Suicidal Women: Prevention and Intervention
Strategies
Year 1998,
Volume: 6 Issue: 1, 43 - 53, 01.03.1998
Silvia Sara Canetto
D. Lester
Bedriye Öncü
Abstract
This review focuses on the prevention and intervention
strategies in suicidal women. Differences
of the suicidal behavior literatüre from others
and risk factors in suicide is revievved. The literatüre
on suicidal behavior neglects the fact that the
prototypical suicidal person is a woman. The prevention,
intervention and therapeutic strategies in
suicide is discussed from this point of view.
References
- Albee GW (1986), Tovvard a just society: Lessons
from observations on the primary prevention of psychopathology,
American Psychologist, 41, 891-898.
- Albee GW (1990) The futility of psychotherapy. The
Journal of Mind and behavior 11,369,384.
- Ansel EL, Mc Gee RK (1971), Attitudes tovvard silicide
attemcpters. Bulletin of Suicidology 8, 22-28
- Arcel LT, Mantonakis J, Petersson B, James J & Kaliteraki
E (1991), Suicide attempts among Greek and Danish
vvomen and the quality of their relationships with
husbands and boyfrieds. Açta Pscyhiatrica Scandinavica,
85,189-195.
- Bancroft JH, Skrimshire AM, Simkin S (1986), The
reason people give for taking overdoses. British Journal
of Psychiatry 128, 538-548.
- Bedrosian RC (1986), Cognitive and family intervenfions
for suicidal patient. Journal of Psychotherapy and
the Family 2, 129-152.
- Birtchnell J (1983), Psychotherapeutic considerations
in the management of the suicidal patient. American
Journal of Psychotherapy 37, 24-36.
- Bongar, B. (1991), The suicidal patient: Clinical and
legal standard of çare. Washington DC. American
Psychological Association
- Bostock T, VVilliams CL (1974), Attempted suicide as
an operant behavior. Archives of General Psychiatry 31,
482-486.
- Brovvn LS (1986), Gender role analysis: A neglected
component of psychological assessment. Psychotherapy
23, 243-248.
- Canetto SS (1991), Gender roles, suicide attempts,
and substance abuse. Journal of Psychology 125, 605-
620.
- Canetto SS, Feldman LB (1993), Overt and covert
dependence in suicidal vvomen and their male partnere.
Omega 27,177-194.
- Canetto SS (1992-1993), She died for love and he
for glory: Gender myths of suicidal behavior Omega 26,
1-17.
- Canetto SS (1994), Gender issues in the treatment
of suicidal individuals. Death Studies 18, 513-527.
- CanettoSS, Lester D. (1995), The epidemiology of
vvomen's suicidal behaviors. SS Canetto & D Lester (editörler),
VVomen and suicidal behaviors (sy 35-57) New
York: Springer.
- Çaplan PJ; Hall-McCorquodale I (1985), The
scapegoating of mothers: a cali for change. American
Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 55(4): 610-3.
- Clovvard RA, Piven FF (1979), Hidden protest: The
channeling of female innovation and resistance. Signs.
Journal of VVomen in Culture and Society 4, 651-669.
- Dew MA; Bromet EJ; Brent D; Greenhouse JB
(1987), A quantitative literatüre revievv of the
effectiveness of suicide prevention center. Journal of
Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55 (2): 239-44.
- Dressler DM; Prusoff B; Mark H; Shapiro D (1975),
Clinician attitudes tovvard the suicide attempter. Journal
of Nervous and Mental Disorders, 160 (2-1 ):146-55.
- Farberovv N (1968), Crisis prevention. International
Journal of Psychiatry, 6(57):382-4.
- Frederick CJ; Resnik HL (1971), How suicidal
behaviors are learned. American Journal of
Psychotherapy, 25 (1): 37-55.
- Hawton K; Blackstock E (1976), General practice aspects
of self-poisoning and self-injury. Psychological Medicine,
6(4):571-5.
- Hawton K; O'Grady J; Osborn M; Cole D (1982),
Adolescents who take overdoses: their characteristics'
problems and contacts with helping agencies. British
Journal of Psychiatry, 140:118-23.
