Transformation of Turkish-Russian Relations: Rivalry and Cooperation in Eurasia and the Levant

Year 2025, , 1 - 19

Mustafa Aydın

https://doi.org/10.33458/uidergisi.1621393

Abstract

Relations between Russia and Türkiye have developed considerably since the end of the Cold War. What began as energy trade in the late 1980s evolved into cooperation in business, energy, construction, tourism, politics and even security. Behind the ever-expanding cooperation lies a mistrust fueled by historical enmity and regional rivalry that occasionally leads to confrontation. As the two countries seek to shape their competitive cooperation beyond the current geopolitical challenges and constraints of regional security and alliances, the question of whether they could find ways to advance their partnership is of paramount importance and has regional and global implications. This paper seeks to understand how they have managed their conflict-ridden past to develop a modus operandi in the post-Cold War world by proposing a new conceptual model, namely “competitive cooperation” or “coopetition”, to understand the relationship that developed over the last 30 years in different geographical regions.

Keywords

Turkish Foreign Policy, Competitive Cooperation, Coopetition, Black Sea, Mediterranean

References

• Aktürk, Ş. 2006. Turkish-Russian Relations after the Cold War (1992-2002). Turkish Studies, 7, 3: 337-364.
• Aktürk, Ş. 2019. Relations Between Russia and Turkey Before, During, and After the Failed Coup of 2016. Insight Türkiye 21, 4: 97-113.
• Altunışık, M. B. 2021. The New Wave of Normalization in Turkey’s Middle East Foreign Policy. Middle East Institute, 27 April, https://www.mei.edu/publications/new-wave-normalization-turkeys-middle-east-foreign-policy.
• Anadolu Agency. 2020. 34.8 billion cubic meters of gas carried through TurkStream in 2 years. 8 January. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/energy/energy-projects/348-billion-cubic-meters-of-gas-carried-through-turkstream-in-2-years/34380.
• Anadolu Agency. 2022. Russia transferring $15B for Türkiye for Akkuyu NPP. 29 July. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/energy/nuclear/russia-transferring-15b-for-turkiye-for-akkuyu-npp/35933.
• Anadolu Agency. 2024. Türkiye attracts 49.2M foreign tourists in 2023. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/economy/turkiye-attracts-492m-foreign-tourists-in-2023/3123805.
• Ananicz, S. 2014. Turkey on the Russian military intervention in Crimea. OSW, Center for Eastern Studies. May 3, https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/analyses/2014-03-05/turkey-russian-military-intervention-crimea.
• Aydın, M. 1996. Turkey and Central Asia: Challenges of Change. Central Asian Survey 15, 2: 157-177.
• Aydın, M. 2000. New Geopolitics of Central Asia and the Caucasus; Causes of Instability and Predicament. Ankara, Center for Strategic Studies.
• Aydın, M. 2003. Between Euphoria and Realpolitik: Turkish Foreign Policy toward Central Asia and the Caucasus. In Türkiye’s Foreign Policy in the 21st Century: Changing Role in World Politics, ed. by T. Y. Ismael and M. Aydın: 139-160. Burlington, Ashgate.
• Aydın, M. 2004. Foucault's Pendulum: Turkey in Central Asia and the Caucasus. Turkish Studies 5, 2: 1-22.
• Aydın, M. 2008. Black Sea: Region of Peace or Region of Conflict? Challenges and Opportunities of Future Cooperation in the Region. Presentation at the Conference on The Wider Black Sea Area and the Transatlantic Alliance. International Centre for Black Sea Studies and Center for International Relations, 13-14 June, Kyiv, Ukraine.
