The Engineering-Oriented Empirical Turn in the Philosophy of Technology and AI: Perspectives from American and Chinese Pragmatism
Abstract
This article critically interrogates the analytical historiography of the engineering-oriented “empirical turn” in the philosophy of technology and artificial intelligence (AI) by contrasting the accounts of Hans Achterhuis, Philip Brey, and Vincent Blok with the pragmatist frameworks of Stephen H. Cutcliffe and Bocong Li. While Achterhuis institutionalized the “American philosophy of technology: empirical turn” and Brey theorized this paradigm through Carl Mitcham’s humanities-vs.-engineering dichotomy, their strictly analytical orientation significantly disregards both American and Chinese pragmatist traditions. To bridge this conceptual omission, this study operationalizes Cutcliffe’s and Li’s engineering philosophies by integrating Charles Sanders Peirce’s nominalism and experimentalism, William James’s consequentialism, and medieval Muslim philosopher al-Ghazâlî’s nominalist-experimentalist insights. We position Cutcliffe and Li as the foundational theorists of American and Chinese pragmatist engineering-oriented empirical turns, respectively, both arguing that the discipline must be fundamentally rooted in society-centered, generative production processes—a stance that directly challenges Brey’s taxonomies. Furthermore, although the “philosophy of AI” emerged through the seminal works of Margaret A. Boden (1990) and Matt Carter (2007), this article substantiates why the discourse must now be subsumed under a broader philosophy of technology. Ultimately, by leveraging Li’s ontology—which aligns technological production with historical identity and existential validation—this article synthesizes an engineering-oriented empirical paradigm with contemporary post-colonial manufacturing and technological agency.
Keywords
Philosophy of technology and AI, Empirical turn, Engineering-oriented philosophy, Pragmatism and nominalism, Decisive societies
Supporting Institution
Ethical Statement
Thanks
References
- Achterhuis, H. (Ed.). (2001). American Philosophy of Technology: The empirical turn (R. P. Crease, Trans.). Indiana University Press.
- Adams, H. (1999). The Education of Henry Adams. (Ira B. Nadel, Ed.). Oxford University Press.
- Adams, J. T. (1941). The Epic of America. Blue Ribbon Books. (Original work published 1931).
- Gazzâlî. H. (2005). Tehâfütü’l-felâsife: Filozofların tutarsızlığı (M. Kaya & H. Sarıoğlu, Trans.). Klasik Yayınları.
- Aşık Birlik, B. (2025). The concept of “digital habitus” by Alberto Romele and the crisis of human existence in the context of Val Dusek’s philosophy of artificial intelligence. MetaMind: Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Philosophy of Mind, 8(1), 83–103. https://doi.org/10.51404/metazihin.1674795
- Boden, M. A. (Ed.). (1990). The philosophy of artificial intelligence. Oxford University Press.
- Bosschaert, M. T. & Blok, V. (2022). The ‘empirical’ in the empirical turn: A critical analysis. Foundations of Science, 28, 783–804 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10699-022-09840-6
- Braidotti, R. (2013). The posthuman. Polity Press.
- Brey, P. (2010). Philosophy of technology after the empirical turn. Techné: Research in Philosophy and Technology, 14(1), 36–48. https://doi.org/10.5840/techne20101416
- Carter, M. (2007). Minds and computers: An introduction to the philosophy of artificial intelligence. Edinburgh University Press.