Montenegrin Constitutional Preamble – Simply a Wishful Plan? - Historical and Comparative Context

Abstract

This paper takes as subject the preamble to the current Constitution of Montenegro of 2007. First, the concept of preamble and its legal nature, the origins and content of the preamble to the constitutions of the world are investigated. Second, precursors of the preambles in Yugoslavia, preambles to the constitutions of Montenegro, compared with the constitutions of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and Federal Republic of Yugoslavia are presented. Furthermore, preambles to the constitutions in the countries of Central Europe, Eurasian countries and the countries created on the territory of the former Yugoslavia are discussed. We used the historical, exegetical, axiological, normative, and comparative method in conduct of this research. The central part of the paper relates to the preamble to the Constitution of Montenegro of 2007, which consists of five determinations: basis of constitutional legitimacy – citizens’ referendum decision to live in the independent and sovereign state of Montenegro; basic values on which the state organization of Montenegro rests – civil concept of the state; the conviction of the state’s responsibility for preservation of nature, healthy environment, sustainable development, balanced development of all its areas; the establishment of social justice and commitment to equal cooperation with other nations and states and European and Euro-Atlantic integrations. All determinations are analysed within the relationship of indivisibility and mutual dependence. Regarding the legal nature of the preamble, the question arose as to whether it has a legal character or is a solemn introduction to it, which can only have the character of a political declaration or program document. In analyzing contents of specific constitutional preambles, which also contain rules of conduct, such as the preamble of the French constitution from 1958 or the Constitution of Montenegro of 1992, then the preamble is of equal rank in legal terms with other parts of the constitution – it holds the highest legal obligation.

Keywords

• Preamble of Constitution
• contents and form of preamble
• constitution
• Constitution of Montenegro
• interpretation
• Constitutional Court of Montenegro

References

1. Constitution of Austria, https://constitutionnet.org/sites/default/files/Austria%20_FULL_%20Constitution.pdfAccessed on 30 March 2023. google scholar
2. Constitution of Germany, https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/German_Federal_Republic_2012.pdfAccessed on 3 March 2023. google scholar
3. Constitution of Kingdom of Jugoslavija, https://projuris.org/RETROLEX/Ustav%20kraljevine%20SHS_Vidovdanski%20ustav%20(1921).pdfAccessed on 3 March 2023. google scholar
4. Constitution of Montenegro, Official Gazette of Federal Republic of Montenegro, no. 1/74. google scholar
5. Constitution of Montenegro, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 1/2007.google scholar
6. Constitution of Social Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, http://www.arhivyu.gov.rs/active/sr-latin/home/glavna_navigacija/leksikon_jugoslavije/konstitutivni_akti_jugoslavije/ustav_sfrj_1963.htmlAccessed on 2 May 2023. google scholar
7. Constitution of the Czech Republic, https://www.psp.cz/en/docs/laws/1993/1.html Accessed on 3 March 2023.google scholar
8. Constitution of the People's Republic of China, http://www.npc.gov.cn/englishnpc/constitution2019/201911/1f65146fb6104dd3a2793875d19b5b29.shtmlAccessed on 16 April 2023. google scholar

