Sustainable Management of a Renewable Fishery Resource with Depensation Dynamics from a Control Systems Perspective

Abstract

Human societies are exploiting natural renewable sources such as fisheries, forests, groundwater basins, rivers, and soil at an increasing intensity. Around the world, these resources are being managed by various institutions or governments. One of the challenges faced by institutions is to develop strategies and policies to effectively manage these renewable resources under social and ecological uncertainties, disturbances, policy implementation difficulties, and measurement errors. In this paper, a fishery is considered as an example and the problem of managing a fishery is approached from a control systems perspective. The justification behind this approach is due to the observation that the problem of managing a renewable resource can be posed as a control systems problem and that the discipline of control systems possesses tools and methods to deal with model uncertainties, external disturbances, measurement errors and implementation issues. For the fishery, a depensation type population dynamics model is considered. Depensatory models are used in social/ecological systems in order to model dynamics of certain species of fish populations. An optimal control strategy based on Pontryagin’s Maximum Principle is derived and its sustainability and robustness properties with respect to parametric uncertainties, measurement errors and disturbances are examined. Finally, a sub-optimal but more robust control strategy is proposed and its robustness properties are provided. The main objective of the paper is to show that a control systems engineering approach can be applied to a social-ecological problem and it can provide easy to implement management strategies, insight, and guidance into the management of renewable resources. 

Keywords

• Sustainability
• Social-ecological systems
• Optimal control
• Renewable resource management

References

1. [1] Clark, C.W., “Fisheries bioeconomics: why is it so widely misunderstood?”, Population Ecology, 48 (2): 95-98, (2006).
2. [2] Clark, C.W., Munro, G.R., Sumaila, U.R., “Subsidies, buybacks, and sustainable fisheries”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 50(1): 47-58, (2005).
3. [3] Holland, D., Gudmundsson, E., Gates, J., “Do fishing vessel buyback programs work: a survey of the evidence”, Marine Policy, 23(1): 47-69, (1999).
4. [4] Myers, R.A., Worm, B., “Rapid worldwide depletion of predatory fish communities”, Nature, 423(6937): 280-283, (2003).
5. [5] Sethi, G., Costello, C., Fisher, A., Hanemann, M., Karp, L., “Fishery management under multiple uncertainty”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 50(2): 300-318, (2005).
6. [6] Moran, E.F., Ostrom, E., “Seeing the forest and the trees: human-environment interactions in forest ecosystems”, The MIT Press, Massachusetts, (2005).
7. [7] Fuchigami, Y., Hara, K., Uwasu, M., Kurimoto, S., “Analysis of the mechanism hindering sustainable forestry operations: a case study of Japanese forest management”, Forests, 7(8): 182, (2016).
8. [8] Cunniffe, N.J., Cobb, R.C., Meentemeyer, R.K., Rizzo, D.M., Gilligan, C.A., “Modeling when, where, and how to manage a forest epidemic, motivated by sudden oak death in California”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 113(20): 5640-5645, (2016).

