
90. • Saunders, A., and B. Wilson, 1996, “Bank Capital Structure: Charter Value and Diversification Effects,” Working Paper: S-96-52, New York University Salomon Center.
91. • Schaeck, K., and M. Čihák, 2007, “Banking Competition and Capital Ratios,” IMF
92. Working Paper: 07/216. Washington: International Monetary Fund. • Schaek, K., M. ˇCihak, and S. Wolfe, 2006, “Are More Competitive Banking
93. Systems More Stable?,” IMF Working Paper: 06/143. • Shaffer, S., 1982, “A Non-Structural Test for Competition in Financial Markets,” In
94. Proceedings of a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition by Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, 225-243. Chicago. • Soedarmono, W., F. Machrouh, and A. Tarazi, 2011, “Bank Market Power,
95. Economic Growth and Financial Stability: Evidence from Asian Banks,” Journal of Asian Economics 22( 6), 460–470. • Soedarmono, W., F. Machrouh, and A. Tarazi, 2013, “Bank Competition, Crisis and Risk Taking: Evidence from Emerging Markets in Asia,” Journal of
96. International Financial Markets, Institutions & Money 23, 196-221. • Stiglitz, J., and A. Weiss, 1981, “Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect
97. Information,” American Economic Review 71(3), 393–410. • Stiroh, K. J., 2004, “Diversification in Banking: Is Noninterest Income the Answer?,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36, 853–882.
98. • Stiroh, K., and A. Rumble, 2006, “The Dark Side of Diversification: The Case of US
99. Financial Holding Companies,” Journal of Banking and Finance 30, 2131-2161.
100. • Tabak, B., D. Fazio, and D. Cajueiro, 2012, “The Relationship between Banking
101. Market Competition and Risk-Taking: Do Size and Capitalization Matter?,” Journal of Banking and Finance 36(12), 3366–3381.
102. • Taylor, L., 1983, Structuralist Macroeconomics: Applicable Models for the Third
103. World. New-York: Basic Books. • Tunay, B., 2009, “Turk Bankacılık Sektorunde Rekabet ve Kırılganlık,” Bankacılar Dergisi 68, 30-54.
104. • Uhde, A., and U. Heimeshoff, 2009, “Consolidation in Banking and Financial
105. Stability in Europe: Empirical Evidence,” Journal of Banking and Finance 33, 1299– 3
106. • Vives, X., 2010, “Competition and Stability in Banking,” CESifo Working Paper 3050(11), Industrial Organization.
107. • Wagner, W., 2007, “The Liquidity of Bank Assets and Banking Stability,” Journal of
108. Banking and Finance 31, 121–39. • Wagner, W., 2010, “Loan market competition and bank risk-taking,” Journal of
109. Financial Services Research 37(1), 71–81. • Yaldız, E., and F. Bazzana, 2010, “The Effect of Market Power on Bank Risk Taking in Turkey,” Financial Theory and Practice 34(3), 297-314.
110. • Yeyati, E. L., and A. Micco, 2007, “Concentration and Foreign Penetration in Latin
111. American Banking Sectors: Impact on Competition and Risk,” Journal of Banking and Finance 31, 1633–47. APPENDIXES
112. Note: *,** and *** denotes statistical significance at the 1%, 5% and 10% level, respectively.