• Aydın, M. 2011. Kafkasya ve Orta Asya’yla İlişkiler, 2001-2012. In Türk Dış Politikası; Olaylar, Olgular Belgeler, Vol. 3, ed. by B. Oran: 463-531. İstanbul, İletişim.
• Aydın, M. 2012. The South Caucasus in Turkey’s New Foreign Policy. Presentation at the Workshop on The Post-Ottoman Space: Soft Politics and Hard Choices. Organized by Turkish Economic and Social Studies Foundation and Peace Research Institute Oslo, 10 September, Tbilisi, Georgia.
• Aydın, M. 2020. The Long View on Turkish-Russian Rivalry and Cooperation, GMF On Türkiye Series, No 5, June, https://www.gmfus.org/news/long-view-turkish-russian-rivalry-and-cooperation.
• Aydın, M. 2021. Türk-Rus İlişkilerinin Tarihi Dönüşümü; Avrasya ve Levant'ta Rekabet ve İşbirliği. In Prof. Dr. Beril Dedeoğlu’na Armağan, ed. by F. Türkmen and A. F. Demir: 127-146. İstanbul, Galatasaray University.
• Baev P. K., and K. Kirişcci. 2017. An Ambiguous Partnership: The Serpentine Trajectory of Turkish-Russian Relations in the Era of Erdoğan and Putin. Brookings Institution, Turkey Project Policy Paper, 13.
• Baldıran, S., D. Bayer and H. Gençer. 2022. The Importance of the 1936 Montreux Convention for the Black Sea Security: A Close Look into Russia-NATO Controversy on the Russian-Ukrainian Conflict in 2022. Information & Security, 51, 1: 11-23.
• Balta, E. 2019. From Geopolitical Competition to Strategic Partnership: Turkey and Russia after the Cold War. Uluslararası İlişkiler, 16, 63: 69-86.
• Balta, E. and B. Özkan. 2016. Türkiye-Rusya İlişkilerine ‘Tarih’ ile Bakmak. İstanbul, TÜSİAD Foreign Policy Forum Research Report. No. DPF2016-RR.01.
• Balta, E, C. Filis and M. Aydın. 2021. Russia, Turkey, and the EU: An Uneasy Triangle. Panorama Portal, October. https://www.uikpanorama.com/blog/2021/10/05/cats-russia-turkey-and-the-eu-an-uneasy-triangle/.
• BBC. 2020. Syria war: Alarm after 33 Turkish soldiers killed in attack in Idlib. 28 February. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-51667717.
• Bechev, D. 2024. Closer Ties to the West Don’t Mean Turkey Will Give Up on Russia. Carnegie Politika, 7 February, https://carnegieendowment.org/politika/91571.
• Brandenburg, A. and B. Nalebuff. 1996. Coopetition. New York, Crown Business.
• Brandenburg, A. and B. Nalebuff. 2021. The rules of Coopetition. Harvard Business Review, January-February. https://hbr.org/2021/01/the-rules-of-co-opetition.
• Bilgin, M. 2010. Turkey's Energy Strategy: What Difference Does It Make to Become an Energy Transit Corridor, Hub, or Center? UNISCI Discussion Papers 23: 113-128.
• Cheterian, V. 2023. Friend and Foe: Russia-Turkey relations before and after the war in Ukraine, Small Wars and Insurgencies, 34, 7: 1271-1294.
• Çelikpala, M. 2007. 1990'lardan Günümüze Türk-Rus İlişkileri. Avrasya Dosyası, 13, 1: 267-298.
• Çelikpala, M. 2019. Viewing the Present as History: The State and Future of Turkey-Russia Relations. İstanbul, EDAM.
• Çelikpala, M. and E. Erşen. 2018. Turkey’s Black Sea Predicament: Challenging or Accommodating Russia? Perceptions, 23, 2: 72-92.
• Demir, Y. and N. S. Erdem. 2002. Türkiye Rusya ve İran’la İttifak Arayışında Olmalı. Sabah, 8 March. https://arsiv.sabah.com.tr/2002/03/08/p01.html.
• Delanoë, I. 2014. After the Crimean Crisis: towards a greater Russian maritime power in the Black Sea. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 14, 3: 367-382.
• Delanoë, I. 2024. Russia’s Black Sea Fleet in the ‘Special Military Operation’ in Ukraine. Foreign Policy Research Institute, February, https://www.fpri.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/russias-black-sea-fleet-.pdf.
