Enhancing climate change resilience: Assessing adaptation needs, and significance of monitoring and evaluation systems

Abstract

Losses and damages from climate change-related extreme weather events and disasters require the development of adaptation measures to increase resilience to the adverse impacts of climate change. In line with the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the Paris Agreement's Global Goal on Adaptation, Parties have developed strategies that include adaptation actions, but there are significant gaps in the identification of adaptation needs and the monitoring and evaluation (M&E) of actions to address them. Adaptation M&E systems are critical for measuring the success of adaptation actions, providing feedback from the implementation process, and identifying new actions. There is no global methodology for adaptation M&E. At international climate change negotiations in 2023, it was agreed that countries should operationalize their national adaptation M&E systems by 2030. The study aims to evaluate adaptation M&E methodologies developed by countries at different development levels and to present future policy recommendations for the adaptation M&E system planned to be established in Türkiye. The study reveals the necessity of up-to-date socio-economic data as well as climate data in determining adaptation needs and adaptation M&E systems. In Türkiye, which is vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, for the success of adaptation actions, besides the rapid operationalization of the adaptation M&E system, the establishment of the system with an approach that includes all stakeholders in the process and considers adaptation actions as integrated with disaster risk management actions is an important requirement in the context of Türkiye's international commitments, national security, and development.

Keywords

• Adaptation
• Climate Change
• Disaster
• Evaluation
• Monitoring
• Resilience

References

1. IPCC, “2022: Summary for Policymakers,” In H.-O. Pörtner, D.C. Roberts, E.S. Poloczanska, K. Mintenbeck, M. Tignor, A. Alegría, M. Craig, S. Langsdorf, S. Löschke, V. Möller, A. Okem (eds.), Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK and New York, NY, USA, pp. 333, 2022. [CrossRef]
2. A. V. Ospina, “Monitoring and evaluation in the NAP process: Opportunities, challenges, and emerging solutions,” https://napglobalnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/napgn-en-2018-snapshot-monitoring-and-evaluation-in-the-nap-process-opportunities-challenges-and-emerging-solutions.pdf, Accessed on Jan 13, 2024.
3. E. Beauchamp, and I. Józefiak, “Next steps for defining a monitoring, evaluation, and learning system for the global goal on adaptation by COP 28,” IISD, Winnipeg, Manitoba, 2023.
4. E. Beauchamp, and I. Józefiak, “Five ways the global goal on adaptation can help build a global monitoring, evaluation, and learning system for adaptation by COP 28,” https://www.iisd.org/articles/insight/five-ways-global-goal-adaptation Accessed on Feb 13, 2024.
5. UNFCCC, “Paris agreement,” https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/english_paris_agreement.pdf, Accessed on Dec 11, 2023.
6. EEA, “Climate change impacts, risks and adaptation,” https://www.eea.europa.eu/en/topics/in-depth/climate-change-impacts-risks-and-adaptation Accessed on Jun 17, 2024.
7. S. Singh, and M. K. Goyal, “Enhancing climate resilience in businesses: The role of artificial intelligence,” Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol 418, Article 138228, 2023. [CrossRef]
8. Ç. Tuğaç, “Urbanization policies in the context of climate resilient Development,” Idealkent, Vol 13(37), pp. 16401666, 2022. [CrossRef]

9. E. Elnagar, A. Zeoli, R. Rahif, S. Attia, and V. Lemort, “A qualitative assessment of integrated active cooling systems: A review with a focus on system flexibility and climate resilience,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol 175, Article 113179, 2023. [CrossRef]
10. Y. H. Labaran, H. Mato, G. Saini, and A.A. Musa, “Towards net zero energy buildings: A review of barriers and facilitators to the adoption of building energy efficiency practices,” Environmental Research and Technology, Vol 7(1), pp. 118130, 2024. [CrossRef]
11. C.N. Novenario, and T. Istiaque, “Three ways that clean energy innovation and climate change adaptation can work in lockstep,” https://gca.org/three-ways-that-clean-energy-innovation-and-climate-change-adaptation-can-work-in-lockstep/ Accessed on Jun 16 Jun 2024.
