Understanding the Complexities of the Eastern Mediterranean Hydrocarbon Puzzle by Regional Security Complex Theory

Year 2025, Volume: 22 Issue: 88, 65 - 82, 13.12.2025

Jude Alabi Hüseyin Işiksal

https://doi.org/10.33458/uidergisi.1747941

Abstract

The discovered hydrocarbon reserves throughout the Eastern Mediterranean hold enormous economic promise but have also increased regional geopolitical tensions. However, the discovery of reserves has failed to advance regional cooperation in the region due to pre-existing territorial conflicts and closed security alliances. Regional Security Complex Theory (RSCT) helps this study understand how security connections in the area determine energy politics by explaining the failure of economic benefits to transcend historical conflicts. This research shows that the securitization process of hydrocarbon resources created new conflicts that generated maritime military disputes and formed special alliances. The Eastern Mediterranean Gas Forum demonstrates how security issues supplant economic advantages since it excludes Türkiye from membership, thereby impeding the creation of an all-encompassing regional energy framework. The research adds value to existing knowledge about energy governance by underscoring the influence of state and non-state forces in the region’s energy sector. According to the analysis, energy diplomacy cannot solve geopolitical conflicts because security concerns need broader political structures for resolution. The Eastern Mediterranean hydrocarbon resources will continue to be a source of regional dispute if no comprehensive solutions are implemented.