• Derman, G. S. 2021. Turkey-Russian Federation Relations in the New Era. In Contemporary Turkish – Russian Relations from Past to Future, ed. by İ. Topsakal and A. Askerov, İstanbul, İstanbul University Press: 39-68.
• Didic, A. and H. Kösebalan. 2019. Turkey’s Rapprochement with Russia: Assertive Bandwagoning. The International Spectator 54, 3: 123-138.
• Dilanian, K., C. Kube and C. E. Lee. 2022. U.S. intel helped Ukraine sink Russian flagship Moskva, officials say. NBC News, 6 May. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/national-security/us-intel-helped-ukraine-sink-russian-flagship-moskva-officials-say-rcna27559.
• Druzhinin, A. G. 2015. The Black Sea Region in Modern Russian-Turkish Cooperation: The Geostrategic Aspect. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 5: 81-84.
• Economist. 2022. Turkey’s rapprochement with Russia may not survive the war in Ukraine. February 24.
• Erşen, E. 2011. Turkey and Russia: An Emerging Strategic Axis. Eur Orient, 35-36: 263-285.
• Erşen, E. 2017. Evaluating the Fighter Jet Crisis in Turkish-Russian Relations. Insight Türkiye, 19, 4: 85-103.
• Erşen, E. and S. Köstem. 2020. Turkey’s Interest in Closer Relations with Russia: Global, Regional and Domestic Dynamics. SİYASAL: Journal of Political Sciences, 29, 2: 231–245.
• Euronews. 2024. Turkey, Bulgaria and Romania sign deal to tackle Black Sea mines. 11 January. https://www.euronews.com/2024/01/11/turkey-bulgaria-and-romania-sign-deal-to-tackle-black-sea-mines
• Fraser, S. 2023. Turkey's parliament ratifies Finland's membership in NATO. AP News, 31 March. https://apnews.com/article/nato-finland-turkey-24e91f6d5141e727872b91b854d5702c.
• Glinski, S. 2023. Turkey’s Balancing Act Between Putin and the West. Foreign Policy, 6 March. https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/03/06/turkey-elections-russia-erdogan-putin-nato/.
• Güvenç, S. 2023. NATO için bir sıklet merkezi olarak Karadeniz. MedyaScope, 2 April. https://medyascope.tv/2023/04/02/serhat-guvenc-yazdi-nato-icin-bir-siklet-merkezi-olarak-karadeniz/.
• Güvenç, S. and M Aydın. 2023. Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea. GMF Insights. 10 May. https://www.gmfus.org/news/between-devil-and-deep-blue-sea.
• Hamilton, R. E. and A. Mikulska. 2021. Russian-Turkish Relations and Their Implications for the West. Foreign Policy Research Institute, https://www.fpri.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/russian-turkish-relations-bssp.pdf.
• Hale, W. 2022. Turkey's energy dilemmas: changes and challenges. Middle Eastern Studies 58, 3: 452-466.
• Hill, F. and Ö. Taşpınar. 2006. Turkey and Russia; Axis of Excluded? Survival 48, 1: 81-92.
• HDN. 2022. Erdoğan says he proposed trilateral mechanism with Russia, Syria. 15 December. https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/erdogan-says-he-proposed-trilateral-mechanism-with-russia-syria-179364
• İldem, T. 2022. Turkey's Misunderstood Position on Ukraine. ELN Commentary, 9 November. https://www.europeanleadershipnetwork.org/commentary/a-balancing-act-turkeys-misunderstood-position-on-ukraine/.
• Interfax. 2023. Ukraine quits BlackSeaFor agreement. 27 February. https://interfax.com/newsroom/top-stories/88244/.
• Isachenko, D. and D. Swistak. 2023. The Black Sea as Mare Clausum: Turkey’s special role in the regional security architecture. SWP Comment. 21 June, https://www.swp-berlin.org/10.18449/2023C33/.
• İşeri, E. 2010. Eurasian Geopolitics and Financial Crisis: Transforming Russian-Turkish Relations from Geopolitical Rivalry to Strategic Cooperation. Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies 12, 2: 173-186.
