EXAMINATION OF CONSTITUTIONALIST MOVEMENTS AND CONSTITUTIONS IN TERMS OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF DEMOCRACY IN THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE

Abstract

Constitutionalism involves curbing state power, protecting fundamental rights, and defending citizens' rights against the state. Aligned with democratic theory, it's grounded in the concept of human dignity, advocating for the autonomy and participation of vulnerable individuals in community governance. Democratic theory emphasizes the crucial right of citizens to influence the selection of lawmakers in a free society. Constitutionalism insists on honoring human dignity and values, affirming citizens' right to democratic participation while ensuring clear constraints on their governments, even when in line with the majority's preferences. Originating with the Magna Carta in 1215, constitutionalism reached Ottoman lands about six centuries later. Ottoman constitutional movements, commencing with the 1808 Sened-i Ittifak and progressing through the 1839 Tanzimat Edict, the 1856 Islahat (Reform) Edict, and the 1876 Constitution, were influenced by both internal and external factors. These movements, despite lacking public demand, played a pivotal role in introducing democratic values and institutions in Ottoman history, including the country's first parliamentary election.

Keywords

• Constitution
• Constitutional Movements
• Democracy
• Democratization
• Ottoman Empire

References

1. Ankara Bar Association (2017) “Constitutionalism from Past to Present”, http://www. ankarabarosu.org.tr/siteler/ankarabarosu/hgdmakale/2008-1/13.pdf (27.02.2017).
2. Bailyn, B. (2003) “To Begin the World Anew: The Genius and Ambiguities of the American Founders”, New York: Vintage Books.
3. Bill of Rights Institute (2024) “Bill of Rights: The 1st Ten Amendments”, https://billofrightsinstitute.org/primary-sources/bill-of-rights (08.03.2024).
4. British Library (2014) “Magna Carta”, https://www.bl.uk/magna-carta/articles/magnacarta-english-translation (14.10.2018).
5. Britannica (2024) “Enlightenment”, https://www.britannica.com/event/Enlightenment-European-history (08.03.2024).
6. Bora, T. (2017) “Currents: Political Ideologies in Turkey” 5th edition, İstanbul: Iletisim Publishing. Cihan, A. and I. Dogan (2006) “Classical Ottoman Social Structure and Civil Society”, Zencirkıran (ed.) Social Structure of Turkey from Past to Present, 1st edition, Ankara: Nova Publishing.
7. Dahl, R. (1971) “Polyarchy: Participation and Opposition”, New Haven: Yale University Press. Dahl, R. (2010) “On Democracy” 2nd edition, Ankara: Phoenix Publishing.
8. Durdu, M. B. (2003) “The Beginning and Effects of the Young Turk Movement in the Ottoman Empire”, Journal of Ankara University Ottoman History Research and Application Center 14: 291-318.