12. Y. Zhou, “Climate change adaptation with energy resilience in energy districts—A state-of-the-art review,” Energy and Buildings, Vol 279, 112649, 2023. [CrossRef]
13. C. G. Diaz, D. Zambrana-Vasquez, and C. Bartolomé, “Building resilient cities: a comprehensive review of climate change adaptation indicators for urban design,” Energies, Vol 17(8), Article 1959, 2024. [CrossRef]
14. Ö. Işınkaralar, “A climate-sensitive approach for determining the urban growth boundaries: Towards a spatial exploration for Bursa, Türkiye” Journal of Urban Planning and Development, Vol 149(4), Article 040223046, 2023. [CrossRef]
15. Ö. Işınkaralar, “Spatio-temporal change of the morphology in west corridor development region of Ankara city and 2022-2039 growth estimation,” Megaron, Vol 19(1), pp. 5160, 2024. [CrossRef]
16. H. Bulkeley, and R. Tuts, “Understanding urban vulnerability, adaptation and resilience in the context of climate change,” Local Environment, Vol 18(6), pp.646662, 2013. [CrossRef]
17. S. C. Woodruff, S. Meerow, M. Stults, and C. Wilkins, “Adaptation to resilience planning: alternative pathways to prepare for climate change,” Journal of Planning Education and Research, Vol 42(1), pp. 6475, 2018. [CrossRef]
18. K. L. Ebi, C. Boyer, K.J. Bowen, H. Frumkin, and J. Hess, “Monitoring and evaluation indicators for climate change-related health impacts, risks, adaptation, and resilience,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol 15(9), Article 1943, 2018. [CrossRef]
19. S. Islam, C. Chu, J.C.R. Smart, and L. Liew, “Integrating disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation: a systematic literature review,” Climate and Development, Vol 12(3), pp. 255267, 2020. [CrossRef]
20. W. N. M. W. M. Rani, K. H. Kamarudin, K. A. Razak, and Z. M. Asmawi, “Climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction in urban development plans for resilient cities,” IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, Vol 409, Article 012024, 2020. [CrossRef]
21. S. J. Birchall, and N. Bonnett, “Climate change adaptation policy and practice: The role of agents, institutions and systems,” Cities, Vol 108, Article 103001, 2021. [CrossRef]
22. L. M. Dellmuth, and M. T. Gustafsson, “Global adaptation governance: how intergovernmental organizations mainstream climate change adaptation,” Climate Policy, Vol 21(7), pp. 868883, 2021. [CrossRef]
23. J. W. Moore, and D. E. Schindler, “Getting ahead of climate change for ecological adaptation and resilience,” Science, Vol 376(6600), pp. 14211426, 2022. [CrossRef]
24. B. Turner, T. Devisscher, N. Chabaneix, S. Woroniecki, C. Messier, and N. Seddon, “The role of nature-based solutions in supporting social-ecological resilience for climate change adaptation,” Annual Review of Environment and Resources, Vol 47, pp. 123148, 2022. [CrossRef]
25. P. Iradunka, E.M. Mwanaumo, and J. Kabika, “A review of integrated multicriteria decision support analysis in the climate resilient infrastructure development,” Environmental and Sustainability Indicators, Vol 20, Article 100312, 2023. [CrossRef]
26. Ç. Tuğaç, “Evaluation of urban infrastructure policies in Turkey for climate resilience and adaptation,” Sustainable and Resilient Infrastructure, Vol 8(Suppl 1), pp. 190202, 2023. [CrossRef]
27. T. Alemu, and A. Mengistu, “Impacts of climate change on food security in ethiopia: adaptation and mitigation options: a review,” In P. Castro, A. Azul, W.L., U. Azeiteiro (eds.). Climate change-resilient agriculture and agroforestry. climate change management (pp. 397412), Springer, 2019. [CrossRef]
28. G. Güneş, “Evaluation of Bartın river water quality index and suitability as irrigation water with physicochemical parameters,” Environmental Research and Technology, Vol 5(4), pp. 357368, 2022. [CrossRef]
29. G. Rasul, and B. Sharma, “The nexus approach to water–energy–food security: an option for adaptation to climate change,” Climate Policy, Vol 16(6), pp. 682702, 2016. [CrossRef]
30. S. Javadinejad, R. Dara, and F. Jafary, “Analysis and prioritization the effective factors on increasing farmers resilience under climate change and drought,” Agricultural Research, Vol 10, pp. 497513, 2021. [CrossRef]
31. S.G. Sandi, J.F. Rodriguez, N. Saintilan, L. Wen, G. Kuczera, G. Riccardi, and P.M. Saco, “Resilience to drought of dryland wetlands threatened by climate change,” Scientific Reports, Vol 10, Article 13232, 2020. [CrossRef]
32. E. Beauchamp, “How to raise the GlaSS on the global goal on adaptation at COP 27: Four foundations to build upon,” https://www.iisd.org/articles/deep-dive/glass-global-goal-adaptation-cop-27, Accessed on Dec 11, 2023.
