Are Collective Punishment Policies Doomed to Backfire? A Social Identity Approach Analysis

Year 2025, Volume: 9 Issue: 1, 93 - 110, 26.12.2025

Sami Çoksan

https://doi.org/10.47478/lectio.1810439

Abstract

This paper examines collective punishment from the perspective of the social identity approach, demonstrating that targeting all members of a group tends to backfire by strengthening rather than weakening their shared social identity. The fundamental rationale behind collective punishment is to create pressure on innocent group members, expecting them to react internally against guilty individuals, thereby bringing about a behavioral change. However, three case analyses focusing on Western sanctions imposed on Russia, trade tariffs implemented by the Trump administration against Canada, and Israel’s systematic policies in the Palestinian territories indicate that this strategy generally fails to achieve its intended outcomes. In accordance with the social identity approach, such external threats generate a shared sense of fate and victimhood within the punished group, thereby reinforcing ingroup solidarity and the collective sense of “we”. Consequently, anger is directed not toward the perpetrators within the group but toward the external punisher, rendering the punishing actor’s objective of dividing the ingroup ineffective. The research concludes that collective punishment is a destructive instrument that deepens polarization, erodes trust, and ultimately proven ineffective, or even counterproductive, in achieving its goals. These findings strongly emphasize that punishment, beyond its ethical and legal dimensions, should be grounded in individual responsibility and applied exclusively to actual perpetrators to ensure fairness and effectiveness.

Keywords

collective punishment , collective financial punishment , retaliatory policies , retaliatory tariffs , punitive policies

Ethical Statement

This study did not require ethics approval because it used publicly available secondary data and did not involve direct interaction with human participants.