Keywords

Eastern Medditerranean , Geopolitics , Securitization , Energy , Diplomacy

References

• Adamides, C. 2022. Energising Tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean: The Impact of Hydrocarbons on Regional Security. St Antony's International Review 17: 115-131
• Andrei, R. 2016. Energy Security: Challenges and Opportunities in the Caspian-Black Sea Region. Security Dialogues 7, 1: 45-61.
• Aydin, M. and C. Dizdaroglu. 2018 Levantine Challenges on Turkish Foreign Policy, Uluslararası İlişkiler 15: 60: 89-103.
• Badarin, E., and T. Schumacher. 2022. The Eastern Mediterranean Energy Bonanza: A Piece in the Regional and Global Geopolitical Puzzle, and the Role of the European Union. Comparative Southeast European Studies 70, 3: 414-438.
• Bastin, K. 2021. The EU in the Eastern Mediterranean—a “Geopolitical” Actor? Orbis 65, 3: 483-489
• BBC News. 2020. Türkiye-Greece Tensions Escalate over Turkish Med Drilling Plans. August 25. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53497741 (accessed March 23, 2024).
• Buzan, B. 2003. Regional Security Complex Theory in the Post-Cold War World. In Theories of New Regionalism, ed. F. Söderbaum, and T. M. Shaw, London, Palgrave Macmillan: 140-159.
• Buzan, B. and O. Wæver. 2003. Regions and Powers: Security complexes: a theory of regional security. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
• Çubukçuoğlu, S. 2021. Energy Alliance in a Turbulent Region: What are Implications of the East Med Gas Forum for Turkey? Turkish Journal of Policy Studies 1, 1: 13 – 22.
• Dangubić, M. 2024. Effects of Hydrocarbon Discoveries on Stability of the Eastern Mediterranean. Diplomová práce, vedoucí Riegl, Martin. Praha: Univerzita Karlova, Fakulta sociálních věd, Katedra politologie.
• De Micco, P. 2014. The Prospect of Eastern Mediterranean Gas Production: An Alternative Energy Supplier for the EU? European Parliament, DG External Policies, Policy Department, April 15. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/briefing_note/join/2014/522339/EXPO-AFET_SP(2014)522339_EN.pdf (accessed March 19, 2024)
• Dokos, T. 2012. The Evolving Security Environment in the Eastern Mediterranean: is NATO still a Relevant Actor? Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 12, 4: 505–517.
• Ellinas, C. 2022a. Aphrodite Back in the Limelight, Cyprus Mail, September 25. https://cyprus-mail.com/2022/09/25/aphrodite-back-in-the-limelight/ (accessed December 23, 2024).
• Ellinas, C. 2022b. Energy and Geopolitics in the Eastern Mediterranean, Atlantic Council Global Energy Center, February 16. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/report/energy- and-geopolitics-in-the-eastern-mediterranean/ (accessed January 21, 2024).
• Ezrahi, A. 2016. Cooperation Prospects and Conflict Potential around Hydrocarbons in the Middle East: Israel–Egypt–Palestinian Territories–Jordan. In Energy Cooperation and Security in the Eastern Mediterranean: A Seismic Shift towards peace or Conflict? ed. A. Giannakopoulos. Tel Aviv, The S. Daniel Abraham Center for International and Regional Studies: 75-84.
• Foyou, V., P. Ngwafu, M. Santoyo, and A. Ortiz. 2018. The Boko Haram Insurgency and Its Impact on Border Security, Trade, and Economic Collaboration between Nigeria and Cameroon: An Exploratory Study. African Social Science Review 9, 1: 66-75.
• Gencturk, A. 2022. US Withdraws Support from EastMed Gas Pipeline Project. Anadolu Agency, November 11. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/world/us-withdraws-support-from-eastmed-gas-pipeline- project/2470881 (accessed August 4, 2024)
• Goldthau, A., J. Richert, and S. Stetter. 2024. Leviathan Awakens: Gas Finds, Energy Governance, and the Emergence of the Eastern Mediterranean as a Geopolitical Region. Review of Policy Research 41, 2: 310-328.
• Harari, M., and A. Sözen. 2023. Lebanon and Israel: Natural Resources and Security Interests as Catalysts for Conflict Resolution. In Conflict Resolution in the Mediterranean: Energy as a Potential Game-Changer, ed. A. Sözen, N. Goren, and C. Limon. Diplomeds, The Council for Mediterranean Diplomacy: 23-36.
• İşeri, E., and A. Ç. Bartan. 2019. Türkiye's Geostrategic Vision and Energy Concerns in the Eastern Mediterranean Security Architecture: A View from Ankara. In The New Geopolitics of the Eastern Mediterranean: Trilateral Partnerships and Regional Security, ed. Z. Tziarras, friedrich-ebert-stiftung ang PRIO Cyprus Centre: 111–124.
• Işeri, E. 2019. Türkiye’s Entangled (Energy) Security Concerns and the Cyprus Question in the Eastern Mediterranean. In Greece and Türkiye in Conflict and Cooperation, ed. A. Heraclides, and G. Alioğlu Çakmak. London, Routledge: 257-270.
• Jabbar, B. J., and M. Direkli. 2023. The Role of Powerbroking in the Mediterranean Hydrocarbon Issue and Its Impact on Environmental Crisis—A Kin-State Case Dimension on Cyprus. Sustainability 15, 3: 2735.
• Khadduri, W. 2012. East Mediterranean Gas: Opportunities and Challenges. Mediterranean Politics, 17, 1: 111–117.
• Köylü, M. 2021. Energy Card of the Eastern Mediterranean: Cyprus. Kıbrıs Araştırmaları ve İncelemeleri Dergisi 4, 8: 43-48.
• Loengarov, A. 2022. Between Maritime Law and Politics in the East Mediterranean. The Washington Institute, March 24. https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/between-maritime-law- and-politics-east-mediterranean (accessed December 20, 2023).
