The Change Caused by the Transition of Ash'ari to Ahl-i Sunnah in the Religious Paradigm

Year 2020, Volume: 1 Issue: 2, 289 - 309, 31.12.2020

Hüseyin Aydın

Abstract

One of the theologians who had the greatest influence in the history of Islamic thought is Ash‘ari. It successfully applied Mu‘tazilah's rational method to Salaf's views. The transition of a strong scholar like Ash'ari from Mu’tazilah to Ahl-i Sunnah increased the dialogue between the two schools. This dialogue is based on the kalam method. People of the submissive narration who refused this rational method started to lose the area. Ash'ari's taking place in the Ahl-i Sunnah side that considering the results, it went down in history as the first and biggest paradigm shift in Islamic thought. As well as adopting the views of the Ahl-i Sunnah, he added the mental examination to the passage, he did not abandon cosmology and theological method, centered on the substence-symptom concept couple. Both the method in Lüma and the quotations of Ibn Fûrek from other books reveal his different aspects and method from Mu‘tazilah and Salafiyya. In general, he put forward a third way that can be counted between the understanding of Mu‘tasilitie and Salafi’s uslüddin, in the area where he lives.

Keywords

Kalam, Religion, Sect, Ash‘ari, Change

References

• Akbulut, Ahmet, “Allah’ın Takdiri-Kulun Tedbiri”, (In New Approaches in Religious Education), İstanbul, 2000.
• Aydın, Hüseyin, Ebu’l-Hasen el-Eş’arî’de Nazar ve İstidlal, Ankara, 2012.
• Barendregt, Marko, Thomas S. Kuhn’s Ideas in the Light of the Structuralist Approach of Science, Amsterdam, 1999.
• Câbirî, Muhammed Âbid, Arap Aklının Oluşumu, Tekvînü’l-akli’l-Arabî, trans. İbrahim Akbaba, İstanbul, 1997.
• Coleman, S.R. and Salamon R. Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions in the Psychological Journal Literature, 1988, 1969-1983: A Descriptive Study, The Journal of Mind and Behavior, 9, (415-446).
• Demir, Ömer, Bilim Felsefesi, Ankara, 2000.
• Descartes, Aklî Yönlendirme Kuralları, trans. Can Şahan, İstanbul, t.y.
• Eş’arî, Ebu’l-Hasen, Risâle fî İstihsâni’l-havd fî İlmi’l-kelâm, thk. Richard, J. McCarthy, Beyrût, 1952.
• Evkuran, Mehmet, Sünnî Paradigmayı Anlamak, Ankara, 2005.
• Gazâlî, Ebû Hâmid, Mihenkü’n-nazar fi’l-mantık, Kahire, t.y.
• Gazzâlî, Ebû Hâmid, Tehâfütü’l-felâsife: Filozofların Tutarsızlığı (pub. And trans. Mahmut Kaya – Hüseyin Sarıoğlu), İstanbul 2005.