THE SUSTAINABILITY OF TOURISM COMPETITIVENESS IN TERNATE

Year 2018, , 75 - 96, 26.10.2018

Muharto Laode

https://doi.org/10.15637/jlecon.262

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the competitiveness of tourism sector in Ternate using three units of analysis, namely the sustainability of competitiveness, the determinant of competition strength and the formulation of sustainable competitive advantage strategy. Secondary data were collected through documentation, such as APBD data, infrastructure conditions, tourism objects, labor, industry of accommodation provider, and tourist numbers. Primary data were collected through interview to 159 respondents. The analysis and strategy formulation used combination of VRIOL, SFM and SWOT. This study found that the tourism sector in Ternate was in a competitive advantage position, but not sustained because its tourism resources did not have uniqueness and could be imitated by competitors. Factors determining tourism competition were the role of government, new areas that were beginning to develop the tourism sector, new tourist spot and tour operators. The strategies that could maintain the sustainability of tourism competitiveness in Ternate are differentiation, inovation, partnership, promotion and marketing system, service quality, and empowering.

Keywords

Sustainable Competitive Advantage, Strategy, Tourism Sector, Ternate

References

• AJI, PRASETIO (2015). Manajemen Strategi, Keunggulan Bersaing Berkelanjutan. Yogyakarta: Ekuilibria.
• ANDRIOTIS, KONSTANTINOS. (2004). Revising Porter’s Five Forces Model for Application in the Travel and Tourism Industry. Torism Today 4: 7-20.
• ARYUNDA, HANNY. (2011). Dampak Ekonomi Pengembangan Kawasan Ekowisata Kepulauan Seribu. Jurnal Perencanaan Wilayah dan Kota 22 (1): 1– 16.
• BALAN, D., V. BALAURE, AND C. VEGHES. (2009). Travel and tourism competitiveness of the world’s top tourism destinations: An exploratory Assessment. Annales Universitatis Apulensis series Oeconomica 11 (2): 979–987.
• DEPARTEMEN KEBIJAKAN EKONOMI DAN MONETER. (2015). Kajian Ekonomi dan Keuangan Regional: Isu Khusus 2 Optimalisasi Potensi Pariwisata dalam Mendukung Percepatan Ekonomi. Nusantara Report, Indonesia Bank 10 (4): 82-94.
• BARNEY, J. B. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management 17 (1): 99-120.
• BARNEY, J B., Jr. D. J. KETCHEN, AND M. WRIGHT. (2011). The Future of Resource-Based Theory: Revitalization or Decline?. Journal of Management 37 (5): 1299-1315.
• BLACK, J., N. HASHIMZADE, G. MYLES. (2009). A Dictionary of Economics. Oxford University Press [Oxford Reference Online]. National Library of Lithuania. Available from Internet: <http://www.oxfordreference.com/views/ENTRY. html?subview=Main&entry=t19.e1657>.
• BASSIL, CHARBEL., M. HAMADEH, AND N. SAMARA. (2015). The tourism led growth hypothesis: the Lebanese case. Tourism Review 70 (1): 43-55.
• BETHAPUDI, ANAND. (2013). The Role Of ICT In Tourism Industry. Journal Of Applied Economics And Business 1 (4): 67-79.
• BIGOVIC, MILOS. (2012). Competitiveness of a Post-Conflict Tourist Destination-Case of sjf Montenegro. Journal of Travel and Tourism Research, Fall: 50-70.
• BLANKED, J AND T. CHIESA (Eds). (2008). The Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Index Report 2008: Meansuring Key Elements Driving The Sector’s Development. Word Economic Forum. Available at: Http://Www.Weforum.Org.
• BRIDA, J. G., S. P. JUAN., F.P. LIONELLO, AND J.S.D. MARÍA. (2010). The Economic Contribution of Tourism Sector. International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Systems 3 (1) :13-22.
• BADAN PUSAT STATISTIK KOTA TERNATE. (2015). Maluku Utara Dalam Angka. SUSENAS, BPS Kota Ternate.
• BADAN PUSAT STATISTIK MALUKU UTARA. (2016). Statistik Maluku Utara. BPS Provinsi Maluku Utara.
