The ethical principles and publication policies of Mebde Journal of Scholarly Research have been established in accordance with the guidelines and policies published by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).
Actions Constituting Violations of Scientific Research and Publication Ethics
• Plagiarism: Presenting the original ideas, methods, data, or works of others, in whole or in part, as one's own without providing appropriate citations in accordance with established scholarly standards.
• Fabrication: Using nonexistent or falsified data in scientific research.
• Falsification: Manipulating research records or collected data; falsely claiming to have used equipment or materials that were not actually employed in the research; or altering or shaping research findings to serve the interests of individuals or institutions providing support.
• Duplicate Publication: Presenting duplicate publications as separate scholarly outputs for the purposes of academic appointment or promotion.
• Salami Slicing (Fragmented Publication): Inappropriately dividing the findings of a single research project into multiple publications in a manner that compromises the integrity of the research and presenting these publications as separate scholarly outputs for academic appointment or promotion.
• Inappropriate Authorship: Including individuals who have made no substantive contribution to a study as authors; excluding individuals who have made substantive contributions; changing the order of authors without appropriate justification; removing the names of legitimate contributors from subsequent editions; or using personal or institutional influence to secure authorship without having made a substantive contribution to the research.
Other Forms of Ethical Misconduct
a) Failing to acknowledge individuals, institutions, or organizations that have provided financial or other forms of support for research, or failing to disclose the nature of their contributions in publications resulting from such research.
b) Using theses or research works that have not yet been submitted or formally defended and approved as sources without obtaining permission from their authors.
c) Disclosing information contained in a manuscript assigned for review to third parties before its publication without the explicit permission of the author.
ç) Using resources, facilities, infrastructure, or equipment allocated for scientific research for purposes other than those for which they were provided.
d) Knowingly making unfounded, unjustified, or malicious allegations of ethical misconduct.
e) Publishing data obtained through surveys or attitude studies without securing the informed consent of participants or, where the research is conducted within an institution, without obtaining the necessary institutional authorization.
f) Failing to fulfil the obligation to inform and warn relevant parties about potentially harmful practices associated with scientific research.
g) Using data or information obtained from other individuals or institutions beyond the scope of the authorization granted, failing to maintain their confidentiality, or failing to ensure their appropriate protection.
h) Making false or misleading statements concerning scientific research and publications in academic appointment or promotion procedures.
Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
Editors may consider issuing a correction when minor errors are identified in a published article that do not affect its findings, interpretations, or conclusions.
Where serious errors or ethical violations invalidate the findings or conclusions of a published article, editors should consider retracting the publication.
Editors may consider publishing an expression of concern when there are indications of possible research or publication misconduct by the authors, when evidence suggests that the findings are unreliable and the authors' institutions have failed to investigate the matter, or when a potential investigation appears likely to be unfair or inconclusive.
The journal follows the relevant COPE guidelines concerning corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern.
Relationships with the Journal Owner and Publisher
The relationship between the editors and the publisher is based on the principle of editorial independence.
In accordance with the written agreement between the editors and the publisher, all editorial decisions are made independently of the publisher and the journal owner.
Protection of Intellectual Property Rights
The journal is responsible for protecting the intellectual property rights associated with all published articles and for safeguarding the rights of both the journal and its authors in cases of potential infringement.
Protection of Participants' Personal Data
All personal data submitted to the journal are protected in accordance with applicable legal regulations and ethical principles.
Conflicts of Interest
The journal takes into account potential conflicts of interest involving authors, reviewers, and editors and ensures that the publication process is conducted independently and impartially.
Ethics Committee Approval
The journal requires prior approval from the relevant ethics committee for all research involving activities or procedures that require ethical authorization, regardless of the academic discipline.
Information concerning ethics committee approval, including the name of the approving committee, the date of approval, and the approval or decision number, must be explicitly stated in the manuscript.
In accordance with the regulations implemented by ULAKBİM TR Dizin since 2020, manuscripts requiring ethics committee approval will not be considered for evaluation unless the necessary approval has been obtained.
Research Requiring Ethics Committee Approval
Research requiring ethics committee approval includes the following:
• All studies employing qualitative or quantitative research methods that involve collecting data from participants through surveys, interviews, focus groups, observation, or similar research techniques.
• Retrospective studies falling within the scope of the applicable legislation on the protection of personal data.
For such studies to be considered for evaluation, the relevant ethics committee approvals must have been obtained, and information concerning these approvals must be explicitly provided in the manuscript.
Plagiarism Action Plan and Preventive Measures
The journal respects intellectual property rights and seeks to protect and promote the originality of its authors' scholarly contributions.
Manuscripts containing plagiarism are incompatible with established standards of academic quality, research integrity, and scholarly originality. Accordingly, all authors submitting manuscripts to the journal are expected to comply with ethical standards and avoid plagiarism in any form.
Where plagiarism is suspected in a submitted or published manuscript, the case will first be examined by the journal's Ethics Editor. The matter will subsequently be reviewed by the Editorial Board.
Following this assessment, the journal will contact the author(s) and request that they submit an explanation within two weeks.
If no response is received within the specified period, the journal will contact the university with which the author is affiliated and request an investigation into the allegations.
The journal screens submitted manuscripts for plagiarism. Following the initial editorial screening, manuscripts are checked for textual similarity using iThenticate or Turnitin software.
If plagiarism or self-plagiarism is detected, the authors will be notified.
Where necessary, editors may subject manuscripts to additional plagiarism checks at various stages of the peer-review or publication process.
A high similarity score may result in the rejection of a manuscript before acceptance or even after it has been accepted for publication.
The journal expects the overall similarity rate to remain below 20%.
Appeals, Complaints, and Reports of Ethical Misconduct
Readers who identify significant errors or inaccuracies in articles published by the journal, or who wish to raise concerns regarding editorial content, including plagiarism, duplicate publication, appeals, complaints, or other potential ethical violations, may submit their concerns by email to ekoc@agri.edu.tr.
All appeals, complaints, and reports of ethical misconduct submitted to the journal will be evaluated in accordance with the relevant COPE principles and guidelines.