9. Constitution of the Republic of Croatia, https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/clanci/sluzbeni/1990_12_56_1092.htmlAccessed on 15 February 2023. google scholar
10. Constitution of the Republic of Serbia, http://mojustav.rs/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Ustav-iz-1990.pdf Accessed on 15 April 2023. google scholar
11. Constitution of the Slovak Republic https://www.prezident.sk/upload-files/46422.pdf Accessed on 25 April 2023. google scholar
12. Constitution of Turkiye, https://global.tbmm.gov.tr/docs/constitution_en.pdf Accessed on 23 March 2023. google scholar
13. Constitutional Charter of State Union of Serbia and Montenegro, Official Gazette of Serbia and Montenegro, no. 1/2003. google scholar
14. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 11/16, 12/17 and 13/17 of 27 March 2018. google scholar
15. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 27/10, 30/10 and 34/10, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 12/11 of 25. February 2011.google scholar
16. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 39/11 and 3/12 of 18 July 2013. Official Gazette of Republic of Montenegro, no. 12/06.google scholar
17. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 13/16, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 11/19. google scholar
18. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 1/16, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 62/18. google scholar
19. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 29/17, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 33/18. google scholar
20. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 37/16, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 37/18. google scholar
21. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Montenegro, U-I no. 28/18, Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 44/20. google scholar
22. Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 45/10. google scholar
23. Official Gazette of Republic of Montenegro, no. 39/91. google scholar
24. Official Gazette of Montenegro, no. 48/08, 40/10 and 27/14. google scholar
25. Official Gazette of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia, no. 200/1931. google scholar
26. Official Gazette of the Republic of Montenegro, no. 36/06. google scholar
27. Official Gazette of the Republic of Montenegro, no. 64/02, 31/05 and 49/07.google scholar
28. Resolution 1244 (1999) / adopted by the Security Council at its 4011th meeting, on 10 June 1999, https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/274488Accessed on 3 May 2023. google scholar
29. Acemoglu D, Robinson J.A, Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity (Crown Publishers, New York 2013). google scholar
30. Alijević M, ‘Tekst preambule kao pomoćna metoda tumačenja ustava’, [2012] Anali Pravnog fakulteta Univerziteta u Zenici, 283-300. http://prf.unze.ba/Docs/Anali/godina_5_broj_10/14.pdf Accessed on 23 October 2022. google scholar
31. Bačić A, ‘Ustav Republike Hrvatske i najviše vrednote ustavnog poretka’ [2012] Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Splitu, 1/2012, 1-21. https://hrcak.srce.hr/79041 Accessed on 20 October 2022. google scholar
32. Bačić A, Ustavno pravo i političke institucije (Pravni fakultet u Splitu, Split 2006). google scholar
33. Bačić A, Ustavno pravo Republike Hrvatske (Split 2006). google scholar
34. Bureau for Statistics of Montenegro, First Results, Census of Population, Households and Dwellings in Montenegro (Podgorica 2011) 1-57. https://www.monstat.org/userfiles/file/popis2011/saopstenje/knjiga_prvi%20rezultati(1).pdfAccessed on 23 October 2022. google scholar
35. Đorđević J, Ustavno pravo (Savremena administracija, Belgrade 1976).google scholar
36. Frosini J, ‘Constitutional Preambles: More than just a narration of history,’ [2017] University of Illinois Law Review, 2/2017, 603-628. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3516805 Accessed on 28 December 2022. google scholar
37. Frosini J, Constitutional preambles At a Crossroads between Politics and Law (Santarcangelo di. Romagna, Maggioli 2012). google scholar
38. Ginsburg T, Foti N, Rockmore D, ‘”We the Peoples”: The Global Origins of Constitutional Preambles’ [2014] The George Washington International Law Review, vol. 4, 101-136. https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=11414&context=journal_articlesAccessed on 26 November 2022. google scholar
39. Government of Montenegro National Council for Sustainable Development, Analysis on achievements and challenges of ecological state, 20th year of ecological Montenegro, Podgorica, 2011, 6-15. google scholar