• BADAN PUSAT STATISTIK INDONESIA. (2016). Statistik Indonesia. BPS Indonesia.
• CHIN, C. H., L. M CHIUN., P. SONGAN, AND V. NAIR. (2014). Rural Tourism Destination Competitiveness: A Study On Annah Rais Longhouse Homestay, Sarawak. Procedia. social and behavioral sciences 144 (2014) :35–44. available at: www.sciencedirect.com.
• CHOI, H. C., AND E. SIRAKAYA. (2006). Sustainability Indicators for Managing Community Tourism. Tourism Management 27 (6): 1274-1289.
• ÇOBAN, AYSE., D. B. KURT, AND O. COBAN. (2015). An Analysis Of Tourism Sector With The Grubel-Lloyd Index: The Case Of Turkey And Selected Countries. International Journal of Arts and Sciences 08 (07): 223–231.
• CROTTI, R AND T. MISRAHI. (2015). World Economic Forum The Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Index: T&T as a Resilient Contribution To National Development. World Economic Forum. Available at :Http://Www.Weforum.Org.
• CROUCH. G.I, AND B.J.R. RITCHIE. (1994). Destination competitive–exploring foundations for a long term research program. In Proceedings of Administrative Sciences Association of canada, Annual Conference, Halifax, Nova Scotia 79-88. -------------------------------------------- (1999). Tourism, competitiveness, and social prosperity. Jurnal Of Business research, Elsevier Science Inc. 44 (3): 137-152.
• CLULOW, VAL., C. BARRY AND J. GERSTMAN. (2007). The resource-based view and value: the customer-based view of the firm. Journal of European Industrial Training 31 (1) :19-35.
• DIERICKX, I, AND K. COOL. (1989). Asset stock accumulation and sustainability of competitive advantage. Management Science 35 (12) :1504-11.
• DAMANIK, J. (2013). Pariwisata Indonesia: Antara Peluang dan Tantangan. Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar.
• DAVID, FRED R., AND F. R. DAVID. (2015). Strategic Management: A Competitive Advantage Approach, Concepts & Cases, 15th” Edition. London: Pearson Education.
• DWYER, L., P. FORSYTH., AND R. RAO. (2000). The price of competitiveness of travel and tourism: A comparison 0f 19 destination. Tourism Management 21 (1): 1-22.
• EDMONDS, T. (2000). Regional Competitiveness & the Role of the Knowledge Economy, House of Commons Library. Research paper. London: Research Publications Office.
• EMZIR. (2011). Metode Penelitian Kualitatif: Analisis Data. Jakarta: RajaGrafindo Persada.
• FAHY, JOHN AND A. SMITHEE. (1999). Strategic Marketing and the Resource Based View of the Firm. Academy of Marketing Science Review 1999 (10) :1-20.
• FALAK, SHAISTA., L. M. CHIUN, AND A. Y. WEE. (2014). A repositioning strategy for rural tourism in Malaysia- community’s perspective. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 2014 (144) :412–415.
• FERNANDO, IMALI N. (2014). Is Competitiveness a Challenge for an Economy? A Comparative Study for Sri Lankan Tourism Sector. In Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Management and Economics. Faculty of Management and Finance, University of Ruhuna, Sri Lanka, 26-27 February.
• FUN, F. SOOK., L. M. CHIUN., P. SONGAN, AND V. NAIR. (2014). The impact of local communities’ involvement and relationship quality on sustainable rural tourism in rural area, Sarawak. The moderating impact of self-efficacy. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 2014 (144) :60–65.
• GUZMÁN, T. L., S. S CAÑIZARES, AND V. PAVÓN. (2011). Community - Based Tourism In Developing Countries: A Case Study. Tourismos, An International Multidisciplinary Journal Of Tourism 6 (1) 69-84.
• GRACAN, D., R. A RADNIC., S. BOGDAN. (2008). Restorable Energy Sources As A Factor Of The Competitive Improvement Ability Of A Tourist Destination. Tourism and Hospitality Management 14 (2) : 217-228.
• HAMARNEH, IVETA. (2013). Jordan as a Tourist Destination. Jurnal Of Tourim and Services 14 (1) : 21-36.