33. P. Guerdat, S. Masud, and E. Beauchamp, “Reporting on progress in national adaptation plan processes: An analysis,” Available: https://napglobalnetwork.org/resource/reporting-on-progress-in-nap-process/ Accessed on Dec 11, 2023.
34. A. Michaelowa, and M. Stadelmann, “Development of universal metrics for adaptation effectiveness,” In L. Christiansen, G. Martinez, P. Naswa, P. (eds.). Adaptation metrics: Perspectives on measuring, aggregating and comparing adaptation results. UNEP DTU Partnership. pp. 63-73, 2018.
35. UNFCCC, “Report of the adaptation committee,” Adaptation Committee, United Arab Emirates, FCCC/SB/2023/5., 2023.
36. UNEP, “Adaptation gap report: Underfinanced. Underprepared–inadequate investment and planning on climate adaptation leaves world exposed,” UNEP, Nairobi, 2023.
37. UNFCCC, “Glasgow–Sharm el-Sheikh work programme on the global goal on adaptation referred to in decision 7/CMA.3,” Available: https://unfccc.int/documents/636595 Accessed on Dec 20, 2023.
38. UNFCCC, “Matters relating to the global stocktake under the Paris agreement,” Available: https://unfccc.int/documents/636584 Accessed on Dec 20, 2023.
39. UNFCCC, “Data for adaptation at different spatial and temporal scales,” UNFCCC, 2020.
40. UNFCCC, “Introduction: adaptation and resilience,” https://unfccc.int/topics/adaptation-and-resilience/the-big-picture/introduction Accessed on Dec 20, 2023.
41. UNFCCC, “Opportunities and options for enhancing adaptation action through education and training, and public and youth participation,” UNFCCC, Technical paper by the secretariat FCCC/TP/2021/1, 2021.
42. L. Christiansen, and G. Martinez, “Adaptation metrics: perspectives on measuring, aggregating, and comparing adaptation results,” In L. Christiansen, G. Martinez, P. Naswa, P. (eds.). Adaptation metrics: Perspectives on measuring, aggregating, and comparing adaptation results. UNEP DTU Partnership (pp. 714), 2018.
43. M. Leitner, K. Mäkinen, J. Mysiak, S. Torresan, S. Vikstrom, W. Ligtvoet, and A. Prutsch, “Monitoring and evaluation of national adaptation policies throughout the policy cycle,” Publications Office of the European Union, EEA Report No 06/2020, 2020.
44. UNDP, “UNDP adaptation monitoring paper/may 2022,” https://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke326/files/migration/mv/Adaptation-Monitoring---Policy-Brief-GGA-May-2022.pdf Accessed on Sep 9, 2023.
45. I.K. Murthy, S. Sahay, I. Feldman, D. Ouazar, H. Bachegour, T.M. Cheranda, and R. Blaghi, “Navigating the fine line: Defining boundaries between adaptation and loss & damage in a changing climate,”: https://adaptationmetrics.org/sites/default/files/2023-11/VC1-Defining-Boundaries_0.pdf Accessed on Dec 19, 2023.
46. UNFCCC, “Draft technical paper on monitoring and evaluation of adaptation at the national and subnational level,” Adaptation Committee, AC22/TP/7C, 2022.
47. UNFCCC, “Technical dialogue of the first global stocktake: synthesis report by the co-facilitators on the technical dialogue,” UNFCCC, FCCC/SB/2023/9, 2023.
48. UNFCCC, “Monitoring and evaluation of adaptation at the national and subnational levels,” Adaptation Committee, Bonn, Technical Paper, 2023.
49. UNFCCC, “United nations framework convention on climate change,” https://unfccc.int/files/essential_background/background_publications_htmlpdf/application/pdf/conveng.pdf Accessed on Nov 2, 2023.
