Pedagogical Analysis of Weiss’s D Minor Passacaglia for Classical Guitar: Structure, Interpretation, and Teaching Application

Year 2025, Volume: 13 Issue: 4, 421 - 441

Jiaqi Wu , Yew Yoong Chong

Abstract

Abstract
This article presents a pedagogically oriented analysis of the D Minor Passacaglia from Sylvius Leopold Weiss’s Suite No. 13, with a specific focus on its interpretive potential and instructional relevance for modern classical guitar education. While Weiss's lute compositions embody remarkable technical complexity and refined musical expression, they are often underrepresented in both performance practice and guitar pedagogy, especially when compared to the more widely adopted works of J.S. Bach. By offering a close examination of the structural logic and expressive detail embedded in this Passacaglia, this study highlights the educational value inherent in Weiss’s music.The research systematically explores melodic development, harmonic progressions, and rhythmic characteristics, particularly the use of hemiola, to uncover key pedagogical opportunities. Attention is also given to idiomatic ornamentation based on historical practices, demonstrating how such stylistic features can be effectively adapted for the modern guitar while respecting the Baroque idiom. The study proposes fingering strategies and interpretive techniques that facilitate the preservation of voice-leading clarity and rhythmic continuity, making the work more accessible to students and performers.The methodology integrates score analysis, comparison of existing transcriptions, and practical experimentation on the instrument. This combination allows for a nuanced discussion that addresses both theoretical considerations and real-world application in teaching contexts. The article argues for the inclusion of Weiss’s repertoire as a valuable resource within classical guitar curricula, providing both artistic depth and stylistic diversity. By situating the Passacaglia as a bridge between lute traditions and modern guitar interpretation, the study seeks to support educators in guiding students toward historically informed yet technically coherent performances.Ultimately, the article contributes to the broader discourse on Baroque performance pedagogy and encourages a re-evaluation of underexplored repertoire in music education. The findings offer important practical implications for curriculum design, repertoire selection, and the cultivation of stylistic awareness in the teaching studio.

Keywords

weiss , performance pedagogy , classical guitar education , baroque ornamentation , passacaglia , hemiola rhythm

Ethical Statement

This research does not require ethics committee approval

Supporting Institution

There is no funding support for the research

Thanks

The under representation of Sylvius Leopold Weiss’s (1687-1750) compositions in classical guitar pedagogy, despite their exceptional musical quality and technical sophistication, presents a significant gap in baroque performance education. This study addresses the pedagogical potential of Weiss’s D major passacaglia from suite no. 13, examining its structural complexity and interpretive possibilities for modern classical guitar instruction. The research aims to demonstrate how this historically significant work can enhance baroque performance pedagogy while providing practical solutions for technical and interpretive challenges. The methodology employs qualitative music analysis combined with practical performance validation. The analytical framework examines harmonic progressions, melodic development, and rhythmic characteristics, particularly focusing on hemiola patterns and their pedagogical implications. Fingering strategies were developed through comparative analysis of existing editions, with particular attention to the Edson Lopes (2012) transcription. Ornamentation practices were investigated based on eighteenth-century performance traditions and adapted for modern guitar technique. Key findings reveal that the passacaglia’s fixed bass structure provides an ideal framework for teaching voice-leading concepts, while its variation form offers progressive technical challenges suitable for intermediate to advanced students. The study identifies specific pedagogical benefits including the development of polyphonic awareness, baroque ornamentation skills, and historical performance practice understanding. Practical fingering solutions address common technical obstacles while maintaining musical integrity and stylistic authenticity. The research demonstrates that Weiss’s repertoire offers valuable alternatives to the commonly used Bach transcriptions, providing music originally conceived for plucked strings. These findings support curriculum diversification in classical guitar education and contribute to the preservation of baroque lute traditions. The study recommends integrating such works into structured pedagogical programs, offering educators evidence-based approaches to expanding student repertoire while maintaining rigorous musical and technical standards.

Historical Performance practice and pedagogical adaptation for classical guitar: Ornamentation and fingering in Sylvius Leopold Weiss’s Passacaglia in D Major

Abstract

The under representation of Sylvius Leopold Weiss’s (1687-1750) compositions in classical guitar pedagogy, despite their exceptional musical quality and technical sophistication, presents a significant gap in baroque performance education. This study addresses the pedagogical potential of Weiss’s D major passacaglia from suite no. 13, examining its structural complexity and interpretive possibilities for modern classical guitar instruction. The research aims to demonstrate how this historically significant work can enhance baroque performance pedagogy while providing practical solutions for technical and interpretive challenges. The methodology employs qualitative music analysis combined with practical performance validation. The analytical framework examines harmonic progressions, melodic development, and rhythmic characteristics, particularly focusing on hemiola patterns and their pedagogical implications. Fingering strategies were developed through comparative analysis of existing editions, with particular attention to the Edson Lopes (2012) transcription. Ornamentation practices were investigated based on eighteenth-century performance traditions and adapted for modern guitar technique. Key findings reveal that the passacaglia’s fixed bass structure provides an ideal framework for teaching voice-leading concepts, while its variation form offers progressive technical challenges suitable for intermediate to advanced students. The study identifies specific pedagogical benefits including the development of polyphonic awareness, baroque ornamentation skills, and historical performance practice understanding. Practical fingering solutions address common technical obstacles while maintaining musical integrity and stylistic authenticity. The research demonstrates that Weiss’s repertoire offers valuable alternatives to the commonly used Bach transcriptions, providing music originally conceived for plucked strings. These findings support curriculum diversification in classical guitar education and contribute to the preservation of baroque lute traditions. The study recommends integrating such works into structured pedagogical programs, offering educators evidence-based approaches to expanding student repertoire while maintaining rigorous musical and technical standards.