• Jenkins, B. M. 2023. Consequences of the War in Ukraine: Two Areas of Contention-Turkey and the Balkans. The Rand Blog, 6 March. https://www.rand.org/blog/2023/03/consequences-of-the-war-in-ukraine-turkey-and-the-balkans.html.
• Johnson, K. 2015. Putin's Mediterranean Power Play in Syria', Foreign Policy, 2 October. http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/10/02/putins-mediterranean-power-play-in-syria-navy-tartus-fleet/#.
• Kardaş, Ş. 2012. Turkey-Russia energy relations: The limits of forging cooperation through economic interdependence. International Journal 67, 1: 81-100.
• Kardaş, Ş. 2022. The normalization agenda in Turkish foreign policy: drivers and parameters. TRENDS Research & Advisory, 23 February. https://trendsresearch.org/insight/the-normalization-agenda-in-turkish-foreign-policy-drivers-and-parameters/.
• Kasapoğlu, C. 2022. Turkish Drone Strategy in the Black Sea Region and Beyond. The Jamestown Foundation, 12 October. https://jamestown.org/program/turkish-drone-strategy-in-the-black-sea-region-and-beyond/.
• Kasenov, O. 1995. Russia and Transcaucasia: Oil, Pipelines and Geopolitics. In Central Asia: Conflict, Resolution and Change, ed. by R. Z. Sagdeev and S. Eisenhower. Washington D.C., Center for Political and Strategic Studies.
• Kaynak, B. 2018. From Blue Stream to Turkish Stream: An Assessment of Türkiye's Energy Dependence on Russia. Aurum 3, 1: 79-90.
• Kelkitli, F. 2017. Turkish-Russian Relations; Competition and Cooperation in Eurasia. London & New York, Routledge.
• Kemal, L. 2021. Turkey blamed Syria for a deadly air strike. Its troops blame Russia. Middle East Eye, 5 November. https://www.middleeasteye.net/big-story/turkey-syria-russia-troops-blamed-air-strike.
• Konarzewska, N. 2023. Turkey will not give up on its Lucrative Trade with Russia. The Turkey Analyst. 26 June, https://www.turkeyanalyst.org/publications/turkey-analyst-articles/item/709-turkey-will-not-give-up-on-its-lucrative-trade-with-russia.html.
• Köremezli, İ. 2021. Turkey’s Foreign Policy toward Russia: Constructing a Strategic Partner Out of a Geopolitical Rival. Türk Dünyası İncelemeleri Dergisi 21, 2: 351-373.
• Köstem, S. 2016. When Can Idea Entrepreneurs Influence Foreign Policy? Explaining the Rise of the ‘Turkic World’ in Turkish Foreign Policy. Foreign Policy Analysis 13, 3: 722-740.
• Köstem, S. 2018. The Political Economy of Turkish-Russian Relations: Dynamics of Asymmetric Interdependence. Perceptions 23, 2: 10-32.
• Köstem, S. 2020. Russian-Turkish Cooperation in Syria: Geopolitical Alignment with Limits. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 34, 6: 795-817.
• Luo, Y. 2004. Coopetition in International Business. Copenhagen, Business School Press.
• Lutkevitch, B. 2021. Coopetition (co-opetition). TechTarget, September. https://www.techtarget.com/searchcio/definition/co-opetition
• Malsin, J. 2023. Turkey Says War Exists in Black Sea, Allowing It to Block Russian Navy. The Wall Street Journal, 17 February. https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/russia-ukraine-latest-news-2022-02-26/card/uDQCa9dMZsNGZLQsfWYg.
• Mamedov, R. and G. Lukyanov. 2018. Russia and Turkey: Approaches to Regional Security in the Middle East. Perceptions 23, 2: 51-71
• Mango, A. 1993. The Turkish Model. Middle Eastern Studies 29, 4: 726-757.
• MFA. 2014a. Statement of the Spokesman of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Turkey. 3 April. http://www.mfa.gov.tr/qa_5_-3-april-2014_-statement-of-the-spokesman-of-the-ministry-of-foreign-affairs-of-turkey-in-response-to-a-question-regardin.en.mfa.
