Nature-based solutions for sustainable cities: A review of the state of the art of green roof research

Abstract

The study of green roofs is an interdisciplinary field recognized for its eco-friendly roofing solutions. Green roofs offer ecological, economic, and societal benefits, making them an ef- fective way to address urbanization's negative impacts. This review explores the evolution of green roofs from ancient prototypes to modern innovations. Using the Google Scholar da- tabase, we conducted a bibliometric analysis of 50 articles to assess publication rates in the "green roof " area. Descriptive statistics were used to identify key contributors, ecosystem ser- vices, research methodologies, and spatial scales in green roof studies. Our analysis showed a rise in research on green roof technology in the early 21st century, with the United States and China leading this research. Urban heat island mitigation emerged as a primary research focus for green roofs, with cities being the most studied spatial scale. The most common keywords were "green roofs," "urban," and "energy." This study thoroughly reviews the past and present state of green roofs, showcasing a range of indicators that provide valuable insights for future research and emerging trends in the area.

Keywords

• Bibliographic compilation
• ecosystem service
• geographical distribution
• green roof history
• study methodologies

References

1. 1. Rapoport, A. (1969). House form and culture. Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall.
2. 2. Urbanczyk, P. (1999). North Atlantic turf architecture as an example of environmental adaptation. Archaeol Pol, 37, 119–133.
3. 3. Buckland, P. C. (2000). The North Atlantic environment. In W. Fitzhugh (Ed.), Vikings: The North Atlantic saga (pp. 146–153). Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press.
4. 4. Van Hoof, J., & van Dijken, F. (2008). The historical turf farms of Iceland: Architecture, building technology and the indoor environment. Build Environ, 43, 1023–1030. [CrossRef]
5. 5. Liu, H., Kong, F., Yin, H., Middel, A., Zheng, X., Huang, J., Xu, H., Wang, D., & Wen, Z. (2021). Impacts of green roofs on water, temperature, and air quality: A bibliometric review. Build Environ, 196, 107794. [CrossRef]
6. 6. Cook, L. M., & Larsen, T. A. (2021). Towards a performance-based approach for multifunctional green roofs: An interdisciplinary review. Build Environ, 188, 107489. [CrossRef]
7. 7. Mihalakakou, G., Souliotis, M., Papadaki, M., Menounou, P., Dimopoulos, P., Kolokotsa, D., Paravantis, J. A., Tsangrassoulis, A., Panaras, G., Giannakopoulos, E., & Papaefthimiou, S.(2023). Green roofs as a nature-based solution for improving urban sustainability: Progress and perspectives. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 180, 113306. [CrossRef]
8. 8. Mazzeo, D., Matera, N., Peri, G., & Scaccianocce, G. (2023). Forecasting green roofs’ potential in improving building thermal performance and mitigating urban heat island in the Mediterranean area: An artificial intelligence-based approach. Appl Therm Eng, 222, 119879. [CrossRef]

9. 9. Lee, K., Williams, K. J., Sargent, L. D., Williams, N. S., & Johnson, K. A. (2015). 40-second green roof views sustain attention: The role of micro-breaks in attention restoration. J Environ Psychol, 42, 182–189. [CrossRef]
10. 10. Mesimäki, M., Hauru, K., & Lehvavirta, S. (2019). Do small green roofs have the possibility to offer recreational and experiential benefits in a dense urban area? A case study in Helsinki, Finland. Urban For Urban Green, 40, 114–124. [CrossRef]
11. 11. Castleton, H. F., Stovin, V., Beck, S. B. M., & Davison, J. B. (2010). Green roofs: Building energy savings and the potential for retrofit. Energy Build, 42, 1582–1591. [CrossRef]