9. [9] Pauloo, R.A., Escriva-Bou, A., Dahlke, H., Fencl, A., Guillon, H., Fogg, G.E., “Domestic well vulnerability to drought duration and unsustainable groundwater management in California’s central valley”, Environmental Research Letters, 15(4): 044010, (2020).
10. [10] Rinaudo, J.D., Donoso, G., “State, market or community failure? Untangling the determinants of groundwater depletion in Copiapo (Chile)”, International Journal of Water Resources, 35(2): 283-304, (2019).
11. [11] Gorelick, S.M., Zheng, C., “Global change and the groundwater management challenge”, Water Resources Research, 51(5): 3031-3051, (2015).
12. [12] Powlson, D.S., Gregory, P.J., Whalley, W.R., Quinton, J.N., Hopkins, D.W., Whitmore, A.P., Hirsch, P.R., Goulding, K.W.T., “Soil management in relation to sustainable agriculture and ecosystem services”, Food Policy, 36: 72–87, (2011).
13. [13] Juerges, N., Hansjurgens, B., “Soil governance in the transition towards a sustainable bioeconomy - a review”, Journal of Cleaner Production, 170: 1628-1639, (2018).
14. [14] Clark, C.W., Kirkwood, G.P., “On uncertain renewable resource stocks: optimal harvest policies and the value of stock surveys”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 13(3): 235-244, (1986).
15. [15] Koenig, E.F., “Controlling stock externalities in a common property fishery subject to uncertainty”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 11(2): 124-138, (1984).
16. [16] Belkhodja, K., Moussaoui, A., Alaoui, M.A.A., “Optimal harvesting and stability for a prey-predator model”, Nonlinear Analysis-Real World Applications, 39: 321-336, (2018).
17. [17] Dubey, B., Agarwal, S., Kumar, A., “Optimal harvesting policy of a prey-predator model with Crowley-Martin-type functional response and stage structure in the predator”, Nonlinear Analysis-Modelling and Control, 23(4): 493-514, (2018).
18. [18] Demir, M., “Optimal control strategies in ecosystem-based fishery models”, Phd. Thesis, University of Tennessee, USA, 11-44 (2019).
19. [19] Huang, L.R., Cai, D.H., Liu, W.Y., “Optimal harvesting of an abstract population model with interval biological parameters”, Advances in Difference Equations, 2020(1): 285, (2020).
20. [20] Kazmi, K.R., Dubey, B., Patra, A., “A mathematical model for optimal management and utilization of a renewable resource by population”, Journal of Mathematics, 2013: 613706, (2013).
21. [21] Ludwig, D., Walters, C.J., “Optimal harvesting with imprecise parameter estimates”, Ecological Modelling, 14(3): 273-292, (1982).
22. [22] Weitzman, M.L., “Landing fees vs harvest quotas with uncertain fish stocks”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 43(2): 325-338, (2002).
23. [23] Andersen, P., “Commercial fisheries under price uncertainty”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 9(1): 11-28, (1982).
24. [24] Clark, C.W., “The worldwide crisis in fisheries: economic models and human behavior”, Cambridge University Press, New York, (2006).
25. [25] Crepin, A.S., Norberg, J., Maler, K.G., “Coupled economic-ecological systems with slow and fast dynamics - modelling and analysis method”, Ecological Economics, 70: 1448-1458, (2011).
26. [26] Pei, Y.Z., Chen, M.M., Liang, X.Y., Li, C.G., “Model-based on fishery management systems with selective harvest policies”, Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 156: 377-395, (2019).
27. [27] Anderies, J.M., Rodriguez, A.A., Janssen, M.A., Cifdaloz, O., “Panaceas, uncertainty, and the robust control framework in sustainability science”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104(39): 15194-15199, (2007).
28. [28] Rodriguez, A.A., Cifdaloz, O., Anderies, J.M., Janssen, M.A., Dickeson, J., “Confronting management challenges in highly uncertain natural resource systems: a robustness-vulnerability trade-off approach”, Environmental Modeling & Assessment, 16(1): 15-36, (2011).
29. [29] Bisson, A., Casenave, C., Boudsocq, S., Daufresne, T., “Maximization of fertility transfers from rangeland to cropland: the contribution of control theory”, Journal of Theoretical Biology, 469: 187-200, (2019).
30. [30] Das, D., Kar, T.K., “Feedback control and its impact on generalist predator-prey system with prey harvesting”, Nonlinear Analysis-Modelling and Control, 24(5): 718-732, (2019).
31. [31] De Giovanni, D., Lamantia, F., “Dynamic harvesting under imperfect catch control”, Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 176(1): 252-267, (2018).
32. [32] Anderies, J.M., Janssen, M.A., “Robustness of social-ecological systems: implications for public policy”, Policy Studies Journal, 41(3): 513-536, (2013).
33. [33] Anderies, J.M., Folke, C., Walker, B., Ostrom, E., “Aligning key concepts for global change policy: robustness, resilience, and sustainability”, Ecology and Society, 18(2): 8, (2013).
34. [34] Schoon, M.L., Cox, M.E., “Understanding disturbances and responses in social-ecological systems”, Society and Natural Resources, 25(2): 141-155, (2012).
35. [35] Brauer, F., Castillo-Chavez, C., “Mathematical models in population biology and epidemiology”, Springer, New York, (2012).
36. [36] Clark, C.W., “Mathematical Bioeconomics”, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, (1990).
37. [37] Liermann, M., Hilborn, R., “Depensation: evidence, models and implications”, Fish and Fisheries, 2: 33-58, (2001).
38. [38] Chan, M.H., Kim, P.S., “Modelling the impact of marine reserves on a population with depensatory dynamics”, Bulletin of Mathematical Biology, 76: 2122-2143, (2014).
39. [39] Saha, B., Bhowmick, A.R., Chattopadhyay, J., Bhattacharya, S., “On the evidence of an Allee effect in herring populations and consequences for population survival: A model-based study”, Ecological Modelling, 250: 72-80, (2013).
40. [40] Knowles, G., “An introduction to applied optimal control”, Academic Press, New York, (1981).
41. [41] Pontryagin, L.S., Boltyanskii, V.G., Gamkrelidze, R.V., Mishchenko, E.F., “The mathematical theory of optimal processes”, CRC Press, New York, (1986).
42. [42] Anderies, J.M., Mathias, J.D., Janssen, M.A., “Knowledge infrastructure and safe operating spaces in social-ecological systems”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116: 5277-5284, (2019).
43. [43] Harris, M.M., Schaubroeck, J., “Confirmatory modeling in organizational behavior/human resource management: issues and applications”, Journal of Management, 16: 337-360, (1990).
44. [44] Yang, Z., Su, C., “Understanding Asian business strategy: modeling institution-based legitimacy-embedded efficiency”, Journal of Business Research, 66(12): 2369-2374, (2013).
45. [45] Schluter, M., Mcallister, R.R.J., Arlinghaus, R., Bunnefeld, N., Eisenack, K., Hölker, F., Milner-Gulland, E.J., Müller, B., Nicholson, E., Quaas, M., Stoven, M., “New horizons for managing the environment: a review of coupled social-ecological¨ systems modeling”, Natural Resource Modeling, 25: 219-272, (2012).
46. [46] Smith, T.D., “Scaling fisheries: the science of measuring the effects of fishing”, 1855-1955, Cambridge University Press, New York, (1994).