Supporting Institution

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

References

• Abatayo, A. L., & Lynham, J. (2023). Resource booms and group punishment in a coupled social-ecological system. Ecological Economics, 206, 107730. doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2022.107730
• Amnesty International. (2024). Israel/OPT: Unlawful attacks and mass displacement in Gaza amount to collective punishment. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/
• B’Tselem. (2001). Civilians under siege: Restrictions on freedom of movement as collective punishment. https://www.btselem.org/publications/summaries/200101_civilians_under_siege
• Benzie, R. (2025). Doug Ford orders LCBO to remove U.S. alcohol from shelves in response to Trump tariffs. The Toronto Star. https://www.thestar.com/politics/provincial/doug-ford-orders-lcbo-to-remove-u-s-alcohol-from-shelves-in-response-to-trump/article_7adea3a0-f909-11ef-b155-4b9949192ccc.html
• Berent, J., Pereira, A., & Falomir-Pichastor, J. M. (2017). Collective apologies moderate the effects of justice concerns on support for collective punishment. Social Psychology, 48(4), 194–207. https://doi.org/10.1027/1864-9335/a000309
• Bown, C. (2025). Trump’s trade war timeline 2.0: An up-to-date guide. https://www.piie.com/blogs/realtime-economics/2025/trumps-trade-war-timeline-20-date-guide
• Boynton, S. (2025). Nearly 70% of Canadians think less of U.S. due to Trump tariffs: Ipsos. Global NEWS. https://globalnews.ca/news/11006887/donald-trump-tariffs-canadians-us-opinion-poll/
• Bruneau, E., Kteily, N., & Falk, E. (2018). Interventions highlighting hypocrisy reduce collective blame of Muslims for individual acts of violence and assuage anti-Muslim hostility. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 44(3), 430–448. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167217744197
• Canadian Federation of Independent Business. (2025). Canada-U.S. trade war: Everything you need to know about the U.S./Canada tariffs. https://canadianlabour.ca/canadas-unions-call-for-immediate-action-on-u-s-tariffs-threatening-over-one-million-jobs/
• Cavale, S., Balu N., & DiNapoli, J. (2025). Focus: As ‘Buy Canadian’ grows, more US companies say retailers turning away their products. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/buy-canadian-grows-more-us-companies-say-retailers-turning-away-their-products-2025-03-31/
• Cho, J. (2025). Canadians trade tips to boycott American stuff. Great app, eh? Barron’s. https://www.barrons.com/articles/canadian-boycott-american-products-d41d4e86
• Confino, D., Schori‐Eyal, N., Gollwitzer, M., & Falomir‐Pichastor, J. M. (2024). When growth mindset backfires: The effect of the perceived malleability of groups and utilitarian motives on support for collective punishment. European Journal of Social Psychology, 54(3), 730–744. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.3049
• Council of the European Union. (2022). Council Regulation (EU) 2022/328 of 25 February 2022… http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2022/328/oj
• Croteau, J. (2022). Russian church in Calgary targeted by vandals amid Russia-Ukraine conflict. Global NEWS. https://globalnews.ca/news/8650685/calgary-russian-orthodox-church-vandalism-russia-ukraine-conflict/
• Çoksan, S., Erdugan, C., & Öner Özkan, B. (2023). Ortak öteki Suriyeli… Türk Psikoloji Dergisi, 38(92), 103-128. https://doi.org/10.31828/turkpsikoloji.1352225
• Çoksan, S., Üzümçeker, E., & Esses, V. (2025). Understanding collective punishment: A systematic review… https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/twkz4_v1
• Department of Finance Canada. (2025). Canada's response to U.S. tariffs on Canadian goods. https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/international-trade-finance-policy/canadas-response-us-tariffs.html
• Duell, D., Mengel, F., Mohlin, E., & Weidenholzer, S. (2024). Cooperation through collective punishment and participation. Political Science Research and Methods, 12(3), 494–520. https://doi.org/10.1017/psrm.2023.52
• Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor. (2022). Suffocation and isolation: 17 Years of Israeli blockade on Gaza. https://euromedmonitor.org/en/gaza
• European Commission. (2022b). Ukraine: EU agrees to exclude key Russian banks from SWIFT. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_22_1484
• European Commission. (2022a). EU sanctions against Russia… https://commission.europa.eu/topics/eu-solidarity-ukraine/eu-sanctions-against-russia-following-invasion-ukraine_en
• European University Association. (2022). EUA suspends membership of 12 Russian universities… https://www.eua.eu/news/eua-news/eua-suspends-membership-of-12-russian-universities-following-statement-by-university-leaders.html
• Falomir-Pichastor, J. M., Staerklé, C., Depuiset, M. A., & Butera, F. (2007). Perceived legitimacy of collective punishment… Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 10(4), 565–579. https://doi.org/10.1177/1368430207081543
• Felty, S. M. (2019). Social identity theory and intergroup conflict in Israel/Palestine (Master’s thesis). Naval Postgraduate School.
• Festinger, L. (1957). A theory of cognitive dissonance. Stanford University Press.
• Fisher, K. (2025). How the Trump effect impacted the elections… OANDA Analysis. https://www.oanda.com/us-en/trade-tap-blog/analysis/fundamental/the-trump-effect-how-donald-trump-influenced-elections-in-canada-and-australia/
• Gianotti, F. (2022). CERN’s response to the invasion of Ukraine… https://home.cern/news/opinion/cern/cerns-response-invasion-ukraine-new-council-measures
• Grenier, É. (2025). How has support changed over time? CBC News. https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/elections/poll-tracker/canada/
• Human Rights Watch. (2008). Israel/Gaza: Israeli blockade unlawful… https://www.hrw.org/news/2008/01/25/israel/gaza-israeli-blockade-unlawful-despite-gaza-border-breach
• Human Rights Watch. (2024). Gaza: Israel’s collective punishment of civilians. https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/
• Human Rights Watch. (2024). Hopeless, starving, and besieged… https://www.hrw.org/report/2024/11/14/hopeless-starving-and-besieged/israels-forced-displacement-palestinians-gaza
• ICRC. (2015). ICRC commentary on Convention (IV)… International Committee of the Red Cross. Institute for Middle East Understanding. (2015). Israel & international law… https://imeu.org/resources/resources/israel-international-law-the-siege-blockade-of-gaza/224
• International Court of Justice. (2024). Application of the convention… https://www.icj-cij.org/case/192
• International Olympic Committee. (2023). Q&A regarding the participation… https://olympics.com/ioc/media/q-a-on-solidarity-with-ukraine-sanctions-against-russia-and-belarus-and-status-of-athletes