- Hendin H (1981): Psychotherapy and suicide. American
Journal of Psychotherapy, 35(4):469-80.
- Hirsch SR; Walsh C; Draper R (1982) Parasuicide. A
revievv of treatment interventions. Journal of Affective Disorders
(4): 299-311.
- Hirsch SR; Walsh C; Draper R (1983), The concept
and efficacy of the treatment of parasuicide. British
Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 15 Suppl 20:189S194S.
- Jack RL; VVilliams JM (1991), Attribution and intervention
in self-poisoning. British Journal of Medical
Psychology, 64 (Pt 4) 0:345-58.
- Kiev A (1975), Psychotherapeutic strategies in the
management of depressed and suicidal patients. American
Journal of Psychotherapy, 29 (3):345-54.
- Lesse S (1975), Fifteenth Emil A. Gutheil Memorial
Conference. The range of therapies in the treatment of
severely depressed suicidal patients. American Journal
of Psychotherapy, 29 (3):308-26.
- Liberman RP; Eckman T (1981), Behavior therapy vs
insight-oriented therapy for repeated suicide attempters.
Archives of General Psychiatry, 38(10): 1126-30.
- Linehan MM; Armstrong HE; Suarez A; Allmon D;
Heard HL (1991), Cognitive-behavioral treatment of
chronically parasuicidal borderline patients. Archives of
General Psychiatry 48 (12): 1060-4.
- Maltsberger JT; Buie DH (1974), Countertransference
hate in the treatment of suicidal patients. Archives of
General Psychiatry, 30(5): 625-33.
- Mclntosh JL (1992), Epidemiology of suicide in the
elderly. Suicide Life Threat Behav, 22 (1):15-35.
- Miller HL; Coombs, DW; Leeper JD; Barton SN
(1984), An analysis of the effects of suicide prevention
facilities on suicide rates in the United States. American
Journal of Public Health, 74 (4):340-3.
- Nidiffer FD(1980), Combining cognitive and behavioral
approaches to suicidal depression: a 42 month follofup.
Psychological Reports, 47 (2): 539-42.
- Novotny P (1972), Self-cutting. Bulletin of Menninger
Clinic, 36(5):505-14.
- Olin HS (1976), Psychotherapy of the chronically
suicidal patient. American Journal of Psychotherapy 30
(4): 570-5.
- Ramon S; Bancroft JH; Skrimshire AM (1975), Attitudes
towards self-poisoning among physicians and nurses
in a general hospital. British Journal of Psychiatry,
127:257-64.
- Richman J; Rosenbaum M (1970), A clinical study of
the role of hostility and death vvishes by the family and
society in suicidal attempts. Isr Ann Psychiatr Relat Discip,
8(3):213-31.
- Salkovskis PM; Atha C; Storer D (1990), Cognitivebehavioural
problem solving in the treatment of patients
who repeatedly attempt suicide. A controlled trial. British
Journal of Psychiatry, 157:871-6.
- Schvvartz DA (1979), The suicidal character, Psychiatry
Q 51(1 ):64-70.
- Schvvartz DA; Flinn DE; Slavvson PF (1974), Treatment
of the suicidal character. American Journal of
Pscyhotherapy 28(2):194-207 .
- Tekavcic-Grad O; Farberov NL; Zavasnik A; Mocnik
M; Korenjak R (1988), Comparison of the two telephone
crisis lines in Los Angeles (USA) and in Ljubljana (Yugoslavia),
Crisis, 9(2): 146-57.
- Wolk-Wasserman D (1985), The intensive çare unit
and the suicide attempt patient. Açta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,
71 (6):581 -95.
- Zich JM (1984), A reciprocal control approach to the
treatment of repeated parasuicide. Suicide and Life
Threatening Behavior, 14 (1):36-51.
