Theoretical Justifications of the Right to Free Speech in the Digital Era
Abstract
Speech is information and communication expressing thoughts, ideas or emotions such as science, poetry, politics, promises, answers, complaints, etc. It is fundamental for individual and social levels to interact. The right to free speech with various theoretical justifications, such as self-fulfillment, personal autonomy, the marketplace for ideas, the search for truth, democracy, tolerance, and pluralism, is the integral existence of individuals and society. These justifications reflect the interrelation between the right to freedom of speech and other rights. Free speech causes individual and social good by achieving these justifications, yet it may result in harmful consequences or conflict with other rights. The digital era advances a new medium to promote the right to free speech within cyberspace. This era shapes individuals and social interrelation for specific ideas and actions in a short time. This represents communication in a new form through the internet, information, and communication technologies rather than print and broadcasting. The international system has been established based on expanding and diffusing cyberspace. Therefore, the coherence of these justifications is analysed within the recent digital transformation process, creating positive and negative impacts on freedom of speech.
Keywords
References
- Abrams v. United States, 250 U.S. 616, 630 (1919) (Holmes, J., dissenting).
- Austin, J. L. (1962). How to Do Things with Words. Oxford, Clarendon Press.
- Baker, Edwin. (2011). Is Democracy a Sound Basis for a Free Speech Principle? Virginia Law Review, Vol: 97, 515-528.
- Balkin, Jack. (2004). How Rights Change: Freedom of Speech in the Digital Era, Sydney Law Review, Vol 26, 1-11.
- Balkin, Jack. (2004a). Commentary, Digital Speech, and Democratic Culture: A Theory of Freedom of Expression for the Information Society. New York University Law Review. Vol. 79 (1): 1-55
- Barendt, Eric. (2005). Freedom of Speech. Second Ed, Oxford University Press.
- Bollinger, Lee C. (1986). The Tolerant Society. Oxford University Press.
- Brewer, Judy. (2017). ‘Standards Bodies, Access to Information Technology, and Human Rights’ in Lazar Jonathan, and Stein Michael Ashley, (Eds) Disability, Human Rights, and Information Technology, University of Pennsylvania Press.
- Chevigny, Paul G. (1980). Philosophy of Language and Free Expression. New York University Law Review, Vol. 55, 157-194.
- Cohen-Almagor, Raphael. (2006). The Scope of Tolerance Studies on the Costs of Free Expression and Freedom of the Press. Routledge.