12. 12. Svendsen, E., Northridge, M. E., & Metcalf, S. S. (2012). Integrating grey and green infrastructure to improve the health and well-being of urban populations. Cities Environ, 5, 1–9. [CrossRef]
13. 13. Perillo, V. L., Brendel, A. S., Ferrelli, F., Gutierrez, A., Vitale, A. J., Marinangeli, P., & Piccolo, M. C. (2023). CO2 flux dynamics of exotic and native species in an extensive green roof simulator with hydric deficit. Urban Clim, 49, 101567. [CrossRef]
14. 14. Robbiati, F. O., Caceres, N., Hick, E. C., Suárez, M., Soto, S., Barea, G., Matoff, E., Galetto, L., & Imhof, L. (2022). Vegetative and thermal performance of an extensive vegetated roof located in the urban heat island of a semiarid region. Build Environ, 212, 108791. [CrossRef]
15. 15. Yang, J., Yu, Q., & Gong, P. (2008). Quantifying air pollution removal by green roofs in Chicago. Atmos Environ, 42, 7266–7273. [CrossRef]
16. 16. Gourdji, S. (2018). Review of plants to mitigate particulate matter, ozone, as well as nitrogen dioxide air pollutants and applicable recommendations for green roofs in Montreal, Quebec. Environ Pollut, 241, 378–387. [CrossRef]
17. 17. Brennelsen, S. (2006). Space for urban wildlife: Designing green roofs as habitats in Switzerland. Urban Habitats, 4, 27–36.
18. 18. Lepezyk, C. A., Aronson, M. F., Evans, K. L., Goddard, M. A., Lerman, S. B., & MacIvor, J. S.(2017). Biodiversity in the city: Fundamental questions for understanding the ecology of urban green spaces for biodiversity conservation. BioScience, 67(9), 799–807. [CrossRef]
19. 19. Talwar, P., Verma, N., Khatri, H., Ahire, P. D., Chaudhary, G., Lindenberger, C., & Vivekanand, V.(2023). A systematic review of photovoltaic-green roof systems in different climatic conditions focusing on sustainable cities and societies. Sustain Cities Soc, 98, 104813. [CrossRef]
20. 20. Dwivedi, A., & Mohan, B. K. (2018). Impact of green roof on microclimate to reduce urban heat island. Remote Sens Appl Soc Environ, 10, 56–69. [CrossRef]
21. 21. VanWeert, N. D., Rowe, D. B., Andresen, J. A., Rugh, C. L., Fernandez, R. T., & Xiao, L. (2005). Green roof stormwater retention: Effects of roof surface, slope, and media depth. J Environ Qual, 34(3), 1036–1044. [CrossRef]
22. 22. Ciller, L. G. Evolution de las cubiertas vegetales. https://www.urbanarbolismo.es/blog/evolution-historical-de-las-cubiertas-vegetales/
23. 23. Osmundson, T. H. (1999). Roof gardens: History, design, and construction. Norton & Company.
24. 24. Wang, C., Er, S., & Abdul-Rahman, H. (2016). Indoor vertical greenery system in urban tropics. Indoor Built Environ, 25, 340–356. [CrossRef]
25. 25. Dalley, S. (2013). The mystery of the Hanging Garden of Babylon. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
26. 26. Shimmin, H. A brief history of roof gardens. https://www.heathershimmin.com/a-brief-history-of-roof-gardens
27. 27. Jim, C. Y. (2017). An archaeological and historical exploration of the origins of green roofs. Urban For Urban Green, 27, 32–42. [CrossRef]
28. 28. Berg, A. (1989). Norske tommerhus fra mellomalderen (Vol. I, pp. 70–73). Landbruksforlaget.
29. 29. Vreim, H. (1966). Laflehus: Tamring og torvtekking (pp. 64–75). Noregs Boklag.
30. 30. Nicklin, M. W. Can tourism help protect the iconic Mont-Saint-Michel? https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/article/france-mont-saint-michel-island-abbey-sustainable-travel
31. 31. Black, A. Torre Guinigi (Guinigi Tower). https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/torre-guinigi-guinigi-tower
32. 32. UNESCO. Mont-Saint-Michel and its Bay. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/80
33. 33. UNESCO. Historic center of Lucca. World Heritage Tentative List, World Heritage Conservationhttp://whc.unesco.org/en/tentativelists/340/ (Accessed Feb 28, 2024).