SUISIDAL KADINLAR: ÖNLEME VE MÜDAHALE STRATEJİLERİ
Year 1998,
Volume: 6 Issue: 1, 43 - 53, 01.03.1998
Silvia Sara Canetto
D. Lester
Bedriye Öncü
Abstract
İntihar girişiminde bulunan kadınlarda intiharı
önleme ve intihara müdahale yöntemleri üzerinde
durulan bu yazıda, intiharla ilgili çalışmaları diğerlerinden
ayıran özellikler ve intiharla ilgili risk faktörleri
gözden geçirilmiştir. İntihar hakkındaki çalışmalarda
intihar davranışının daha çok kadınlarda
görüldüğü gerçeğinin ihmal edildiği belirtilmiştir.
Ölümle sonuçlanmayan intihar davranışının daha
çok kadınlarda görüldüğü göz önüne alınarak intiharı
önleme, intihara müdahale ve tedavi stratejileri
bu bakış açısı ışığında tartışılmıştır.
References
- Albee GW (1986), Tovvard a just society: Lessons
from observations on the primary prevention of psychopathology,
American Psychologist, 41, 891-898.
- Albee GW (1990) The futility of psychotherapy. The
Journal of Mind and behavior 11,369,384.
- Ansel EL, Mc Gee RK (1971), Attitudes tovvard silicide
attemcpters. Bulletin of Suicidology 8, 22-28
- Arcel LT, Mantonakis J, Petersson B, James J & Kaliteraki
E (1991), Suicide attempts among Greek and Danish
vvomen and the quality of their relationships with
husbands and boyfrieds. Açta Pscyhiatrica Scandinavica,
85,189-195.
- Bancroft JH, Skrimshire AM, Simkin S (1986), The
reason people give for taking overdoses. British Journal
of Psychiatry 128, 538-548.
- Bedrosian RC (1986), Cognitive and family intervenfions
for suicidal patient. Journal of Psychotherapy and
the Family 2, 129-152.
- Birtchnell J (1983), Psychotherapeutic considerations
in the management of the suicidal patient. American
Journal of Psychotherapy 37, 24-36.
- Bongar, B. (1991), The suicidal patient: Clinical and
legal standard of çare. Washington DC. American
Psychological Association
- Bostock T, VVilliams CL (1974), Attempted suicide as
an operant behavior. Archives of General Psychiatry 31,
482-486.
- Brovvn LS (1986), Gender role analysis: A neglected
component of psychological assessment. Psychotherapy
23, 243-248.
- Canetto SS (1991), Gender roles, suicide attempts,
and substance abuse. Journal of Psychology 125, 605-
620.
- Canetto SS, Feldman LB (1993), Overt and covert
dependence in suicidal vvomen and their male partnere.
Omega 27,177-194.
- Canetto SS (1992-1993), She died for love and he
for glory: Gender myths of suicidal behavior Omega 26,
1-17.
- Canetto SS (1994), Gender issues in the treatment
of suicidal individuals. Death Studies 18, 513-527.
- CanettoSS, Lester D. (1995), The epidemiology of
vvomen's suicidal behaviors. SS Canetto & D Lester (editörler),
VVomen and suicidal behaviors (sy 35-57) New
York: Springer.
- Çaplan PJ; Hall-McCorquodale I (1985), The
scapegoating of mothers: a cali for change. American
Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 55(4): 610-3.
- Clovvard RA, Piven FF (1979), Hidden protest: The
channeling of female innovation and resistance. Signs.
Journal of VVomen in Culture and Society 4, 651-669.
- Dew MA; Bromet EJ; Brent D; Greenhouse JB
(1987), A quantitative literatüre revievv of the
effectiveness of suicide prevention center. Journal of
Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55 (2): 239-44.
- Dressler DM; Prusoff B; Mark H; Shapiro D (1975),
Clinician attitudes tovvard the suicide attempter. Journal
of Nervous and Mental Disorders, 160 (2-1 ):146-55.
- Farberovv N (1968), Crisis prevention. International
Journal of Psychiatry, 6(57):382-4.
- Frederick CJ; Resnik HL (1971), How suicidal
behaviors are learned. American Journal of
Psychotherapy, 25 (1): 37-55.
