School Leadership and Gender in Africa: A Systematic Overview

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to report the findings of a systematic review of school leadership and gender in Africa, and to identify gaps in the literature, to prompt and encourage further research. The literature search focused based on school leadership and gender, linked to all 54 African countries. The review focused on articles in non-predatory journals, plus university theses. The review provides a compelling picture of school leadership and gender in Africa, with three main findings. First, there is limited knowledge production on this important topic, with no sources identified in most African countries. Second, organisational, social and personal factors combine to inhibit women's accession to school leadership. Third, African women principals are shown to be more collegial and collaborative than men, with some evidence that they may be more effective school leaders. The article’s conclusion draws out three main implications. First, the findings indicate a strong need for ministries of education to review their recruitment and selection policies to address barriers to women's accession as school principals. Second, they show deeply embedded social attitudes that women should be focused on domestic and family responsibilities, rather than school leadership. This calls for community education programmes to address family and social attitudes. Third, while the article presents a significant picture of the extent and nature of women principals' leadership accession and enactment across the continent, further research is recommended to address knowledge gaps, especially in those African countries where there is no knowledge production on school leadership and gender.

Keywords

• Africa
• gender
• principals
• school leadership

References

1. Aladejana, F. and Aladejana, T. I. (2005), Leadership in education: The place of Nigerian women, International Studies in Educational Administration, 33 (2): 69-75.
2. Amakyi, M. and Ampah-Mensah, A. (2021), Changing cultural norms through educational leadership: Voices from Ghanaian women principals, Educational Leadership Faculty Publications. 269. https://ecommons.udayton.edu/eda_fac_pub/269
3. Arar, K. (2019), The challenges involved when Arab women forge a path to educational leadership: Context, personal cost, and coping, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 47 (5): 749-765.
4. Armstrong, D. and Mitchell, C. (2017), Shifting identities: Negotiating intersections of race and gender in Canadian administrative contexts, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 45 (5): 825-841.
5. Brion, C. and Ampah-Mensah, A. (2021), Changing Cultural Norms through Educational Leadership: Voices from Ghanian Women Principals, Educational Leadership Faculty Publications, 269. Bush, T. (2020), Theories of Educational Leadership and Management: Fifth Edition, London: Sage.
6. Chabaya, O., Rembe, S. and Wadesango, N. (2009), The persistence of gender inequality in Zimbabwe: factors that impede the advancement of women into leadership positions in primary schools, South African Journal of Education, 29 (2): 235-251
7. Coleman, M. (1996), The management style of female headteachers, Educational Management and Administration, 24 (2): 163-174.
8. Coleman, M. (2012), Leadership and diversity, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 40 (5): 592-609.