34. 34. Shepherd, J. C., & Jellicoe, G. A. (1925). Italian gardens of the Renaissance. Academy Editions.
35. 35. Dunnet, N., & Kingsbury, N. (2008). Planting green roofs and living walls. Timber Press.
36. 36. Werthmann, C. (2007). Green roof: A case study. Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates design for the headquarters of the American Society of Landscape Architects. Princeton Architectural Press.
37. 37. Thuring, C. E., & Dunnett, N. (2014). Vegetation composition of old extensive green roofs (from 1980s Germany). Ecol Process, 3, 1–11. [CrossRef]
38. 38. Vijayaraghavan, K. (2016). Green roofs: A critical review on the role of components, benefits, limitations, and trends. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 57, 740–752. [CrossRef]
39. 39. Lee, K. E., Williams, K. J., Sargent, L. D., Williams, N. S., & Johnson, K. A. (2015). 40-second green roof views sustain attention: The role of micro-breaks in attention restoration. J Environ Psychol, 42, 182–189. [CrossRef]
40. 40. Van Mechelen, C., Dutoit, T., & Hermy, M. (2015). Adapting green roof irrigation practices for a sustainable future: A review. Sustain Cities Soc, 19, 74–90. [CrossRef]
41. 41. Blanchini, F., & Hewage, K. (2012). How "green" are the green roofs? Lifecycle analysis of green roof materials. Build Environ, 48, 57–65. [CrossRef]
42. 42. Lundholm, J., & Williams, N. (2015). Effects of vegetation on green roof ecosystem services. In R. Sutton (Ed.), Green roof ecosystems (Ecological Studies, Vol. 223, pp. 211–232). Springer. [CrossRef]
43. 43. Lundholm, J., MacIvor, J. S., Macdougall, Z., & Ranalli, M. (2010). Plant species and functional group combinations affect green roof ecosystem functions. PLoS One, 5(3), e9677. [CrossRef]
44. 44. Martens, R., Bass, B., & Alcazar, S. S. (2008). Roof-envelope ratio impact on green roof energy performance. Urban Ecosystem, 11, 399–408. [CrossRef]
45. 45. Wolf, D., & Lundholm, J. T. (2008). Water uptake in green roof microcosms: Effects of plant species and water availability. Ecol Eng, 33(2), 179–186. [CrossRef]
46. 46. He, Y., Yu, H., Ozaki, A., & Dong, N. (2020). Thermal and energy performance of green roof and cool roof: A comparison study in Shanghai area. J Clean Prod, 267, 122205. [CrossRef]
47. 47. Jim, C. Y., & Peng, L. L. (2012). Weather effect on thermal and energy performance of an extensive tropical green roof. Urban For Urban Green, 11(1), 73–85. [CrossRef]
48. 48. Jim, C. Y., & Tsang, S. W. (2011). Biophysical properties and thermal performance of an intensive green roof. Build Environ, 46(6), 1263–1274. [CrossRef]
49. 49. Li, W. C., & Yeung, K. K. A. (2014). A comprehensive study of green roof performance from an environmental perspective. Int J Sustain Built Environ, 3(1), 127–134. [CrossRef]
50. 50. Li, J. F., Wai, Q. W., Li, Y. S., Zhan, J. M., Ho, Y. A., Li, J., & Lam, E. (2010). Effect of green roof on ambient CO2 concentration. Build Environ, 45(12), 2644–2651. [CrossRef]
51. 51. Peng, L. L., & Jim, C. Y. (2013). Green-roof effects on neighborhood microclimate and human thermal sensation. Energies, 6(2), 598–618. [CrossRef]
52. 52. Xiao, M., Lin, Y., Han, J., & Zhang, G. (2014). A review of green roof research and development in China. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 40, 633–648. [CrossRef]
