Evaluation of the Impact of Dam Reservoirs on Outdoor Thermal Comfort: The Case of Keban Dam Lake, Elazığ

Abstract

Dams not only regulate river flow and provide essential irrigation for adjacent agricultural areas but also induce microclimatic modifications due to the formation of large water bodies. This study investigates the microclimatic effects of the Keban Dam, located in Elazığ, eastern Türkiye, with a particular focus on its influence on local thermal comfort conditions. Meteorological data spanning a total of 32 years were categorized into three periods: pre-construction (1963–1973), postconstruction (1974–1984), and a recent period (2011–2020). Thermal comfort was assessed using data from three meteorological stations, employing two widely recognized indices: The Temperature-Humidity Index (THI) and the Physiologically Equivalent Temperature (PET). The findings indicate notable changes in both climatic conditions and thermal comfort following the dam’s construction. Compared to the pre-dam period, an average increase of 1.0 °C in THI values was observed, with this rise evident in both summer and winter seasons. The 10-year PET analysis revealed average values of 13.8 °C at the Keban Meteorology Station, 11.1 °C at the Elazığ Airport Meteorology Station, and 12.0 °C at the Elazığ Regional Meteorology Station. These variations in thermal comfort are considered to result not only from the hydrological and surface energy balance changes associated with the dam’s reservoir, but also from broader climatic factors such as global warming. In this context, the findings contribute to a better understanding of anthropogenic landscape modifications and their long-term bioclimatic implications.

Keywords

• Urban microclimate
• Dam reservoirs
• Impact of dams on climate
• Thermal comfort
• Physically Equivalent Temperature (PET)
• Temperature Humidity Index (THI)

References

1. Aboelata A (2020). Vegetation in different street orientations of aspect ratio (H/W 1: 1) to mitigate UHI and reduce buildings’ energy in arid climate. Building and Environment. 172. 106712
2. Ali-Toudert F & Mayer H (2007). Effects of asymmetry, galleries, overhanging facades and vegetation on thermal comfort in urban street canyons. Solar Energy. 81(6): 742-754 Anonymous (2024). Geographical Structure. https://www.elazig.bel.tr/kent-rehberi/cografi-yapi/217/ (In Turkish)
3. Antoniou A, Larissi I, Maitos A & Paliatsos A G (2008). Case studies on discomfort levels in different regions in Athens, Greece. International Scientific Conference SynEnergy Forum (S.E.F.) The Conference for International Synergy in Energy, Environment, Tourism and Information Technology. II. Energy/ Environment II Session 4. Spetses, Greece 28-31 May 2008, 8 pp
4. Aram F, Solgi E, Higueras Garcia E, Mosavi A & R. Várkonyi-Kóczy A (2019). The cooling effect of large-scale urban parks on surrounding area thermal comfort. Energies. 12(20): 3904
5. Atay H, Tüvan A, Demir Ö & Balta İ (2012). The effects of climate change on health. Ankara: Ministry of Forestry and Water Affairs General Directorate of Meteorology. (In Turkish)
6. Broadbent A M, Coutts A M, Tapper N J, Demuzere M & Beringer J (2018). The microscale cooling effects of water sensitive urban design and irrigation in a suburban environment. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 134: 1-23
7. Chatzidimitriou A & Yannas S (2017). Street canyon design and improvement potential for urban open spaces; the influence of canyon aspect ratio and orientation on microclimate and outdoor comfort. Sustainable Cities and Society 33: 85-101
8. Cinar İ, Karakus N & Toy S (2023). Analysing daytime summer thermal comfort conditions for Turkey’s third largest tourism destination. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 30(17): 50046-50056