50. UNFCCC, “Cancun agreements,” https://unfccc.int/process/conferences/pastconferences/cancun-climate-change-conference-november-2010/statements-and-resources/Agreements, Accessed on Nov 2, 2023.
51. The GCOS website, https://gcos.wmo.int/en/home, 2024.
52. GCOS, “Essential climate variables,” Available: https://gcos.wmo.int/en/essential-climate-variables/table Accessed on Sep 1, 2023.
53. UNFCCC, “Methodologies for assessing adaptation needs and their application,” UNFCCC, Bonn, Technical Paper, 2022.
54. D. Bours, C. McGinn, and P. Pringle. Monitoring & Evaluation for Climate Change Adaptation and Resilience: A Synthesis of Tools, Frameworks, and Approaches, 2nd ed., SEA Change CoP, Phnom Penh & UKCIP. 2023.
55. M. Spearman, and H. McGray. Making Adaptation Count: Concepts and Options for Monitoring and Evaluation of Climate Change Adaptation. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH, Germany, 2011.
56. L. Berrang-Ford, R. Biesbroek, J. D. Ford, A. Lesnikowski, A. Tanabe, F. M. Wang, C. Chen, A. Hsu, J. J. Hellmann, P. Pringle, M. Greceque, J.C. Amado, S. Hug, S. Lwasa, and S. J. Heymann, “Tracking global climate change adaptation among governments,” Nature Climate Change, Vol. 9(6), pp. 440449, 2019. [CrossRef]
57. UNFCCC, “Report on the workshop on the monitoring and evaluation of adaptation,” Adaptation Committee, AC/2014/4, 2014.
58. M. Haasnoot, S. van’t Klooster, and J. van Alphen, “Designing a monitoring system to detect signals to adapt to uncertain climate change,” Global Environmental Change, Vol. 52, pp. 273–285, 2018. [CrossRef]
59. J. Klostermann, K. van de Sandt, M. Harley, M. Hildén, T. Leiter, J. van Minnen, N. Pieterse, and L. van Bree, “Towards a framework to assess, compare and develop monitoring and evaluation of climate change adaptation in Europe,” Mitigation and Adaptation Strategy for Global Change, Vol. 23(2), pp. 187–209, 2018. [CrossRef]
60. J.W. Pearce-Higgins, L.H. Antão, R.E. Bates, K.M. Bowgen, C.D. Bradshaw, S.J. Duffield, C. Foulkes, A.M.A. Franco, J. Geschke, R.D. Gregory, M.J. Harley, J.A. Hodgson, R.L.M. Jenkins, V. Kapos, K.M. Maltby, O. Watts, S.G. Willis, and M.D. Morecroft, “A framework for climate change adaptation indicators for the natural environment,” Ecological Indicators, Vol. 136, Article 108690, 2022. [CrossRef]
61. R. Taylor, “Monitoring and evaluation of climate change adaptation: an introduction,” https://www.weadapt.org/knowledge-base/governance-institutions-and-policy/monitoring-and-evaluation-of-climate-change-adaptation-an-introduction Accessed on Sep 9, 2023.
62. M. Olazabel, I. Galarraga, J. Ford, E. Sainz De Murieta, and A. Lesnikowski, “Are local Climate-ADAPTation policies credible? A conceptual and operational assessment framework,” International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development, Vol. 11(3), pp. 277–296, 2019. [CrossRef]
63. N. Brooks, and S. Fisher. Tracking Adaptation and Measuring Development: A Step-By-Step Guide. IISD, 2014.
64. GLISA, “Adaptation monitoring and evaluation toolkit,” https://glisa.umich.edu/resources-tools/adaptation-monitoring-and-evaluation-toolkit/ Accessed on Sep 18, 2023.
65. Resilience Metrics, “Indicators & metrics,” Available: https://resiliencemetrics.org Accessed on Oct 3 2023.
66. T. Rayner, “Adaptation to climate change: EU policy on a mission towards transformation?,” NPJ Climate Action, Vol. 2, Article 36, 2023. [CrossRef]
67. Ç. Tuğaç, “The evolution of European Union’s climate change adaptation policies and the importance of current adaptation policies for Turkey,” Urban Academy Journal, Vol. 15(3), pp. 958982, 2022. [CrossRef]
68. Climate-ADAPT, “Monitoring and evaluating adaptation,” Available: https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/en/knowledge/tools/adaptation-support-tool/step-6-1 Accessed on Dec 13, 2023.