9. Grimm, D. (2016) “Constitutionalism: Past, Present, and Future”, New York: Oxford University Press. Gozler, K. (2011) “General Principles of Constitutional Law” 2nd edition, Bursa: Ekin Publishing.
10. Gozler, K. (2013) “Turkish Constitutional Law Courses” 14th edition, Bursa: Ekin Publishing.
11. Gozubuyuk, S. and Kili, S. (1982) “Turkish Constitutional Texts” 2nd edition, Ankara: Ankara University Faculty of Political Sciences Publications.
12. Grand National Assembly of Türkiye (2023), “Turkish Constitutional Texts from the Ottoman to the Present”, Ankara: Grand National Assembly of Turkiye Printing House.
13. Held, D. (2006) “Models of Democracy” 3rd edition, Cambridge: Polity Press.
14. Humboldt, W. (2013) “The Limits of State Action”, Anakara: Liberte Publishing.
15. Ilal, E. (1968) “Magna Carta”, Istanbul University Faculty of Law Journal, 34(1-4): 210-242.
16. Isiksel, T. (2013) “Between Text and Context: Turkey’s Tradition of Authoritarian Constitutionalism”, International Journal of Contitutional Law, 11(3): 702-726.
17. Karpat, K. (2012) “History of Turkish Democracy: Social, Cultural, Economic Foundations” 3rd edition, İstanbul: Timas Publishing.
18. Kucuk, A. (2005) “Constitutions and Constitutional Movements in Turkey” 1st edition, Kucuk et. al. (eds.) Political Life in Turkey on the Threshold of the 21st Century, V. I., İstanbul: Aktuel Publishing.
19. Landemore, H. (2020) “Open Democracy: Reinventing Popular Rule for the Twenty-First Century”, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
20. Lederman, S. (2022) “Representative Democracy and Colonial Inspirations: The Case of John Stuart Mill”, American Political Science Review, 116(3): 927-939.
21. Mardin, S. (1990) “Society and Politics in Turkey: Articles 1” 1st edition, İstanbul: Iletisim Publishing.
22. Murphy, W. F. (1993) “Constitutions, Constitutionalism, and Democracy”, Greenberg et. al. (eds.) Constitutionalism and Democracy: Transitions in the Contemporary World, New York: Oxford University Press.
23. Olgun, K. (2011) “General Election Practices from the Proclamation of the Republic to 1950 in Turkey”, Journal of Atatürk Research Center, 27(79): 1-36.
24. Ozbudun, E. (2000) “Turkish Constitutional Law” 6th edition, Ankara: Yetkin Publishing.
25. Ozdemir, Y., Ciydem, E. and Aktas, E. (2014) “Background of Tanzimat Edict”, Kastamonu Education Journal, 22(1): 321-338.
26. Presidency of the Turkish Grand National Assembly, Constitution and Bylaws Site (2018) https://anayasa.tbmm.gov.tr/1876.aspx (15.10.2018).
27. Presidency of the Turkish Grand National Assembly, Constitution and Bylaws Site (2019) https://anayasa.tbmm.gov.tr/docs/1876/1876-1/1876-1-degisiklik.pdf (06.05.2019).
28. Tanor. B. (2017) “Ottoman-Turkish Constitutional Developments” 28th edition, İstanbul: Yapı Kredi Publications.
29. Tepekaya, M. (2013) “Saruhan (Manisa) Sancak Union and Progress Party Candidate Yusuf Riza Bey’s Election Declaration During the Ottoman Parliament Election in 1912”, Journal of Modern Turkish History Studies, 13(27): 33-61.
30. Timur, T. (2001) “Ottoman Social Order” 4th edition, Ankara: İmge Kitabevi.
31. Turkish Constitutional Law Site (2017) http://www.anayasa.gen.tr/osmanli.htm#_ftn5 (28.02.2017).
32. Turkish Language Society (2018) http://www.tdk.gov.tr/ (15.10.2018).
33. Tushnet, M. (2015) “Authoritarian Constitutionalism”, Cornell Law Review, 100(2): 391-462.
34. Ulken, H. Z. (2018) “History of Contemporary Thought in Turkey” 5th edition, İstanbul: Türkiye İş Bankası Cultural Publications.
35. Unsal, A. (1998) “Citizenship Hard Craft”, From Subject to Citizen in 75 Years, İstanbul: Türkiye İş Bankası Publications.
36. Urhan, V. (2016) “Constitutional Administration in Aristotle's Political Philosophy”, Kaygı: Bursa Uludağ University Faculty of Arts and Sciences Journal of Philosophy, 27: 211-230.
37. Yale Law School the Avalon Project (2024) “Declaration of the Rights of Man – 1789”, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/rightsof.asp (08.03.2024).
38. Yayla, A. (2012) “Constitutionalism, Constitutional Democracy and Ideologies”, Liberal Thought, (66): 13-22. Yayla, A. (2015) “Liberalism” 7th edition, Ankara: Liberte Publishing.
39. Yılmaz, F. (2012) “Turkish Constitutional History”, İstanbul: Iz Publishing.
40. Zens, R., (2011) “Provincial Powers: The Rise of Ottoman Local Notables (Ayan)”, History Studies, 3(3): 433-447.