53. 53. Zhang, X., Shen, L., Tam, Y. W., & Lee, W. W. Y. (2012). Barriers to implement extensive green roof systems: A Hong Kong study. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 16(1), 314–319. [CrossRef]
54. 54. Shafique, M., Kim, R., & Rafiq, M. (2018). Green roof benefits, opportunities, and challenges - A review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 90, 757–773. [CrossRef]
55. 55. Ouldboukhtine, S. E., Belarb, R., Jaffal, I., & Trabelsi, A. (2011). Assessment of green roof thermal behavior: A coupled heat and mass transfer model. Build Environ, 46(12), 2624–2631. [CrossRef]
56. 56. Niachou, A., Papakonstantinou, K., Santamouris, M., Tsangrassoulis, A., & Mihalakakou, G.(2001). Analysis of the green roof thermal properties and investigation of its energy performance. Energy Build, 33(7), 719–729. [CrossRef]
57. 57. Kumar, R., & Kaushik, S. C. (2005). Performance evaluation of green roof and shading for thermal protection of buildings. Build Environ, 40(11), 1505–1511. [CrossRef]
58. 58. Blank, L., Vasi, A., Levy, S., Grant, G., Kadas, G., Dafni, A., & Blaustein, L. (2013). Directions in green roof research: A bibliometric study. Build Environ, 66, 23–28. [CrossRef]
59. 59. Cascone, S. (2019). Green roof design: State of the art on technology and materials. Sustainability, 11(11), 3020. [CrossRef]
60. 60. Cascone, S., Catania, F., Gagliano, A., & Sciuto, G. (2018). A comprehensive study on green roof performance for retrofitting existing buildings. Build Environ, 136, 227–239. [CrossRef]
61. 61. Fioretti, R., Palla, A., Lanza, L. G., & Principi, P. (2010). Green roof energy and water-related performance in the Mediterranean climate. Build Environ, 45(8), 1890–1904. [CrossRef]
62. 62. Lazzarin, R. M., Castellotti, F., & Busato, F. (2005). Experimental measurements and numerical modelling of a green roof. Energy Build, 37(12), 1260–1267. [CrossRef]
63. 63. Pisello, A. L., Piselli, C., & Cotana, F. (2015). Thermal-physics and energy performance of an innovative green roof system: The Cool-Green Roof. Sol Energy, 116, 337–356. [CrossRef]
64. 64. Takebayashi, H., & Moriyama, M. (2007). Surface heat budget on green roof and high reflection roof for mitigation of urban heat island. Build Environ, 42(8), 2971–2979. [CrossRef]
65. 65. Manso, M., Teotonio, I., Silva, C. M., & Cruz, C. O. (2021). Green roof and green wall benefits and costs: A review of the quantitative evidence. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 135, 110111. [CrossRef]
66. 66. Korol, E., & Shushunova, N. (2016). Benefits of a modular green roof technology. Procedia Eng, 161, 1820–1826. [CrossRef]
67. 67. Fernandez-Canero, R., Emilsson, T., Fernandez-Barba, C., & Machuca, M. A. H. (2013). Green roof systems: A study of public attitudes and preferences in southern Spain. J Environ Manage, 128, 106–115. [CrossRef]
68. 68. Kader, S., Chadalavada, S., Jaufer, L., Spalevic, V., & Dudic, B. (2022). Green roof substrates-A literature review. Front Built Environ, 8, 1019362. [CrossRef]
69. 69. Bengtsson, L., Grahn, L., & Olsson, J. (2005). Hydrological function of a thin extensive green roof in southern Sweden. Hydrol Res, 36(3), 259–268. [CrossRef]
70. 70. Berndtsson, J. C. (2010). Green roof performance towards management of runoff water quantity and quality: A review. Ecol Eng, 36(4), 351–360. [CrossRef]