• HATZICHRONOGLOU, T. (1996). Globalisation and Competitiveness: Relevant Indicators, OECD Science, Technology and Industry. Working Papers 5: 62.
• HUTTASIN, NARA., H. MOMMAAS, AND L. KNIPPENBERG. (2015). Towards Tourism Development Of The Isan Region, Northeastern Thailand. IJAPS 11 (1) :103–128.
• JOLLIFFE, LEE, AND T. BAUM. (2004). Event Tourism Partnership Evolution – Evidence From The Highlands Of Scotland. The Journal Of The College Of Tourism And Hotel Management 2004 (4) :7-20.
• JOVANOVIĆ, VERKA, AND N. ANGELINA. (2008). The Application Of Gis and Its Components In Tourism Yugoslav. Journal of Operations Research 18 (2) :261-272.
• JOVANOVIĆ, SONJA., V. J MILIĆ, AND B. KRSTIĆ. (2014). Homogeneity analysis of south-eastern European countries according to tourism competitiveness performances. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja 27 (1) :207–220.
• JOVICIC, DOBRICA AND IVANOVIC, VANJA (2008). Enviromental Protection–Key Prerequisite For Sustainable Tourism On Mediterranean. Tourism and Hospitality Management 14 (2) :217-228.
• KADI, ALAA J., M. JAAFAR, AND F. HASSAN. (2015). Stakeholder’s Contribution in Sustainable Tourism. Advances In Environmental Biology 9 (5) : 74-77.
• KARINI, N. M OKA. (2011). Pengelolaan Daya Tarik Wisata Tinggalan Arkeologi Yang Berkelanjutan Di Bali. Jurnal Analisis Pariwisata 11 (1) :1-7.
• KEMENTRIAN PARIWISATA REPUBLIK INDONESIA. (2014). Laporan Kinerja Kementrian Pariwisata Tahun. KEMENPAR RI, 2014.
• KEMENTRIAN PARIWISATA REPUBLIK INDONESIA. (2017). Laporan Kinerja Kementrian Pariwisata Tahun. Biro Perencanaan Dan Keuangan Sekretariat Kementerian, Jakarta 2017.
• KOGUT, B., & U. ZANDER. (1992). Knowledge of the firm, combinative capabilities, and the replication of technology. Organization Science (3): 383-397.
• KOR, Y Y, and J. T Mahoney. 2004. Edith Penrose’s (1959) Contributions to the Resource-based View of trategic Management. Journal of Management Studies 41 (1) :183-191.
• KNOTT, PAUL. (2009). Integrating resource-based theoryin a practice-relevant form. Journal of Strategy and Management 2 (2): 163-174.
• KOTLER, PHILIP DAN ARMSTRONG, GERY. (2008). Prinsip-prinsip Pemasaran: Edisi Dua Belas Jilid 1. Dialihbahasakan oleh Bob Sabran. Jakarta: Erlangga.
• KOVAČIĆ, M., Z. GRŽETIĆ & D. BOSKOVIĆ. (2011). Nautical Tourism In Fostering The Sustainable Development: A Case Study Of Croatia’s Coast And Island. Tourismos: An International Multidisciplinary Journal Of Tourism 6 (1) :221-232.
• LUSBY, CAROLIN, AND K. EOW. (2015). Tourism Development in a New Democracy: Residents’ Perceptions of Community-based Tourism in Mawlamyine, Myanmar. Journal of Tourism and Recreation 2 (1) : 23-40.
• MAHONEY, J.T, AND J.R PANDIAN. (1992). The Resource-Based View Within The Conversation Of Strategic Management. Strategic Management Journal 3 (5) :363-380.
• MARZUKI, A., A. A. HUSSIN., B. MOHAMED., A. G OTHMAN, AND A. P. M SOM. (2011). Assessment Of Nature-Based Tourism In South Kelantan, Malaysia. Tourismos: An International Multidisciplinary Journal Of Tourism 6 (1) :281-295.
• MEYER, BEATA. (2012). Environmental Impacts Of The Development Of Brand Tourist Products In The West-Pomeranian Province. Scientific Journal No. 658 Economic Problems Of Tourism 1 (17) : 251-261.