• Joshi, J. (2025). Tariff war making its mark… https://ca.news.yahoo.com/tariff-war-making-its-mark-new-survey-shows-canadians-feeling-price-hikes-swapping-us-goods-for-local-brands-120052684.html
• Kennedy, L. (2025). Buy Canadian: There’s an app for that. https://money.ca/news/buy-canadian-app
• Kocatepe, D. (2025). Identity and resistance… Filistin Araştırmaları Dergisi, 17, 1–34. https://doi.org/10.34230/fiad.1651510
• Landry, A. P., et al. (2024). Harnessing dehumanization theory… Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 111, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2023.104567
• Levada-Center. (2025). Mass perceptions of Western sanctions… https://www.levada.ru/en/2025/03/19/mass-perceptions-of-western-sanctions-february-2025/
• Liberman, P., & Skitka, L. (2019). Vicarious retribution… Security Studies, 28(2), 189–215. https://doi.org/10.1080/09636412.2019.1551568
• Lyall, J. (2009). Does indiscriminate violence incite insurgent attacks? Journal of Conflict Resolution, 53(3), 331–362. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022002708330881
• Macdonald, L. (2025). Canada and the Trump presidency… Analisis Plural (8). https://doi.org/10.31391/h3qbcr31
• Newheiser, A. K., Sawaoka, T., & Dovidio, J. F. (2012). Why do we punish groups? Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 48(4), 931–936. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2012.02.013
• OCHA. (2025). Humanitarian situation update #328 | West Bank. https://www.ochaopt.org/content/humanitarian-situation-update-328-west-bank
• Pereira, A., & van Prooijen, J. W. (2018). Why we sometimes punish the innocent. PLoS One, 13(5), e0196852. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0196852
• Privy Council Office. (2025). Canada’s fentanyl czar – Interim report. https://www.canada.ca/en/privy-council/services/publications/canada-fentanyl-czar-interim-report-june-2025.html
• Rahman, K. (2022). College backtracks on banning teaching Dostoevsky… https://www.newsweek.com/college-backtracks-banning-teaching-dostoevsky-russian-1684080
• Reicher, S., Spears, R., & Haslam, S. A. (2010). The social identity approach in social psychology. SAGE.
• Rice, J. (2022). An update on AKC and the crisis in Ukraine. https://www.akc.org/press-releases/update-akc-crisis-ukraine/
• Smith, C. E., & Warneken, F. (2016). Children’s reasoning about distributive and retributive justice. Developmental Psychology, 52(4), 613–628. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0040069
• Soss, J., & Weaver, V. (2017). Police are our government… Annual Review of Political Science, 20, 565–591. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-polisci-060415-093825
• Stenstrom, D. M., et al. (2008). Ingroup identification and outgroup entitativity… Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 34(11), 1570–1582. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167208322999
• Stephan, W. G., & Stephan, C. W. (2000). Integrated threat theory… In S. Oskamp (Ed.), Reducing prejudice and discrimination (pp. 23–45). Lawrence Erlbaum.
• Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict… In W. G. Austin & S. Worchel (Eds.), The social psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 33–37). Brooks & Cole.
• Taylor-Vaisey, N., Blanchfield, M., & Djuric, M. (2025). Tariff tally. Politico. https://www.politico.com/newsletters/canada-playbook/2025/05/21/tariff-tally-00361755
• U.S. Customs and Border Protection. (2024). CBP enforcement statistics… https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/cbp-enforcement-statistics-fy2024
• U.S. Department of the Treasury. (2022). U.S. Treasury imposes sanctions… https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy0612
• United Nations Children’s Fund. (2022). The Gaza Strip… https://www.unicef.org/mena/documents/gaza-strip-humanitarian-impact-15-years-blockade-june-2022
• United Nations Human Rights Council. (2024). Report of the independent international commission of inquiry… https://www.ohchr.org/en/hr-bodies/hrc/iici-israel/index
• United Nations OCHA. (2023). Hostilities in the Gaza Strip and Israel: Flash update. https://www.ochaopt.org/content/flash-update-hostilities-gaza-strip-and-israel
• United Nations. (2020). Geneva convention relative to the protection of civilian persons in time of war. United Nations.
• Uysal, M. S., Çoksan, S., & Kessler, T. (2024). How collective punishment harms intergroup relations… Political Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1111/pops.13028
• van Zomeren, M., Leach, C. W., & Spears, R. (2012). Protesters as “Passionate Economists.” Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(2), 180–199. https://doi.org/10.1177/1088868311430835
• van Zomeren, M., Postmes, T., & Spears, R. (2008). Toward an integrative social identity model… Psychological Bulletin, 134(4), 504–535. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.134.4.504
• Vasquez, E. A., et al. (2015). Any of them will do… Aggressive Behavior, 41(3), 242–252. https://doi.org/10.1002/ab.21581
• Weaver, M. (2022). Cardiff Philharmonic removes Tchaikovsky performance… The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/mar/09/cardiff-philharmonic-orchestra-removes-tchaikovsky-over-ukraine-conflict
• Wilhelm, S. (2025). Some Canadians sell their homes in U.S.… Calgary Herald. https://calgaryherald.com/news/canadians-selling-us-homes-donald-trump-51st-state-exchange-rate
• Wohl, M. J. A., & Branscombe, N. R. (2008). Collective angst… In H. A. Wayment & J. J. Bauer (Eds.), Transcending self-interest (pp. 171–181). APA.
• Wohl, M. J. A., Branscombe, N. R., & Reysen, S. (2010). Extinction threat and collective angst… Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 36(7), 898–910. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167210372505
• Wong, J. (2025). Forget Vegas and Florida… CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/where-canadians-are-travelling-instead-of-united-states-1.7602862
• WTO. (2025). Canada initiates WTO dispute complaint… https://www.wto.org/english/news_e/news25_e/ds635rfc_13mar25_e.htm
• Yousif, N. (2025). Canada votes in pivotal election… BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c5ylzkzxkndo
• Zahn, M. (2025). A timeline of the U.S.-Canada trade dispute. ABC News. https://abcnews.go.com/Business/timeline-us-canada-trade-dispute/story?id=123335160
• Zhang, E., & Woo, R. (2023). China-Russia trade hits $218 bln… Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/markets/china-russia-trade-hits-218-bln-jan-nov-completing-goal-planned-reach-2024-2023-12-07/
• Zhao, L., et al. (2021). Effects of trust and threat messaging on academic cheating. Psychological Science, 32(5), 729–742. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797620977513
• Zurcher, A. (2025). Trump made Carney’s turnaround victory possible. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c5ypz7yx73wo