• Maed, N. V. 2018. China in Africa: win-win development, or a new colonialism? The Guardian, July 31. https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/jul/31/china-in-africa-win-win-development-or-a- new-colonialism (accessed March 24, 2024)
• Mehmet, O., and V. Yorucu. 2020. Location Theory and the Modern Geopolitics of Hydrocarbons in The Eastern Mediterranean. In Modern Geopolitics of Eastern Mediterranean Hydrocarbons in an Age of Energy Transformation. Lecture Notes in Energy, 78. Cham, Springer: 21-41
• Panarello, D., and A. Gatto. 2023. Decarbonising Europe – EU Citizens’ Perception of Renewable Energy Transition Amidst the European Green Deal. Energy Policy 172: 113272.
• Philenews. 2024. AKEL Criticises Government’s Approach to Cyprus Issue. April 22. https://in-cyprus.philenews.com/local/akel-criticises-governments-approach-to-cyprus-issue/ (accessed May 19, 2024).
• Prontera, A. 2017. The New Politics of Energy Security in the European Union and Beyond. New York, Routledge.
• Raimondi, P. R. 2023. The East Mediterranean’s Energy Resources are More Important Than Ever. Middle East and North Africa Forum (MENAF), January 18. https://manaramagazine.org/2023/01/the- east-mediterranean-energy-resources/ (accessed August 17, 2024)
• Rubin, A., and E. Eiran. 2019. Regional Maritime Security in the Eastern Mediterranean: Expectations and Reality. International Affairs 95, 5: 979-997.
• Ruble, I. 2017. European Union Energy Supply Security: The Benefits of Natural Gas Imports from the Eastern Mediterranean. Energy Policy 105: 341-353.
• Şahin, D., and A. Sözen. 2023. Russia and Turkey: A Roller Coaster Relationship between Securitization and Cooperation. Uluslararası İlişkiler 20, 79: 87-104.
• Schulz, F. 2019. EU’s New List of Energy Projects Includes 32 Gas Facilities. Euractiv. https://www.euractiv.com/section/climate-environment/news/eus-new-list-of-energy-projects-includes-32-gas- facilities/ (accessed August 5, 2024)
• Shama, N. 2019. Between Alliance and Entente: The Egyptian-Greek-Cypriot Partnership. In The New Geopolitics of the Eastern Mediterranean: Trilateral Partnerships and Regional Security, ed. Z. Tziarras, friedrich-ebert-stiftung ang PRIO Cyprus Centre: 96–110.
• Shiddigy, M. A., D. S. Lugo, and R. Novarizal. 2024. Regional Security Complex (RSC) in the Security Complexity of the Southeast Asia Region. International Journal of Religion 5, 11: 1244-1253.
• Stergiou, A. 2023. Eastern Mediterranean Energy Geopolitics Revisited: Green Economy Instead of Conflict. Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies 25, 4: 604–625.
• Stivachtis, Y. 2018. The EU and the Middle East: The European Neighbourhood Policy. E-International Relations. Nov 26. https://www.e-ir.info/2018/11/26/the-eu-and-the-middle-east-the-european- neighbourhood-policy/ (accessed April 11, 2024).
• Tagliapietra, S. 2013. Towards a New Eastern Mediterranean Energy Corridor? Natural Gas Developments between Market Opportunities and Geopolitical Risks. Fondazione ENI Enrico Mattei 12: 14-15.
• Tichý, L. and Z. Dubský. 2024. The EU Energy Security Relations with Russia until the Ukraine War. Energy Strategy Reviews 52: 101313.
• Tsakiris, T. 2014. Greece and the Energy Geopolitics of the Eastern Mediterranean. IDEAS reports - Strategic Updates (SU14.1). LSE IDEAS, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK.
• Tsakiris, T. 2017. The Energy Geopolitics of the Eastern Mediterranean and the Cyprus Problem. IEMed Mediterranean Yearbook 2017: 289–292.
• Tsakiris, T. 2021. The Energy Security Evolution of the Eastern Mediterranean: The Rise of Turkish Revisionism, Its Counter-Coalitions and the Geopolitical Significance of the East Med Gas Pipeline. In The New Eastern Mediterranean Transformed: Emerging Issues and New Actors, ed. A. Tziampiris and F. Asderaki, Springer eBooks: 139–158.
• Tziampiris, A. 2015. The Emergence of Israeli-Greek Cooperation. Cham, Springer.
• Tziarras, Z. 2016. Israel-Cyprus-Greece: a ‘Comfortable’ Quasi-Alliance. Mediterranean Politics 21, 3: 407-427.
• Wendt, M., and E. Petropoulos. 2023. Energy Region Greece & Eastern Mediterranean - a Region Arises as Europe's Supplier!. Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, March 20. https://www.kas.de/en/country- reports/detail/-/content/energy-region-greece-eastern-mediterranean (accessed November 25, 2024)
• Winrow, G. 2016. The Anatomy of a Possible Pipeline: The Case of Türkiye and Leviathan and Gas Politics in the Eastern Mediterranean. Journal of Balkan & Near Eastern Studies 18, 5: 431–447.
• Yacoob, R. 2023. Not Only the Dragon: Understanding Southeast Asia's Complex Security Landscape. The Interpreter. https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/not-only-dragon- understanding-southeast-asia-s-complex-security-landscape (accessed December 17, 2024)
• Youssef, H. 2023. The Future of Conflicts and Energy in the Mediterranean. In Conflict Resolution in the Mediterranean: Energy as a Potential Game-Changer, ed. A. Sözen, N. Goren, and C. Limon. Diplomeds - The Council for Mediterranean Diplomacy: 8-22.
• Zemach, S. 2016. Israel’s Exploitation of Hydrocarbons: Status quo or Quo vadis? In Energy Cooperation and Security in the Eastern Mediterranean: A Seismic Shift towards peace or Conflict? Ed. A. Giannakopoulos, Tel Aviv, The S. Daniel Abraham Center: 73-74.