9. Deng X, Cao Q, Wang L, Wang W, Wang S & Wang L (2022). Understanding the impact of urban expansion and lake shrinkage on summer climate and human thermal comfort in a land‐water mosaic area. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 127(11): e2021JD036131.
10. Deng J Y & Wong N H (2020). Impact of urban canyon geometries on outdoor thermal comfort in central business districts. Sustainable Cities and Society 53: 101966
11. Emmanuel R (2005). Thermal comfort implications of urbanization in a warm-humid city: the Colombo Metropolitan Region (CMR), Sri Lanka. Building and Environment 40(12): 1591-1601
12. Erol O (2011). General climatology. Istanbul: Cantay Publications. (In Turkish) Fabbri K, Ugolini A, Iacovella A & Bianchi A P (2020). The effect of vegetation in outdoor thermal comfort in archaeological area in urban context. Building and Environment 175: 106816
13. Gholami Z, Jalilisadrabad S & Amrollahi R (2023). The effect of using nanomaterial at the ground level of urban space on the thermal comfort. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology pp. 1-14
14. Grene M & Depew D (2004). The philosophy of biology: an episodic history. Cambridge University Press. Gulyás Á & Matzarakis A (2009). Seasonal and spatial distribution of physiologically equivalent temperature (PET) index in Hungary. Quarterly Journal of the Hungarian Meteorological Service 113(3): 221-231
15. Höppe P (1999). The physiological equivalent temperature a universal index for the biometeorological assessment of the thermal environment. International Journal of Biometeorology 43: 71–75
16. Irmak M A, Yilmaz S, Mutlu E & Yilmaz H (2018). Assessment of the effects of different tree spesciess on urban microclimate. Environmental Science and Pollution Research pp. 1- 21
17. Irmak M A, Yilmaz S, Mutlu E & Yilmaz H (2020). Analysis of different urban spaces on thermal comfort in cold regions: A case from Erzurum. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 141: 1593-1609
18. Irmak M A, Yilmaz S, Yilmaz H, Ozer S & Toy S (2013). Evaluation of different thermal conditions based on thi under different kind of tree types-as a specific case in ata botanic garden in eastern Turkey. Irmak M A, Yilmaz S & Dursun D (2017). Effect of different pavements on human thermal comfort conditions. Atmósfera. 30(4): 355-366
19. Kyle W J (1994). The human bioclimate of Hong Kong. In Proceedings of the Contemporary Climatology Conference, Brno. TISK LITERA, Brno. pp. 345-350
20. Lai D, Liu Y, Liao M & Yu B (2023). Effects of different tree layouts on outdoor thermal comfort of green space in summer Shanghai. Urban Climate. 47: 101398
21. Lashaki A B, Motevalli S & Ghobadi G J (2022). Investigating beach tourism climate of Mazandaran Province emphasizing the sustainable development approach using beach climate index (BCI) and physiologically equivalent temperature (PET). Theoretical and Applied Climatology 150(3-4): 1253-1269
22. Lehnert M, Brabec M, Jurek M, Tokar V & Geletič J (2021). The role of blue and green infrastructure in thermal sensation in public urban areas: A case study of summer days in four Czech cities. Sustainable Cities and Society 66: 102683
23. Li H, He Y & Harvey J (2016). Human thermal comfort: Modeling the impact of different cool pavement strategies. Transportation Research Record 2575(1): 92-102
24. Lin T P & Matzarakis A (2011). Tourism climate information based on human thermal perception in Taiwan and Eastern China. Tourism Management 32(3): 492-500
25. Lopez-Cabeza V P, Alzate-Gaviria S, Diz-Mellado E, Rivera-Gomez C & Galan-Marin C (2022). Albedo influence on the microclimate and thermal comfort of courtyards under Mediterranean hot summer climate conditions. Sustainable Cities and Society 81: 103872
26. Matzarakis A (2006). Weather-and climate-related information for tourism. Tourism and Hospitality Planning & Development. 3(2): 99-115 Matzarakis A & Mayer H (1997). Heat stress in Greece. International Journal of Biometeorology 41: 34-39
27. Matzarakis A, Mayer H & Iziomon M G (1999). Applications of a universal thermal index: physiological equivalent temperature. International Journal of Biometeorology 43: 76-84
28. Matzarakis A & Fröhlich D (2017). Influence of urban green on human thermal bioclimate-application of thermal indices and micro-scale models. In International Symposium on Greener Cities for More Efficient Ecosystem Services in a Climate Changing World 1215. 1-10
29. Mayer H & Höppe P (1987). Thermal comfort of man in different urban environments. Theoretical and Applied Climatology 38: 43-49