• MIHALIC. (2000). Environmental management of tourist destinations; a factors of tourist competitiveness. Tourism Management 21 (1) : 65-78.
• MUHAMMAD, S. (2013). Manajemen Strategik: Konsep dan Alat Analisis. (cet ke-5). Yogyakarta: Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Manajemen.
• MUHARTO., B. TEWAL., S. L MANDEY, AND A. TUMBEL. (2017). Competitiveness And The Increasing Strategy Of Competitiveness In Tourism Sector Of Ternate City, North Maluku Province. Interational Journal of Life Economıcs 4 (14) :11-32.
• MUKHTAR. (2013). Metode Praktis Penelitian Dskriptif Kualitatif. Jakarta Selatan: Referensi.
• NENE, G, AND A. TAIVAN. (2017). Causality Between Tourism and Economic Growth: Evidence From Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). The Journal of Developing Areas Volume 51 (2) :155-169.
• OKECH, R. N., (2004). The Role of Tour Operators in Sustainable Ecotourism: Lessons from Kenya. Tourism Today: The Journal Of The College Of Tourism And Hotel Management 2004 (4) : 78–88.
• OTHMAN, PAZIM, AND R. M MOHD. (2011). The Impact of Tourism on Small Business Performance: Empirical Evidence from Malaysian Islands. International Journal of Business and Social Science 2 (1) :11-21.
• PETERAF, M. A. (1993). The Cornerstoners of Competitive Advantage: A Resource Based View. Strategic management Journal 14 (3) :179-191.
• PITELIS, CHRISTOS. (2007). Edith Penrose and a Learning-Based Perspective on the MNE and OLI1 Management. International Review 47 (2) :207-219.
• PORTER, M. E. (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industri and Competotors. New York: Free Press. --------------- 1985. The Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior. New York: Free Press. --------------- 1990. The Competitive Advantage of Nations. New York: Free Press. PRASETYA, D. DWI. (2011). Aplikasi Virtual Tour Berbasis Web Sebagai Media Promosi Pariwisata. Seminar On Electrical, Informatics, and Its Education (2011) :58-63.
• PRAYOGI, P. A. (2011). Dampak Perkembangan Pariwisata di Objek Wisata Penglipuran. Jurnal Perhotelan dan Pariwisata, Sekolah Tinggi Pariwisata Triatma Jaya 1 (1) :64-79.
• PRIMAYESA, E., W. WIDODO., F.X SUGIYANTO, AND FIRMANSYAH. (2017). The Dynamic Relationship between Economic Growth. Tourism Activity, and Real Exchange Rate in Indonesia 8 (20) : 798-810.
• PUGRA, I W, DAN S. I KETUT. (2011). Mengoptimalkan Pengolahan Limbah Menuju Pariwisata Berkelanjutan Pada Kawasan Wisata di Bali. Jurnal Analisis Pariwisata 11 (1) :8-15.
• RANGKUTI, FREDDY. (2014). Analisis SWOT, Teknik Membedah Kasus Bisnis. Jakarta: Gramedia Pustaka Utama.
• SAPTANA. (2010). Tinjauan konseptual mikro-makro daya saing dan strategi pembangunan pertanian. Forum penelitian agro ekonomi 28 (1) : 1-8.
• SAAYMAN, M, AND A. GIAMPICCOLI. (2016). Community-based and pro-poor tourism: Initial assessment of their relation to community. European Journal of Tourism Research 12 : 145-190.
• SAVILLE, N. M. (2001). Pratical Strategies for Pro-Poor Tourism: case study of pro-Poor Tourism and SNV in Humla District, West Nepal. Working Paper 3, April, available at: http://www. Propoortourism.org.uk.
• SEDARMAYANTI. (2014). Manajemen Strategi. Bandung: Refika Aditama.
• SAFTIC, D., A. TEŽAK, AND L. NINOSLAV. (2011). Stakeholder Approach In Tourism Management: Implication In Croatian Tourism. International Conference On Organizational Science Development Future Organization, March 23rd – 25th, Portorož, Slovenia.