• MFA. 2014b. Press Release Regarding the Implementation of the Montreux Convention. 12 April. http://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_-116_-12-april-2014_-press-release-regarding-the-implementation-of-the-montreux-convention.en.mfa.
• NATO. 2022. Strategic Concept. https://www.nato.int/strategic-concept/.
• NATO. 2023. Turkish Fighter Detachment Ready for NATO Air Policing in Romania. 6 December, https://ac.nato.int/archive/2023/TUR_F16_mission_ready_ROU.
• Morozov, V. and B. Rumelili. 2012. The external constitution of European identity: Russia and Turkey as Europe-makers. Cooperation and Conflict 47, 1: 28-48.
• Neset, S., M. Aydın, E. Balta, K. K. Ataç, H. D. Bilgin and A. Strand. 2021. Turkey as a regional security actor in the Black Sea, the Mediterranean, and the Levant Region. Bergen, Chr. Michelsen Institute, CMI Report 2021/2.
• Neset, S., M. Aydın, A. Ergun, R. Giragosian, K. Kakachia and A. Strand. 2023. Changing Geopolitics of the South Caucasus after the Second Karabakh War. Prospect for Regional Cooperation and/or Rivalry. Bergen, Chr. Michelsen Institute, CMI Report 2023/4.
• Osganian, V. 2022. Competitive Cooperation; Institutional and Social Dimensions of Collaboration in the Alliance of Science Organizations in Germany. NTM Zeitschrift für Geschichte der Wissenschaften, Technik und Medizin 30, 1.
• Oral, N. 2017. Black Sea Security under the Montreux Convention. In Ocean Law and Policy; Twenty Years of Development Under the UNCLOS Regime. Ed. by C. Espósito, J. Kraska, H. N. Scheiber and M. S. Kwon: 266-286. Leiden, Brill & Nijhoff.
• Öniş, Z. and Ş. Yılmaz. 2016. Turkey and Russia in a shifting global order: cooperation, conflict and asymmetric interdependence in a turbulent region. Third World Quarterly 37, 1: 71-95.
• Özcan, G., E. Balta and B. Beşgül (eds.). 2017. Kuşku ile Komşuluk: Türkiye ve Rusya İlişkilerinde Değişen Dinamikler, İstanbul, İletişim.
• Ramazani, R. 1966. The Northern Tier: Afghanistan, Iran, and Turkey. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
• Resmi Gazete. 2022. No 31787, 22 March, https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2022/03/20220323-1.pdf.
• Rumelili, B. and A. B. Çelik. 2017. Ontological Insecurity in Asymmetric Conflicts: Reflections on Antogonastic Peace in Turkey’s Kurdish Issue. Security Dialogue 48, 4: 279-296.
• Rüma, İ. and M. Çelikpala. 2019. Russian and Turkish Foreign Policy Activism in the Syrian Theater. Uluslararası İlişkiler 16, 62: 65-84.
• Schneider, A. 2017. Russia's Black Sea Fleet Buildup. The Maritime Executive, 29 March. https://www.maritime-executive.com/editorials/russias-black-sea-fleet-buildup#gs.9vQF=e0.
• Sezer, D. 2000. Turkish-Russian Relations: The Challenges of Reconciling Geopolitical Competition with Economic Partnership. Turkish Studies 1, 1: 59-82.
• Svarin, D. 2015. Towards a Eurasian Axis? Russia and Turkey Between Cooperation and Competition. Global Affairs 1, 4-5: 381-398.
• TASS. 2015. Russia suspends participation in Blackseafor drills after Turkey’s downing of Russian jet. 27 November. https://tass.com/defense/839869?utm_source=en.wikipedia.org&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=en.wikipedia.org&utm_referrer=en.wikipedia.org.
• Witt, S. 2022. The Turkish Drone That Changed the Nature of Warfare. The New Yorker, 9 May. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/05/16/the-turkish-drone-that-changed-the-nature-of-warfare.
• Yinanç, B. 2023. Türkiye bilindiğinden daha fazla Rus karşıtı adım atıyor. T24, 5 April. https://t24.com.tr/yazarlar/barcin-yinanc/turkiye-bilindiginden-daha-fazla-rus-karsiti-adim-atiyor,39440.