30. Muniz-Gäal L P, Pezzuto C C, de Carvalho M F H & Mota L T M (2020). Urban geometry and the microclimate of street canyons in tropical climate. Building and Environment 169: 106547
31. Niu J, Xiong J, Qin H, Hu J, Deng J, Han G & Yan J (2022). Influence of thermal comfort of green spaces on physical activity: Empirical study in an urban park in Chongqing, China. Building and Environment 219: 109168
32. Nouri A S, Fröhlich D, Matos Silva M & Matzarakis A (2018). The impact of Tipuana tipu species on local human thermal comfort thresholds in different urban canyon cases in Mediterranean climates: Lisbon, Portugal. Atmosphere 9(1): 12
33. Peng M & Huang H (2022). The synergistic effect of urban canyon geometries and greenery on outdoor thermal comfort in humid subtropical climates. Frontiers in Environmental Science 10: 851810
34. Schibuola L & Tambani C (2022). A monthly performance comparison of green infrastructures enhancing urban outdoor thermal comfort. Energy and Buildings 273: 112368
35. Shiue I & Matzarakis A (2011). Estimation of the tourism climate in the Hunter Region, Australia, in the early twenty-first century. International Journal of Biometeorology 55: 565-574
36. Sodoudi S, Zhang H, Chi X, Müller F & Li H (2018). The influence of spatial configuration of green areas on microclimate and thermal comfort. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 34: 85-96
37. Song X, Wang G, Deng Q, Wang S & Jiao C (2023). The influence of residential block form on summer thermal comfort of street canyons in the warm temperate zone of China. Buildings 13(7): 1627
38. Taleghani M & Berardi U (2018). The effect of pavement characteristics on pedestrians' thermal comfort in Toronto. Urban Climate. 24: 449-459
39. Taleghani M, Clark A, Swan W & Mohegh A (2020). Air pollution in a microclimate; the impact of different green barriers on the dispersion. Science of the Total Environment 711: 134649
40. Taleghani M, Sailor D & Ban-Weiss G A (2016). Micrometeorological simulations to predict the impacts of heat mitigation strategies on pedestrian thermal comfort in a Los Angeles neighborhood. Environmental Research Letters 11(2): 024003
41. Theeuwes N E, Solcerova A & Steeneveld G J (2013). Modeling the influence of open water surfaces on the summertime temperature and thermal comfort in the city. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 118(16): 8881-8896 Thom E C (1959). The discomfort index. Weatherwise 12: 57–60
42. Tian Y, Hong B, Zhang Z, Wu S & Yuan T (2022). Factors influencing resident and tourist outdoor thermal comfort: A comparative study in China's cold region. Science of the Total Environment 808: 152079 Toy S, Yilmaz S & Yilmaz H (2007). Determination of bioclimatic comfort in three different land uses in the city of Erzurum, Turkey. Building and Environment 42(3): 1315-1318
43. Türkeş M (1997). On the concepts of weather and climate. TÜBİTAK Science and Technical Journal 355: 36-37, Ankara. (In Turkish)
44. Tzenkova A, Ivancheva J, Koleva E & Videnov P (2007). The human comfort conditions at Bulgarian black sea side. A. Matzarakis, C. R. de Freitas, D. Scott (ed), Developments in Tourism Climatology. 150-157. Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia. Unger J (1999). Urban – rural air humidity differences in Szeged, Hungary. International Journal of Climatology 19: 1509 – 1515
45. Wang L, Wang G, Chen T & Liu J (2023). The regulating effect of urban large planar water bodies on residential heat islands: a case study of Meijiang Lake in Tianjin. Land. 12(12): 2126
46. Xiao J, Yuizono T & Gokon H (2021). Numerical simulation of winter microclimate and thermal comfort of an asymmetric canyon in the urban square area. In 2021 5th International Conference on Vision, Image and Signal Processing (ICVISP). 201-205. IEEE.
47. Xiong J, Cheng B, Zhang J, Liu Y, Tan X, Shi M & Guo J (2023). A study of waterside microenvironmental factors and their effects on summer outdoor thermal comfort in a Cfa-climate campus. Journal of Thermal Biology 117: 103700
48. Yılmaz S, Irmak M A & Matzarakis A (2013). The importance of thermal comfort in the different elevation for city planning. Global NEST Journal 15(3): 408-420
49. Yilmaz S, Toy S, Irmak M A & Yilmaz H (2007). Determination of climatic differences in three different land uses in the city of Erzurum, Turkey. Building and Environment 42(4): 1604-1612
50. Yilmaz S, Sezen I, Irmak M A & Külekçi E A (2021). Analysis of outdoor thermal comfort and air pollution under the influence of urban morphology in cold-climate cities: Erzurum/Turkey. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 28: 64068-64083