Keywords

baroque performance , classical guitar pedagogy , historical performance practice , music education , passacaglia analysis , weiss transcription

Ethical Statement

This research does not require ethics committee approval

Supporting Institution

There is no funding support for the research

Thanks

I would like to extend my sincere gratitude to my supervisor Dr. Chong Yew Yoong for guiding me and helping me review the article, and Dr. Aaron Pergram, whose invaluable support has been crucial in the development of this thesis. His assistance in integrating and supplementing literature, as well as his insightful advice on paragraph structuring, has greatly enriched the work. Dr. Pergram’s profound expertise has clarified numerous concepts and enhanced the logical organization of the paper. His careful proofreading of academic terminology has also been immensely helpful. Additionally, I am deeply appreciative of Mr. Tal Hurwitz for his dedicated guidance on the practical application of ornamentation in lute and guitar performance, which has contributed to a balanced approach between musicality and technique.

References

• Amos, C.N. (1975). Lute practice and lutenists in Germany between 1500 and 1750. Doctoral dissertation. University of Iowa. US.
• Asmayawati, Yufiarti, & Yetti, E. (2024). Pedagogical innovation and curricular adaptation in enhancing digital literacy: A local wisdom approach for sustainable development in Indonesia context. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 10(1), 100233. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.joitmc.2024.100233 Bach, J.S. (1994). Das Lautenwerk und verwandte Kompositionen im Urtext, für Gitarre (T. Hoppstock, Ed.). Prim- Musikverlag.
• Baron, E.G. (1976). Historisch‐theoretisch und practische Untersuchung des Instruments der Lauten (Historical‐ theoretical and practical investigation of the lute). Amsterdam: Frits Knuf. (Original work published 1727)
• Besard, B.T.J. (1975). Thesaurus Harmonious (Cologne, 1603). Facs. Geneva: Minkoff.
• Crawford, T. (1992). Review of Pièces de Luth; Los Seis Libros del Delphín de Música; Solo Guitar Music, by S. L. Weiss, H. Smith, L. de Narváez, L. Eisenhardt, M. Giuliani, & D. Starobin. Early Music, 20(3), 515–518. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3127730
• Del Barrio, L., & Arús, M. E. (2024). Music and movement pedagogy in basic education: a systematic review. Frontiers in Education, 9:1403745. https://doi.org/10.3389/ feduc.2024.1403745
• Donington, R. (1974). The Performance of Baroque Music. Music and Letters, 55(4), 509-b.
• González-Zamar, M.D., & Abad-Segura, E. (2021). Emotional creativity in art education: An exploratory analysis and research trends. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(12), 6209. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18126209
• Hilton, W. (1986). Dances to music by Jean- Baptiste Lully. Early Music, 14(4), 500–509. https://doi.org/10.1093/earlyj/14.4.500
• Julian Rushton (2001), “Hemiola [hemiolia] (from Gk. hemilios: ‘the whole and a half’; Lat. sesquialtera; It.: emiolia),” Grove Music Online, https://doi.org/10.1093/ gmo/9781561592630.article.12768
• Kalniņa, D., Nīmante, D., & Baranova, S. (2024). Artificial intelligence for higher education: Benefits and challenges for pre- service teachers. Frontiers in Education, 9:1501819. https://doi.org/10.3389/ feduc.2024.1501819
• Legl, F. (2000). Zwischen Grottkau und Neuburg – Neues zur Biographie von Silvius Leopold Weiss. Jahrbuch der Deutschen Lautengesellschaft, 4, 1–40. Retrieved from https://www.lautengesellschaft.de
• Neumann, F. (1983). Ornamentation in Baroque and Post‐Baroque Music: With special emphasis on J. S. Bach. Princeton University Press.
• Nevile, J. (2019). Baroque Dance. The Oxford Handbook of the Baroque, 264.
• Poulton, D. (1982). John Dowland. Berkeley: University of California Press.
• Quantz, J. J. (1966). On playing the flute (ER Reilly, Trans.). Mcmillan Company. (Original work published 1752).
• Serrano, R. (2016). Guidelines for transcription of Baroque lute music for the modern guitar, using Silvius Leopold Weiss’s Sonata 36 (from the Dresden manuscript) as a model. Doctoral dissertation. University of Arizona. US.
• Smiles, J. E. (1976). Improvised ornamentation in late 18th century music: An examination of contemporary evidence. University Microfilms.
• Spitzer, J., & Zaslaw, N. (1986). Improvised Ornamentation in Eighteenth-Century Orchestras. Journal of the American Musicological Society, 39(3), 524-577. https://doi.org/10.2307/831627
• Weber, W. (1999). The history of musical canon. In Rethinking Music (Eds. Nicholas Cook and Mark Everist). Oxford University Press.
• Weiss, S. L. (n.d.). Passacaglia (Transcribed for guitar by Edson Lopes). Retrieved from https://imslp.org/wiki/Passacalle,_ WeissSW_18.6_(Weiss,_Sylvius_Leopold)
• Weiss, S. L. (n.d.). Passagaille from Suite XII: Score and fingering.
• Werner, A., & Kuusi, T. (2025). Gender equality discourse in classical music higher education: Women, individualisation, and change. International Journal of Music Education, 43(2), 256-268. https://doi. org/10.1177/02557614231199473