71. 71. Villarreal, E. L., & Bengtsson, L. (2005). Response of a Sedum green roof to individual rain events. Ecol Eng, 25(1), 1–7. [CrossRef]
72. 72. Speak, A. F., Rothwell, J. J., Lindley, S. J., & Smith, C. L. (2013). Rainwater runoff retention on an aged intensive green roof. Sci Total Environ, 461, 28–38. [CrossRef]
73. 73. Speak, A. F., Rothwell, J. J., Lindley, S. J., & Smith, C. L. (2014). Metal and nutrient dynamics on an aged intensive green roof. Environ Pollut, 184, 33–43. [CrossRef]
74. 74. Stovin, V., Poe, S., & Berretta, C. (2013). A modelling study of long-term green roof retention performance. J Environ Manage, 131, 206–215. [CrossRef]
75. 75. Stovin, V., Vesuviano, G., & De-Ville, S. (2017). Defining green roof detention performance. Urban Water J, 14(6), 574–588. [CrossRef]
76. 76. Bliss, D. J., Neufeld, R. D., & Ries, R. J. (2009). Storm water runoff mitigation using a green roof. Environ Eng Sci, 26(2), 407–418. [CrossRef]
77. 77. Carter, T., & Fowler, L. (2008). Establishing green roof infrastructure through environmental policy instruments. Environ Manage, 42, 151–164. [CrossRef]
78. 78. Clark, C., Adriaens, P., & Talbot, F. B. (2008). Green roof valuation: A probabilistic economic analysis of environmental benefits. Environ Sci Technol, 42(6), 2155–2161. [CrossRef]
79. 79. Dvorak, B., & Volder, A. (2010). Green roof vegetation for North American ecoregions: A literature review. Landsc Urban Plan, 96(4), 197–213. [CrossRef]
80. 80. Getter, K. L., Rowe, D. B., & Andresen, J. A. (2007). Quantifying the effect of slope on extensive green roof stormwater retention. Ecol Eng, 31(4), 225–231. [CrossRef]
81. 81. Gregoire, B. G., & Clausen, J. C. (2011). Effect of a modular extensive green roof on stormwater runoff and water quality. Ecol Eng, 37(6), 963–969. [CrossRef]
82. 82. Hathaway, A. M., Hunt, W. F., & Jennings, G. D. (2008). A field study of green roof hydrologic and water quality performance. Trans ASABE, 51(1), 37–44. [CrossRef]
83. 83. Li, Y., & Babcock, R. W. Jr. (2014). Green roof hydrologic performance and modeling: A review. Water Sci Technol, 69(4), 727–738. [CrossRef]
84. 84. Moody, S. S., & Sailor, D. J. (2013). Development and application of a building energy performance metric for green roof systems. Energy Build, 60, 262–269. [CrossRef]
85. 85. Niu, H., Clark, C., Zhou, J., & Adriaens, P. (2010). Scaling of economic benefits from green roof implementation in Washington, DC. Environ Sci Technol, 44(11), 4302–4308. [CrossRef]
86. 86. Sailor, D. J. (2008). A green roof model for building energy simulation programs. Energy Build, 40(8), 1466–1478. [CrossRef]
87. 87. Scherba, A., Sailor, D. J., Rosenstiel, T. N., & Wanner, C. C. (2011). Modeling impacts of roof reflectivity, integrated photovoltaic panels, and green roof systems on sensible heat flux into the urban environment. Build Environ, 46(12), 2542–2551. [CrossRef]
88. 88. VanWoert, N. D., Rowe, D. B., Andresen, J. A., Rugh, C. L., Fernandez, R. T., & Xiao, L. (2005). Green roof stormwater retention: Effects of roof surface, slope, and media depth. J Environ Qual, 34(3), 1036–1044. [CrossRef]
89. 89. Guarino, R., Andreucci, M. B., Leone, M., Bretzel, F., Pasta, S., & Catalano, C. (2021). Urban services to ecosystems: An introduction. In C. Catalano, M. B. Andreucci, R. Guarino, F. Bretzel, M. Leone, & S. Pasta (Eds.), Urban services to ecosystems (Future City, Vol. 17). Springer. [CrossRef]