• SOTERIADES, MARIOS., C. AIVALIS, AND S. VARVARESSOS (2004). E-marketing and E-commerce in the Tourism Industry: A Framework to Develop and Implement. Business Initiatives. The Journal Of The College Of Tourism and Hotel Management 2004 (4) :157-169.
• SNIEŠKA, V, AND J. BRUNECKIENE. (2009). Measurement of Lithuanian Regions by Regional Competitiveness Index. Inzinerine Ekonomika–4Engineering Economics 2009 (1) : 45–57.
• ŠIMUNDIĆ, B., Z. KULIŠ, AND N. ŠERIĆ. (2016). Tourism And Economic Growth: An Evidence For Latin American And Caribbean Countries. Tourism & Hospitality Industry 2016, Congress Proceedings, 2016:. 457-469.
• SOEBAGYO. (2012). Strategi Pengembangan Pariwisata di Indonesia. Jurnal Liquidity 1 (2) :153-158.
• STIPANOVIC, C AND S. BARESA. (2008). The Development Design Model In The Competitiveness Of Intelligent Business Organisations. Tourism and Hospitality Management 14 (2) : 217-228.
• STEINICKE, E AND M. NEUBURGER. (2012). The Impact of Community-based Afro-alpine Tourism on Regional Development: A Case Study in the Mt Kenya Region. Mountain Research and Development 32 (4) : 420–430.
• SUARDANA, I WAYAN. (2011). Dekontruksi Kebijakan Pembangunan Pariwisata Yang Berkelanjutan Di Bali. Jurnal Analisis Pariwisata 11 (1) :16-26.
• SUGIYONO. (2016). Metode Penelitian Kuantitatif, Kualitatif dan R&D. Bandung: Alvabeta.
• SUPRIYADI, Edy. (2017). The Economic Impact of International Tourism to Overcome the Unemployment and the Poverty in Indonesia. Journal of Environmental Management and Tourism 8 (2) :451–459.
• TATOĞLU, A. P. E., A. P. F ERDAL., A. P. H ÖZGÜR, AND A. P. S AZAKLI. (2000). Resident Perceptions of the Impact of Tourism in a Turkish Resort Town. Availabel at: http://www.opf.slu.cz/vvr/akce/turecko/pdf/Tatoglu.pdf.
• TATHAGATI AND INDSCRIPT. (2015). Super Tourismpreneur: A-Z Inspirasi Bisnis dan Mengelola Bisnis Pariwisata. Yogyakarta: Andi Offset.
• VALLE, P O D., J. A SILVA., J. MENDES, AND M. GUERREIRO (2006). Tourist Satisfaction and Destination Loyalty intention: A Structural and Categorical Analysis. Journal of Business Science and Applied Management 1 (1) :25-44.
• WERNERFELT, B. (1984). A resource-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal 5 (2) :171-80.
• WÖBER, KARL W. (2003). Information Supply in Tourism Management by Marketing Decision Support Systems. Tourism Management 24 (2003) :241-255, availableat: www.elsevier.com/locate/tourman.
• WU, C. LUNG, AND H. M CHANG. (2013). Island Marine Tourism Development Critical Success Factors–Case by Wangan in Taiwan. The Journal of Global Business Management 9 (3) : 126-135.
• WORD ECONOMIC FORUM (WEF). (2013). The Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Report. Available at: Http://Www.Weforum.Org.
• ----------------------------------------- 2015. The Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Report. Available at: Http://Www.Weforum.Org.
• ---------------------------------------- 2017. The Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Report. Available at: Http://Www.Weforum.Org.
• WORLD TOURISM ORGANIZATION (WTO). (2002). Tourism and Poverty Alleviation. Avalable at: http: //www.world tourism.org/liberalization/poverty /tourism.
• XIN, T. KAI, DAN J. K. L CHAN. (2014). Tour operator perspectives on responsible tourism indicators of Kinabalu National Park, Sabah. Journal Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 144 (2014) :25–34.
• ZADEL, ZRINKA. (2012). The Importance Of Developing Cultural Tourism In Creating Competitive Advantages Of Croatian Tourism. In Conference Proceedings of Tourism & Hospitality Management :205-214.