The Case of Jamal Khashoggi and the Right to Life

Year 2025, Volume: 13 Issue: 1, 317 - 329, 10.07.2025

Murat Balcı , Kerim Çakır

https://doi.org/10.56701/shd.1486671

Abstract

The right to life imposes two main responsibilities on states. On one hand, states are charged with a negative obligation, which implies that states shall refrain from violating the right to life of the people in their territories. On the other hand, states have the positive obligation to ensure effective security that allows people to enjoy their right to life. In other words, states are obligated to protect the people in their territory from fatal acts of aggression. Türkiye’s handing of the Khashoggi case over to Saudi Arabia raised the argument that, as a party to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), it had violated the right to life by acting against procedural obligations in the case of the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. This study will briefly discuss the right to life and how states protect it and then examine whether Türkiye and Saudi Arabia had violated Khashoggi’s right to life by acting against their procedural obligations regarding investigations and prosecutions that had taken place in Türkiye and Saudi Arabia by Türkiye transferring the Khashoggi case to Saudi Arabia after Jamal Khashoggi’s murder.

Keywords

Jamal Khashoggi , Right to Life , Positive Procedural Obligation , Efficient Investigation , Transfer of Proceedings

References

• Agrawal, Anshita. “Murder of Jamal Khashoggi: A Mystery”. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities 3 (2020, June).
• AYM, Anayasa Mahkemesi. Rahil Dink and others, Application No: 2012/848, (17 July 2014). Saini, Saloni, "Law of Extradition." Supremo Amicus 12, (2019, December).
• AYM, Anayasa Mahkemesi. Serpil Kerimoğlu and others, Application No: 2012/752, (17 September 2013).
• AYM, Anayasa Mahkemesi. Binali Camgöz and others, Application No: 2019/36978, (26 May 2022). AYM, Anayasa Mahkemesi. Vetha Oğru, Application No: 2018/25614, (frameworthe a 16 June 2022). AYM, Anayasa Mahkemesi. Müberra Yılmaz, Application No: 2019/18532, (16 March 2022).
• AYM, Anayasa Mahkemesi. Nuray Zencir, Application No: 2018/3087, (02 February 2022). Christodoulidou, Theodora. “The Duty to Investigate and Punish those Responsible for the Deaths of
• Missing Persons and its Limits: The Cases of Gurtekin, Akay and Eray and others v Cyprus”.
• Cyprus Human Rights Law Review 3/1 (2014, May).
• Doğru, Osman. Yaşama Hakkı Anayasa Mahkemesine Bireysel Başvuru El Kitapları Serisi – 5, Anayasa Mahkemesine Bireysel Başvuru Sisteminin Desteklenmesi Ortak Projesi. Ankara: Council of Europe, 2018.
• Durocher, Martine. “United Nations Mission to Kosovo: In Violation of the Right to Life?”. Criminal Law Forum 27/4 (2016, December).
• ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Case of A and B v. Georgia, 73975/16, (10 May 2022).
• ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Abdülsamet Yaman v. Türkiye, 32446/96, (02 November 2004).
• ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Case of Boboc and Others v. The Republic of Moldova, 44592/16, (07 June 2022).
• ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Durmaz v. Türkiye, 3621/07, (13 November 2014). ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Kalicki v. Poland, 46797/08, (08 December 2015).
• ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Case of Khabirov v. Russia, 69450/10. (12 January 2022)
• ECHR, European Court of Human Rights. Case of Makuchyan and Minasyan v. Azerbaijan and Hungary, 17247/13, (26 May 2020)
• Frisso, Giovanna Maria. “The Duty to Investigate Violations of the Right to Life in Armed Conflicts in the Jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights”. Israel Law Review 51/2 (2018, July).
• Goel, Mehak – Subramanian, Suraj – Bhatia, Uday – Mishra, Utkarsh. Murder of Jamal Khashoggi: An International Law Perspective. (October 2, 2020).
• Gözübüyük, Şeref – Gölcüklü, Feyyaz. Avrupa İnsan Hakları Sözleşmesi ve Uygulaması. Ankara: Turhan Kitabevi, 4. Baskı, 2003.
• Kamber, Kresimir, Prosecuting Human Rights Offences, Brill/Nijhoff, 2017.
• Korff, Douwe. Right to Life - A Guide to the Implementation of Artcle 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Belgium: Council of Europe, Human Rights Handbooks No:8, 2006.