- Hawton K; Blackstock E (1976), General practice aspects
of self-poisoning and self-injury. Psychological Medicine,
6(4):571-5.
- Hawton K; O'Grady J; Osborn M; Cole D (1982),
Adolescents who take overdoses: their characteristics'
problems and contacts with helping agencies. British
Journal of Psychiatry, 140:118-23.
- Hendin H (1981): Psychotherapy and suicide. American
Journal of Psychotherapy, 35(4):469-80.
- Hirsch SR; Walsh C; Draper R (1982) Parasuicide. A
revievv of treatment interventions. Journal of Affective Disorders
(4): 299-311.
- Hirsch SR; Walsh C; Draper R (1983), The concept
and efficacy of the treatment of parasuicide. British
Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 15 Suppl 20:189S194S.
- Jack RL; VVilliams JM (1991), Attribution and intervention
in self-poisoning. British Journal of Medical
Psychology, 64 (Pt 4) 0:345-58.
- Kiev A (1975), Psychotherapeutic strategies in the
management of depressed and suicidal patients. American
Journal of Psychotherapy, 29 (3):345-54.
- Lesse S (1975), Fifteenth Emil A. Gutheil Memorial
Conference. The range of therapies in the treatment of
severely depressed suicidal patients. American Journal
of Psychotherapy, 29 (3):308-26.
- Liberman RP; Eckman T (1981), Behavior therapy vs
insight-oriented therapy for repeated suicide attempters.
Archives of General Psychiatry, 38(10): 1126-30.
- Linehan MM; Armstrong HE; Suarez A; Allmon D;
Heard HL (1991), Cognitive-behavioral treatment of
chronically parasuicidal borderline patients. Archives of
General Psychiatry 48 (12): 1060-4.
- Maltsberger JT; Buie DH (1974), Countertransference
hate in the treatment of suicidal patients. Archives of
General Psychiatry, 30(5): 625-33.
- Mclntosh JL (1992), Epidemiology of suicide in the
elderly. Suicide Life Threat Behav, 22 (1):15-35.
- Miller HL; Coombs, DW; Leeper JD; Barton SN
(1984), An analysis of the effects of suicide prevention
facilities on suicide rates in the United States. American
Journal of Public Health, 74 (4):340-3.
- Nidiffer FD(1980), Combining cognitive and behavioral
approaches to suicidal depression: a 42 month follofup.
Psychological Reports, 47 (2): 539-42.
- Novotny P (1972), Self-cutting. Bulletin of Menninger
Clinic, 36(5):505-14.
- Olin HS (1976), Psychotherapy of the chronically
suicidal patient. American Journal of Psychotherapy 30
(4): 570-5.
- Ramon S; Bancroft JH; Skrimshire AM (1975), Attitudes
towards self-poisoning among physicians and nurses
in a general hospital. British Journal of Psychiatry,
127:257-64.
- Richman J; Rosenbaum M (1970), A clinical study of
the role of hostility and death vvishes by the family and
society in suicidal attempts. Isr Ann Psychiatr Relat Discip,
8(3):213-31.
- Salkovskis PM; Atha C; Storer D (1990), Cognitivebehavioural
problem solving in the treatment of patients
who repeatedly attempt suicide. A controlled trial. British
Journal of Psychiatry, 157:871-6.
- Schvvartz DA (1979), The suicidal character, Psychiatry
Q 51(1 ):64-70.
- Schvvartz DA; Flinn DE; Slavvson PF (1974), Treatment
of the suicidal character. American Journal of
Pscyhotherapy 28(2):194-207 .
- Tekavcic-Grad O; Farberov NL; Zavasnik A; Mocnik
M; Korenjak R (1988), Comparison of the two telephone
crisis lines in Los Angeles (USA) and in Ljubljana (Yugoslavia),
Crisis, 9(2): 146-57.
- Wolk-Wasserman D (1985), The intensive çare unit
and the suicide attempt patient. Açta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,
71 (6):581 -95.
- Zich JM (1984), A reciprocal control approach to the
treatment of repeated parasuicide. Suicide and Life
Threatening Behavior, 14 (1):36-51.