69. K. Mäkinen, A. Prutsch, E. Karali, M. Leitner, S. Völler, J. Lyytimäki, P. Pringle, and W. Vanneuville. Indicators for Adaptation to Climate Change at National Level-Lessons From Emerging Practice in Europe. European Topic Centre on Climate Change Impacts, Vulnerability and Adaptation (ETC/CCA). 2018.
70. EU, “Commission implementing regulation (EU) 2020/1208,” EU Official Gazette, L278/1, 2020.
71. C. Kind, T. Kaiser, and H. Gaus. Methodology for the Evaluation of the German Adaptation Strategy. Umweltbundesamt [German Environment Agency], Germany, 2019.
72. P. Van Rüth, K. Schönthaler, S. von Andrian-Verburg, and M.Buth, “2019 Monitoring report on the German strategy for adaptation to climate change,” Umweltbundesamt [German Environment Agency], 2019.
73. MEIDECC, “Joint national action plan 2 on climate change and disaster risk management 2018-2028,” Available: https://library.sprep.org/sites/default/files/jnapdrm-2018-2028.pdf Accessed on Sep 18, 2023.
74. MEIDECC, “Joint national action plan 2 on climate change and disaster risk management 2018-2028: monitoring and evaluation system guide,” Available: https://climatechange.gov.to/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/JNAP-2-ME-System-Guide-.pdf Accessed on Sep 18, 2023.
75. UNDRR, “Comprehensive disaster and climate risk management,” Available: https://www.undrr.org/climate-action-and-disaster-risk-reduction/comprehensive-disaster-and-climate-risk-management Accessed on Jan 09, 2024.
76. UNFCCC, “Eighth national communication and fifth biennial report of Türkiye under the UNFCCC,” Available: https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/8NC-5BR%20T%C3%BCrkiye.pdf Accessed on Feb 02, 2024.
77. MoEUCC, “E-hizmetler ve projeler,”. Available: https://www.csb.gov.tr/uygulamalar Accessed on Sep 12, 2023.
78. MOAF, “İzleme ve değerlendirme eğitim programı,” Available: https://www.tarimorman.gov.tr/ABDGM/Belgeler/%C4%B0ZLEME%20VE%20DE%C4%9EERLEND%C4%B0RME/2-%C4%B0zleme_De%C4%9Ferlendirme.25_26%20Kas%C4%B1m.pdf Accessed Jan 12, 2024.
79. MoEU. Turkey’s National Climate Change Adaptation Strategy and Action Plan. MoEU, Ankara, Turkey, 2012.
80. Climate Adaptation Project, “Enhancing adaptation action in Türkiye project,” https://iklimeuyum.org/en/about/about-project/ Accessed on Feb 13, 2024.
81. CCP, “İklim değişikliği ve uyum koordinasyon kurulu’nun ikinci toplantısı gerçekleştirildi,” Available: https://iklim.gov.tr/iklim-degisikligi-ve-uyum-koordinasyon-kurulu-nun-ikinci-toplantisi-gerceklestirildi-haber-4201 Accessed on March 03, 2024.
82. CCP, “İklim değişikliğine uyum stratejisi ve eylem planı, 2024-2030,” Available: https://iklim.gov.tr/db/turkce/icerikler/files/%C4%B0klim%20De%C4%9Fi%C5%9Fikli%C4%9Fine%20Uyum%20Stratejisi%20ve%20Eylem%20Plan_%202024-2030.pdf Accessed on June 16, 2024.
83. CCP, “İklim değişikliği başkanlığı 2024-2028 stratejik plan,” Available: https://iklim.gov.tr/db/turkce/icerikler/files/2024-2028%20Stratejik%20Plan.pdf Accessed on Mar 03, 2024.
84. CCP, “Uzun zamandır gündemde olan kayıp ve zarar fonu COP28'in ilk gününde kabul edildi,” Available: https://iklim.gov.tr/uzun-zamandir-gundemde-olan-kayip-ve-zarar-fonu-cop28in-ilk-gununde-kabul-edildi-haber-4171 Accessed on Mar 03, 2024.