9. Dagnew, A., Yirdaw, A. and Asrat, S. (2020), Challenges that contribute to low participation of women in educational leadership at government primary schools, Ethiopia, Contemporary Educational Research Journal, 10 (1): 109–122.
10. Faulkner, C. (2015), Women’s experience of principalship in two South African high schools in multiply deprived rural areas: A life history approach, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 43 (3): 418-432.
11. Garcia-Rodriguez, M., Carmona, J., Fernandez-Serrat, M. and Teixido-Saballs, J. (2020), Spanish principals: Motives for accession and difficulties in accessing their role, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 48 (1): 45-63. Guihen, L. (2019), The career experiences -and aspirations of women deputy headteachers, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 47 (4): 538-554.
12. Hockett, E. (2021), Women in leadership: a study of five Kenyan principals and their challenges as leaders, SN Social Sciences, 1: 177.
13. Hygin, K. and Ayena, F. (2021), Career paths of women in the education systems in the Βénin: Analysis by gender in primary and secondary education, Research Project (Government of Benin).
14. Jones, D. (2017), Constructing identities: Female head teachers’ perceptions and experiences in the primary sector, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 45 (6): 907-928..
15. Komiti, M. and Moorosi, P. (2020), Career development of women principals in Lesotho: Influences, opportunities, and challenges. Journal of Education (University of KwaZulu-Natal), 79: 95-114.
16. Larusdottir, S. (2007), ‘The fact that I’m a woman may have been a deciding factor’: The moral dilemmas of an Icelandic headteacher, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 35 (2): 261-276.
17. Leithwood, K., Day, C., Sammons, P., Harris, A. and Hopkins, D. (2006), Seven Strong Claims about Successful School Leadership, Nottingham: NCSL.
18. Lopez, A. and Rugano, P. (2018) Educational leadership in post-colonial contexts: What can we learn from the experiences of three female principals in Kenyan Secondary Schools? Educational Sciences, 8: 1-18.
19. Lumby, J. (2015), School leaders’ gender strategies, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 43 (1): 28–45.
20. Mapolisa, T.M., Mhlanga, E., Madziyire, N.C. and Chimbwadzwa, Z. (2015), Female leadership dilemmas in primary schools: A case study of primary schools in Harare province in Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe Journal of Educational Research, 25 (2): 261-271.
21. Martinez, M., Molina-Lopez, M. and de Cabo, M. (2021), Explaining the gender gap in school principalship: A tale of two sides, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 49 (6): 863-882.
22. Mbpera, J. (2015) An Exploration of the Influences of Female Underrepresentation in Senior Leadership Positions in Community Secondary Schools (CSSs) in Rural Tanzania, Ph.D. thesis, UCL.
23. Mberia, A.W (2017), Women and leadership in mixed secondary schools in Kenya: Do stakeholders’ attitudes matter? International Journal of Social Science Research, 5 (1): 39-52
24. Moorosi P. (2010), South African females career paths: understanding the gender gap in secondary school management, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 38 (5): 547-562.
25. Moorosi, P., Fuller, K. and Reilly, E. (2018), Leadership and intersectionality: Constructions of successful leadership among Black women school principals in three different contexts, Management in Education, 32 (4): 152–159
26. Moyo, Z. and Perumal, J. (2019), Disadvantaged school contexts and female school leadership in Zimbabwe, International Journal of African Renaissance Studies - Multi-, Inter- and Transdisciplinarity, 14 (1): 83-105.
27. Moyo, Z., Perumal, J. and Hallinger, P. (2020), Struggling to make a difference against the odds: a synthesis of qualitative research on women leading schools in Zimbabwe, International Journal of Educational Management, 34 (10): 1577-1594.
28. Murakami, E. and Tornsen, M. (2017), Female secondary school principals: Equity in the development of professional identities, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 45 (5): 790—805.
29. Ndebele, C. (2018), Gender and School Leadership: Breaking the Glass Ceiling in South Africa. Multidisciplinary Journal of Gender Studies, 7 (2), 1582-1605.
30. Nosike, A. and Oguzor, N. (2011), Motivating the Nigerian academic and non-academic staff for sustainable higher education: Insights for policy options. Perspectives of Innovations, Economics and Business, 62–65.
31. Oyedele,V., Mamvuto, A. and Nhiwatiwa, L. (2010), Teachers’ perceptions on the effectiveness of women leadership in Mutare district schools, Zimbabwe Journal of Educational Research, 22 (2): 170- 179.
32. Shaked, H., Gross, Z. and Glanz, J. (2020), Between Venus and Mars: Sources of gender differences in instructional leadership, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, 48 (5): 821=839.
33. Shapira, T., Arar, K. and Azaiza, F. (2011), ‘They didn’t consider me and no-one even took me into account’: Female school principals in the Arab education system in Israel, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 39 (1): 25-43.
34. Shava, G.N., Tlou, F.N. and Mpofu, M. (2109), Challenges facing women in school leadership positions: Experiences from a district in Zimbabwe, Journal of Education and Practice, 10 (14): 30-41.
35. Showunmi, V., Atewologun, B. and Bebbington, D. (2016), Ethnic, gender and class intersections in British women’s leadership experiences, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 44 (6); 917-935.
36. Smit, B. (2013), Female leadership in a rural school: A feminist perspective, Studies of Tribes and Tribals, 11 (1): 89–96.
37. Smith, J. (2011), Agency and female teachers’ career decisions: A life history study of 40 women, Educational Management Administration and Leadership, 39 (1): 7-24. Sperandio, J. and Kagoda, A.M. (2010), Women teachers’ aspirations to school leadership in Uganda, International Journal of Educational Management, 24 (1): 22–33.
38. Weinstein, J., Sembler, M., Weinstein, M., Marfan, J., Valenzuela, P. and Munoz, G. (2021), A female advantage: Gender and educational leadership practices in urban primary schools in Chile, Educational Management, Administration and Leadership, https://doi-org/10.1177/17411432211019407.
39. Zikhali, J. and Perumal, J. (2016), Leading in disadvantaged Zimbabwean school contexts: Female school heads’ experiences of emotional labour, Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 44, 347–362.