Cezayir'de Hukuki Güvenlik: Anayasal Güvence ile Yasal İstikrarsızlık Arasında

Year 2025, Volume: 13 Issue: 1, 49 - 61

Bouzid Benmahmoud , Hamza Selam

https://doi.org/10.56701/shd.1531846

Abstract

Bu çalışma, Cezayir'de hukuki güvenlik ilkesinin anayasal güvence altına alınmasını incelemekte ve 2020 değişikliğinde bu ilkenin anayasallaşmasına odaklanmaktadır. Çalışma, bu anayasal tanınma ile Cezayir hukuk sisteminin gerçekliği arasındaki ilişkiyi analiz ederek, ilkenin etkin bir şekilde uygulanmasının önündeki zorlukları araştırmaktadır. Çalışma, Cezayir hukuk sisteminin özelliklerinin ilkenin uygulanmasındaki zorlukları açıklayan temel faktör olduğunu ve 2020 anayasa reformlarının bu zorluklara rağmen ilkeyi güçlendirmede önemli olduğunu varsaymaktadır.
Çok boyutlu bir metodoloji kullanan çalışma, ilkenin anayasallaştırılmasının, yasal istikrarsızlığın süregelen zorluklarına rağmen, yasal çevreyi reforma tabi tutma yolunda önemli bir adım olduğu sonucuna varmaktadır. Çalışma, yasal olarak istikrarsız sistemlerde bile ilkenin önemini vurgulamakta ve gelecekteki araştırmaların, anayasal reformlar ile yasal istikrarı sağlama mekanizmaları arasındaki ilişkiye odaklanması gerektiğini, böylece ilkenin Cezayir hukuk sistemine vatandaşların güvenini artırmadaki etkinliğinin daha derin bir şekilde anlaşılabileceğini belirtmektedir.

Keywords

Hukuki güvenlik, Cezayir, Anayasal reform, Yasal istikrarsızlık.

Legal Security in Algeria: Between Constitutional Enshrinement and Legislative Instability

Abstract

This study examines the enshrinement of the principle of legal security in Algeria, focusing on its constitutionalization in the 2020 amendment. It analyzes the relationship between this constitutional recognition and the reality of the Algerian legal system, exploring the challenges facing its effective implementation. The study hypothesizes that the characteristics of the Algerian legal system are the primary factor in explaining the challenges of applying the principle, and that the 2020 constitutional reforms are significant in strengthening it despite these challenges.
Employing a multi-dimensional methodology, the study concludes that the constitutionalization of the principle represents an important step towards reforming the legislative environment, despite the persistent challenges of legislative instability. The study emphasizes the importance of the principle even in legislatively unstable systems and calls for future research to focus on the relationship between constitutional reforms and mechanisms for achieving legislative stability, to gain a deeper understanding of the principle's effectiveness in enhancing citizens' confidence in the Algerian legal system.

Keywords

Legal Security, Algeria, Constitutional Reform, Legislative Instability

References

• Al-hanoudi, Ali. “Legal Security: Its Concept and Dimensions.” Moroccan Journal of Local Administration and Development 96 (February 2011), 117–138.
• Badawi, Abdel Jalil - Hannan, Ali. “The Concept of the Principle of Legal Security and Its Requirements.” Journal of Public Function Studies 4/2 (June 2021), 1–15.
• Bara, Samir. “Reform of the Electoral System in Algeria: A Study of Electoral Laws from 1989 to 2021.” Eliza Journal for Research and Studies 8/1 (December 2013), 114–134.
• Benbenaissa, Fadwa. “Legal Security as a Guarantee for the Protection of Human Rights and Freedoms.” Moroccan Journal of Legal and Judicial Governance 6 (2019), 24–36.
• Douini, Mukhtar. “The Principle of Legal Security and Requirements for Its Achievement.” Journal of Legal Studies 3/1 (June 2016), 24–38.
• Eduardo García Maynez, "Justice and Legal Security", Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 9/3 (1948), 496-503.
• Eid Sayed, Rifaat. “Legal Security - An Analytical Study in Light of Administrative and Constitutional Judiciary Rulings.” Journal of the Association of Arab Universities for Legal Studies and Research, 34 (October 2013), 12–237.
• Guillaume Valdelièvre, "La sécurité juridique – Le point de vue de l'avocat", Titre VII 5/2 (2020), 11-19.
• Heriche, Siham. “Executive Regulation and the Issue of Legal Security.” Journal of the Researcher Professor for Legal and Political Studies 2/4 (December 2017), 107–127.
• Iftissan, Ouarida - Ben Nasser, Wahiba. “Constitutionalization of the Principle of Legal Security: The Algerian Experience as a Model.” Journal of Legal Studies 8/2 (June 2022), 969–986.
• Jean-Louis Bergel, "La sécurité juridique", Revue du notariat 110/2 (September 2008), 271-285.
• Kassal, Salah. "Legislative Inflation as an Obstacle to Foreign Investment: Updates of Law No. 16-09 to Address this Obstacle." Voice of Law Journal 5/2 (2018), 438-471.
• Kassi, Fouzia. Requirements for Establishing the Rule of Law: Constitutionalization of the Principle of Legal Security - A Comparative Study between European and Algerian Experiences. Algeria: University of Oran, PhD Thesis In Political Sciences, 2018.
• Khellaf, Fateh. “On the Impact of Constitutionalizing the Principle of Legal Security on Attracting Investors to the Algerian Investment Market.” Journal of Legal and Social Sciences 6/2 (June 2021), 921–938.
• Laouiji, Abdullah. “Legal Security and Obstacles to its Achievement in Algeria.” Journal of Research in Contracts and Business Law 6/2 (June 2021), 99–119.
• Martinez G. P.-B, "Legal Security from the Point of View of the Philosophy of Law", Ratio Juris 8/2 (1995), 127–141.
• Mohamed El-Shenawy, Walid. “Legal Security and Principles of Good Law-Making.” Journal of Legal and Economic Research 56 (October 2014), 277–330. https://doi.org/10.21608/MJLE.2014.156390
• Rabhi, Ahsan. “Reference of Inflation in Algerian Constitutional Documents.” Journal of Law for Legal, Economic and Political Sciences, 48/2 (June 2011), 71–85.
• Rouchou, Khaled. “The Role of Constitutional Rule in Establishing Legal Security.” Journal of Public Function Studies 3/1 (June 2018), 109–121.
• Tawahriya, Abu Dawood - Ghitawi, Abdelkader. “Legal Security and Its Role in Protecting Rights and Freedoms in the Algerian Constitutional System.” Journal of Law and Society 10/1 (June 2022), 117–135.