• Kotilainen and Others v. Finland, 62439/12, (17 December 2020).
• Mahmutoğlu, Fatih Selami, Kovuşturulması Suudi Arabistan’a Nakledilen Cemal Kaşıkçı Dosyasının Uluslararası Adli Yardım Bağlamında Değerlendirilmesi, http://www.tchd.org.tr/ . Accessed 17.05.2024.
• Mavronicola, Natasa. “Taking Life and Liberty Seriously: Reconsidering Criminal Liability under Article 2 of the ECHR”. Modern Law Review 80/6 (November 2017).
• Milanoviç, Marko. The Murder of Jamal Khashoggi: Immunities, Inviolability and the Human Right to Life. Human Rights Law Review 20/1 (2020, March).
• Mostaghimi, Alex. “Transfer of Criminal Proceedings”. International Enforcement Law Reporter. 38/4 (April 2022).
• Özel, Sadullah. “Uluslararası Hukuk Açısından Cemal Kaşıkçı Cinayeti”. DÜHFD 27/46 (2022, June), 169- 199.
• Özgüç, Levent Emre. Bireysel Başvuru İçtihatlarında Yaşam Hakkının Usuli Boyutu: Etkili Soruşturma Yükümlülüğü. https://anayasatakip.ku.edu.tr/wp- content/uploads/sites/34/2017/08/Levent-Emre-O%CC%88zgu%CC%88c%CC%A7- Bireysel-Bas%CC%A7vuru-I%CC%87c%CC%A7tihatlar%C4%B1nda-Yas%CC%A7am- Hakk%C4%B1n%C4%B1n-Usuli-Boyutu.pdf (17.05.2024).
• Sicilianos, Linos-Alexande. “Preventing Violations of the Right to Life: Positive Obligations under Article 2 of the ECHR”. Cyprus Human Rights Law Review 3/2 (2014, June).
• Tan, Amy M. L. “The Duty to Investigate Alleged Violations of International Humanitarian Law: Outdated Deference to an International Accountability Problem”. New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 49/1 (Fall 2016, July).
• Tezcan, Durmuş – Erdem, Mustafa Ruhan – Sancakdar, Oğuz. Avrupa İnsan Hakları Sözleşmesi ışığında Türkiye’nin İnsan Hakları Sorunu. Ankara: Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2. Baskı, 2004.
• Turhan, Faruk. “Cezai Konularda Uluslararası Adli İş Birliği Kanununa Göre İadenin Kabul Edilebilirlik Koşulları: Doktrin ve Uluslararası Gelişmeler Işığında Bir Değerlendirme”. SDUHFD 8/2 (2018, December), 1-87.
• UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. Report of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. UN HRC Annex to the Report of the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions: Investigation into the unlawful death of Mr. Jamal Khashoggi, 19 June 2019.
• van Hout (Britt), B. C. J. L. The Obligation to Investigate Under Article 2 of The European Convention on Human Rights in Iraq, (MA Thesis Tilburg Law School), 2013.
• Xenos, Dimitris. “Asserting the Right to Life (Article 2, ECHR) in the Context of Industry”. German Law Journal 8/3 (March 1, 2007).
• Yang, Philemon Y. The Inviolability of Diplomatic and Consular Premises in International Law. (Master Thesis, University of Ottawa), Ottawa Canada: 1939.
• Yargı, Mehmet Ali. Suudi Arabistan’ın Yargı Sistemi. İstanbul: MÜİF Vakfı Yayınları, 2014.
• Internet Sources
• University of Minnesota Human Rights Library. “Law of Criminal Procedure - Saudi Arabia Accessed 17.05.2024. http://hrlibrary.umn.edu/research/saudiarabia/criminal_proceedure.html AA,
• Anadolu Ajansı. “Kaşıkçı cinayeti 2'nci yılı geride bıraktı” Accessed 17.05.2024. https://www.aa.com.tr/tr/cemal-kasikci/kasikci-cinayeti-2nci-yili-geride-birakti/1991744
• Aljazeera “Jamal Khashoggi’s son Salah says family ‘forgives’ killers” Accessed 17.05.2024. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/5/22/jamal-khashoggis-son-salah-says-family-forgives-killers
• TRT Haber, Türkiye Radyo Televizyon Kurumu. “Portre: Suudi Arabistan Başkonsolosluğunda katledilen Cemal Kaşıkçı” Accessed 17.05.2024. https://www.trthaber.com/haber/dunya/portre- suudi-arabistan-baskonsoloslugunda- katledilen-cemal-kasikci-476812.html
• WP, Washington Post “Sons of Jamal Khashoggi Forgive His Killers Clearing Pathfor Official Pardons” Accessed 17.05.2024. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/sons-of-jamal- khashoggi-forgive-his-killers-clearing-pathfor-official-pardons/2020/05/22/11d109d0-9c24-11ea-ad79- eef7cd734641_story.html
• NYC Times, The Newyork Times. “Khashoggi’s Son Says Family Pardons His Father’s Killers” Accessed 17.05.2024. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/22/world/middleeast/jamal- khashoggi-family-pardon.html