90. 90. Leite, F. R., & Antunes, M. L. P. (2023). Green roof recent designs to runoff control: A review of building materials and plant species used in studies. Ecol Eng, 189, 106924. [CrossRef]
91. 91. Vera, S., Viceco, M., & Jorquera, H. (2021). Effects of biodiversity in green roofs and walls on the capture of fine particulate matter. Urban For Urban Green, 63, 127229. [CrossRef]
92. 92. Muratet, A., Barra, M., Hardion, L., & Chiron, F. (2024). Origins and drivers of roof plant assemblages: Designing green roofs for biodiversity conservation. Urban For Urban Green, 94, 128247. [CrossRef]
93. 93. Li, H., Xiang, Y., Yang, W., Lin, T., Xiao, Q., & Zhang, G. (2024). Green roof development knowledge map: A review of visual analysis using CiteSpace and VOSviewer. Heliyon, 10(3), e24958. [CrossRef]
94. 94. Balasbaneh, A. T., Sher, W., Madun, A., & Ashour, A. (2024). Life cycle sustainability assessment of alternative green roofs: A systematic literature review. Build Environ, 248, 111064. [CrossRef]
95. 95. He, Y., Yu, H., Ozaki, A., & Dong, N. (2020). Thermal and energy performance of green roof and cool roof: A comparison study in Shanghai area. J Clean Prod, 267, 122205. [CrossRef]
96. 96. Liu, W., Zhang, X., Feng, Q., Engel, B. A., & Li, Z. (2023). Substrate moisture variations of extensive green roofs with different structural configurations in a semi-arid region: Observational data and dynamic simulation. J Hydrol, 626, 130133. [CrossRef]
97. 97. Yang, S., Kong, F., Yin, H., Zhang, N., Tan, T., Middel, A., & Liu, H. (2023). Carbon dioxide reduction from an intensive green roof through carbon flux observations and energy consumption simulations. Sustain Cities Soc, 99, 104913. [CrossRef]
98. 98. Wang, M., Yu, H., Liu, Y., Lin, J., Zhong, X., Tang, Y., Guo, H., & Jing, R. (2024). Unlock city-scale energy saving and peak load shaving potential of green roofs by GIS-informed urban building energy modelling. Appl Energy, 366, 123315. [CrossRef]
99. 99. Awakipunda, G. C., Jia, R., Mgimba, M. M., Ngata, M. R., Mmbuji, A. O., Said, A. A., & Yu, L.(2023). A critical review on low salinity waterflooding for enhanced oil recovery: Experimental studies, simulations, and field applications. Geoenergy Sci Eng, 227, 211936. [CrossRef]
100. 100. Pumo, D., Francipane, A., Alongi, F., & Noto, L. V. (2023). The potential of multilayer green roofs for stormwater management in urban areas under semi-arid Mediterranean climate conditions. J Environ Manage, 326, 116643. [CrossRef]
101. 101. Mazzeo, D., Matera, N., Peri, G., & Scaccianoce, G. (2023). Forecasting green roofs’ potential in improving building thermal performance and mitigating urban heat island in the Mediterranean area: An artificial intelligence-based approach. Appl Therm Eng, 222, 119879. [CrossRef]
102. 102. Jahangir, M. H., Zarfeshani, A., & Arast, M. (2024). Investigation of green roofs’ effects on reducing the urban heat islands formation: The case of a municipal district of Tehran City, Iran. Nature-Based Solutions, 5, 100100. [CrossRef]
103. 103. Talwar, P., Verma, N., Khatri, H., Ahire, P. D., Chaudhary, G., Lindenberger, C., & Vivekanand, V.(2023). A systematic review of photovoltaic-green roof systems in different climatic conditions focusing on sustainable cities and societies. Sustain Cities Soc, 98, 104813. [CrossRef]