40. Häberle P, ‘Hrvatski ustav (1991.) u europskoj pravnoj usporedbi’ [2000] Politička misao, Vol XXXVII, no. 1, 49-55. https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/43374Accessed on 28 December 2022. google scholar
41. Havel V, Paradise Lost (New York Review of Books 1992). google scholar
42. Jelić I, ‘Osnivanje AVNOJ-a u povodu 30-godišnjice Prvoga zasjedanja AVNOJ-a’ [1975] Časopis za suvremenu povijest, 85-98. https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/319955 Accessed on 20 December 2022. google scholar
43. Jovičić M, O ustavu – teorijsko-komparativna studija (Savremena administracija, Belgrade 1977). google scholar
44. Kardelj E, Put nove Jugoslavije (Kultura, Belgrade-Zagreb 1946). google scholar
45. Kelsen H, Opšta teorija prava i države (Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu, Centar za publikacije, Belgrade 1988). google scholar
46. Kutlešić V, ‘Preambule ustava, uporedna studija 194 važeća ustava’ [2010] Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu, LVIII, 2/2010, Belgrade, 60-76. https://scindeks.ceon.rs/article.aspx?artid=0003-25651002060K Accessed on 15 March 2023. google scholar
47. Legal Encyclopaedia (Savremena administracija, Belgrade 1985). google scholar
48. Marković R, Ustavno pravo i političke institucije (Službeni glasnik, Belgrade 1995). google scholar
49. McKenna M, Simpson A, Williams G, ‘First words: The Preamble to the Australian Constitution’ [2001], UNSW Law Journal, 382-400. https://www.unswlawjournal.unsw.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/24-2-18.pdfAccessed on 17 May 2023. google scholar
50. Mihajlović V, Ustavno pravo (Kraljevo 2009). google scholar
51. Milenković M, Međunarodni instrumenti za zaštitu ljudskih prava u oblasti životne sredine, (Institut društvenih nauka, Belgrade 2011). google scholar
52. Mirić J, Demokracija i ekskomunikacija (Prosvjeta, Zagreb, 1999). google scholar
53. Montenegrin Constitutions 1905-2005, Official Gazette of Montenegro, 2005. google scholar
54. Orgad L, ‘The Preamble in Constitutional Interpretation’ [2010] International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol. 8, no. 4, 714–738. https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/mor010 Accessed on 30 April 2023. google scholar
55. Pajvančić M, Vukčević M, Ustavno pravo (Podgorica 2009). google scholar
56. Perić, Živojin, Crna Gora u Jugoslovenskoj federaciji (Belgrade 1940).google scholar
57. Political Encyclopaedia (Savremena administracija, Belgrade 1975). google scholar
58. Pravni leksikon (Savremena administracija, Belgrade 1964). google scholar
59. Rakočević N, Crnogorska narodna skupština 1906-1914 (Unireks, Podgorica 1997). google scholar
60. Simović D, ‘Funkcije preambule ustava i osobenosti preambule Ustava Republike Srbije’ [2020] Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Novom Sadu, 1/2020, 173-194. https://scindeks-clanci.ceon.rs/data/pdf/0550-2179/2020/0550-21792001173S.pdfAccessed on 26 May 2023. google scholar
61. Smerdl B, Sokol S, Ustavno pravo (Pravni fakultet Zagreb 2006). google scholar
62. Smerdl B, Ustavno uređenje Europske Hrvatske, II. izmijenjeno i dopunjeno izdanje (Narodne novine, Zagreb 2020). google scholar
63. Stojanović D, Ustavno pravo (Pravni fakultet u Nišu 2014). google scholar
64. Štrbac N, Vuković M, Voza D, Sokić M, ‘Održivost identiteta Srba i nacionalnih manjina u pograničnim opštinama istočne i jugoistočne Srbije (MPNTR - 179013)’ [2012], Recycling and Sustainable Development, vol. 5, br. 1, Belgrade, 1559-1582. [sumnjiva veza uklonjena] Accessed on 20 May 2023. google scholar
65. Šuković M, Ustavno pravo (CID, Podgorica 2009). google scholar
66. Trnka K, Ustavno pravo (Fakultet za javnu upravu, Sarajevo 2006). google scholar
67. Unković M, Održivi razvoj i ekologija (Univerzitet Singidunum, Belgrade 2012). google scholar
68. Vasiljevič Spektorski E, Država i njen život (Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu, Belgrade 2000). google scholar
69. Voermans W, Stremler M, Cliteur P, Constitutional Preambles, A Comparative Analysis (Edward Elgar, 2017). google scholar
70. Vukas B, ‘Povijesnopravne reference u ustavnim preambulama država srednje ve jugostočne Europe u postkomunističkom razdoblju’ [2013] Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu, 63/2013, 1233-1255. https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/171901 Accessed on 20 May 2023. google scholar
71. Vukčević M, Komentar Ustava Crne Gore (Podgorica 2015). google scholar