Cost factors in Zero-Carbon Technologies Applied in Buildings: Nigeria’s Perspective

Abstract

The integration of renewable energy technologies in buildings across Africa is low. Enormous improvements to intrinsic cost drivers affecting their affordability are therefore prerequisite to achieve diffused adoption. In a search for the relevant strategies to improve the adoption of these technologies, this paper appraised critical cost factors inhibiting the affordability of solar photovoltaic (PV) in Nigeria. The research adopted a structured questionnaire survey administered to 480 stakeholders in the building sub-sector and PV value chain. Data reduction tool (factor analysis) determined the components of principal factors critical to the affordability of PV in the research environment. The result showed that the dearth of local competencies, lack of skilled labour, lack of research, lack of locally accessible technologies, high cost of maintenance, foreign exchange fluctuation, and inflation are important drivers of PV costs that must improve to facilitate PV integration in buildings. The strategies to improving PV adoption must stimulate affordability by mitigating technical and economic cost factors. The study recommends strong government incentives using waivers on tariff, education and awareness, training in requisite skills, and local manufacturing of components as prerequisite drivers needed to improve affordability.

Keywords

• affordability
• building
• barriers
• cost
• emerging market
• photovoltaic

References

1. 1. P. A. Nwofe. Need for energy efficient buildings in Nigeria, Int J of Energy and Envi Res vol. 2(3), 2014:1-9.
2. 2. IEA (2017). World energy outlook, International Energy Agency, United States of America.
3. 3. W. Ebhota and P. Tabakov. The place of small hydropower electrification scheme socioeconomic stimulation of Nigeria, Inter J of Low-Carbon Tech 13(4), 2018:1-9.
4. 4. M. Shaaban and J. Petinrin. Renewable energy potentials in Nigeria: Meeting rural energy needs, Renew and Sustain Energy Rev, 29, 2014:72-84.
5. 5. N. Edoma and S. Nwaubani. Energy security challenges in developing African mega-cities: the Lagos experience, Built Envi, 2014:1-9.
6. 6. E. Uyigue. Energy efficiency survey in Nigeria, a guide for developing policy and legislation, Community Research and Development Centre, Benin, Nigeria, 2009.
7. 7. J. Oji, N. Idusuyi, T. Aliu, M. Petinrin, O. Odejobi and A. Adetunji. Utilization of solar energy for power generation in Nigeria. Int J of Energy Eng, 2(2), 2012:54-59.
8. 8. E. Eleri, P. Onuvae, and O. Ugwu. Low carbon energy development in Nigeria: challenges and opportunities. International Centre for Energy, Environment and Development.

9. 9. H.A. Bada. Managing the diffusion and adoption of renewable energy technologies in Nigeria. World Renewable Energy Congress, Sweden, 2011, 8-13 May 2011.
10. 10. A.S. Isa, Y.A. Dodo, H. Ojobo and I.B. Alkali. Deployment of smart technologies for improving energy efficiency in office building in Nigeria. J of Multi Eng Science and Tech, 3(1), 2016:3808- 3811.
11. 11. I.J. Bachellerie. Sustainability and competitiveness: A pragmatic approach to solar energy transition in the GCC Countries. GRC Paper, Gulf Research Centre 2013.
12. 12. N.V. Emodi and N.E. Ebele. Policies Enhancing Renewable Energy Development and Implications for Nigeria. Sustain Energy, 4(1), 2016:7-16.
13. 13. IRENA. (2016), REmap: Roadmap for a Renewable Energy Future, Abu Dhabi: IRENA
14. 14. M. Tripathy, P. Sadhu and S. Panda. A critical review on building integrated photovoltaic products and their applications. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 61, 2016:451-465.
15. 15. H. Chen and S. Riffat. Development of photovoltaic thermal technology in recent years: a review. Int J of Low-Carbon Tech, 6, 2011:1-13.
16. 16. J.N. Mayer. Current and Future Cost of Photovoltaic, Long-Term Scenarios for Market Development, system prices and LCOE of utility-scale PV systems, Agora Energiewende, Germany, 2015.
17. 17. D. Abdullahi, S. Suresh, S. Renukappa and D. Oloke. Key barriers to the implementation of solar energy in Nigeria: a critical analysis. 2nd International Conference on Green Energy Technology (ICGET 2017), IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 2017, vol. 83, p.012015, 2017 doi:10.1088/1755- 1315/83/1/
18. 18. O. K. Akande, O. Fabiyi and I. C. Mark. Sustainable approach to developing energy efficient buildings for resilient future of the built environment in Nigeria. American J of Civ Eng and Archi, 3(4), 2015:144-152 doi: 10.12691/ajcea-3-4-5
19. 19. E. T. Ochedi, A. Taki and B. Painter. Low cost approach to energy efficient buildings in Nigeria: a review of passive design options. 21st Century Habitat: Issues, Sustainability and Development, Proceeding of Joint International Conference (JIC) Book of Abstract, p. 8, 2016.
20. 20. B.M. Manzuma and I. Mbamali. Harnessing solar energy in Nigeria – a review of the prospect and challenges’’, Construction in Developing Countries and its Contribution to Sustainable Development’’, Proceedings of the CIB W107 2014 International Conference, Lagos, Nigeria, pp.493-503, 28th-30th January 2014.
21. 21. Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission [NERC]. Multi-Year Tariff order for the determination of the cost of electricity sold by distribution/retail companies for the period 1June 2012 to 31 May 2017, 2012.
22. a. Shukla AK, Sudhakar K, Baredar P, Mamat, R. Solar PV and BIPV systems: barriers, challenges and policy recommendations in India. Renew and Sustain Energy Rev, 83, 2018:3314-3322
23. b. Alexey, JA, Mikhaylov, EL, Moiseev, N, Ritcher, U, Varyash, I, Dooyum, UD, Oganov, A, Bertelsen, RG, Bioenergy potential in Russia: method of evaluating costs. Int J of Energy Eco and Policy, 9(5), 2019:244-251.
24. c. Goh KC, Yap ABK, Goh HH, Seow TW, Toh TC. Awareness and Initiatives of Building Integrated Photovoltaic (BIPV) implementation in Malaysian Housing Industry. Procedia Eng, 118, 2015:118:1052–9.
25. 22. S. Luong, K. Liu and J. Robey. Sustainability assessment framework for renewable energy technologies. TSBE Conference paper.
26. 23. A. Okafor and C. Joe-Uzoegbu. The challenges to development of renewable energy technologies for electric power sector in Nigeria. Int J of Aca Res, 2, 2010:211-231.
27. 24. H.Y. Yeung. Overview of building integrated photovoltaic installation in Hong Kong government building. Conference on Sustainable Building East Asia, 5-7 November 2007, Malaysia.
28. 25. S. Harrison and L. Jiang. An investigation into the energy performance gap between predicted outputs of photovoltaic systems using software – a case study. Int J of Low-Carbon Tech, 13, 2018:.23-29.
29. 26. J.E. Elusakin, A.O. Olufemi and D.J. Chuks. Challenges of sustaining off-grid power generation in Nigeria rural communities. African J of Eng Res, 2(2), 2014:55-57.
30. 27. L. Gyoh and M. Hugo, Sustainable environmentally responsive passive building in hot humid climate - A case study of PIND Alternative Technology Enabled Development (ATED) Building Warri, Delta State Nigeria’. Paper presented at the Architects Colloquium '13 - Architecture and the National Development Agenda VI. Architects Registration Council or Nigeria (ARCON), Abuja.
31. 28. Kahneman, D. Thinking, Fast and Slow. Macmillan, ISBN 978-1-4299-6935-2, 2011.
32. 29. N.E. Bouhou, Assessing the Performance of Demand-Side Strategies and Renewables: Cost and Energy Implications for Residential Sector, Doctoral Dissertation, Faculty of Graduate School, The University of Texas at Austin, 2015.
33. 30. M.M. Aji, B. Gutti, B. K. Highina, and M.A. Hussaini. Challenges to energy sustainability in Nigeria as a developing nation and the way forward. App Res J, 1(2), 2015:.46-50.
34. 31. T. Olaoye, T. Ajilore, K. Akinluwade, F. Omole, and A. Adetunji. Energy crisis in Nigeria: Need for renewable energy mix. American J of Elec and Elec Eng, 4(1), 2016:1-18.
35. 32. McGraw Hill Construction, Canada green building trends: benefits driving the new and retrofit market, Canada Green Building Council, 2013.
36. 33. E.L. Efurumibe. Barriers to the development of renewable energy in Nigeria. Scholar J of Biotech, 2(1), 2013:11-13.
37. 34. J. Bryne, PV planner a decision analysis tool for solar electric systems, user manual. Centre for Energy and Environmental Policy, University of Delaware, USA Building Design, 2010.
38. 35. H. Sozer and M. Elnimeiri. Sensitivity factors in building integrated photovoltaic (BIPV) System Cost. Proceeding of ISEC 2003, International Solar Energy Conference, Hawaii, USA 15 -18 March, 2003.
39. 36. M.M. Rahman, L. K. Haur and H.Y. Rahman. Building integrated photovoltaic (BIPV) in Malaysia: an economic feasibility study. Elixir Int J of Fin Manag, 45, 2012:7683-7688.
40. 37. F. Cucchiella, I. D’Adamo, M. Gastaldi and S.C.L. Koh. Renewable energy options for buildings: performance evaluations of integrated photovoltaic systems. Energy Build, 55, 2012:208-217.
41. 38. N. Lawton, Shrinking solar soft costs: policy solutions to make solar power economically competitive, Green Energy Institute, Lewis & Clark Law School, USA, 2014.
42. 39. H. Xue, S. Zhang, Y. Su and Z. Wu. Capital cost optimisation for prefabrication: a factor analysis evaluation model’’, Sustainability, 10(159), 2018:1-22 doi:10.3390/su10010159.
43. 40. S. O. Babatunde and S. Perera. Barriers to bond financing for public-private partnership infrastructure projects in emerging markets: a case of Nigeria. J of Fin Manag in Prop and Cons, 22, 2017:2–19.
44. 41. K.W.H. Lee and H. Seung. Quantitative analysis for country classification in the construction industry, J of Manag in Eng, 33, 2017:04017014.
45. 42. M. Shan, Y. Le, K.T. Yiu, A.P. Chan, Y. Hu. Investigating the underlying factors of corruption in the public construction sector: evidence from China. Sci Eng Ethics, 6, 2017:1643–1666.
46. 43. C. Marnewick. Information system project’s sustainability capability levels. Int J Proj Manag, 35, 2017: 1151-1166.
47. 44. D. Cao, H. Li, G. Wang, T. Huang. Identifying and contextualising the motivations for BIM implementation in construction projects: an empirical study in China. Int J Pro Manag, 17(35), 2017:658–669.
48. 45. P. Bonomo, F.P Frontini, D. Berardinis and I. Donsante. BIPV: building envelope solutions in a multi-criteria approach: a method for assessing lifecycle costs in the early design phase. Adv in Build Energy Res, 2016, DOI:10.1080/17512549.2016.1161544.
49. 46. A. Ahmed and K. Gidado. Evaluating the potential of renewable energy technologies for buildings in Nigeria. 24th Annual ARCOM Conference, Cardiff, UK, Association of Researchers in Construction Management, pp.1175-1182, 1-3 September 2008.
50. 47. B. Rezaie, E. Esmailzadeh, and I. Dincer. Renewable energy options for buildings: case studies, Energy and Build, 43, 2012:56-65.
51. 48. I.G. Kelechi, A.M. Zungeru, O.E. Ayobami, H. Habibu and A.F. Olugbenga. Design and modelling of a solar water heating system. Ind Eng Let, 4(12), 2014:70-79.
52. 49. M.G. Prasanna, S.M. Sameer and G. Hemavathi, ‘’Financial analysis of solar photovoltaic power plant in India, IOSR Journal of Economics and Finance (IOSR-JEF), International Conference on Innovative Management Strategies, 9-15, 2014.
53. 50. J. Seel, G. Barbose, W. Ryan, Lawrence, W. and Berkeley National Laboratory, why are residential PV prices in Germany so much lower than in the United States: a scoping analysis, PowerPoint Presentation http://emp.lbl.gov/sites/all/files/german-us-vpriceppt.pdf.retrieved 22nd August,2019.
54. 51. K. Tamer, A review of designing, installing and evaluating standalone photovoltaic power systems’’, J of App Sci, 10(13), 1212-1228.
55. 52. S.M. Abubakar, H.A. Guda and Y. Jibril. Optimal sizing of a standalone photovoltaic power plant and cost comparison with grid and diesel generator for a remote farm. Int J of Eng and Tech, 5(7), 2015:411-420.
56. 53. S. Wei and T. Egbelakin. Adoption of solar grid-tied PV-system adopted in a residential building. Australasian Journal of Construction Economics and Building 2014 Conference Series.
57. 54. Abdullah, DZ, Shah, T, Jebran, K, Ali, S, and Ali, S. Acceptance and willingness to pay for solar home system: survey evidence from northern area of Pakistan. Energy Reports, 3, 2017:54-60.
58. 55. Qureshi, TM, Ullah, K, Aresten, MJ. Factors responsible for solar PV adoption at household level: a case of Lahore, Pakistan. Renew and Sustain Energy Rev, 78, 2017:78, 754-763.
59. 56. Palm, J, Household installation of solar panels-motives and barriers in a 10-year perspective. Energy Policy, 113, 2018:1-8